Premier powerless to axe misfiring KZN MECs
KZN Premier Thamsanqa Ntuli.
Image: Supplied
DESPITE calls for Premier Thamsanqa Ntuli to sack the under performing MECs for Health and Education in KwaZulu-Natal, his hands were said to be tied as any cabinet reshuffle would likely collapse the provincial power pact of the Government of Provincial Unity (GPU).
At the centre of the storm were Sipho Hlomuka, the MEC for Education, and Nomagugu Simelane-Mngadi, the MEC for Health, both senior ANC figures in KZN politics. Their departments account for the lion's share of the provincial budget, yet both have been rocked by controversy and dysfunction claims.
Hlomuka has been under fire from teacher unions amid the crisis besetting his department, including the delayed payment of Grade R teachers and non-payment of service providers. This has sparked widespread condemnation of the Education MEC.
UMphathiswa wezeMpilo KwaZulu-Natal uNksz Nomagugu Simelane, umnyango wakhe okweleta osomabhizinisi uR1.7 billion
Image: SIGCINIWE
Simelane-Mngadi who is at the helm of the ailing health department, has also been on receiving end of criticism from disgruntled service providers who were not paid. She revealed last week that her department owed them R1.7 billion.
Hlomuka was the deputy provincial secretary while Simelane-Mngadi was deputy provincial chairperson for thw ANC in KZN, before the provincial structure was reconfigured in February following poor showing during the last year's national elections.
MEC for Education in KwaZulu-Natal Sipho Hlomuka.
Image: Tumi Pakkies Independent Newspapers
Ntuli, in his capacity as premier, has the powers to appoint and remove members of the provincial executive council.
He is also the IFP provincial chairperson, and assembled his cabinet in June last year, following his election as premier of the province.
Despite the pressure, insiders said Ntuli cannot act unilaterally.
The GPU, an alliance between the Inkatha Freedom Party (IFP), African National Congress (ANC), Democratic Alliance (DA), and the National Freedom Party (NFP), was formed to govern the province after no party secured an outright majority in the last election. Any reshuffle would require consensus from all coalition partners.
This was part of the power-sharing deal agreed to by the said parties.
National Education, Health and Allied Workers' Union's (Nehawu) provincial secretary Ayanda Zulu said: "We are not happy with a lot of things that are happening in the department of health as Nehawu. We had a meeting with the MEC and raised the matters that concern us as the union."
Zulu said some of their concerns included the plight of workers amid the ongoing crisis in the department of health.
"Our biggest concern is the workers and people of the province who continue to receive bad service from the department of health," said Zulu.
A source in the provincial government said Ntuli's hands were tied and argued that any reshuffle without the agreement with GPU partners would" backfire spectacularly".
"The reality is that the premier is not happy with the performance of some of his MECs. But if he just replaced them. That would backfire spectacularly for him and this could even collapse the provincial government," said the source.
The provincial secretary for the South African Democratic Teachers Union (SADTU) said:" The problems in the education department in KZN are as a result of austerity measures (budget cuts ) and the cost cutting measures imposed by the Provincial Treasury and the Office of the Premier."
A Grade R teacher in KZN, who spoke on condition of anonymity, said:" The MEC is clearly failing. I think it's time the province gets a new MEC, maybe they will deliver. But again, the turnaround of the provincial department will not be an overnight thing because of the many crises the department is facing," said the teacher.
Another teachers' union, the National Teachers Union (NATU) have also previously called for accountability, and demanded Premier Ntuli to wield the axe over Hlomuka.
Attempts by Daily News to obtain responses from the offices of Premier Ntuli, MEC Hlomuka, and MEC Simelane-Mngadi were unsuccessful, as their spokespersons failed to respond to inquiries.
DAILY NEWS
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
eNCA
6 hours ago
- eNCA
Peaceful protest in front of US consulate
US consulate protest PRETORIA - The ANC is joining pro-Palestine groups to picket outside the US Consulate. They are protesting the ongoing Israeli strikes against Iran. Among the groups are Islamic Centre for Africa and the Holocaust Committee. The picket comes as US President Donald Trump considers the US involvement in the conflict.
