Farm-to-fork watchdog could tackle ‘unfairnesses' which farmers face, says MP

A farm-to-fork food watchdog could help growers make more money when retailers sell their produce, an MP has suggested.
Alistair Carmichael has said 'behemoth' supermarkets should face a tougher regulator in a bid to ease 'unfairnesses' in the supply chain without passing costs onto shoppers.
On Wednesday, he will seek to table his proposed Food Products (Market Regulation and Public Procurement) Bill, which aims to lay the groundwork for a new watchdog covering farmers, suppliers and shops.
National Farmers' Union (NFU) president Tom Bradshaw has called for a 'trading environment that remains competitive and innovative' and said he 'fully supports' the Bill being tabled.
Mr Carmichael, the Commons Environment, Food and Rural Affairs Committee chairman, described the existing framework as 'a bit of regulation at one end and a bit of regulation at the other and no wiring between the two and nothing actually even to join together the two bits of regulation'.
He told the PA news agency: 'Experience has been that we really need to have something that goes from the farm gate to the supermarket shelf.
'And there are lots of different unfairnesses that have been allowed to be hardwired into the system.'
The Liberal Democrat MP for Orkney and Shetland added: 'It has to look at the market as a whole because it's a very unusual market.
'You've got tens of thousands, maybe hundreds of thousands, of primary producers and what?
'Six, 10 behemoth supermarkets at the top and all sorts of bits and pieces in between?'
Supermarkets backtrack on past commitments without a reason and say 'we don't want your product anymore', Mr Carmichael claimed, adding: 'That farmer or processor will probably have gone to some expense to market and batch and package their product in such a way that the supermarket demands but they'll pull the rug out from underneath you.'
He also said that if supermarkets decide to cut milk prices 'everybody then passes that on down the line to the family farmer, and the farmer essentially at the end of the day is left having to shrug his shoulders and just take the hit'.
The Groceries Supply Code of Practice (GSCOP) promotes 'fair dealing' and discourages supermarkets from demanding changes to their supply chains without 'reasonable notice'.
Mr Carmichael said farmers 'take it' because complaining to the Groceries Code Adjudicator, who is supposed to enforce the code, could mean they struggle to 'get back in' with the supermarkets and suffer 'bad long-term consequences'.
A new regulator could have built-in protections, including the power and resources to proactively investigate suspected breaches without the need for farmers to complain.
Asked whether shoppers will face higher prices amid efforts to pass a bigger share of sales to farmers, Mr Carmichael said: 'I don't think the people who can afford to be impacted by this are the consumers.
'I think that the people who are doing rather nicely out of this are the supermarkets and indeed some of the processors and distributors as well.
'So, if you're going to find a way of improving the lot of the farmer, you have to do it in a way that doesn't actually work to the detriment of the consumer, and that's why you've got to have a regulator that is big enough and has sufficient resource to be taken seriously by supermarkets.'
Mr Carmichael criticised 'tacit consensus amongst policymakers that we didn't need farmers, we could import all our food', calling instead for a strengthened domestic industry following international shocks such as the outbreak of war in Ukraine followed by US president Donald Trump 'playing fast and loose with trade'.
Mr Bradshaw called for a 'policy which doesn't undermine' farmers, adding: 'Strengthening farmers' position means making our food system more resilient and provides a trading environment that remains competitive and innovative.'
Andrew Opie, director of food and sustainability at the British Retail Consortium (BRC), said: 'We support appropriate regulation to strengthen the resilience of UK food producers.
'The Groceries Code Adjudicator has been operating for more than a decade, overseeing a legal code between retailers and their suppliers, and retailers have developed strong internal processes to ensure compliance.
'Given the success of this model, the BRC has been lobbying for more intervention for suppliers, such as farmers, further up the supply chain who are not currently covered by GSCOP and would need different regulation and support to help them.
'We believe that is best delivered by the Agricultural Adjudicator, which is already active in the dairy chain and could be replicated across all farming supply chains.'

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Daily Mirror

9 hours ago

• Daily Mirror

Wes Streeting says there 'isn't a budget' in NHS for assisted dying law

The Health Secretary - one of the top opponents of the legislation - said assisted dying would take 'time and money' away from other parts of the health service Wes Streeting has claimed there "isn't a budget" in the NHS for assisted dying services after a historic Commons vote on the issue. The Health Secretary - one of the most senior opponents of the legislation - said it would take "time and money" away from other parts of the health service. On Friday the Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill was passed by MPs with a majority of 23 in a move championed by campaigners. ‌ Keir Starmer and Chancellor Rachel Reeves voted for the legislation, which would allow terminally ill adults with six months left to live the option to end their life early. The application would be approved by two doctors and an expert panel featuring a social worker, senior legal figure and psychiatrist. ‌ But Mr Streeting was among several Cabinet ministers, including Deputy PM Angela Rayner and Justice Secretary Shabana Mahmood, to vote against the bill. In a post on his Facebook page over the weekend, said he had "no doubt that this is a major and profound social change for our NHS and our country". READ MORE: Assisted dying law PASSES Commons in historic moment - see how your MP voted He said the Department of Health and Social Care "will continue to work constructively with Parliament to assist on technical aspects of the Bill" as it goes through the House of Lords. But he warned: "Even with the savings that might come from assisted dying if people take up the service - and it feels uncomfortable talking about savings in this context to be honest - setting up this service will also take time and money that is in short supply. "There isn't a budget for this. Politics is about prioritising. It is a daily series of choices and trade-offs. I fear we've made the wrong one." Assisted dying campaigner Dame Esther Rantzen also urged peers not to block the landmark legislation. Dame Esther told BBC Radio 4's Today programme on Saturday: "I don't need to teach the House of Lords how to do their job. ‌ "They know it very well, and they know that laws are produced by the elected chamber. Their job is to scrutinise, to ask questions, but not to oppose. "So yes, people who are adamantly opposed to this Bill, and they have a perfect right to oppose it, will try and stop it going through the Lords, but the Lords themselves, their duty is to make sure that law is actually created by the elected chamber, which is the House of Commons who have voted this through." Dame Esther, who has terminal cancer, acknowledged the legislation would probably not become law in time for her to use it and she would have to "buzz off to Zurich" to use the Dignitas clinic.

