FOCUS: Nippon Steel buyout spat hints at business fragility in U.S.
By Junko Horiuchi, KYODO NEWS - 7 minutes ago - 13:07 | Japan, All
U.S. President Donald Trump's bid to attract investment threatens to undermine the appetite for corporate spending in an ironic twist, with the 18-month saga over Nippon Steel Corp.'s buyout of United States Steel Corp. showing the growing vulnerability of businesses in the U.S. market, according to analysts.
The U.S. administration's earlier blocking of the $14.1 billion takeover deal was clearly driven by political motives and corporate executives will no longer be able to make decisions regarding their U.S. operations based only business criteria, they said.
The wrangling in the high-profile case could lead global companies to think twice about making sizeable investments and acquisitions in the world's largest economy, with many moving to reduce their exposure to the U.S. market.
"I do think many companies are pausing investments and major capital expenditures, not only because of the Nippon-U.S. Steel deal but due to general uncertainty surrounding political and economic dynamics in Washington," said Zack Cooper, senior fellow at the American Enterprise Institute.
Trump had repeatedly rejected Nippon Steel's plan to take full control of U.S. Steel.
But Nippon Steel, the world's fourth-largest steel producer, and U.S. Steel, the 29th largest, said Wednesday following Trump's approval of the buyout plan that they had signed a national security agreement with the U.S. government and finalized the acquisition transaction.
Under the deal, the Japanese steelmaker is obliged to invest $11 billion by 2028 on bolstering the U.S. steelmaker's operations, far more than the previously planned $2.7 billion.
The U.S. government also obtained a golden share allowing it to veto key management decisions, such as when reducing investment, shedding production capacity in the United States or closing plants.
Nippon Steel CEO Eiji Hashimoto told a press conference on Thursday that his company had learned from a year and a half of negotiations with the U.S. government that a flexible management strategy is required.
The top executive said it had been believed that governments should not get involved in business deals.
"But now...governments are strengthening their involvement in economic and business matters through industrial policy," he said.
Trump's predecessor, Joe Biden, initially blocked the purchase of U.S. Steel on national security grounds, saying the manufacturing icon, based in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania -- a key battleground state in the 2024 presidential election -- should be "American-owned and American-operated."
Trump also opposed the deal during the presidential race, saying the acquisition of a minority stake in U.S. Steel would not cause any issues, but foreign ownership of the company would not be good psychologically. He ordered a new review of the deal by the Committee on Foreign Investment in the United States in April with a deadline for Trump to make a final decision initially set for June 5.
"Because predictability is insanely low right now in the United States, Japanese companies are going to cut back the percentage of their business in the country," said Keisuke Hanyuda, the chief executive of Owls Consulting Group.
While rising costs must be dealt with, "The last thing a business wants is to lose predictability," said Hanyuda, a former Japanese trade ministry official in charge of trade talks.
Nippon Steel is betting on firm demand for high-tensile strength steel in the U.S. market, capitalizing on its advanced production technology for high-end steel plates used in products such as electric vehicles.
The United States is one of three growth markets for the Japanese steelmaker, compensating for shrinking domestic demand.
Under Trump, the steel, aluminum, auto and semiconductor sectors have been targeted by specific tariffs driven by political pressures and companies in these industries should consider other markets for growth to hedge their risks, analysts say.
Earlier this month, Trump signed an order doubling the tariffs on steel and aluminum imports to 50 percent.
"I think Japanese companies will have a difficult time purchasing famous American companies in sectors that President Trump prioritizes, such as autos, steel, aluminum, and chipmaking," Cooper at the American Enterprise Institute said, though investment in other sectors may still be viable.
"But any Japanese company that is considering a major deal in the United States should develop a detailed political strategy before announcing a deal, lest they suffer similar roadblocks as Nippon Steel," he said.
The United States remains a lucrative market with high growth potential but some global companies are beginning to reduce their reliance on it after the tariffs imposed by Trump, Hanyuda said.