IOL News
12 hours ago
- IOL News
Unclaimed bodies in South Africa's mortuaries drop below 3,000, says Motsoaledi
Health Minister Aaron Motsoaledi says there has been a general improvement in the management of unclaimed bodies in allstate mortuaries in provinces, as the number stood at 2,858 in February 2025, compared to 3,186 in August 2024. Image: Chris Collingridge / Independent Newspapers The number of unclaimed bodies at state mortuaries is showing signs of improvement, with figures reported at the end of February, revealing that the tally has dropped to 2,858, a decline from the 3,186 recorded in August 2024. This was disclosed by Health Minister Aaron Motsoaledi when he stated that there was a total of 3,819 pauper burials between April 2024 and April 2025 when he responded to parliamentary questions from ANC and Rise Mzansi parliamentarians. Motsoaledi said the total number of unclaimed bodies in state mortuaries due to next-of-kin being unknown stood at 2,858 as at the end of February. 'There has been a general improvement in the management of unclaimed bodies in all provinces. The total number of unclaimed bodies stood at 2,858 in February 2025, compared to 3,186 in August 2024,' he said. Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Next Stay Close ✕ Ad loading Motsoaledi stated that the number of unclaimed bodies did not remain static since families come forward to claim their loved ones, or the unclaimed bodies were buried as paupers. 'To date, the total number of pauper burials conducted in all provinces between 30 April 2024 and 30 April 2025 stood at 3,819.' He named Limpopo, Kwa-Zulu Natal, North West, Eastern Cape, and the Western Cape as the provinces that have made progress in the management of unclaimed bodies. Motsoaledi's responses showed that KwaZulu-Natal recorded 695 uncollected bodies in February, down from 1,527 recorded six months earlier, while the North West reduced the unclaimed bodies from 166 to 132. The Eastern Cape reduced its numbers from 526 to 485, and the Western Cape decreased the uncollected bodies from 299 to 176. The Free State also showed a decrease in uncollected bodies from 93 to 65, while Limpopo recorded a decrease from 315 to 267. However, Gauteng saw an upsurge from 176 uncollected bodies to 868 during the same period, Northern Cape recorded an increase from 31 to 71, and Mpumalanga's numbers increased from 53 to 99. Motsoaledi said the management of unclaimed bodies remained a collaborative effort between the Departments of Health and the SAPS, which was responsible for the identification of the unknown bodies and the tracing of the next of kin, and the municipalities that allocated burial sites and conducted pauper burials. The situation of uncollected bodies was complicated by illegal foreign nationals who sometimes provided wrong names when attended to in healthcare facilities.
IOL News
a day ago
- IOL News
The weaponisation of intelligence in SA politics
Nco Dube a political economist, businessman, and social commentator. Image: Supplied The recent revelation by former uMkhonto weSizwe Party Secretary General Floyd Shivambu, who claims he was sacked on the basis of a fake intelligence report, is neither new nor surprising in the context of South Africa's post-apartheid political landscape. Instead, it is the latest in a long line of controversies where unverified intelligence reports have been deployed as weapons in intra-party feuds, factional battles, and the broader contest for power, often with former president Jacob Zuma at the centre. The use of intelligence reports—real, doctored, or entirely fabricated—as tools for political ends is deeply embedded in our recent history. The so-called 'Browse Mole Report' is a prime example: a controversial document that allegedly implicated various political figures and was used as justification for decisive political actions, despite its questionable provenance. Throughout Zuma's presidency and beyond, a series of unverified intelligence reports have surfaced, each conveniently appearing at moments of heightened political tension, often to the detriment of Zuma's rivals or critics. These reports have not only been used to discredit opponents but have also served as pretexts for removals, suspensions, and even criminal investigations. The pattern is clear: intelligence, or at least the suggestion of it, becomes a bludgeon in the hands of those seeking to manipulate outcomes within the ANC (or its offshoots like the EFF and the MKP) and the state at large. Another one of the most infamous cases was the so-called 'Operation Check Mate' intelligence report. In March 2017, then-President Jacob Zuma abruptly instructed Finance Minister Pravin Gordhan to cancel an international investor roadshow and return to South Africa. The only explanation offered was an 'intelligence report' alleging that Gordhan was plotting with foreign interests in the UK and the US to overthrow the state. The report's existence and authenticity were never substantiated, and it was widely dismissed as a fabrication designed to justify Gordhan's removal and facilitate a cabinet reshuffle. In December 2021, journalist Thabo Makwakwa received a purported State Security Agency (SSA) report alleging that the United States had infiltrated the ANC's leadership to the point of influencing or subverting national policy. The report was used to justify a High Court gag order preventing publication, ostensibly for reasons of national security. However, the Supreme Court of Appeal later ruled that the classification of the