Milton Friedman's Warning to DOGE
"Wise words," wrote Elon Musk about this 1999 viral clip described as "Milton Friedman casually giving the blueprint for DOGE [the Department of Government Efficiency]" as he ticks off a list of federal government agencies he'd be comfortable eliminating.
Musk is right. Friedman, a Nobel Prize–winning libertarian economist, did offer a solid blueprint for creating a smaller, less intrusive government. At the peak of his fame, he seemed poised to influence an American president to finally slash the federal bureaucracy.
But those efforts ended in disappointment because they were blocked by what Friedman called the Iron Triangle of Politics.
Slashing government waste and making the federal bureaucracy more accountable are incredibly important. But President Donald Trump and Musk are hitting the same wall President Ronald Reagan did more than four decades ago.
Now more than ever, it's time to pay attention to Milton Friedman's advice for how to defeat the tyranny of the status quo.
In the 1980s, Friedman's influence reached deep into the halls of power.
"Government is not the solution to our problem. Government is the problem," said President Reagan during his first inaugural address in January 1981.
Like Trump, Reagan was preceded in the White House by a big government liberal, who expanded the size of government and whose presidency was plagued by inflation.
Reagan, who awarded Friedman the Presidential Medal of Freedom, promised to enact many of the libertarian policy ideas laid out in the 1980 bestseller co-authored with his wife Rose.
"I don't think it's an exaggeration to call Milton Friedman's Free to Choose a survival kit for you, for our nation, and for freedom," Reagan said in an introduction to the television adaptation of Friedman's book.
But for the most part, the Reagan Revolution failed to deliver on its libertarian promises.
"Reagan's free market principles…clashed with…political reality…everywhere," wrote his former budget director David Stockman in his 1986 book The Triumph of Politics: Why the Reagan Revolution Failed. "For the Reagan Revolution to add up," he wrote, all the people "lured" by politicians into milking social services "had to be cut off."
Reagan tried to keep his promises but, like most presidents, he was only partly successful.
Reagan lifted price controls on oil, cut taxes, and pushed for deregulation. But his commitment to these initiatives quickly fizzled. Federal spending exploded, and he even left trade quotas in place for the automotive industry.
The failure of the Reagan revolution inspired the Friedmans to write The Tyranny of the Status Quo, which examines the political obstacles that obstruct government cost cutting. Their insights are as relevant today as they were 41 years ago.
The book, which came out in 1984, pinpoints the Iron Triangle of Politics as the main obstacle to cutting government. The triangle's three points reinforce each other to uphold the status quo: the Beneficiaries, the Politicians, and the Bureaucrats.
The "beneficiaries" are interest groups and connected industries that profit off of government programs at the expense of taxpayers. Today's beneficiaries include farmers who receive federal dollars. The new budget bill backed by the Republican Party would extend the Farm Bill, which subsidizes crop purchases. As Friedman said, the people paying the bill are "dispersed." You might not have noticed your share of the $2.1 billion going to prop up corn, soybeans, wheat, and other prices when you paid your 2023 taxes, but the farmers who get that money certainly did.
The "politicians" depicted on the triangle are supposed to be responsive to their constituents but end up serving interest groups instead. But it's the bureaucrats who actually distribute the money.
They grow their power when politicians grow the size of their departments, which generates more spoils to distribute to the beneficiaries. It's a symbiotic relationship all at taxpayer expense.
Bureaucracy tends to "proceed by laws of its own," wrote Friedman, noting that in the half-century between Franklin Delano Roosevelt's New Deal and the Reagan Revolution, the U.S. population "didn't quite double but federal government employees multiplied almost fivefold."
Musk has also observed that a metastasizing bureaucracy "proceeds by laws of its own," stating in a press conference from the Oval Office that "if the people cannot vote and have their will be decided by their elected representatives…then we don't live in a democracy, we live in a bureaucracy."
And, like Friedman, he senses danger if the ballooning of the bureaucratic state isn't reversed. At another press conference, he told attendees that "the overall goal here with the DOGE team is to help address the enormous deficit….If this continues, the country will become de facto bankrupt."
DOGE's strategy is to try breaking through the Iron Triangle by the force of a thousand cuts, looking for little inefficiencies with the mindset of a software engineer. Musk has described his role as "tech support," which is fairly accurate given that the Executive Order that created DOGE actually just rebranded an Obama-era agency called the U.S. Digital Service.
It's a good start. The federal work force should be streamlined, and much of it even automated. But Musk might be repeating some mistakes of the Reagan years.