The European Union and the Association of Southeast Asian Nations, for example, have resumed economic partnership negotiations, while the EU is also looking at Japan, which is part of a trans-Pacific free trade pact that took effect in 2018 without the United States.
Related coverage:
U.S. Steel's strategic importance growing: Nippon Steel CEO
Nippon Steel finalizes deal to make U.S. Steel wholly owned
Trump effectively approves Nippon Steel's takeover of U.S. Steel
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Asahi Shimbun
31 minutes ago
- Asahi Shimbun
Hotels work to retain foreign staff to tackle labor shortage
Nguyen Thi Thuy and Nguyen Thi Nhung who work at a hotel operated by Sumitomo Realty and Development Co. in Tokyo's Ota Ward in June (Takeshi Owada) As inbound tourism to Japan skyrockets, the hospitality industry is facing a labor shortage and is increasingly relying on foreign staff to clean rooms, make beds and keep hotels running. Hotel operators are therefore enhancing their efforts to train and retain foreign staff to secure workers. On June 17, a reception was held at a hall in Haneda Airport for Vietnamese technical intern trainees working at a hotel owned by Sumitomo Realty and Development Co. A video of the event will be shown to their families in Vietnam later. The group hired its first 80 Vietnamese trainees in 2019, and in 2024, it increased the number to 400. They are all Vietnamese women and, between them, oversee about 3,500 rooms out of the group's total of about 5,350 hotel rooms. Tomoyuki Komori, president of Villa Fontaine Hotel, which is operated by the company, said, 'They are extremely talented. They greet guests with a smile, so they have a great reputation with the guests.' Komori said the hotel plans to hire more staff in the future. The labor shortage in the industry is serious. According to a labor force survey by the internal affairs ministry, the number of employees in the hospitality industry stood at 580,000 as of 2024 and has not recovered to its pre-pandemic level of 650,000 in 2019. The employment vacancy rate in the accommodation and food services industry was 4.4 percent, higher than the 2.9 percent rate for all industries, according to a survey conducted by the labor ministry on employment trends for the first half of 2024. For this reason, hotel operators are turning to foreign staff as the human resources needed to support on-site operations, and are working to retain them by providing detailed support. Sumitomo Realty and Development promotes foreign staff to on-site supervisor positions, or other positions with salary increases, after three or five years of service as incentives to stay with the company. Particular attention is paid to the families of foreign workers. Since 2019, the company has held a total of eight company information sessions and get-togethers for families in Hanoi and Ho Chi Minh City, showing videos of their children at work and enjoying barbecues. Nguyen Thi Thuy, 23, is a staff member who joined the company in 2023. 'I want to make use of what I have learned when I return home after gaining experience,' she said. Another employee, Nguyen Thi Nhung, 25, who joined the company in 2022, said, 'I want to study more so that I can contribute to the company and support my family financially.' Daiwa House Industry Co. manages 56 hotels nationwide, where 777 Indonesian women work as of May. The company hires 200 people a year who have studied at Japanese language schools in Indonesia. Once they join the company, they are evaluated once every three months on their ability, motivation and Japanese language level. Their performance is then reflected in their grade, salary increase and promotion opportunities. Kazuhisa Yamamoto, who heads the hotel support department at Daiwa Lifenext Co., said, 'We give back through raises and promotions so that their motivation continues.' Mori Trust Hotels and Resorts Co. had 99 foreign employees as of the end of fiscal 2024, accounting for 9.7 percent of its total workforce. Since February, the company has been working to enable a diverse workplace to play an active role by holding a trial Japanese language course focusing on 'omotenashi' hospitality with university lecturers. It has also held competitions and other events for foreign staff and Japanese employees to work together to come up with company-wide initiatives. Miwako Date, the company president who is also the vice chair of the Japan Association of Corporate Executives (Keizai Doyukai), said that the central government has set a target of attracting 60 million annual visitors to Japan by 2030. 'There is increasing concern about a labor shortage in the hospitality industry,' she said. 'We would like to build a system to accommodate travelers with a high-quality experience so that there will be no opportunities lost in one of the few growth industries in Japan.'