report as 'secret' was unjustified and that its suppression served the political interests of the ANC, not the country. The court's decision exposed how the SSA's mechanisms were misused to fight internal ANC battles and highlighted the blurred lines between party and state. There have also been instances where fake intelligence reports were used to push false claims of judicial corruption. Political figures like Bantu Holomisa, Julius Malema, and former Public Protector Busisiwe Mkhwebane have been accused of leveraging such reports to undermine the judiciary's credibility. These tactics not only damage individual reputations but also erode public trust in key democratic institutions. Another example is the 'enemy of the state' dossier targeting the National Union of Metalworkers of South Africa (Numsa). This fake report surfaced during a period of intense labour and political contestation, aiming to discredit Numsa leaders and justify state surveillance or action against them. The report was later exposed as baseless, but not before it had caused significant disruption within the union and the broader labour movement. The Supreme Court of Appeal's rulings and investigative journalism have repeatedly shown how the SSA has been weaponised to serve the interests of particular ANC factions. The agency's resources and credibility have been compromised by their use in intra-party feuds, often with little regard for legality or national interest. Shivambu's claim that a fake intelligence report was used to justify his removal fits seamlessly into this established pattern. His experience reflects the broader reality of intelligence being weaponised in the service of political factionalism. The implications of his allegations are profound: they highlight the persistent challenge of verifying intelligence in a context where its very existence is often shrouded in secrecy and where the mere mention of a 'report' can be enough to destroy reputations and careers. Why Intelligence Is So Easily Weaponised South Africa's intelligence community has its roots in the clandestine operations of both the apartheid regime and the liberation movements. The skills, networks, and mindsets developed during those years did not simply disappear with the advent of democracy. Instead, they were repurposed, sometimes for noble ends, but often for the pursuit of personal or factional power. The ANC, as the dominant political force, has long been riven by internal divisions. Intelligence operatives and their reports are frequently drawn into these battles, not in the service of national security, but to gather dirt on rivals, discredit them, and sway internal elections. This dynamic has only intensified as the stakes have grown, with control of the state and its resources hanging in the balance. The Zuma Factor Jacob Zuma's career is inextricably linked with the intelligence world. As a former head of intelligence for the ANC in exile, Zuma has always understood the power of information and disinformation. His rise to power and his presidency were marked by a proliferation of intelligence-related scandals, from the so-called 'spy tapes' to the endless stream of dossiers implicating his enemies in plots, corruption, or treason. Zuma's embedded relationship with intelligence operatives, both official and shadowy, allows him to cultivate an aura of omniscience and threat: his opponents could never be sure what he knows, what he was willing to fabricate, or how far he would go to protect himself. The Mechanics of Fake Intelligence Reports Fake intelligence reports are typically crafted by individuals or groups with access to the language, format, and networks of the intelligence community. They are then leaked, sometimes anonymously, sometimes through willing intermediaries, to the media, party structures, or law enforcement agencies. The reports are rarely subjected to rigorous verification; their power lies in their ability to sow doubt and suspicion, not in their factual accuracy. Once in circulation, these reports serve multiple functions, discrediting political opponents by associating them with scandal or criminality. They then justify suspensions, removals, or investigations under the guise of 'due diligence,' creating an atmosphere of fear and mistrust, deterring would-be challengers from stepping out of line. The media, often hungry for scoops and exclusives, can become unwitting amplifiers of these reports. Even when journalists are sceptical, the mere existence of a 'leaked intelligence report' is newsworthy, and the damage to reputations is often irreversible, regardless of subsequent denials or debunking. Few, if any, of those responsible for producing or disseminating fake intelligence reports are ever held to account. The ephemeral nature of these documents and the secrecy that surrounds them make it difficult to trace responsibility or impose consequences. For those in power, the ability to instill fear and uncertainty is a potent weapon. Zuma's Legacy: Intelligence as a Source of Power and Control Zuma's presidency did not invent the use of intelligence as a political tool, but it did elevate it to an art form. By cultivating relationships with both official intelligence operatives and shadowy figures, Zuma created an environment where information, real or fabricated, became the currency of power. His willingness to deploy intelligence innuendo, to hint at plots and conspiracies, and to use reports (however dubious) as justification for political action has left a lasting mark on South African politics.