As Stockman observed, the Reagan Revolution floundered because his team only focused on "easy solutions" like ferreting out "obscure tidbits of spending that could be excised without arousing massive political resistance," which" yielded savings that amounted to rounding errors in a trillion-dollar budget."
To make real progress on cutting spending, the cost reduction must go deeper than tech support could manage on its own. Friedman knew that the path to shrinking the federal government began with abolishing federal agencies. In his viral clip, he lists the departments of Housing and Urban Development, Agriculture, Commerce, and Education as ones to put on the chopping block.
Trump has already shut down the Department of Education…kind of. His executive order directs the Education secretary to draw up plans to eliminate or shift some spending to other departments. It keeps major spending like federal student loans intact, and a total dismantling will require Congress to act.
The Trump administration has made severe cuts to the U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID), and it defunded the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, the brainchild of Elizabeth Warren, which made access to credit and banking more difficult for low-income customers. DOGE also enticed 75,000 federal workers to resign. But many of these cost-cutting initiatives have been challenged in court. Truly eliminating federal agencies requires congressional action.
Because Trump holds only slim congressional majorities and didn't win on a platform to slash government, he won't be able to eliminate entire federal departments like Commerce or Agriculture.
But what would happen if the Trump administration had really followed the Friedman blueprint, learned from the shortcomings of the Reagan Revolution, and created a political movement capable of pressuring Congress to finally start permanently eliminating entire agencies?
Friedman says it would actually make the federal government function better by narrowly focusing on providing what state governments and the private sector can't.
"One function of government is to protect the country against foreign enemies—national defense," says Friedman. "A second function of government, and one which it performs very, very badly, is to protect the individual citizen against abuse and coercion by other citizens….I believe that the government performs that function very ineffectively because it's doing so many things that it has no business doing."
Earlier this year, Musk wielded a chainsaw gifted to him by Argentina's libertarian president, Javier Milei, who more closely followed the Friedman blueprint by targeting the beneficiaries and the bureaucracy, which he calls "La Casta."
In Argentina, it took massive poverty and triple-digit inflation to spark a real libertarian movement that now has a chance of overthrowing the tyranny of the status quo.
We don't want to wait for things to get that bad.
Musk praised Milei's approach at an event in Buenos Aires co-hosted by the libertarian Cato Institute.
"I think governments around the world should be actively deleting regulations, questioning whether departments should exist," said Musk. "Obviously President Milei seems to be doing a fantastic job on this front."
Fantastic indeed. But how can the Iron Triangle be overcome in the American system?
DOGE itself can't legally delete entire departments. DOGE's website claimed $140 billion in cuts out of its $2 trillion goal as of early April 2025.
But it hasn't provided full documentation, and various media and open source analyses have ball-parked DOGE's total savings as more in the $2 billion to $7 billion range.
Either way, DOGE isn't anywhere close to reaching its goal of cutting $2 trillion in government spending, or almost 30 percent of the $7 trillion annual budget. The Congressional Budget Office found the deficit grew 5 percent in February compared to the previous year despite DOGE's early cuts. Meanwhile, the Republican majority passed a budget projected that would add $3.4 trillion to our $28.8 trillion debt.
And we haven't even talked about Social Security and Medicare, which are the major drivers of debt, and which Trump has promised not to touch.
As Stockman came to realize, this is a bipartisan problem.
"There isn't a difference [between the parties] when it comes to the debt," he said on an episode of Reason's Just Asking Questions. "How in the world can we keep adding $1 trillion to our public debt every three months? How are we going to get away with basically enslaving the next generation of Americans with debt?"
The only way to break the Iron Triangle, Friedman suggested, is to push through deep structural reforms that are hard to overturn: a balanced budget amendment that forces Congress to spend responsibly, a line item veto allowing a president to eliminate special interest handouts without scrapping an otherwise popular law, a flat tax to eliminate special interest carve-outs, and a hard limit on how much money the government can print each year.
Sounds easy, right? Of course, it isn't.
Friedman believes that to defeat the Iron Triangle, a popular politician must break free of the grip of the triangle's other two points.
A new president, with a broad popular mandate and bully pulpit, is in a unique position to push the kind of radical but necessary reforms needed to cut government. And it all must happen, says Friedman, within the first six-month "honeymoon" period.
Trump entered his second term with a bold and disruptive plan, but he's spending his political capital unwinding America's global trade and defense partnerships, not on slashing spending.
To really cut the government, Friedman says you must capture the White House with a plan to cut spending and then make it harder to spend more. Trump isn't fighting that battle. He went to war with Rep. Thomas Massie (R–Ky.) for opposing the GOP's bloated budget.
