Alberta companies ordered to repay almost $165K to temporary foreign workers
Two Alberta-based companies are appealing Ontario labour ministry decisions that say they charged temporary foreign workers tens of thousands of dollars to be placed in retail jobs at a Canadian Tire. The companies were ordered to repay almost $165,000.
Some of the workers were originally from the Philippines but ended up at a Canadian Tire in Etobicoke, Ont. Though they said they each paid up to $7,900 US to an Alberta company to get the position, once they got the jobs, they say they were underpaid and poorly treated.
Many of the workers quit and found jobs in Atlantic Canada and other provinces around the country.
An employment standards officer from the Ontario Ministry of Labour conducted an investigation following a series of complaints from workers in October 2023. The ministry issued repayment orders on May 14 against Allison Jones Consulting and AJ Immigration Group in eight cases. Both companies share an owner, Allison Jones, and a common address in St. Albert, Alta.
Allison Jones declined an interview and told CBC News via email that the companies are appealing the decisions.
"We trust the appeal process and are committed to a fair and accurate resolution based on a complete review of the facts," she wrote.
One of the workers who received the recent decision was Rowell Pailan, who previously shared his story with CBC News from his home in Wolfville, N.S.
Pailan says he came to Canada in 2023 after being offered a position as a stock clerk supervisor at an Ontario Canadian Tire. However, paystubs he showed CBC News indicated that while he started being paid at the wage in his contract, his wages were later reduced, making it challenging for him to pay his bills and provide for his family in the Philippines.
He says he got the position after he paid the fee to Jones' company using money borrowed from family members.
The Ontario Labour Ministry's employment standards officer said Jones should repay Pailan $10,655.52 in Canadian dollars, the calculated equivalent of the $7,900 US he paid in 2022, plus a ten per cent administration fee.
"I [was] so happy and teary-eyed, because finally I got justice," he said in a phone interview.
"Maybe they [were] thinking that they can do whatever they want, because we are eager to come into Canada," Pailan said, adding that he wants to send a message that people should not "take advantage" of temporary foreign workers.
"We didn't have any idea about the amount in regards to the immigration fee, or whatever it is to come into Canada."
Companies acted together, decision says
It's illegal under federal and Ontario law for a recruiter to charge a foreign worker for a job placement; the recruiter is supposed to be paid by the employer.
However, it is legal to charge a fee for immigration advice or assistance with immigration paperwork.
In the written decision issued to Pailan and reviewed by CBC News, a lawyer for the two companies told the employment standards officer that Allison Jones Consulting and AJ Immigration are "separate and independent" companies, each with their own branding and invoicing.
The lawyer told the officer that Allison Jones Consulting charged Canadian Tire for recruiting services, while AJ Immigration Group was a separate entity that provided immigration services to the foreign workers and charged them fees for these services.
This did not convince employment standards officer Charles Beauparlant, who concluded the fees were not legal because both companies were related. He found they shared "common management" in the owner, Allison Jones.
"It does not change the fact that both businesses functioned as one comprehensive and unified business," Beauparlant wrote in his decision in Pailan's case.
Jones' position, according to the lawyer, was that she is the "directing mind" behind the recruitment company, but not the other company as she "does not participate in the day-to-day operation of AJ Immigration."
In her email to CBC News, Jones re-stated her position.
"We respectfully disagree with the findings and with the characterization of these two companies — Allison Jones Consulting Services Inc. and AJ Immigration Group Inc. — as a 'unified business,' " she wrote.
"Each is a distinct legal entity, and both maintain that their respective practices fully comply with applicable legislation."
Beauparlant found that evidence like employee emails and information on Jones' two business websites showed both companies were sharing employees and that Jones was the "controlling mind" behind both.
He also noted that Jones was described as the leader of both companies in a sentence on the website for Allison Jones Consulting that read: "She has successfully led the companies since inception creating one of Canada's leading recruitment agencies and immigration consultancies."
As well, Beauparlant wrote, "having AJ Immigration Group Inc. collect fees through a retainer agreement after each phase of recruitment demonstrates not only their involvement but further confirms that AJ Immigration was assisting in the process of finding the claimant employment."
Pailan previously told CBC News that he had to pay in three stages.
The officer issued identical orders to both of Jones' companies, but the Ontario Labour Ministry told CBC News the intent was that the companies should repay Pailan "jointly," not twice over.
The ministry also fined Allison Jones Consulting $250 for each of the eight cases, totalling $2,000.
'An affront to our entire system'
Chris Ramsaroop is an instructor at the University of Toronto and an organizer with Justice for Migrant Workers, which supported Pailan's case.
He says it concerns him that workers must be the ones to ensure the process is followed.
"There's an expectation that [the workers] need to come forward, rather than the province or the federal government taking steps to protect the interests of workers," he said.
"This is an affront to our entire system — this is disgusting."
