'Everyone's got a different story' - James Lowe dismisses criticism of foreign-born Lions

James Lowe has hit back against the criticism of the number of 'imported' players on the British and Irish Lions tour.
Former Ireland and Lions captain Willie John McBride was a high-profile critic, saying the number of players in the squad who weren't born in Britain or Ireland "bothered" him.
New Zealand-born Lowe is one of five players in the squad who qualified through residency, along with his Ireland team-mates Bundee Aki and Jamison Gibson-Park, as well as Scotland pair Pierre Schoeman and Duhan van der Merwe.
Additionally, Mack Hansen and Sione Tuipulotu were both born in Australia, but qualified for Ireland and Scotland respectively through family.
And Lowe, who made his Ireland debut in 2020 after joining Leinster in 2017, says the recent scrutiny of his nationality is nothing new for him.
"When you don't have the blood running through your veins, there is a little bit of that [criticism],' Lowe said.
"When I was first selected for Ireland, all the people come out of the woodwork saying, 'How is this person representing Ireland?'
"I'm sure it was the same for Sione [Tuipulotu], but the rules are there. We've all done our time. I am fully embedded in the culture of Ireland. Sione's captained Scotland. You don't have to question where his allegiance lies.
Lowe is set to join a small group of people who have played both for and against the Lions, having been part of the Maori All Blacks team for their meeting with the Lions in 2017 (below).
And he emphasised that while he wasn't born in Ireland, he doesn't see himself leaving any time soon.
"Leinster and Ireland have given me everything. They've made me a lot better as a rugby player, they've looked after me physically and they've given me time off to get back to New Zealand when I need it.
"It's something I'll forever be grateful for. The boys still slag me for my accent, but we are so well connected in so many ways.
"Everyone's got a different story. My story didn't start in Ireland. But I can see it ending in Ireland. My two kids were born in Ireland.
"My wife and I are super happy with everything Ireland has given us and we don't see ourselves moving. We've got our residency and I don't think you are going to get rid of us any time soon," he added.
Similarly, Scotland captain Tuipulotu insists he is "all in" with the Lions, and admits he's felt pressure to prove his international allegiance in the past.
Melbourne-born Tuipulotu (below), who made his international debut in 2021, was appointed Scotland captain last year.
The 28-year-old's Greenock-born grandmother was at Murrayfield last autumn to see him score a try while leading Scotland to a 27-13 defeat of the Wallabies.
"I put so much on myself that I really wanted to be a Lion because I know how much it means to people over here," said Tuipulotu, who initially feared his tour participation may be ruined by injury.
"I had gone all in with the stuff with Scotland and I just felt what better way to prove my allegiance to Scotland than go all in and try and make the Lions. That's why it meant so much to me.
"Genuinely early days you have that feeling of 'am I part of this?'. I always feel like talking about it is one thing, but showing people how much it means to you in how you play [is another].
"When my gran came over before the Australia game, it allowed the public to put a face to the story and listen to my grandma and how much it meant to her. I think that gave eyes to the public that my story was authentic.
"I'm all in and I'm looking forward to showing how committed I am to playing for the Lions."
Tuipulotu is raring to go after returning from four months out with a pectoral issue during Glasgow's 13-5 defeat to Leinster on Saturday.
"I've been nothing but embraced by the Scottish public ever since I started playing for Scotland," said Tuipulotu, who has 30 Test caps.
"There's always going to be a couple of people (who criticise), like there are for some of the Irish boys, but I take that in my stride because I don't blame those people either.
"I didn't grow up dreaming of playing for Scotland or the Lions, that's the truth.
"But this is where my path has led me and I'm all in for this Lions team and for Scotland and for Glasgow, and I genuinely feel like this is where I'm supposed to be.
"I just want to grab this opportunity because I'll never get it again, to go back to Australia, and play for the Lions," he added.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Irish Examiner

an hour ago

• Irish Examiner

Sam Mulroy: 'Families, lives, work and holidays need to count. We're not paid for this thing'