And with Trump's tariffs throwing the market into turmoil, legal challenges to his executive action piling up, and his popularity already waning, the "honeymoon" is already over.
The gargantuan task of breaking the Iron Triangle will probably be left to whoever comes next. But the Iron Triangle will remain unbroken, and the looming threat of an increasingly centralized and bloated government will persist, until a movement emerges that is dedicated to achieving enduring structural reforms.
As Friedman wisely observed, it's not only short-term results that matter but the methods and their long-term consequences.
When asked what he'd do if made dictator for a day, Friedman replied, "I don't want to be made dictator. I don't believe in dictators. I believe we want to bring about change by agreement of the citizens. If we can't persuade the public that it's desirable to do these things, we have no right to impose it on them even if we had the power to do it."
DOGE's mission to rein in our catastrophic debt and unrestrained federal government is one of the most important political battles of our time. But it's a mission that will need more than a single executive agency to ultimately succeed: It needs a mass political movement.
Photo credits: Everett Collection/Newscom, Bonnie Cash - Pool via CNP/CNP / Polaris/Newscom, Graeme Sloan/Sipa USA/Newscom, Mattie Neretin - CNP/Newscom, CNP/AdMedia/SIPA/Newscom, Mattie Neretin - CNP/Sipa USA/Newscom, CNP/AdMedia/SIPA/Newscom, Yuri Gripas - Pool via CNP/ZUMAPRESS/Newscom, © Tobias Arhelger | Dreamstime.com, Sipa USA/Newscom, Sipa USA/Newscom, Everett Collection/Newscom, Gage Skidmore (CC BY-SA 2.0), rawpixel.com / Library of Congress, © Joe Sohm | Dreamstime.com, Joe Tabb, The U.S. National Archives, Michael Evans/ZUMAPRESS/Newscom
Producer: John Osterhoudt
Graphics: Lex Villena
The post Milton Friedman's Warning to DOGE appeared first on Reason.com.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Upturn
23 minutes ago
- Business Upturn
Trump's airstrike on Iran, crypto investors flock to Blockchain Cloud Mining for risk aversion This crypto market is shaken
London, UK, June 23, 2025 (GLOBE NEWSWIRE) — June 2025, US President Trump once again drew the world's attention back to the crosshairs of the Middle East war. As the US military precisely struck Iran's nuclear facilities, the entire international financial market has intensified, and the crypto market has also been caught in turmoil. In this chaotic situation, more and more investors are turning their attention to a more stable option: blockchain cloud mining. In particular, Blockchain Cloud Mining, a platform regulated by the UK, compliant and transparent, is rapidly becoming a new generation of digital safe-haven asset allocation tools. On the evening of June 21, 2025, the US Air Force dispatched stealth bombers and unmanned fighter jets to carry out air strikes on multiple Iranian nuclear-related targets, including the three core facilities of Natanz, Fordow and Isfahan. Although the White House claimed that it was 'necessary defense to prevent nuclear proliferation', Iran said that it 'has been regarded as a formal declaration of war' and threatened to block the Strait of Hormuz, causing panic in the global crude oil supply. The shadow of war once again looms over the world: oil prices soared, gold prices hit new highs, Nasdaq and Dow Jones plummeted, and U.S. bond yields plummeted. At the same time, the cryptocurrency market also experienced violent fluctuations, with Bitcoin falling to $103,000 at one point, and mainstream currencies such as DOGE and XRP fluctuating by more than 12% in a day. Data from mainstream trading platforms such as Robinhood and Coinbase show that a large number of users reduced their holdings within 48 hours and turned to stablecoins, fiat currencies or other low-risk configurations. It is in this atmosphere of spreading anxiety that an investment method that does not rely on the rise and fall of currency prices but can obtain sustainable crypto returns has quickly gained attention: BlockchainCloudMining. Why do crypto investors choose BlockchainCloudMining? ⦁ Register to get an instant reward of $12. ⦁ High profit levels and daily dividends. ⦁ No other service fees or management fees. ⦁The platform supports settlement of more than 9 cryptocurrencies such as DOGE, BTC, ETH, SOL, USDC, USDT, XRP, LTC, and BCH. ⦁The company's affiliate program allows you to refer friends and receive up to $50,000 in referral bonuses. ⦁McAfee® security. Cloudflare® security. 