Ban parents from calling children ‘naughty', says Kate Silverton
Parents should be banned from calling their children 'naughty', according to Kate Silverton.
Mrs Silverton, the child therapist and former BBC newsreader, said it is harmful for children because they 'internalise' the message of the word, and it reinforces a belief that it is 'who I am', leading to more problematic behaviour.
Mrs Silverton, 54, also said it is a 'fallacy' to use the word because it is 'not scientifically correct' as their brains are too immature.
The counsellor called for parents to 'change the language'.
'Our children internalise every day,' she told the Netmums podcast.
'They're taking in messages from us, from their friends, from their teachers. And words carry such weight of meaning. 'Oh, stop being silly. Oh, you are so naughty. Oh, he's the naughty one'.
'We all fall into that trap, but our children are paying very close attention to how we think of them.
'And we might dismiss it as a comment – 'oh, he's so untidy. Oh, she's always late. She's a bit of a scatterbrain'.
'They are internalising. And what they're internalising, because, again, they don't have that fully formed rational brain.
''I'm bad. I'm naughty.' And then it becomes: 'That's me. That's who I am'.
'And you may well end up with a child that then thinks, well, 'that's who I am so I may as well just be that'. You know, that's where sort of delinquency comes from.'
'Labels are not who our children are,' Mrs Silverton added.
'So we might say, 'I didn't like that behaviour', but it's not 'I don't like who you are'. And that's really important.'
Mrs Silverton added: 'It's just a fallacy to call children naughty.
'They're not making conscious choices for the majority of the time. They are driven by a very, very immature brain and a nervous system that very often is being triggered because they're coping with a lot during the day.
'It's just not scientifically correct. It's not, it's just, as I say, it's a fallacy.
'And I'd really like to change that language.'
Broaden your horizons with award-winning British journalism. Try The Telegraph free for 1 month with unlimited access to our award-winning website, exclusive app, money-saving offers and more.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBS News
an hour ago
- CBS News
How a Baltimore-based organization is supporting LGBTQ+ first responders
Being a first responder can take a toll on anybody, but if you're also a part of the LGBTQ+ community, that toll can be even bigger to deal with. That's why the group 'Responders For Pride' works to support the community and teach agencies how to be good allies. LGBTQ+ stigma Nicola Maguire has been a firefighter for 18 years. However, when she started, she wasn't out to her colleagues. Eventually, she came out as a lesbian, and while she didn't experience any hate from them, there was still a stigma she grappled with—a stigma that's still alive and well today. "I won't be the same provider, or firefighter, or police officer I am tomorrow if I came out today," Maguire said as she explained the sort of thoughts some LGBTQ+ members grapple with. It's a stigma she is working to get rid of with the help of 'Responders For Pride', or RFP. "So, we want to be able to make it [so] that they can be their true identity. Growing up as LGBT, you never get to truly grow up, just being your true self," she stated. Mental health awareness for first responders Maguire is the president and one of RFP's founders, created in 2023. The group focuses on raising mental health awareness for LGBTQI+ first responders, sharing resources, and working with different agencies to develop liaison programs. Last month, RFP put on its first ignite conference, providing hands on training to ten different agencies, including one based in Canada. Allison Bingner and Sarah Corrigan, RFP volunteers and first responders, said the org's work has built a local LGBTQ+ support network. "You have your firefighters, you have police, you have everyone that's there that understands everything, from not only the work that you're doing career-wise, but what it is in your personal life," Bingner said. The network RFP curated has been essential in creating safe, welcoming spaces for LGBTQ+ first responders to be themselves. "Use it as a strength instead of a weakness..." WJZ first met Corrigan in 2022, when she first came out and transitioned. "By having groups like RFP out there that make all of this visible to everybody, and showing the world you can be LGBTQ+ and still do this job, I think it really opens up the possibility for more people from our community to do this job," she said. That's all RFP wants first responders to do: be themselves. "Use it as a strength instead of a weakness within their departments, I think really would've helped me from the beginning to just be me and be the person I got hired within the department," Maguire explained. To learn more about 'Responders For Pride' and get involved, click here.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Woman Sparks Debate After Saying People Who Call Repeatedly After Being Ignored the First Time Are ‘Rude'
A woman says she thinks it's 'rude' when people repeatedly call her cell phone 'If I don't answer the first call, what makes them think I'm going to answer the second, third or tenth time?' she wrote on the community forum Mumsnet Readers had mixed opinions on her takeA woman says she thinks it's 'rude' when someone calls her multiple times directly after she doesn't pick up the first time — and it's sparking some debate. The woman detailed her experience in the 'Am I Being Unreasonable?' forum on the U.K.-based community site a place where people can go to get input and advice about an array of topics. 'If I don't answer the first call, what makes them think I'm going to answer the second, third or tenth time?' she argued. 'Sometimes I'm having a shower or my phone is in another room [charging], and I'll go to it and there'll be 20 missed calls. Or I might be at work. Any number of reasons why I can't answer,' she continued, adding that it's a 'few certain people' in her life who do this. 'Mobile phones have missed call notifications, so it's obvious that someone will ring back when they can,' she concluded her post. A number of post commenters vehemently agreed with the original poster (OP). 'My phone is for me, for my convenience. I'll answer or call back when I want to, no matter how many times you ring. I really hate being contactable so easily,' one person wrote. 'The more people do that, the more I don't answer,' someone else said. 