Who pays the price?
When the MSC ELSA-3 sank off the Kerala coast, identifying a clear line of liability or even a coherent chain of operational command proved almost impossible. The flag state, Liberia, refused to participate in the investigation.
The Classification Society that had certified the ship as seaworthy only months earlier bore no accountability for oversight lapses. The German owner company maintained distance through limited liability. The Cyprus-based manager handled operations but carried no ultimate legal responsibility. Meanwhile, MSC—one of the world's largest shipping conglomerates—claimed only a commercial interest through charter.
This tangled structure is no anomaly. It is the result of a deliberately opaque system designed to prioritize legal insulation over accountability. The MSC ELSA-3 had changed names and flags at least 10 times in under two decades—moving from CSAV Barcelona to TMM Hidalgo to Delmas Tourville to MSC ELSA-3—each change coinciding with opportunities to limit legal exposure, avoid scrutiny, or benefit from lenient regulation.
While not illegal, this practice of shifting ownership, registry, and management undermines transparency and accountability. It stands at odds with the spirit of the international maritime framework set by the International Maritime Organization (IMO), which promotes safety and environmental responsibility.
At the time of the incident, MSC ELSA-3 flew the Liberian flag—a classic example of a Flag of Convenience (FoC), often chosen for minimal regulatory scrutiny.
But the vessel's operational complexity ran far deeper. It was owned by a German company, managed from Cyprus, chartered by MSC—a Swiss-based conglomerate—and certified by French classification society Bureau Veritas. Its crew was multinational, comprising seafarers from countries including Russia, the Philippines, and Ukraine.
This spiderweb of ownership, management, registry, and operation illustrates how modern commercial shipping is designed to disperse responsibility across jurisdictions.
In such setups, legal obligations are diluted across national borders, making it extraordinarily difficult for coastal states like India to enforce accountability or secure timely cooperation.
The issue is compounded by the lack of mandatory public disclosure on beneficial ownership, the actual role of commercial operators in daily navigation decisions, and the operational influence of ship managers. Even in cases where insurers such as P&I Clubs are involved, jurisdictional complications and multi-layered contracting structures delay compensation, investigation, and resolution.
For India, the lesson is urgent and clear. It must challenge this structural opacity. Ships calling at Indian ports must be subject to stricter requirements on transparency in ownership, crew composition, and management accountability. India must also push at the IMO for reforms mandating full disclosure of beneficial ownership, enhanced flag state obligations, and clearer delineation of managerial vs. operational control responsibilities.
The MSC ELSA-3 wasn't merely lost to rough seas or human error. It was a victim of a system that fragments responsibility until it disappears. Unless this system is challenged, similar disasters will keep playing out in coastal waters, with little hope for justice or meaningful accountability.
At the same time, such tragedies test not only our systems of rescue and recovery but also our sense of fairness, proportion, and justice.
The contrast in societal, legal, and media response to such events reveals a disquieting inconsistency in how accountability is perceived—and demanded—depending on the domain of disaster.
In the MSC ELSA-3 case, India's directorate general of shipping (DGS) promptly invoked provisions under the Merchant Shipping Act, 1958, launching a statutory investigation aligned with IMO's Casualty Investigation Code.
Pollution control and salvage efforts began swiftly. Nonetheless, public anger surged. Kerala Police filed criminal cases under the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS). The high court questioned why arrests hadn't been made.
Demands arose to apply international oil pollution laws—even though such conventions don't govern container vessels.
Now contrast this with the Air India Dreamliner crash. No FIRs were filed.
No pilot's family was harassed. The ministry of civil aviation launched an ICAO-compliant probe. Public debate remained within the bounds of regulatory procedure.
The US handling of the Baltimore bridge collapse offers a further contrast. Despite major loss and global media coverage, there was no rush to criminalise the incident. A factual investigation was led by the National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB), consistent with IMO protocols.
Only after evidence emerged did the US department of justice weigh criminal action.