100% uptime guarantee and excellent 24/7 human online technical support. How to get started with BlockchainCloudMining Step 1: Register an account In this case, we chose BlockChainCloudMining as our cloud mining service provider. Go to the service provider of your choice to register and create a new account. BlockChainCloudMining offers a simple registration process, just enter your email address and create an account to participate. After registration, users can start mining Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies immediately. Step 2: Purchase a mining contract Currently, BlockChainCloudMining offers a variety of mining contracts, each with a unique return on investment (ROI) and a specific contract period. After purchasing a contract, you can receive earnings the next day, and you can also choose to withdraw to your crypto wallet or continue to purchase other contracts. (The platform has launched a number of stable income contracts, for more contract details, please log in to the official website of Collective shift of Robinhood and Coinbase users In the past 72 hours, several crypto analysis bloggers have found that users from Robinhood and Coinbase are turning to cloud mining platforms on a large scale. Some popular KOLs said on the X platform: 'Instead of wandering anxiously in the exchange, it is better to use BTC for production.' This is exactly the concept emphasized by BlockchainCloudMining – let assets 'generate coins' instead of just 'store coins' When will the next impact come? Will Iran retaliate? Will the United States expand its military operations? Will OPEC intervene in the crude oil market? There are no answers to these. But what can be confirmed is that the logic of war is diffuse, and the sense of security of assets is scarce. At this moment when the smoke of gunpowder has not yet dissipated, the real winners are not speculators who sell high and buy low, but those long-termists who have a stable, continuous and transparent source of income. For more details, please visit the official website: Or contact the company email: [email protected] Disclaimer: The information provided in this press release is not a solicitation for investment, nor is it intended as investment advice, financial advice, or trading advice. Cryptocurrency mining and staking involve risk. There is potential for loss of funds. It is strongly recommended you practice due diligence, including consultation with a professional financial advisor, before investing in or trading cryptocurrency and securities. Disclaimer: The above press release comes to you under an arrangement with GlobeNewswire. Business Upturn takes no editorial responsibility for the same. Ahmedabad Plane Crash
Business Upturn
23 minutes ago
- Business Upturn
SRC to Deliver Counter-UAS Technologies to Qatar as Part of Landmark $1B Agreement with U.S.
Syracuse, NY, June 23, 2025 (GLOBE NEWSWIRE) — Syracuse, NY – SRC, Inc. ('SRC' or 'Company'), a not-for-profit defense research and development company, announced today that it will deliver a suite of its advanced counter-unmanned aircraft systems (C-UAS) technologies to international buyers as a part of a historic $1 billion foreign military sales agreement between the U.S. government and the State of Qatar. This milestone marks the first international sale of the U.S. Army's Fixed Site–Low, Slow, Small Unmanned Aircraft System Integrated Defeat System (LIDS), underscoring SRC's role as a global leader in the defense against UAS threats. SRC's LIDS technologies are engineered to detect, track, identify and defeat unmanned aircraft systems, which are a growing threat in modern conflict zones. Under this agreement, SRC will deliver mission-critical technologies that enable detection and robust electronic warfare capabilities to international buyers for the first time. These technologies allow for layered defense at fixed-site locations and provide real-time situational awareness and threat response. The inclusion of LIDS in the agreement highlights the urgency with which nations are addressing the rising threat of unmanned systems to critical infrastructure and defense operations. 'We're proud that our proven systems will be deployed internationally to secure critical airspace, defend warfighters and protect high-value infrastructure,' said Kevin Hair, president and CEO of SRC. 'In today's rapidly evolving threat landscape, advanced sensing and electronic warfare capabilities are essential. This achievement reflects the strength of the LIDS team, the trust placed in us by our government partners and the operational relevance of American-engineered solutions.' LIDS supports the rapid detection and engagement of unmanned aircraft, while maintaining low collateral damage to minimize risk to friendly forces and surrounding infrastructure. As a system of systems, LIDS allows for the swift integration of emerging sensors and effectors, ensuring the system can adapt to evolving threats and remain effective across future mission sets. Its modular design supports deployment in both fixed and mobile configurations, offering tactical commanders the flexibility to address a wide range of operational scenarios. As a trusted provider of critical sensing and electronic warfare components, SRC is proud to support the continued advancement and international deployment of lifesaving technologies that empower our warfighters and strengthen global defense readiness. About SRC SRC, Inc. (@SRCDefense), a not-for-profit research and development company, combines information, science, technology and ingenuity to solve 'impossible' problems in the areas of defense, environment and intelligence. Across a family of companies, SRC applies bright minds, fresh thinking and relentless determination to deliver innovative products and services that are redefining possible ® for the challenges faced by America and its allies. Since 1957, SRC's commitment to the customer and the best solution — not the bottom line — has remained a core value that guides its efforts. This passion for quality carries through to the technologies the company invents and manufactures, the laboratories and facilities it builds, the people they hire, and communities where they work. Today, more than 1,400 engineers, scientists and professionals work together at SRC to protect people, the environment and our way of life. Disclaimer: The above press release comes to you under an arrangement with GlobeNewswire. Business Upturn takes no editorial responsibility for the same. Ahmedabad Plane Crash