Ramsaroop feels temporary foreign workers like Pailan are in extremely vulnerable positions, and placing the onus on them to pursue the case to the next level when there is an appeal is a high burden.
Pailan says he worries that he won't get the money back after an appeal.
"That amount is not a joke, it's totally big," he said, adding that he's trying to repay his relatives who lent him the money.
Ramsaroop noted that temporary foreign workers are often tied to a single job by virtue of the closed-permit system, which makes their position in Canada vulnerable.
"These injustices will continue as a result of a system where we have workers tied to a particular employer," he said.
WATCH | Why this professor believes closed permit system should end:
Canadian Tire store still under investigation
The Ontario Ministry of Labour confirmed it's also investigating complaints against the Canadian Tire store where the workers were employed, but the case is still open.
There is a separate federal investigation underway by Employment and Social Development Canada into that Canadian Tire, but as of early June, it wasn't complete either.
The store owner, Ezhil Natarajan, previously told CBC News he "vehemently denies" all the allegations against him.
Canadian Tire Corporation made a policy change in the fall of 2024 to prohibit its stores from using recruiters that charge fees to temporary foreign workers.
The corporation said it made the decision together with its dealers, who own franchised stores and make their own hiring decisions.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
35 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Latin Metals Signs Definitive Option Agreement for Huachi Copper-Gold Project, San Juan Province, Argentina
VANCOUVER, British Columbia, June 23, 2025 (GLOBE NEWSWIRE) -- Latin Metals Inc. ("Latin Metals" or the "Company") - (TSXV: LMS) (OTCQB: LMSQF) is pleased to announce that it has entered into a definitive option agreement (the "Agreement") with Golden Arrow Resources Corp. ("Golden Arrow") to acquire up to a 100% interest in the Huachi property ("Huachi"), a 3,500-hectare copper-gold project located in San Juan Province, Argentina (see previous news release, dated March 13, 2024). The Huachi property is immediately contiguous with Latin Metals' Esperanza project (Figure 1). Figure 1: Location of the Huachi property, located immediately west of the Company's Esperanza property, San Juan Province, Argentina. Definitive Agreement Terms Latin Metals has the right to acquire an initial 75% interest in the Huachi property by completing US$1,000,000 in exploration expenditures and US$1,000,000 in cash payments to Golden Arrow over a four-year period (Table 1). Upon earning the 75% interest, Latin Metals has a Top-Up Right to acquire the remaining 25% interest (for an aggregate 100% ownership) by paying US$2,000,000 in cash to Golden Arrow within 90 days (Table 1). Should Latin Metals choose not to exercise the Top-Up Right, the parties will form a joint venture (JV) with Latin Metals holding 75% and Golden Arrow 25%. Each party will fund its pro-rata share of future expenditures. A party diluting below 15% will have its interest converted to a 1% net smelter return (NSR) royalty. Work commitments and cash payments commence on the first anniversary of approval of the environmental permit (Declaración de Impacto Ambiental or DIA), approving the start of exploration activities including drilling (the "Commencement Date").Anniversary Following the Commencement Date WorkCommitmentUSD CashPaymentsUSD Vesting First Anniversary $100,000 $100,000 - Second Anniversary $150,000 $150,000 - Third Anniversary $250,000 $250,000 - Fourth Anniversary $500,000 $500,000 75% Top-Up Right - $2,000,000 25% Total $1,000,000 $3,000,000 100% About the Esperanza and Huachi Projects The Esperanza project hosts a partially defined copper-gold porphyry system, with surface expression of a pyrite halo measuring 1,400m x 850m. Historical drilling by Latin Metals returned 387m @ 0.57% Cu and 0.27 g/t Au, including 166m @ 0.84% Cu and 0.37 g/t Au from surface. Mineralization remains open in all directions and at depth, with vectors suggesting continuity westward toward the Huachi project. Latin Metals previously entered into an option agreement regarding the Esperanza and Huachi properties with Atlantic Metals Limited, a wholly owned subsidiary of Moxico Resources plc., a private copper mining company with producing and development assets in Zambia and the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, made as of October 7, 2024 (see previous news release dated October 8, 2024)Latin Metals Inc. is a copper, gold and silver exploration company operating in Peru and Argentina under a prospect generator model, minimizing risk and dilution while maximizing discovery potential. With 18 projects, the company secures option agreements with major mining companies to fund exploration. Current option holders include AngloGold Ashanti (Organullo Gold Project) and Moxico Resources (Esperanza & Huachi Copper-Gold Projects). This approach provides early-stage exposure to high-value mineral assets. Latin Metals is actively seeking new strategic partners to advance its Metals recently presented and met with investors at three investor events: 121 Mining Investment Conference – London (May 12–13, 2025) Deutsche Goldmesse – Frankfurt (May 16–17, 2025) THE Mining Event – Quebec City (June 3–5, 2025) Upcoming investor conferences include: The Rule Symposium on Natural Resource Investing 2025 - Florida (July 7-11, 2025) These events provide key opportunities to showcase Latin Metals' progress and introduce its high-quality portfolio to new strategic and institutional Latin Metals on YouTube, X, Facebook, LinkedIn and Instagram to stay informed on our latest developments, exploration updates, and corporate Leon, QP, is the Company's qualified person as defined by NI 43-101 and has reviewed the scientific and technical information that forms the basis for portions of this news release. He has approved the disclosure herein. Mr. Leon is not independent of the Company, as he is an employee of the Company and holds securities of the Company. On Behalf of the Board of Directors of LATIN METALS INC. 