India, too, is a party to multiple international conventions. The law is clear. The Merchant Shipping Act outlines a well-established process for marine casualty investigations. Internationally, the IMO framework is built on objectivity, fairness, and due process. Short-circuiting that process to satisfy public sentiment erodes global confidence in India's maritime administration. Investigations must be about finding facts—not scapegoats.
The writer is a senior official with the shipping ministry. The views expressed are personal. Identity has been withheld on request
Follow more information on
Air India plane crash in Ahmedabad here
. Get
real-time live updates
on rescue operations and check
full list of passengers onboard AI 171
.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hindustan Times
8 hours ago
- Hindustan Times
Two old boys from Sainik School in Andhra perform yoga during NZ-Vizag sea voyage
New Delhi, Two military veterans and former students of a Sainik School in Andhra Pradesh with a penchant for sailing are currently on a sea voyage from New Zealand to Visakhapatnam, and celebrated Yoga Day mid-sea on Saturday. Two old boys from Sainik School in Andhra perform yoga during NZ-Vizag sea voyage For Delhi-based strategic expert Commodore C Uday Bhaskar , this feat made his heart flush with delight. Bhaskar, also an alumnus of Sainik School Korukonda, said he was in its first batch when the institution began its journey in January 1962. "And, for us Saikorians , it is a matter of great pride as Andhra is in focus today on International Day of Yoga with Visakhapatnam being the centerpiece, and two of the old boys, both in their 60s, performed yoga onboard their boat 'Tystie', on their nautical voyage," he told PTI. As the world celebrated the 11th International Day of Yoga, Bhaskar also shared a note written by Vice Admiral M S Pawar , a former Deputy Chief of Naval Staff , on the duo's voyage. "The day was heralded by two 63-year-old alumni of the National Defence Academy, who are also classmates from Sainik School Korukonda Col Kolsani Srinivas and Capt CDNV Prasad, from the Navy, onboard their 34-ft-long boat named 'Tystie' sailing near the International Date Line in the Pacific," the former DCNS wrote. The 26-year-old boat is on a passage from New Zealand to India via Fiji and the next port of call is Noro in Solomon Islands, Vice Admiral Pawar wrote. Bhaskar said Vice Admiral Pawar is also a Saikorian and that makes this day very special for students and alumni of the Sainik School in Andhra Pradesh that itself has a rich legacy. "The school started in the old palace that was built over a century ago by a maharaja of the Gajapathi royal family . The school's Houses carry the names of the different historic dynasties, such as Gupta House, Maurya House, Pallava House, Kakatiya House, Ganapathi House, Chalukya House and Moghul House," he said. "When I was there, we had just few houses, and I was in Gajapathi House," he proudly recalled. This article was generated from an automated news agency feed without modifications to text.
Indian Express
9 hours ago
- Indian Express
Sewage flowing through ancient Siri Fort storm water drain concerning: Report
A field assessment report by a Delhi-based non-profit organisation has revealed unauthorised discharge of sewage into an ancient stormwater drain along the August Kranti Marg near Siri Fort, raising concerns about environmental degradation and public health hazards in the heart of South Delhi. The report has been shared with several offices, including that of the chief secretary, the Delhi Jal Board CEO, the Hauz Khas sub-divisional magistrate, and the National Green Tribunal (NGT). The affected channel, originally meant to carry only rainwater, stretches from the Malviya Nagar Assembly constituency to Greater Kailash and passes through densely populated and commercial areas, including Shahpur Jat village. The report was submitted on June 16 to Mekala Chaitanya Prasad, District Magistrate, South, by student interns from the National Institute of Construction Management and Research (NICMAR) in Pune and Chandigarh University, who are currently working with Delhi-based non-profit, Centre for Holistic Development (CHD). Prasad has since been transferred. It documents how the storm drain has been contaminated by untreated sewage, with photographic evidence showing stagnant, foul-smelling, discoloured water and widespread solid waste accumulation. 'Instead of clear rainwater, the channels are filled with discoloured water, consistent with the appearance of sewage,' the report states. It also points to visible discharge points and smaller outlets feeding into the main channel, indicating the presence of multiple unauthorised connections. The findings highlight that there is widespread misuse of rainwater infrastructure by nearby residential and commercial units. According to the report, there are four main causes behind the contamination: unregulated sewage connections, poor sewage infrastructure, weak enforcement, and a general lack of public awareness. 