NATO agrees to higher defence spending goal, Spain says it is opting out
FILE PHOTO: The logo of NATO is seen at a meeting of the North Atlantic Council in the NATO defence ministers' session together with Sweden as the invitee, at the Alliance's headquarters in Brussels, Belgium February 15, 2024. REUTERS/Johanna Geron/File Photo
NATO agrees to higher defence spending goal, Spain says it is opting out
BRUSSELS/MADRID - NATO members agreed on Sunday to a big increase in their defence spending target to 5% of gross domestic product, as demanded by U.S. President Donald Trump, but Spain said it did not need to comply just days before a summit in The Hague meant to be a show of unity.
NATO officials had been anxious to find consensus on a summit statement on a new spending commitment ahead of Wednesday's gathering. But Spanish Prime Minister Pedro Sanchez declared on Thursday he would not commit to the 5% target.
NATO boss Mark Rutte has proposed to reach the target by boosting NATO's core defence spending goal from 2% to 3.5% of GDP and spending an extra 1.5% on related items like cyber security and adapting roads and bridges for military vehicles.
After diplomats agreed on a compromise text on Sunday, Sanchez swiftly proclaimed Spain would not have to meet the 5% target as it would only have to spend 2.1% of GDP to meet NATO's core military requirements.
"We fully respect the legitimate desire of other countries to increase their defence investment, but we are not going to do so," Sanchez said in an address on Spanish television.
Spain spent 1.24% of GDP on defence in 2024, or about 17.2 billion euros ($19.8 billion), according to NATO estimates, making it the lowest spender in the alliance as a share of its economic output.
NATO officials argue big defence spending increases are needed to counter a growing threat from Russia and to allow Europe to take on more responsibility for its own security as the United States shifts its military focus to China.
TRUMP CRITICISM
Sanchez's stance risked setting up a summit clash with Trump, who has frequently accused European countries of not spending enough on defence and threatened not to defend them if they do not meet their targets.
On Friday, Trump said Spain "has to pay what everybody else has to pay" and Madrid was "notorious" for low defence spending.
However, he also suggested the U.S. should not have to meet the new target, as the U.S. had spent large amounts to protect the continent over a long period. Washington spent an estimated 3.19% of GDP on defence in 2024, NATO says.
But Sanchez argued it was not necessary for Spain to meet the new target and trying to do so would mean drastic cuts on social spending such as state pensions, or tax hikes.
NATO did not release the compromise summit text, which will only become official when it is endorsed by the leaders of NATO's 32 members at the summit.
But diplomats said one tweak in the language on the spending commitment, from "we commit" to "allies commit," allowed Spain to say the pledge does not apply to all members.
In a letter seen by Reuters, Rutte told Sanchez that Spain would have "flexibility to determine its own sovereign path" for meeting its military capability targets agreed with NATO.
A NATO diplomat said Rutte's letter was simply "an affirmation that allies chart their own course for making good on their commitments" to meet their capability targets.
NATO officials have expressed scepticism that Spain can meet its military capability targets by spending just 2.1% of GDP, as Sanchez has suggested. The targets are secret so their costs cannot be independently verified.
"All allies have now agreed to the summit statement – which includes the new defence investment plan," said the diplomat, speaking on condition of anonymity to discuss internal matters.
Rutte had originally proposed countries meet the new target by 2032 but the deadline in the final text is 2035, according to diplomats. There will also be a review of the target in 2029. REUTERS
Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Straits Times
an hour ago
- Straits Times
From fallen giants to giant-killers: Botafogo's remarkable revival
Soccer Football - FIFA Club World Cup - Group B - Paris St Germain v Botafogo - Rose Bowl Stadium, Pasadena, California, U.S. - June 19, 2025 Botafogo players celebrate after the match IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters/Kirby Lee REUTERS Once Brazilian football royalty, Botafogo had languished for decades as a debt-ridden sleeping giant before they toppled Paris St Germain at the Club World Cup to cap a resurrection tale three years in the making. When American entrepreneur John Textor acquired the club in 2022, fresh from their promotion back to Brazil's first division, he took on a training ground so decrepit that then-coach Luis Castro dismissed it as "good for parking cars," alongside crushing liabilities exceeding one billion reais ($181.39 million). Botafogo were a storied but shattered institution. The club that once nurtured Brazilian greats - Garrincha, Zagallo, Jairzinho and Nilton Santos, architects of three World Cup triumphs - was drowning in debt, having endured the humiliation of relegation three times in just over a decade. On Thursday, they outplayed European champions Paris St Germain to win 1-0 in the Club World Cup's most eye-catching upset, propelling themselves to the top of the tournament's "group of death" and on the verge of the knockout stage. Their squad, assembled through shrewd bargain-hunting in football's forgotten corners, now faces Diego