'Keith Henderson' President & CEO For further details on the Company, readers are referred to the Company's website ( and its Canadian regulatory filings on SEDAR+ at For further information, please contact: Keith HendersonSuite 890 - 999 West Hastings Street,Vancouver, BC, V6C 2W2E-mail: info@ Elyssia Patterson, VP Investor RelationsEmail: elyssia@ 778-683-4324 Neither TSX Venture Exchange nor its Regulation Services Provider (as that term is defined in the policies of the TSX Venture Exchange) accepts responsibility for the adequacy or accuracy of this news news release contains forward-looking statements and forward-looking information (collectively, "forward-looking statements") within the meaning of applicable Canadian and U.S. securities legislation, including the United States Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. All statements, other than statements of historical fact, included herein including, without limitation, the anticipated content, commencement, timing and cost of exploration programs in respect of the Property and otherwise, anticipated exploration program results from exploration activities, and the Company's expectation that it will be able to enter into agreements to acquire interests in additional mineral properties, the discovery and delineation of mineral deposits/resources/reserves on the Properties, and the anticipated business plans and timing of future activities of the Company, are forward-looking statements. Although the Company believes that such statements are reasonable, it can give no assurance that such expectations will prove to be correct. Often, but not always, forward looking information can be identified by words such as "pro forma", "plans", "expects", "may", "should", "budget", "scheduled", "estimates", "forecasts", "intends", "anticipates", "believes", "potential" or variations of such words including negative variations thereof, and phrases that refer to certain actions, events or results that may, could, would, might or will occur or be taken or achieved. In making the forward-looking statements in this news release, the Company has applied several material assumptions, including without limitation, market fundamentals will result in sustained precious and base metals demand and prices, the receipt of any necessary permits, licenses and regulatory approvals in connection with the future development of the Company's Argentine projects in a timely manner, the availability of financing on suitable terms for the development, construction and continued operation of the Company projects, and the Company's ability to comply with environmental, health and safety laws. Forward-looking statements involve known and unknown risks, uncertainties and other factors which may cause the actual results, performance or achievements of the Company to differ materially from any future results, performance or achievements expressed or implied by the forward-looking information. Such risks and other factors include, among others, operating and technical difficulties in connection with mineral exploration and development and mine development activities at the Properties, including the geological mapping, prospecting and sampling programs being proposed for the Properties (the "Programs"), actual results of exploration activities, including the Programs, estimation or realization of mineral reserves and mineral resources, the timing and amount of estimated future production, costs of production, capital expenditures, the costs and timing of the development of new deposits, the availability of a sufficient supply of water and other materials, requirements for additional capital, future prices of precious metals and copper, changes in general economic conditions, changes in the financial markets and in the demand and market price for commodities, possible variations in ore grade or recovery rates, possible failures of plants, equipment or processes to operate as anticipated, accidents, labour disputes and other risks of the mining industry, delays or the inability of the Company to obtain any necessary permits, consents or authorizations required, any current or future property acquisitions, financing or other planned activities, changes in laws, regulations and policies affecting mining operations, hedging practices, currency fluctuations, title disputes or claims limitations on insurance coverage and the timing and possible outcome of pending litigation, environmental issues and liabilities, risks related to joint venture operations, and risks related to the integration of acquisitions, as well as those factors discussed under the heading as well as those factors discussed under the heading 'Risk Factors' in the Company's annual management's discussion and analysis and other filings of the Company with the Canadian Securities Authorities, copies of which can be found under the Company's profile on the SEDAR+ website at Readers are cautioned not to place undue reliance on forward looking statements. Except as otherwise required by law, the Company undertakes no obligation to update any of the forward-looking information in this news release or incorporated by reference herein. A photo accompanying this announcement is available at
San Francisco Chronicle
40 minutes ago
- San Francisco Chronicle
F1 owner Liberty Media finally set to seal deal to take control of MotoGP after European approval