Asahi Shimbun
33 minutes ago
- Asahi Shimbun
Poll: Japanese opinion of South Korea up from 10 years prior
A recent survey has revealed sentiments and perceptions of current Japan–South Korea relations have improved among residents of both countries compared to a similar survey taken a decade ago. This latest joint public opinion survey was conducted by The Asahi Shimbun and South Korea's Dong-A Ilbo to mark the 60th anniversary of the normalization of diplomatic relations between Japan and South Korea. On the Japanese side, those who said they 'like' South Korea increased from 10 percent in 2015 to 19 percent this time around. Those who felt that Japan–South Korea relations are 'going well' rose from 7 percent to 29 percent. Even so, views on the future of the bilateral relationship remained mostly unchanged from a decade ago, with only 17 percent of Japanese respondents believing ties will move in a 'positive direction.' BILATERAL FEELINGS IMPROVED This year's survey was conducted by phone in both countries, while the 2015 joint survey relied on the post on the Japanese side, making a direct comparison of the figures difficult. However, compared to the strained relations at that time, in the wake of events such as the 2012 visit by then South Korean President Lee Myung-bak to Takeshima, known as Dokdo in South Korea, and the 2013 visit by then Prime Minister Shinzo Abe to Yasukuni Shrine, current relations appear more favorable. On the South Korean side, those who said they 'like' Japan increased from 5 percent in the previous survey to 23 percent. Those who said they 'dislike' Japan dropped from 50 percent to 23 percent, while those who answered 'neither' increased from 43 percent to 54 percent. In Japan, older age groups were less favorable toward South Korea 10 years ago. However, in the survey this time, age differences were small, except that only 12 percent of respondents in their 40s answered that they like South Korea. Twenty-two percent of those in their 60s and the same ratio of those in their 30s answered that they liked South Korea. The proportion of people who said they 'dislike' South Korea was especially low among those in their 30s and younger, at around 5 percent. Among older generations, the figure was around 15 percent, with little variation by age. When asked about the current state of Japan–South Korea relations, 29 percent of Japanese respondents said the relationship was 'going well,' while 50 percent said it was 'not going well.' In the previous survey, those figures were 7 percent and 86 percent, respectively. So, the survey this time showed a significant improvement. On the South Korean side, 3 percent of the respondents said it was 'going well' and 90 percent said it was 'not going well' the last time. But the numbers shifted to 26 percent and 59 percent, respectively, this time. However, when asked about the future of Japan--South Korea relations, Japanese optimism remained low. Only 17 percent responded that the relationship would go in a 'positive direction,' nearly unchanged from the 15 percent of 10 years ago. Those who said it would go in a 'negative direction' was 14 percent, which increased from 10 percent in 2015, and those who believed it would 'remain the same' were 61 percent, decreased from 67 percent in 2015. While the Japanese outlook for future Japan–South Korea relations remains cautious, South Korean respondents showed a more positive trend. Those who said the relationship would move in a 'positive direction' doubled from 22 percent to 42 percent, making it the most common response. Those who expected it to worsen increased from 11 percent to 20 percent, and those who said it would remain the same dropped from 60 percent to 31 percent. HISTORICAL TENSIONS REMAIN In the joint poll, respondents were also asked about historical issues, including Japan's colonialization of the Korea Peninsula from 1910 to 1945. In Japan, opinions were evenly split: 46 percent respondents said the issues had been 'resolved,' while the same percentage of respondents said they had 'not been resolved.' In South Korea, 17 percent said the issues had been 'resolved,' up from 2 percent a decade ago, while those who said they had 'not been resolved' dropped from 95 percent to 80 percent. Although there are signs of a shift toward a more future-oriented perspective, a considerable gap in perceptions of historical issues still remains between the two countries. This year's survey was conducted by telephone in both countries. In contrast, the 2015 joint survey was conducted via postal mail in Japan, so a direct numerical comparison is difficult. At that time, 49 percent of Japanese respondents said the issue had been resolved, while 42 percent said it had not. Respondents were