'Rajiv Gandhi Sought US Mediation': BJP's Claim Amid India-Pakistan Tensions, Congress Responds
Last Updated:
BJP's Nishikant Dubey claimed former PM Rajiv Gandhi sought mediation from then US President Ronald Reagan on India–Pakistan disputes, triggering a response from the Congress.
A war of words erupted between the Bharatiya Janata Party and the Congress on Wednesday after BJP MP Nishikant Dubey claimed that former Prime Minister Rajiv Gandhi had requested the then United States President Ronald Reagan for mediating between India and Pakistan.
In an X post, the BJP MP shared a response by Reagan to Rajiv Gandhi, and questioned the party on why such request was made by Gandhi when under the 1972 Shimla Agreement, it was decided that any dispute between India and Pakistan would be negotiated only between the two countries and there would be no mediator.
'It is not easy to be Gandhi. This letter is in reply to a letter written by US President Ronald Reagan to the then Indian Prime Minister Rajiv Gandhi," Dubey wrote on X.
'When it was decided under the 1972 Shimla Agreement that any dispute between India and Pakistan would be negotiated only between the two countries and there would be no mediator, why did the then Indian Prime Minister Rajiv Gandhi ask for US President Reagan's help in negotiating with Pakistan?" he questioned.
गांधी होना आसान नहींयह पत्र अमेरिकी राष्ट्रपति रोनाल्ड रेगन का तत्कालीन भारतीय प्रधानमंत्री राजीव गांधी जी के द्वारा लिखे पत्र के उत्तर में है ।1972 के शिमला समझौते के तहत जब यह तय हो गया कि भारत पाकिस्तान के बीच किसी विवाद पर बातचीत केवल दोनों देशों के बीच होगी,कोई मध्यस्थ… pic.twitter.com/kJLSF75TaT — Dr Nishikant Dubey (@nishikant_dubey) May 28, 2025
Countering Dubey's claims, Congress leader Udit Raj, in an X post, called Nishikant Dubey 'fake Kant Dubey' and asserted that Reagan's response to Rajiv Gandhi nowhere mentions that the Indian Prime Minister had requested the United States for mediation between India and Pakistan.
'Not only the degree of fake Kant Dubey, but everything about him is fake. The US President Reagan read the letter written to Shri Rajiv Gandhi but it is not mentioned anywhere that India has asked for support for mediation," Udit Raj responded.
'Fake Kant Dubey does not know how to read English, so how can we help him? Modi ji should be called back from the delegation immediately because he has gone to expose Pakistan and the opposite is happening," he added, quoting Dubey's X post.
फर्जी कांत दूबे की डिग्री ही नहीं बल्कि हर बात फर्जी है । अमेरिका के राष्ट्रपति रीगन ने श्री राजीव गांधी को जो पत्र लिखा था उसे पढ़ा लेकिन कहीं यह नहीं है कि भारत ने मध्यस्ता के लिए साथ मांगा हो ।फर्जी कांत दूबे को अंग्रेजी पढ़ना नहीं आता तो उसमे हम कैसे मदद करें ? प्रतिनिधि मंडल… https://t.co/4cRvS0CFE9 — Dr. Udit Raj (@Dr_Uditraj) May 28, 2025
The war of words between the two parties comes amid the ongoing political debates over third-party involvement in India-Pakistan relations, especially in the wake of recent escalations triggered following the Pahalgam terror attack and India's retaliatory 'Operation Sindoor'.
On Tuesday, Nishikant Dubey shared a purportedly declassified 1971 US intelligence cable regarding former Prime Minister Indira Gandhi's decision to accept a United Nations' ceasefire proposal during the Bangladesh Liberation War, in response to the Opposition's demand for clarification from the Union Government on the US's involvement in the recent understanding on the cessation of hostilities between India and Pakistan.
He further asked whether India prioritised the creation of Bangladesh over reclaiming Pakistan-occupied Kashmir (POK) and securing assets like the Kartarpur Gurdwara.
Earlier, Congress leader Jairam Ramesh took a dig at External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar, saying that he had been 'silent" on US Secretary of State Marco Rubio's remarks about 'US mediation" and 'neutral site" for India-Pakistan talks.
However, India refuted the claims made by the US President, reiterating its policy that India and Pakistan bilaterally address any matter related to the Union territory of Jammu and Kashmir.