'If someone called me that number of times without a damned good reason, I would block their number.' Never miss a story — sign up for to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories. Some people, however, said it depends on the situation. 'Generally, yes, but it depends why,' one person wrote. 'If someone is ringing me because I'm 10 minutes late to meet them and they want to know an ETA or whatever, I think it's far more acceptable than if someone is ringing for a chat or something that can wait.' Other community members said they completely disagreed with the OP's perspective, and said they actually take issue with people not answering their phones in the first place. 'I don't find it rude at all if someone rings me. I grew up with landline phone calls and letters. When I was a teenager, the only way to contact someone quickly was by phone call or telegram. I think most of you need to unclench,' one person commented. The PEOPLE Puzzler crossword is here! How quickly can you solve it? Play now! Another person suggested the OP should perhaps consider having some empathy for the person who's calling, as they might not mean to be rude. "I do this [call repeatedly] — I can't help it. It's an anxiety thing,' they explained. "If people don't answer their phones, I think they are dead … If someone doesn't want to speak to me, that's fine, but a quick message to say, 'I'm busy' is fine. Then I'll leave you alone.' Read the original article on People
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
6 Rude Things People Can't Stop Doing at the Grocery Store
This article may contain affiliate links that Yahoo and/or the publisher may receive a commission from if you buy a product or service through those links. The grocery store is my happy place. I know I know, but it's true. As soon as I push through the revolving door, there's a sense of calm that comes over me — like the door is a gateway from the chaotic outside world to the pleasant predictability that lives inside my grocery store. Things there are just how I like them: the temperature is spot-on, the music is playing at the perfect level, and I'm surrounded by glorious stacks of delicious food. It's a good spot for me and my mental health, at least most of the time. Recently I've noticed an influx of people seeking to destroy my happy place, doing things they obviously don't find disrespectful (or think twice about). I know many of them aren't doing it out of spite, but nonetheless, it's time we address the concerning behavior and hopefully squash it. The people who work in the produce section of my grocery store are amazing. They create the most beautiful displays and work constantly to ensure the shelves are stocked. It has to be rough watching customers aggressively grab, squeeze, shake and even peel it all with what feels like reckless abandon. I have witnessed several people peel off corn husks and leave them on the floor (ditto for onions and lettuce). Rather than piling things on the floor, take a few extra moments to pick out your produce. If you're looking for that perfect avocado and you think it's buried under all of the others, don't wreck the tower so that you can find it. On that note… I really dislike food waste, so when I see someone pick up a perishable item and then set it down in a totally different part of the store because they changed their mind, it bugs me. Just a few weeks ago I found a big package of meat someone must have ordered from the butcher counter just sitting in the refrigerated section by the cheese. Yes, it was at least refrigerated, but regardless, once that meat leaves the counter, it can't go back, so it's wasted. Let's not contribute to the food waste problem any longer. Stick with what you ordered and if it's produce or any other packaged food, put it back where you found it. This one might not annoy everyone, but it bothers me. The scenario goes like this: The cart offenders leave the cart, centrally placed in the aisle. They travel to the shelf and then stand in front of it to look closer. Meanwhile, everyone else in the aisle is left to wait for those shoppers to either make a decision or move their cart. We all need to move and get around so that we can go home and unpack our groceries. Please make that easier by moving your cart to a less-trafficked spot or wait until the aisle isn't so crowded to grab what you need. I get it, you need the 'tea' from Macey, but couldn't it wait until after you're done shopping? I can't imagine that you want to spend more than 15 to 20 minutes in the store and I bet the gossip is better when you can actually focus on what your friend is saying. If you need to have that call, do it somewhere in the corner away from everyone else (and definitely don't use speaker phone). Manners go a long way and having a conversation on a phone while — especially when someone is ringing up your groceries — is rude. Why not greet the person working in the aisles and talk to them instead? I've learned so much from the employees stocking the shelves and working the registers. You could too. I think it's fun that my grocery store also sells wine and beer that you can sip while shopping. But just like driving a car, you need to drink responsibly. It's not okay to attempt steering one-handed with a full beverage in your other hand. This makes your moves erratic and unpredictable, which can lead to accidents with fellow shoppers, workers, and even inanimate objects like end-cap displays. My advice? Take a sip every once in a while, choose to do it in a place where you won't be in the way. Oh yeah, and please take your glass back to where you got it. You're done shopping! Yay! The next best move is to leave your cart in a random spot in the parking lot or push it close to the cart corral, but definitely not in it! All kidding aside, I bet you have a few extra minutes to put your cart away. Or, if you need assistance it's perfectly OK to ask a fellow shopper or store employee for help. Everyone wins when you're a team player! Got any grocery shopping dos and don'ts to share? Tell us about it in the comments below. Sign up for The Weekly Checkout to get the most up-to-date grocery news, tips, and highlights. Subscribe to The Kitchn! Why People Are Ditching Their Seltzer After a Disturbing Study The One Cookware Brand That Gordon Ramsay Can't Stop Talking About Ball Just Dropped the Most Beautiful Mason Jars for Its 140th Anniversary ("So Iconic!") Sign up for The Kitchn's Daily newsletter to receive our best recipes, posts, and shopping tips in your inbox.