Liberty Media's made a successful business of racing on four wheels. Now, it's time for two wheels. Formula 1 owner Liberty Media is finally set to complete a deal to take control of motorcycle racing series MotoGP after receiving approval from the European Commission. Liberty Media said Monday the 'unconditional' approval was the last step in completing the deal to buy 84% of Spain-based MotoGP rights holder Dorna Sports. It values Dorna at 4.3 billion euros ($4.97 billion), Liberty said. 'MotoGP is a highly attractive premium sports asset with incredible racing, a passionate fanbase and a strong cash flow profile," Liberty Media president and CEO Derek Chang said in a statement. "We believe the sport and brand have significant growth potential, which we will look to realize through deepening the connection with the core fan base and expanding to a wider global audience.' Liberty said the deal, which was first announced in April 2024, could go through by July 3. The process was held up in December when the European Commission opened what it called an 'in-depth investigation' into whether the agreement would hike the cost of broadcast rights for motorsports events. The European Commission said its investigation found F1 and MotoGP are 'not close competitors for the licensing of broadcasting rights for sports content' in national markets, and that broadcasters would be able to choose from other sports with similarly large audiences. 'Therefore, the transaction will not remove important competitive constraints between Formula 1 and MotoGP,' the commission said in a statement. Liberty Media immediately transformed how F1 was run when it took over in 2017. The U.S. company installed its own people in key positions to end decades with Bernie Ecclestone in charge. This time, it's keeping key staff in place. MotoGP management keeps a minority stake and long-time Dorna chief executive Carmelo Ezpeleta remains in charge of MotoGP. But Liberty said he will be joined on the Dorna board by Chase Carey and Sean Bratches, two veterans of Liberty's takeover of F1 in 2017. They were part of its efforts to grow and modernize F1 as a business, especially in the United States. Since then, F1 has attracted a new audience through the Netflix docu-series 'Drive To Survive' and expanded its calendar to a record 24 races, including lucrative new showpieces in locations like Miami, Las Vegas and Saudi Arabia. MotoGP is running a 22-race calendar this year. It includes events in markets where F1 has either never raced, like Indonesia, the Czech Republic and Thailand, or hasn't raced in years, like Argentina and Malaysia. Four of the MotoGP races are in Spain, with only one in the U.S., at the Circuit of the Americas in Austin, Texas in March. The Circuit of the Americas is one of five tracks which host both F1 and MotoGP this year. ___
Yahoo
41 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Novo Nordisk ends Wegovy sales on Hims & Hers over "deceptive marketing"
Novo Nordisk is pulling the plug on its partnership with Hims & Hers Health over claims that the telehealth company sold fake versions of the pharmaceutical firm's weight-loss drug, Wegovy. The Danish drugmaker said Monday that Wegovy will no longer be available on Hims & Hers and that it is ending the collaboration because the San Francisco-based online health company sold "illegitimate, knockoff versions of Wegovy that put patient safety at risk." Novo Nordisk's move to dissolve the partnership came less than two months after the companies said they were entering a "long-term collaboration" to make obesity treatment more accessible. Shares of Hims & Hers plunged more than $20, or roughly 31%, to $44.10 following Novo Nordisk's announcement. Hims & Hers did not immediately respond to a request for comment. Novo Nordisk said it began selling Wegovy via telehealth companies, including Hims & Hers, after a nationwide shortage of the drug. In offering the drug through more retailers, Novo Nordisk said it wanted to shift patients from using "knock-off, compounded versions" of Wegovy to the Food and Drug Administration-approved semaglutide drug. "After over one month into the collaboration, Hims & Hers Health, Inc. has failed to adhere to the law which prohibits mass sales of compounded drugs under the false guise of 'personalization' and are disseminating deceptive marketing that put patient safety at risk," a Novo Nordisk spokesperson told CBS MoneyWatch. "This is unacceptable, and that is why we have decided to end the collaboration." The FDA approved Wegovy for adults with obesity in March 2024, adding it to an expanding market of weight-loss drugs that include Ozempic and Mounjaro. Demand for GLP-1 drugs, which are used to treat diabetes and weight loss, has surged in recent years, with one in eight U.S. adults saying they've used the treatments, according to health research publisher KFF. In its release, Novo Nordisk said a company investigation showed that the ingredients in knock-off drugs sold by telehealth entities and compounding pharmacies are manufactured by foreign suppliers in China and that a large share of the drugs were never inspected by the FDA. "U.S. patients should not be exposed to knock-off drugs made with unsafe and illicit foreign ingredients," Novo Nordisk said. Novo Nordisk will continue to sell Wegovy on other telehealth platforms that "share our commitment to patient safety," said Dave Moore, executive vice president at Novo Nordisk, in the company's statement. Among the telehealth companies Novo Nordisk partners with are LifeMD and Ro. Kidney dialysis industry accused of maximizing profits over patients Pentagon officials reveal new details about U.S. strikes on Iran's nuclear sites Netanyahu reacts to U.S. strikes on Iranian nuclear sites