First Published:
May 28, 2025, 12:33 IST
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Indian Express
11 minutes ago
- Indian Express
AAP retains Ludhiana West against odds, a Rajya Sabha seat for Arvind Kejriwal may be next
In a significant boost for the embattled Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) in Punjab, the party's Sanjeev Arora won the bitter Ludhiana West bypoll Monday by a decent margin of over 10,637 votes. Arora, a prominent industrialist, who is a sitting Rajya Sabha MP of the AAP, defeated the Congress's Bharat Bhushan Ashu, a former minister and two-time MLA. It was the second consecutive defeat for Ashu from Ludhiana West, an urban constituency dominated by Hindu voters. The Akali Dal's slide continues, with the party finishing even behind the BJP to end up fourth. In the 2022 Assembly elections, the AAP's Gurpreet Bassi Gogi had won from Ludhiana West, defeating Ashu. The bypoll was necessitated due to Gogi's death. The speculation all through the campaign was that if Arora won, the Rajya Sabha seat vacated by him would be filled by AAP convenor Arvind Kejriwal. Even if that does not happen, the Ludhiana West victory will come as a breather for the party that lost power to the BJP in Delhi, with even Kejriwal losing his seat, and whose Punjab government has been beset with problems. The takeaways from Monday's result: The Ludhiana West bypoll, coming soon after the AAP defeat in Delhi for the first time since its formation, was seen as a test of if the party could bounce back. Leaving nothing to chance, the AAP was the first to declare Arora as its candidate – doing so in February itself, long before the elections were even announced – and deployed an array of star leaders to campaign. In a major action, a protest by farmers on the Shambhu and Khanauri borders of Punjab, blocking highways for months and inconveniencing movement, was removed overnight, as the business community and industrialists, including from Ludhiana, complained to the AAP government over their mounting losses. During the campaign, Kejriwal made tall promises for Ludhiana and told voters to pick 'the humble and hardworking' Arora, not 'the angry and arrogant' Ashu, and to go with the ruling party in the state. If Arora won, Kejriwal said, he would be made a minister and 'get several projects to Ludhiana'. A defeat in Ludhiana West would have emboldened the Opposition, which has been accusing the AAP Delhi leadership of holding the reins of the Punjab government, including in appointments to government postings, of indulging in 'VVIP culture', and of failure to tackle the drug menace and meet pre-poll promises such as its cash scheme for women. One barb the AAP would have found it difficult to dodge was how it had 'used' Arora, just to get Kejriwal to Parliament. A two-time MLA from Ludhiana West (2012, 2017), Ashu hoped to make a comeback in the bypoll after his defeat to the AAP's Gogi in 2022. A victory would have also been a nice payback for the AAP government imprisoning him for nearly a year in an alleged corruption case. However, again, the Congress's campaign remained fragmented. The faction led by party Punjab chief and Ludhiana Lok Sabha MP Amrinder Singh Raja Warring and, including Leader of the Opposition Partap Singh Bajwa, stayed away from Ashu's campaign. The faction led by former CM Charanjit Singh Channi, and senior MLA Rana Gurjeet Singh and Pargat Singh threw its weight behind him. The AAP repeatedly raised the fact that Ashu and Warring were not on talking terms with each other. The BJP could not repeat its performance from the 2024 Lok Sabha elections, when it had led other parties in the Ludhiana West Assembly segment. However, BJP candidate Jiwan Gupta, whose candidature was announced at the fag end of nomination filing, managed a decent share of 22% votes. That is a contrast to its former ally SAD, whose existential crisis continues. The party's Ludhiana West candidate, Advocate Parupkar Singh Ghumman, got just 9% of the votes, even though SAD president Sukhbir Singh Badal camped in Ludhiana for days and headed the party's campaign in the bypolls. The ruling AAP faced massive allegations of distributing cash, freebies, ration etc to the voters during the bypoll, and several complaints were filed against it by the Opposition parties. The party also faced allegations of brazenly using administrative power and machinery in its campaigning. After the results were declared, CM Mann said: 'This victory shows that the people of Punjab are extremely happy with the working of our government. We are working day and night for the progress and development of Punjab. We will fulfill every promise made during the bypoll.' Ashu said he took 'the entire responsibility for this defeat'. 'I believe that the entire Congress was always with me. I will wholeheartedly support Arora whenever he needs me for Ludhiana's development. I congratulate him for the win.'
Time of India
20 minutes ago
- Time of India
PM spoke to Iran President; Will he talk to US, Israel too? Asks Congress
Congress has questioned Prime Minister Narendra Modi's selective outreach after his phone conversation with Iranian President Masoud Pezeshkian amid escalating tensions in West Asia. Party MP Pramod Tiwari asked why the Prime Minister hasn't spoken to the US and Israeli leaderships, urging a balanced peace appeal and an all-party meeting. Show more Show less
Time of India
20 minutes ago
- Time of India
"Why are you wasting time on a quack?": Pawan Khera hits out at Nishikant Dubey for questioning Indira Gandhi over Shimla Agreement
Congress leader Pawan Khera on Monday slammed BJP MP Nishikant Dubey , who questioned former Indian Prime Minister Indira Gandhi over the Shimla agreement . Pawan Khera called Nishikant Dubey a "quack" and urged the media not to pay attention to him. Taking a dig at Nishikant Dubey, the Congress leader said that he is not even a student from " WhatsApp University " but of "WhatsApp Nursery". Khera further asked Dubey to go to the Prime Minister's Office (PMO) and discontinue the Shimla Agreement. "Why are you (the media) wasting time on a quack? These are not even students of WhatsApp University but of WhatsApp nursery. Ask him to go to the PMO and tell them to discontinue the Simla Agreement. Why is he wasting time?", Pawan Khera told ANI. Earlier, Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) MP Nishikant Dubey targeted former Indian Prime Minister Indira Gandhi, alleging that she signed the Shimla Agreement between India and Pakistan under the pressure of the United States. Sharing a document of a Rajya Sabha debate on 'X', Nishikant Dubey questioned why Indian governed 5000 square mile territory was given to Pakistan by India's "iron lady".The BJP MP further queried why 57 Indian soldiers killed in Pakistan's jail dispute were returning the 93000 Pakistsoldiers, who had surrendered after the 1971 war. Live Events Nishikant Dubey mentioned that former Defence Minister Mahavir Tyagi had raised these questions, but former Indian PM Indira Gandhi left them unanswered. Earlier on Sunday, Nishikant Dubey slammed Rahul Gandhi , questioning the motives of the Congress leader to encourage learning English rather than local languages while also alluding to the "hypocrisy" of opposing the National Education Police (NEP) 2020 for language choice, stating that the 1986 NEP had similar goals. "Rahul Gandhi ji, your investigative advisor is hell bent on destroying you. This is the education policy of 1986 given by your father to the country. in this, your father is promising the country to promote Hindi, teach the Sanskrit language and translate English into regional languages. This same education policy is almost in place now. Students should also grow with regional languages, changes in this have been made by Prime Minister Modi ji in 2020," Dubey said in a post on X in Hindi.