also asked whether they believed Japan had sufficiently apologized for its annexation of Korea and colonial rule. In Japan, 67 percent said the country had 'apologized sufficiently,' while 22 percent said the apologies were 'still insufficient.' These numbers were similar to the 2015 results, with 65 percent and 20 percent, respectively. In South Korea, 13 percent said Japan had 'apologized sufficiently,' while 85 percent said the apologies were 'still insufficient.' These figures on the South Korean side reflect a certain degree of change from 10 years ago when 1 percent were satisfied with the apology and 96 percent said it was not enough. However, the majority still believe Japan's attempts to make amends are not enough. Regarding the historical issues in Japan–South Korea relations, the two governments agreed at the end of 2015 that the issue of wartime 'comfort women' was 'finally and irreversibly resolved.' Despite this shared official stance, strong domestic criticism in South Korea against the agreement has been persistent, and effectively became a mere formality following the change in the South Korean administration in 2017. Regarding the issue of wartime mobilized workers, the South Korean Supreme Court ordered Japanese companies to compensate the South Korean wartime laborers in 2018. The companies did not comply with the order. Under then President Yoon Suk-yeol, the South Korean government proposed a solution in 2023 where a state-affiliated foundation would provide compensation on behalf of the Japanese companies, funded by donations. FINDING PARTICIPANTS On the Japanese side, The Asahi Shimbun carried out the survey with eligible voters on June 7 and 8, using both landline and mobile phone numbers that were randomly generated by computer. A total of 1,124 of 2,824 voters who received the phone call provided valid responses The Dong-A Ilbo conducted the survey in South Korea through a private research institution. The survey was conducted on those 18 and older on June 9 and 10 using mobile phone numbers that were also randomly generated by computer. A total of 1,010 of 13,828 people who received the phone call provided valid answers to the survey. (This article was written by Yasuhito Watanabe and Nozomi Matsui.)
39 minutes ago
Hit the Brakes: Slowdown in Japan Auto Exports to the United States
The impact of US President Donald Trump's tariffs has led to a sudden slowdown in Japanese auto exports to the United States. Japan's auto industry appears to have responded by lowering its prices to absorb the impact of the tariffs, prompting some analysts to predict a major blow to the profits of the industry as a whole. On top of his tariffs applied across the board to Japanese exports to the US market, Trump imposed an additional 25% tariff on automobiles and auto parts. The Japanese government has been negotiating with the United States in an effort to have the tariffs removed, but no agreement has been reached as of June. Recently, Trump has talked about further increasing the automotive tariffs. Trade statistics from the Ministry of Finance show that in May, the second month since the initial imposition of tariffs on automobiles, the export value of Japanese cars to the United States was ¥363.4 billion, which was the lowest level for over a year. This was down 24.7% compared with May 2024, far greater than the equivalent 4.8% year-on-year drop in April. While the decrease in the number of vehicles sold was only 3.9%, the fall in unit price was 21.7%. As there has been little change in the value of the yen since April, this is not a factor in reduced prices. NLI Research Institute suggests that Japanese automakers are absorbing a certain amount of the tariff costs by lowering prices. An estimate produced by the institute forecasts that if export prices continue to be reduced by 10%, this would mean a decrease in ordinary profits of ¥1.3 trillion for Japan's auto industry in fiscal 2025. This could be a greater hit than the fall resulting from a 10% reduction in sales volume, such as that seen if tariff costs were passed on to buyers in the form of higher prices. As noted by Saitō Tarō, who heads the institute's economic research department, 'Even if lower prices keep volume high, variable costs for things like materials will put major pressure on profits.' Impact of Trump Tariffs on Japanese Auto Industry (YOY) 10% reduction in sales volume Ordinary profits: Down ¥0.2 trillion Variable costs rate: Unchanged 10% reduction in prices Ordinary profits: Down ¥1.3 trillion Variable costs rate: Up 1.2% Taken by from an estimate by NLI Research Institute. The variable costs rate refers to the ratio of variable costs to sales. Data Sources (Translated from Japanese. Banner photo © Pixta.)