Business Upturn
23 minutes ago
- Business Upturn
PBKMiner launches revolutionary XRP mining contract, sparking market enthusiasm
Carshalton, UK, June 23, 2025 (GLOBE NEWSWIRE) — PBKMiner's bold move has attracted the attention of cryptocurrency enthusiasts around the world with the launch of a revolutionary XRP mining model that could mark a turning point for the digital asset. As XRP continues to consolidate, analysts believe a breakout could be imminent. XRP has been trading in a relatively tight range in recent months, sparking debate among traders over its next move. As market momentum builds and investor interest picks up, PBKMiner's newly launched mining contracts are breathing new life into the XRP ecosystem. Breaking the Rules: Cloud Mining Contracts Designed for XRP Visit the official PBKMiner website: Unlike traditional mining based on proof of work (PoW), XRP uses a consensus protocol, which makes traditional mining infeasible. PBKMiner solves this challenge by introducing a simulated cloud mining model that allows users to receive XRP rewards through mining contracts. PBKMiner is a remote digital asset mining platform that allows users to rent computing power from PBKMiner's high-performance, environmentally friendly mining facilities. The platform supports multiple cryptocurrencies, including XRP, DOGE, BTC, LTC, and SOL, thereby eliminating technical and financial barriers and making passive income more accessible than ever before. 'This is not just an ordinary cryptocurrency project,' said PBKMiner's CTO. 'We are creating a community-driven growth opportunity in the XRP ecosystem, allowing users to mine through a smart yield mechanism that is consistent with the XRP architecture while providing real and transparent value to users.' Main features of PBKMiner XRP cloud mining contract – No hardware required: accessible to all users, no mining equipment or technical setup required – Daily payouts: earn mining rewards daily based on your contract participation – Safe custody: assets are protected by PBKMiner's industry-grade security standards – Flexible contract terms: choose short-term, mid-term or long-term options to match your investment strategy Flexible mining plans suitable for all types of investors PBKMiner provides more than 10 contract options, allowing users to freely choose the one that suits them best. For example: $10 Mining Contract – 1 Day Term – Earn $0.60 per day $100 Mining Contract – 2 Day Term – Earn $3.50 per day $1,000 Mining Contract – 10 Day Term – Earn $13.50 per day; $5,000 Mining Contract – 30 Day Term – Earn $77.50 per day. These innovative programs allow long-term XRP holders to remain invested during market consolidation or corrections while earning steady returns. Click here to explore more XRP mining contracts. Data from June showed a surge in participation in XRP mining contracts, with tens of thousands of wallets registered during the pilot phase (new users receive a $10 welcome bonus upon signing up). Many in the cryptocurrency community saw this as a positive sign, especially as XRP prices have proven resilient amid overall market volatility. How is PBKMiner's XRP mining contract different? 100% remote access: No hardware, no technical skills required – just log in and activate your plan. Capital protection: The contract guarantees a full return of principal at maturity. AI-driven profitability: Smart optimization ensures returns even during price stagnation. Daily rewards: Predictable XRP payouts improve cash flow and reduce volatility risk. How to start mining XRP on PBKMiner Sign up for an account: Get a $10 bonus plus a $0.60 daily login bonus Choose a mining contract: Use your bonus to activate a plan or choose your preferred option Start mining: Sit back and earn – rewards are automatically credited daily A smarter way to wait: Income during XRP consolidation periods Founded in 2019, PBKMiner has been at the forefront of cloud-based cryptocurrency mining, democratizing access to passive income through a secure, AI-driven, and environmentally friendly infrastructure. The platform helps users mine mainstream cryptocurrencies such as XRP, BTC, SOL, and DOGE without expensive equipment or deep technical knowledge. Don't wait for the next rally to start earning money – activate your XRP mining contract now at Disclaimer: The information provided in this press release does not constitute an investment solicitation, nor does it constitute investment advice, financial advice, or trading recommendations. Cryptocurrency mining and staking involve risks and the possibility of losing funds. It is strongly recommended that you perform due diligence before investing or trading in cryptocurrencies and securities, including consulting a professional financial advisor. Disclaimer: The above press release comes to you under an arrangement with GlobeNewswire. Business Upturn takes no editorial responsibility for the same. Ahmedabad Plane Crash