Sam Mulroy got a message from his clubmate JP Rooney earlier this week. It was a picture of the former Louth player's son playing football in the backyard. Before Louth's victory in last month's Leinster final, which sealed their first senior provincial title in 68 years, it seemed the apple had fallen far from the tree. 'His young lad John was never in love with football until he came and watched Louth playing in a Leinster final a few weeks back,' explained Mulroy at the All-Ireland knockout stages launch. 'It was very nice to see that you're inspiring the next generation of players. 'Louth is a small county with two massive towns and two massive soccer clubs in Dundalk and Drogheda. It's been a battle over the last while, especially with Dundalk's success in recent years in Europe. There's definitely more Louth jerseys floating around on kids these days.' Three years ago, Mulroy appeared on the BBC's The GAA Social podcast and said winning a Leinster title in the next five or six years was a realistic ambition for Louth. He took flak for his comments. To some, it seemed fanciful. Dublin's All-Ireland juggernaut might have been halted the previous year, but they still looked unstoppable in the province. After losing the Leinster finals of 2023 and 2024 to Dublin, Mulroy's prophecy came through. He had stopped just short of saying 'why not?' when asked on that podcast if Louth could win the All-Ireland. Now he's edging closer towards it. 'Last week Meath beat Kerry, and they've beaten Dublin, and there's games, there's results that you wouldn't be calling, maybe last year, that are happening this year,' said Mulroy, top scorer in the championship with 4-34. He believes Gaelic football's new rules have made the game more open. That's not to say he loves every one of them. He doesn't like that the kickout has to go beyond the 40m arc or having to hand the ball to an opposition player after a foul is committed, but what annoys him most is the altering of the rules during the season. 'It's 11 v 11 instead of 15 v 15, there's space to get shots off; players are expressing themselves a little bit more because the game's so fast, and there seems to be a lot more plays happening,' he said. 'Each play doesn't seem to be as important, whereas last year, if you turned the ball over, you could go without the ball for three, four, five minutes.' Louth face Donegal in a preliminary quarter-final on Sunday in Ballybofey. Mulroy knows Donegal manager Jim McGuinness well. McGuinness was involved with Mulroy's club when they won the Louth SFC in 2020 and 2021, the former being the first time Naomh Mairtín claimed the senior title. 'Jim was immense when he was with us, and a gentleman, and always very good with his time,' said Mulroy. 'I've got an awful lot of respect for Jim and what he's done for the game, for Donegal and our club. That was our first ever senior title in the club, so it was very special. I'll never forget that and the help he gave us. 'I was captain in 2021. He was very big on leadership and driving the group on. He would have spoken to me individually. I learned an awful lot. Just on the training pitch, how he spoke to players and got us to bring up our levels - you can see why he's been so successful.' GAA president Jarlath Burns said earlier this month that moving the All-Ireland finals to August from 2027 on would have his support. It would not have the support of Mulroy, who enjoys the split season as it stands. 'It gives a bit more time for those county players to get a little bit of a rest before they go back to the club,' he said. 'Taking into consideration the players' downtime is massively important. If you bring the All-Ireland final back to August and then they're still playing their club finals in November, December, when are they going to stop? That has to be a key consideration for everyone that's making that decision: when do the players get time off? Families and lives and work and holidays need to count. We're not paid for this thing, so I think that definitely has to be the big consideration. 'Even if you got a few more weeks between games… It's not as if you get to go and live your life for a few weeks. You're still training like a professional athlete, you're still in the camp, you're still going away on training weekends. If you push the weeks out, you don't get the time off. It's not as if we're going to be let go and go sun ourselves for a few weeks. 'Prolonging the thing adds more volume of training for players. I know it's tight between games right now, but like, Jesus, I love it. I played last weekend, I get to play again this weekend, I'd rather that than having to go train.' The possibilities for Louth in Monday's draw were all tough. It was Kerry in Killarney, Dublin in Croke Park or Donegal in Ballybofey. They would have been underdogs in the first two, and also will be on Sunday, but it's not outlandish to think they could pull off an upset. 'That's my belief, and I'll definitely be putting that message to the players when we go to training, that we're not going up to Ballybofey for the craic, or to fulfil a fixture, we're in a preliminary quarter-final of the All-Ireland Series,' said Mulroy. 'We played in a quarter-final here (in Croke Park against Donegal) last year, so it's a case of, 'let's try to go better again this year, and try to progress as a team.''

Irish Examiner

an hour ago

• Irish Examiner

Lions Tour Podcast: Special occasion but Pumas deliver long list of learnings

Brendan O'Brien and Simon Lewis review Argentina's defeat of the Lions in their Aviva Stadium pre-tour clash. Just how bad was it for the Lions? The Irish Examiner Rugby Podcast Lions Tour Special is brought to you in partnership with Dove Men+Care – the official Personal Care Product of Choice for the British and Irish Lions. Video available later today

