Second homes tax poses 'serious risk' to Millport's economy, islanders say
A second homes tax could pose a 'serious risk' to the Cumbrae island economy, according to the local community.
North Ayrshire Council is reconsidering its plans to bring a double council tax on second homes following backlash from the Cumbrae Community Council.
'Our community is extremely concerned that the impacts of this policy disproportionately impact Cumbrae,' Graham Wallace, advisor to Cumbrae Community Council, said.
'This is a cynical cash grab by North Ayrshire Council that will lead to vacant properties on our island that nobody wants. It will directly reduce vital income into our local economy.'
Back in February, North Ayrshire Council voted to double the council tax for second homes from April 1, 2025, bringing it into line with almost all other Scottish local authorities.
However, those plans are now under review.
The council opened up a consultation to review the double council tax charges on second homes following the Cumbrae Community Council's challenge at the end of April.
North Ayrshire Council previously argued that the aim was to increase the availability of housing by encouraging more homes to be used for living in, rather than lying empty for long periods.
However, the community of Millport – the town on Cumbrae – has argued that the second home council tax 'disproportionately' impacts the island's 'fragile' economy and housing balance.
'The type of properties that will be forced onto the market are not the ones permanent residents want,' Mr Wallace said.
'They are small flats in old buildings which are expensive to heat in the winter. We're calling for a proper plan, including a detailed study into Cumbrae's second homes, and a programme to make them fit for permanent occupation —rather than driving people and investment away.'
The local community council has claimed that the new tax could strip £500,000 annually from the island's economy, which generates approximately £12.9m per year.
'Given the island's reliance on tourism and part-time residents, this poses a serious risk to local jobs, services, and community stability,' a spokesperson from the Cumbrae Community Council said.
Despite a population of just 1,262, Cumbrae accounts for 30% of all second homes in North Ayrshire, which has a population of 133,413.
According to the Cumbrae Community Council, that means the per capita impact on the island will be '74 times greater than on the mainland'.
The community council is calling for residents, visitors and businesses to contribute to the consultation which closes on Tuesday May 20, 2025.
North Ayrshire Council has been contacted for comment.
Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News
Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Record
7 minutes ago
- Daily Record
Celtic see Matt O'Riley windfall put in major jeopardy as 'preferred' suitor performs £30m Brighton transfer trick
A host of Italian clubs are on alert despite the Premier League side remaining keen to keep the playmaker at the AMEX In-demand Matt O'Riley has reportedly told Brighton he would prefer to join Roma this summer if he leaves the club. But that could leave Celtic's sell-on windfall at risk with the Serie A giants looking to avoid a major Financial Fair Play pitfall. The Hoops have already seen the Parkhead coffers boosted this summer by a sell-on windfall after Jeremie Frimpong 's move to Liverpool from Bayer Leverkusen. And the Scottish champions powerbrokers are on alert again amid reports that Napoli made a £25.6million (€30million) offer for the Danish international just 12 months on from his £25million Parkhead exit. Celtic hold a 10 per cent sell-on clause in the deal that took the 24-year-old to the AMEX Stadium last season - but the Seagulls are said to be in no rush to sell with talks "ongoing" over a deal. La Gazzetta dello Sport now claim Roma have already made contact with the midfielder's entourage with O'Riley "eager" to join the club. However, I Giallorossi are said to be 'formulating" a loan offer with obligation to buy next summer - with Brighton demanding £30million for the playmaker. It is noted that Roma are currently focussed on selling players to balance the books before the June 30 FFP deadline. O'Riley is said to be willing to wait for a move to link up with Gian Piero Gasperini - who is a big fan of the player having previously attempted to bring him to Atalanta from Celtic. O'Riley endured an injury-hampered debut campaign at the AMEX Stadium but showed flashes of his best form in the final weeks of the season. But the man himself has bemoaned the fact he's been unable to play in his favoured position under head coach Fabian Hurzeler - with Georginio Rutter deployed in the playmaker role. Speaking in his homeland, the Denmark international said: "I am not completely happy, and I am just giving my opinion. 'It makes it difficult to show off when you play a position you are not completely happy with. I can play better for the team if I play the number eight position, but I can play well in other positions. "You can say it in a way that is not aggressive. If you are honest with another person, you don't lose anything. The coach can always say he doesn't agree." You can get all the news you need on our dedicated Rangers and Celtic pages, and sign up to our newsletters to make sure you never miss a beat throughout the season. We're also on WhatsApp, where we bring all the latest breaking news and transfer gossip directly to your phone. Join our Rangers community here and our Celtic community here.