Simeone's Atletico Madrid in Los Angeles on Monday, sitting comfortably, knowing even a two-goal defeat would still secure their passage to the round of 16. The victory over PSG vindicated Textor's vision, outlined in a Reuters interview three years prior, of "beating the system" through astute scouting in under-explored talent pools. The architects of Thursday's victory exemplified this approach. Match-winner Igor Jesus arrived as a free agent after three anonymous years in the UAE and was transformed into a Brazil international. Argentine defender Alexander Barboza, who neutralised PSG's vaunted attack, was plucked from Paraguay's Club Libertad for nothing. Captain Marlon Freitas came from second-division Atletico Goianiense, while experienced European campaigners Alex Telles and Allan were revitalised after spells in Middle Eastern leagues. Gregore, Jefferson Savarino, John and Cuiabano were all signed for under two million euros ($2.30 million) each. "The goal is to be sustainably competitive every year," Botafogo CEO Thairo Arruda told Reuters. "With a top six payroll, we produce like a top three." The transformation extends far beyond the pitch. Revenues have soared from 140 million reais in 2022 to projected earnings exceeding 1.1 billion by 2025, while liabilities have been slashed by 40%. Textor's Eagle Football empire also encompasses stakes in Ligue 1's Olympique Lyonnais and Premier League Crystal Palace. Botafogo's renaissance - crowned by last year's domestic and continental double - has breathed new life into a club motto once heavy with self-pity: "There are things that only happen to Botafogo." After outclassing Europe's elite, those words now carry an altogether sweeter resonance. REUTERS Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
Business Times
2 hours ago
- Business Times
Cybersecurity firm Trend Micro bets on AI to offset US tariff woes
[SINGAPORE] The Trump administration's policies have cast a shadow over Japanese cybersecurity firm Trend Micro, contributing to a slowdown in its first-quarter revenue, but the company believes that artificial intelligence (AI) offers longer-term promise that could more than make up for the current troubles. 'Even though everybody is pulling back their spending, nobody has stopped the exploration of AI,' said the company's chief executive officer, Eva Chen, in an interview with The Business Times. The company provides products and services for all cybersecurity layers such as endpoint devices like laptops, servers where data is stored and Internet networks. With a hand in all security layers, Trend Micro can keep up with innovation and industry changes quickly, including progress in AI, said Chen. Trend Micro was first listed on Japan's stock exchange for emerging and venture companies, the Jasdaq, in 1998. It later listed on the Tokyo Stock Exchange in 2000. Since then, the company's share price has risen nearly 20 per cent. Trend Micro currently has a market capitalisation of 1.3 trillion yen (S$11.4 billion) and annual revenue of about US$2 billion, selling cybersecurity products to both consumers and enterprises. Company performance In its latest Q1 results for FY2025, Trend Micro turned in a net sales of 67.5 billion yen, up 2.4 per cent from a year ago. This was a slowdown from Q4 of FY2024, which had a 7.7 per cent increase in net sales compared to a year ago. Chen attributed the slowdown in sales to several reasons. BT in your inbox Start and end each day with the latest news stories and analyses delivered straight to your inbox. Sign Up Sign Up Firstly, one of Trend Micro's suppliers, which operates the company's electronic payment system for its consumer business, went bankrupt. Thus, Trend Micro's payment service was not functional in regions outside Japan in the first quarter of FY2025. On a macro level, Trend Micro's business slowed down due to the policies introduced by the Trump administration in the US. In its Asia markets, Chen observed that businesses, especially manufacturers, were more cautious about their spending given uncertainty over US tariffs. Within the US market itself, Chen observed a slowdown in business from the US government sector, likely due to the impact of the Department of Government Efficiency, or Doge, an initiative by the Trump administration to cut wasteful government spending. Chen said she expects the impact of Doge to linger in Q2 as overall US government spending slows. Overall, Q1 net income fell 17.6 per cent to 8.9 billion yen. However, Chen attributed this to an employee stock option programme which allows Trend Micro staff to cash in their shares whenever they want at the current market price. 'And fortunately or unfortunately, our stock price jumped up a lot last quarter, so that (stock-option related) cost increased a lot,' said Chen. Trend Micro's share price hit a 52-week high of 12,160 yen per share on Feb 19. Good sales over FY2024 Despite the lower revenue and net income, Trend Micro's Q1 operating income – which represents the company's income from core business operations – hit a record high of 15 billion yen, an increase of 23.7 per cent from a year ago. Chen said that the performance is due to Trend Micro's evolving business strategy. In its early years, Trend Micro adopted a perpetual licence model for its sales where customers could purchase Trend Micro's software licence, and pay additional fees annually to update the software. Trend Micro later moved to a subscription-based software delivery model called Software as a Service (SaaS). This allows customers to subscribe to the software, which is run by Trend Micro, on a cloud-based server. However, Trend Micro's profit margin dropped during this period as the operation cost for a cloud service provider was expensive. It was also difficult to expand the range of products sold to customers through the SaaS model. In 2023, Trend Micro introduced its Vision One cybersecurity platform, which integrates all of Trend Micro's products and services for various cybersecurity layers into one platform. 