The 42

2 hours ago

• The 42

Defeat doesn't detract from sense Lions should do this more often

THE FIRST WAVES of red hit Dublin sometime around Thursday afternoon. Strolling from Aungier Street toward the north side of the city, the pubs and streets were swarming with pockets of red jerseys. Today it lifted another notch, with groups of supporters making a day of it in the city and adding a notably more lively atmosphere to the areas surrounding Lansdowne Road than your typical Ireland matchday experience. Something was brewing. There was chanting in the streets, groups video calling friends and family back home and younger supporters snapping selfies with their newly-acquired Lions merch. There was no denying the sights and sounds on show. Lions fever had hit Dublin. It would be easy to be sneering about the occasion, and if you're that way inclined, the very existence of this team, tour and brand. Tickets were touching €200, and all for a game that wasn't being capped. A core of Andy Farrell's squad enjoyed it with their feet up, with most of those involved in last weekend's URC and Premiership finals given the night off. But on the day it looked and felt big time. This was a loud and lively launch night for the Lions' 2025 tour. The Aviva Stadium was alive with noise and colour before kick-off. Ben Brady / INPHO Ben Brady / INPHO / INPHO Many were already in their seats an hour before kick-off. A lull in the pre-match music 30 minutes out allowed a small smattering of Argentina supporters to break out in song. The vast majority of those present to cheer on the home side came wearing that distinctive shade of red. You couldn't help but think about how it will feel even more vibrant when the tourists get down to the real work in Australia. Or about how they should do these 'home' Lions games more often. Or about how the source of the atmosphere might have been rooted in how, and to who, those pricey tickets were sold. Those who forked out came wanting a show and to see the home favourites. Bundee Aki received the loudest cheer when the teams were read out pre-game. Tadhg Beirne got the first touch of the Lions' 2025 campaign, leaping to collect Argentina's kick-off as firework smoke slowly cleared. Advertisement You could argue that what followed doesn't overly matter. Win or lose for the Lions, this was a worthwhile occasion and something that should be visited again ahead of future tours. Tonight the Lions played a home game for only the second time, and their fans loved it. You could also argue that Argentina taking the spoils only added to it all. Maybe it's time these tours visited new parts of the world. Those who were here will remember it as a rip-roaring game sprinkled with moments of real quality, many of which came from the swaggering crowd wearing blue and white. Aki took the distinction of being the 2025 Lions' first try-scorer, finishing a wonderful move at the end of the first quarter – Luke Cowan-Dickie, Marcus Smith, Sione Tuipulotu and Fin Smith all showing sharp handling before Aki became the focus. The Connacht man had Tommy Freeman in space on his right but took the more challenging option, barreling three Argentina defenders out of his way to score. This didn't look like a group thrown together for the first time just a couple of weeks ago. THE FIRST TRY OF THE 2025 LIONS TOUR ‼️ Bundee Aki finally gets the Lions opening try on familiar territory 🔥 — Sky Sports (@SkySports) June 20, 2025 They had for patches of the previous 18 minutes. Duhan van der Merwe burst through a hole but didn't spot Alex Mitchell off his shoulder. Van der Merwe was also the unfortunate man sent flailing as Ignacio Mendy finished the game's opening try, slicing inside the Scotland winger to seal a flowing move that saw the Pumas cut Farrell's men open. The Lions were frustrated to see two tries crossed off before Aki chalked his in. Otherwise there was plenty to like. Tom Curry started like steam train. Fin Smith looked confident and sharp. Bealham was powerful in the scrum, with Ellis Genge doing similar on the far side. Around the half-hour mark, a dip in the game sparked a stream out toward the bars. Only then we noticed how the familiar conveyor belt of pints alongside the press box had been operating at a slower pace than usual. Those still in their seats looked to lift the tempo by starting into The Fields of Athenry. Argentina were making this a proper challenge, and finished the first half with another sumptuous score, stitching together a series of passes to run one in from their own 22. The Lions went in 11 points down at the break. Which one was the 'dream team' again? Five minutes after the restart a penalty try brought the Lions back to within touching distance. Moments later the introduction of Henry Pollock, who dominated this pitch on his last visit with Northampton Saints, injected a jolt of anticipation. The sight of Beirne punching through to push the Lions into the lead had the crowd on their feet. Another roar erupted when the cameras flashed to Mack Hansen on the sideline. His former Connacht teammate, Santiago Cordero, turned the game again by beating Marcus Smith in the chase to a kick-through, another scintillating swipe from the South Americans which again started in their own half. It was perhaps even their best of the night. Mack Hansen was introduced midway through the second half. Billy Stickland / INPHO Billy Stickland / INPHO / INPHO Aki departed, but Hansen and the lesser-spotted Tadhg Furlong came in to keep the Irish interest up. Across the final quarter the Lions looked increasingly like the strangers they essentially still are. Rónan Kelleher threw a lineout that sailed past the target. Freeman dropped a ball he should have gathered. Beirne was caught for a costly neck roll as the Pumas held out on the line. The crowd revisited The Fields. Argentina protected their four point lead to take a deserved victory. They celebrated it full-heartedly. It was clear to see what it meant to Felipe Contepomi's men. It was harder to know what to really make of it all from a Lions point of view. Farrell's squad will need improvement against Joe Schmidt's Wallabies but it would have been startling to see a fully cohesive, commanding display on this first run out. By the time that first Test rolls around on 19 July the cobwebs will be long blown off and this group will be much more familiar with each other. The real stuff starts in Australia, but this was a fine way to pop the cork on what promises to be a memorable Lions tour.