'Unregulated or illegal connections from residential and commercial establishments are directly discharging sewage into the rainwater drains, by passing the proper sewage treatment network,' it notes. The report also flags insufficient monitoring by authorities and a failure to penalise illegal practices, which has allowed the situation to persist. In terms of infrastructure, the report points out that many buildings may not be properly connected to the main sewage system, forcing them to illegally route waste into storm drains. This, combined with poor maintenance and lack of public knowledge about the consequences of such actions, has resulted in a drain that is now a breeding ground for health hazards. 'Stagnant sewage-filled drains become breeding grounds for disease vectors such as mosquitoes and other insects,' the report warns, citing risks of outbreaks of dengue, malaria, cholera, typhoid, among others. Beyond health risks, the accumulation of solid waste is also damaging the structural integrity of the drainage system, the report states. With the monsoon approaching, the report warns that such blockages could significantly reduce the drain's capacity, increasing the likelihood of local flooding and waterlogging. In response, the report recommends urgent and coordinated action by the authorities. It calls for a comprehensive survey of the rainwater drain network to identify and map all unauthorised sewage discharge points. It also stresses the need for strict enforcement, including penalties for violators, and an upgrade of the existing sewage infrastructure to ensure legal and adequate disposal systems. The team has proposed launching large-scale awareness campaigns to educate the public about the environmental and health consequences of polluting rainwater systems. 'Prompt and decisive action from your esteemed office is crucial to rectify this situation and ensure a healthier, cleaner, and safer environment for the residents of New Delhi,' the students wrote.
Hindustan Times
11 hours ago
- Hindustan Times
Texas man suffers burns on 40 percent of his body after saving dog from house fire
A Texas man has endured a harrowing ordeal after suffering third-degree burns to nearly half of his body while saving his dog from a house fire. The blaze, which was caused by a fuel leak, occurred at Zain Cano's San Antonio home on May 22, as reported by The People. A Texas man was left hospitalised for a month after a gas leak caused a fire; he ran inside to rescue his dog.(Reddit) (Also read: 'Struggle with English, cut lines, litter': Texas-based founder slams Gujaratis) According to Cano's detailed post on Reddit, the incident began when he had been working on his motorcycle and failed to secure the fuel line. The leaked petrol seeped into the carpet and ignited, triggering the house fire. 'Luckily I was the only one home at the time,' he wrote. 'But I realised my dog was in the house and ran in to get him.' Though Cano initially managed to escape the fire with minimal injuries, he rushed back into the flames upon realising that his dog, Clarence, was still inside. That act of bravery cost him dearly. Third-degree burns and prolonged hospital stay By the time Cano emerged with Clarence, the fire had engulfed the house. His girlfriend, Jenna Carter, later revealed through a GoFundMe appeal that Cano suffered third-degree burns covering 40% of his body and required an extended hospital stay lasting over a month. 'He's going to need multiple weeks of continuous medical care and help from me,' Carter wrote. 'He has to use a walker and cannot use his hands.' She added that the couple is now homeless and seeking donations to secure a temporary, accessible place to live during Cano's recovery. Community support and ongoing challenges Carter's fundraising page describes the couple's urgent need for a 'stable environment' where Cano can heal. 'Anything that's able to be contributed will help immensely and go straight into finding an affordable, handicap-friendly place to stay to make this transition for Zain as painless and worry-free as possible,' she explained. Cano, meanwhile, continues to grapple with the emotional and physical toll of the incident. 'The recovery process has been literally the worst experience of my life,' he shared on Reddit. 'I feel horrible because my family is now homeless because of my mistake. We're staying at a motel for the time being but it's expensive, and I can't work and probably won't be able to for at least another month or more.'