'When the SaaS customer re-subscribes to our services in the second year, we don't need to re-establish the whole platform for them again. Therefore the profit margin gets better,' explained Chen. This reduces the operating cost and encourages customers to buy more products offered by Trend Micro through its Vision One platform, she added. The figures for FY2024 have been encouraging. For the full year ended Dec 31, 2024, Trend Micro's net income more than tripled to 34.4 billion yen. Operating income rose to 48.1 billion yen, up 47.6 per cent. Net sales for the full year rose nearly 10 per cent to 272.6 billion yen, with the Asia-Pacific region its fastest growing market in FY2024. Sales in the region jumped 20 per cent from a year ago, compared to Trend Micro's other markets in Japan, the Americas and Europe. The power of AI Chen said she is optimistic that the longer-term business opportunities offered by AI will override the shorter-term challenges presented by current US policies. Firstly, AI can help to improve Trend Micro's products, said Chen. 'We use AI to make our products much smarter. The whole detection and protection – which we call proactive security – for our customers is much faster and better,' she explained. For example, Trend Micro can use AI to create 'digital twins' which can replicate a system or programme, while providing businesses with customisable, higher-value products at a lower cost. Secondly, the incorporation of AI by businesses also presents them with new cybersecurity risks. For instance, companies need to ensure that the data that they use to train the AI is 'not polluted', meaning that the data is accurate and not biased. For these reasons, opportunities in AI will be the focus of Trend Micro's business strategy in the next few years, said Chen. The company is projecting a 13.2 per cent rise in its net income for FY2025, with net sales rising 5.9 per cent to 288.6 billion yen. It also estimates that its operating income will grow by 25.3 per cent to 60.3 billion yen for the current financial year. Challenges remain, but with AI reshaping both its product and business model, Trend Micro sees more opportunity than risk ahead.
Straits Times
2 hours ago
- Straits Times
‘Slim to none': US strikes on Iran leave hopes for nuclear diplomacy in tatters
A handout satellite image made available by Maxar Technologies shows damage at the Isfahan nuclear technology centre after US airstrikes on June 22. PHOTO: EPA-EFE 'Slim to none': US strikes on Iran leave hopes for nuclear diplomacy in tatters PARIS/ISTANBUL - In a bid to defuse the conflict over Iran's nuclear programme, foreign ministers from Europe's top three powers hurried to meet their Iranian counterpart on June 20 in Geneva. Those hopes collapsed on June 21 when US President Donald Trump ordered airstrikes on Iran's three main nuclear sites, in support of Israel's military campaign. 'It's irrelevant to ask Iran to return to diplomacy,' Iran's foreign minister Abbas Araqchi, visibly angry, told reporters in Istanbul on June 22, promising a 'response' to the US strikes. 'It's not time for diplomacy now.' Mr Trump, who said the US airstrikes 'obliterated' the sites, warned in a televised speech on June 21 that the US could attack other targets in Iran if no peace deal was reached and urged Tehran to return to the negotiating table. Reuters spoke to seven Western diplomats and analysts who said the prospect of negotiations was negligeable for now, with an unbridgeable gap between Washington's demand for zero enrichment by Iran and Tehran's refusal to abandon its nuclear programme. 'I think the prospects of effective diplomacy at this point are slim to none,' said Mr James Acton, co-director of the Nuclear Policy Program at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, a think tank headquartered in Washington. 'I'm much more worried about escalation, both in the short and the long term.' According to European diplomats, the three European allies - Britain, France and Germany - were not made aware of Mr Trump's decision to strike Iran ahead of time. French President Emmanuel Macron had promised on June 21 - just before the US strikes - to accelerate the nuclear talks, following a call with his Iranian counterpart. One European diplomat, who asked not to be identified, acknowledged there was now no way of holding a planned second meeting with Iran in the coming week. In the wake of the US military action, any European diplomatic role appears likely to be secondary. Mr Trump on June 20 dismissed Europe's efforts towards resolving the crisis, saying Iran only wanted to speak to the United States. Three diplomats and analysts said any future talks between Iran and Washington would likely be through regional intermediaries Oman and Qatar, once Tehran decides how to respond to the US airstrikes on its nuclear sites at Fordow, Natanz and Isfahan. The attacks leave Iran with few palatable options on the table. Since Israel began its military campaign against Iran on June 13, some in Tehran have raised the prospect of withdrawing from the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT) to signal Iran's determination to accelerate enrichment, but experts say that would represent a considerable escalation and likely draw a forceful response from Washington. Mr Acton, of the Carnegie Endowment, said Iran's most obvious means for retaliation is its short-range ballistic missiles, that could be used to target US forces and assets in the region. But any military response by Iran carried the risk of miscalculation, he said. 