The Herald Scotland
an hour ago
- The Herald Scotland
Family sells famed Scottish hotel where Romantics stayed
We revealed the sale of the hotel, visited by Dorothy Wordsworth and John Keats, this week. The hotel is renowned. (Image: Cornerstone Business Agents) The inn, which has operated since 1780, was also a regular stop-off point for Queen Victoria. The Cairndow Stagecoach Inn on the shore of Loch Fyne is described as one of the Highlands' oldest coaching inns. Cornerstone Business Agents said: 'We are delighted to have concluded the sale of the Cairndow Stagecoach Inn on behalf of the Fraser family.' Read the full story here Scottish business which worked on Liverpool FC's Anfield eyes growth Derek Pierce of J&D Pierce. (Image: Mike Wilkinson) One of Scotland's largest structural steel fabricators, which has worked on projects including the redevelopment of Glasgow Queen Street railway station and Liverpool FC's Anfield stadium, is gearing up for major expansion as it celebrates its 50th anniversary. J&D Pierce Contracts, based at Glengarnock in Ayrshire and 80%-owned by Swedish investment group Storskogen, expects annual turnover to rise towards £200 million as it capitalises on 'growth in key sectors including data centres, distribution hubs, distilleries, stadia and arenas, transport infrastructure, and the social and supply chain requirements related to renewable energy'. Accounts filed with Companies House last July show the turnover of J&D Pierce Contracts was £103.8 million in the year to December 31, 2023. Read Ian McConnell's story here BUSINESS INSIGHT 📈 Premier Inn bosses upbeat as hotels planned for Edinburgh Whitbread's Premier Inn portfolio spans hundreds of hotels in the UK and Germany. (Image: PA) Whitbread underlined the challenges facing the hotel sector today as it reported Premier Inn UK sales had dipped in the first quarter, with London showing a sharper decline than other parts of the country.
The Herald Scotland
an hour ago
- The Herald Scotland
John Swinnney: 'World must pull itself back from the brink'
He said he agreed with the UN Secretary General on the need for an end to the conflict through diplomacy. Mr Swinney said: 'The conflict in the Middle East has escalated to an intensely more dangerous and alarming level as a result of the US intervention overnight, which risks spiralling into disaster for the region and the wider world. 'The world finds itself at a profoundly dangerous moment and must pull itself back from the brink.' READ MORE: He added: 'It is vital that the UK Government takes any and all steps it can through diplomatic channels to insist upon that. We also call on Iran to return to negotiations.' United Nations Secretary-General Antonio Guterres said earlier on Sunday he was "gravely alarmed by the use of force" by the United States against Iran. 'This is a dangerous escalation in a region already on the edge – and a direct threat to international peace and security," he said. He added that there is a 'growing risk' that this conflict could 'rapidly get out of control – with catastrophic consequences for civilians, the region, and the world'. Mr Guterres called on member states to 'de-escalate' and 'uphold their obligations under the UN Charter and other rules of international law'. He said: 'At this perilous hour, it is critical to avoid a spiral of chaos. There is no military solution. The only path forward is diplomacy. The only hope is peace.' The First Minister's response to the developments in the Middle East came after Sir Keir Starmer urged Iran to return to negotiations. UK minister Douglas Alexander said the Government 'has been putting contingencies in place' as the region braces for any potential retaliation from Iran. US President Donald Trump said early on Sunday that three key nuclear sites in Iran were 'completely and fully obliterated' in the military strikes. The US is thought to have used B-2 stealth bombers to drop bunker-busting munitions on the sites – including the deeply-buried Fordo facility – as well as 30 Tomahawk cruise missiles launched from submarines. The US-UK base at Diego Garcia in the Indian Ocean is not thought to have been used in the operation. The Prime Minister had earlier said Iran should 'return to the negotiating table', noting the region remains 'volatile'. He said: 'Iran's nuclear programme is a grave threat to international security. 'Iran can never be allowed to develop a nuclear weapon and the US has taken action to alleviate that threat.' Former Scottish first minister Humza Yousaf was critical of the Prime Minister's response. He posted on social media: 'An awful statement from the PM, which ignores our collective responsibility to uphold international law. 'Supporting illegal military action in Iran, and gas-lighting us about an imminent nuclear threat, is hauntingly reminiscent of the lies told in the run up to the Iraq war.' During a protest march in London, Mr Yousaf had earlier accused the UK Government of 'abusing' anti-terror laws against the Palestine Action group, which vandalised two aircraft at RAF Brize Norton. Trade policy minister Mr Alexander, who is the MP for Lothian East and a former international development minister, spoke to the BBC's Sunday Show. He said: 'I understand that people have woken up this morning to the news that was breaking overnight with a real sense of concern. 'I want to assure your viewers that the British Government has been putting contingencies in place. 'There have been a whole series of meetings, I and other have been attending Cobra meetings in the course of the week.' He said plans are being put in place to move UK nationals in affected countries to safety, stressing the UK 'took no part in this military action'.