Powys County Times

10 hours ago

• Powys County Times

New IT 'will defend Powys Council from cyber attack'

New IT will help protect Powys County Council against a cyber attack, council chiefs believe. At a meeting of the Governance and Audit committee on Friday, June 20, councillors and lay members received a report on the council's strategic risk register for the last quarter of 2024/2025 (January to end of March). The report says that the digital services department want to de-escalate the risk that the council's 'information and systems will be vulnerable to a cyberattack' from phishing emails. If senior councillors agree to this, the risk will drop down to be managed by a departmental risk register. Cllr Graham Breeze (Powys Independents) said: 'I'm really uncomfortable that we're asking for this to be de-escalated. 'The current situation we live in, worldwide massive organisations such as Marks and Spencer have come under a huge attack which has cost that company over £300 million to date. 'I'm interested to know how we feel so confident that we have control over this that we can de-escalate a risk I would consider to be one of the biggest we have as an authority. 'The sheer significance of this authority being hit by a cyberattack is unthinkable.' He wanted to be convinced that the council had a 'super system' to defend it from cyberattack. Head of digital services Ellen Sullivan said: 'The risk remains high, what is reduced is threat. 'We've actually purchased and deployed extra phishing software, so we have that across all our systems that detects any phishing concerns.' She added that extra 'phishing training' for staff had also been rolled out by the council. This means that 'fake emails' are sent out to test whether staff each month. Ms Sullivan explained that staff who click on the fake emails would then be given 'refresher training'. Cllr Chris Walsh (Labour) said: 'Cyber criminals will change their behaviour and tactics on a regular basis, it's not a stationary situation it's an evolving one. 'Reducing it feels slightly complacent.' Cabinet member for customers, digital and community services, Cllr Raiff Devlin (Liberal Democrat) said: 'There is no complacency here whatsoever. 'The council has invested significantly into its cyber defence. 'While members are absolutely correct to point out it's a dynamic environment, the key to maintaining our defence is our ongoing investment and there is a commitment by the cabinet to do just that. 'So, I feel that we are managing this risk appropriately and I'm reassured that the department has what it needs in place to do that.'

Leader Live

14 hours ago

• Leader Live

First Minister Eluned Morgan visits Wrexham University

Eluned Morgan MS toured the Enterprise Engineering and Optics Centre (EEOC) during her visit to the campus, meeting students and staff and learning more about the university's ambitions under its recently launched 2030 Vision and Strategy. The EEOC, which is expected to be completed soon, is the first construction project under the North Wales Growth Deal. Professor Joe Yates, vice-chancellor of Wrexham University, said: "We were delighted to welcome the First Minister to the University today and proudly showcase our incredible facilities – in particular, our Enterprise Engineering and Optics Centre, which is due to open at the start of the next academic year in September, as well as our cutting-edge Health Simulation Centre. "The visit also provided us with a welcome opportunity to highlight our newly launched 2030 Vision and Strategy, and also shine a light on how higher education institutions have a crucial role to play in helping to shape a more resilient and prosperous Wales. READ MORE: Celebrate the class of 2025 with your prom photos "Our work in building skills but also strengthening and developing a bilingual public sector workforce in North Wales, and our civic mission, in terms of providing systems leadership, demonstrates the positive impact our institution has on the communities we serve. "Thank you to the First Minister for her time and engagement with us today – it was a pleasure to welcome her, and showcase just some of our fantastic work." The First Minister toured the EEOC, which will serve as a centre for industry collaboration, research, and innovation, with the aim of supporting growth in renewables and manufacturing. Her visit came days before International Women in Engineering Day on June 23. During the tour, Ms Morgan spoke with Selina Thomas, a final-year aeronautical and mechanical engineering student, who shared her work with KnitMesh Technologies. She has been investigating the impact strength of composite materials for the North Wales-based company. The First Minister also visited the university's Health Simulation Centre, which provides immersive training environments for healthcare students and professionals. Staff highlighted the university's role in strengthening the public sector workforce in North Wales, with a focus on Welsh language provision. Since launching its Welsh Language Academic Strategy and Action Plan, 'Cyfle,' nearly three years ago, the university has introduced Welsh language modules across several degree programmes. These include speech and language therapy, professional policing, and education. Ms Morgan was also updated on the next phase of development within the university's Health and Education Innovation Quarter (HEIQ). This phase will introduce new teaching facilities, including virtual and augmented reality environments. It will also feature a new teaching and learning lab and a hydra simulation suite, developed in partnership with the Hydra Foundation. The suite will be designed to help students build decision-making skills by simulating emergency scenarios. Ms Morgan said: "I was pleased to see first-hand the facilities at Wrexham University, especially the EEOC, which will soon become a vital hub for industry collaboration and skills development across North Wales. "Through their civic work, our higher education institutions can serve as powerful anchors in their communities, supporting business and unlocking collective action to tackle inequality while preparing students for the jobs of tomorrow."