'On the one hand, they want a strong enough response that they feel the US has actually paid a price. On the other hand, they don't want to encourage further escalation,' he said. European effort ended in failure Even before the US strikes, the June 20 talks in Geneva showed little sign of progress amid a chasm between the two sides and in the end no detailed proposals were put forward, three diplomats said. Mixed messaging may have also undermined their own efforts, diplomats said. European positions on key issues like Iran's enrichment programme have hardened in the past 10 days with the Israeli strikes and the looming threat of US bombing. The three European powers, known as the E3, were parties to a 2015 nuclear deal that Mr Trump abandoned three years later during his first term. Both the Europeans and Tehran believed they had a better understanding of how to get a realistic deal given the E3 have been dealing with Iran's nuclear programme since 2003. But the Europeans have had a difficult relationship with Iran in recent months as they sought to pressure it over its ballistic missiles programme, support for Russia and detention of European citizens. France, which was the keenest to pursue negotiations, has in the last few days suggested Iran should move towards zero enrichment, which until now was not an E3 demand given Iran's red line on the issue, two European diplomats said. Britain has also adopted a tougher stance more in tune with Washington and that was expressed in Geneva, the diplomats said. And Germany's new government appeared to go in the same direction, although it was more nuanced. 'Iran has to accept zero enrichment eventually,' said one EU official. A senior Iranian official on June 21 showed disappointment at the Europeans' new stance, saying their demands were 'unrealistic', without providing further details. In a brief joint statement on June 2, which acknowledged the US strikes, the European countries said they would continue their diplomatic efforts. 'We call upon Iran to engage in negotiations leading to an agreement that addresses all concerns associated with its nuclear programme,' it said, adding the Europeans stood ready to contribute 'in coordination with all parties'. Mr David Khalfa, co-founder of the Atlantic Middle East Forum, a Paris-based think tank, said Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei's government had taken advantage of the Europeans for years to gain time as it developed its nuclear programme and ballistic missile capabilities. 'The European attempt ended in failure,' he said. However, the Europeans still have one important card to play. They are the only ones who, as party to the nuclear accord, can launch its so-called 'snapback mechanism', which would reimpose all previous UN sanctions on Iran if it is found to be in violation of the agreement's terms. Diplomats said, prior to the US strikes, the three countries had discussed an end-August deadline to activate it as part of a 'maximum pressure' campaign on Tehran. 'Multiple channels' for US talks In total, the US launched 75 precision-guided munitions, including more than two dozen Tomahawk missiles, and more than 125 military aircraft in the operation against the three nuclear sites, US officials said. US Defecse Secretary Pete Hegseth on June 22 warned Iran against retaliation and said both public and private messages had been sent to Iran 'in multiple channels, giving them every opportunity to come to the table'. Five previous rounds of indirect negotiations between the United States and Iran collapsed after a US proposal at the end of May called for Iran to abandon uranium enrichment. It was rejected by Tehran, leading to Israel launching its attack on Iran after Mr Trump's 60-day deadline for talks had expired. Iran has repeatedly said from then on that it would not negotiate while at war. Even after Israel struck, Washington reached out to Iran to resume negotiations, including offering a meeting between Mr Trump and Iranian President Masoud Pezeshkian in Istanbul, according to two European diplomats and an Iranian official. That was rebuffed by Iran, but Mr Araqchi did continue direct contacts with US Special envoy Steve Witkoff, three diplomats told Reuters. One of the challenges in engaging with Iran, experts say, is that no one can be sure of the extent of the damage to its nuclear programme. With the IAEA severely restricted in its access to Iranian sites, it is unclear whether Tehran has hidden enrichment facilities. A senior Iranian source told Reuters on June 22 that most of the highly enriched uranium at Fordow, the site producing the bulk of Iran's uranium refined to up to 60 per cent, had been moved to an undisclosed location before the US attack there. Mr Acton, of the Carnegie Endowment, said that - putting aside from the damage to its physical installations - Iran had thousands of scientists and technicians involved in the enrichment programme, most of whom had survived the US and Israeli attacks. 'You can't bomb knowledge,' he said. REUTERS Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
