Families of 737 Crash Victims Urge Rejection of Boeing Deal
(Bloomberg) -- Family members of people killed in two fatal crashes of Boeing Co.'s 737 Max jets urged a federal judge to reject a proposed deal the company reached with US prosecutors that would allow the planemaker to avoid a criminal charge.
Lawyers for 15 families argued Boeing should stand trial for criminal conspiracy as the government had originally planned, to hold the company more accountable for the deaths of 346 people, according to a court filing Wednesday.
'The conspiracy charge against Boeing has been pending now for more than four years,' the families' lawyers said. 'Boeing has admitted all the facts necessary to prove it is guilty. And yet, the government now moves to dismiss the charge.' They added, 'It is difficult to imagine a case more deserving of a public trial than this one.'
The US Justice Department in May asked US District Judge Reed O'Connor in Fort Worth to dismiss the case as part of a proposed settlement reached with Boeing. Under the deal, the planemaker agreed to pay more than $1.1 billion in fees and fines, while taking steps to strengthen internal quality and safety measures.
In return, the company will avoid criminal prosecution.
Prosecutors have argued that the deal 'secures meaningful accountability' and ensures Boeing faces penalties and oversight, an outcome they say would not be guaranteed if they took the case to trial.
A representative of Boeing didn't immediately respond to a request for comment.
In Wednesday's filing, lawyers for family members who oppose the agreement said it would essentially allow the company to 'buy its way out of a criminal conviction.'
The families also claimed language in the deal would obligate the government to not prosecute Boeing even if O'Connor rejects the motion to dismiss the case, which would skirt full judicial review.
'If this court approves the parties' maneuver in this widely publicized case, then this unprecedented approach will likely become the blueprint for all future dismissal motions in federal criminal prosecutions,' they said in the filing.
Relatives of crash victims have spent years fighting for harsher penalties for Boeing following the two fatal crashes of its 737 Max jet in 2018 and 2019. Both crashes were linked to a flawed flight control system on the jets.
The families said the fatal Air India crash earlier this month involving a Boeing 787 Dreamliner shows that 'the stakes for aviation safety are very high.' The cause of the crash remains under investigation.
To be sure, some families support the settlement. But those who want Boeing to go to trial said the company had dangled money 'in front of the families, apparently hoping that it will lead them to back off their efforts to hold Boeing accountable for killing their loved ones. And Boeing's offer appears to have had the desired effect, at least with respect to a few families.'
If O'Connor agrees to a dismissal, it would end the long-running criminal case against Boeing over the crashes. But it would also mark a notable reversal in the proceedings. Just last year, Boeing had agreed to plead guilty to the pending criminal conspiracy charge under a deal that was ultimately rejected by O'Connor.
Under the new settlement Boeing will admit to the underlying accusation of 'conspiracy to obstruct and impede the lawful operation of the Federal Aviation Administration Aircraft Evaluation Group,' but that admission does not constitute a guilty plea.
The government said it could refile criminal charges against the company if Boeing is accused of violating the terms of the two-agreement. Some family members dispute that claim, saying the statute of limitations has already expired.
The agreement requires Boeing to pay a total of $1.1 billion in assorted fines and fees. The total includes:
Boeing would be required to retain a so-called independent compliance consultant to oversee its efforts to improve the effectiveness of its anti-fraud compliance and ethics program. The consultant will be expected to make recommendations for improvements and report their findings directly to the government.
The case is US v. Boeing, 21-cr-005, US District Court, Northern District of Texas (Fort Worth).
--With assistance from Allyson Versprille.
(Updates with outreach to Boeing for comment.)
More stories like this are available on bloomberg.com
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Mint
4 hours ago
- Mint
US Refining Capacity Declines Amid Uncertain Fuel Demand Outlook
(Bloomberg) -- US refiners' operating capacity edged lower in 2024 as an uncertain outlook for gasoline and diesel prompted fuelmakers to pull back after a period of expansion. America's refining fleet — the world's largest — contracted by 43,000 barrels a day in 2024, shrinking to 18.3 million barrels a day of operating capacity, according to an Energy Information Administration report that gives a snapshot of the industry as of Jan. 1 each year. US refining capacity has swung between expansion and contraction over the past five years. The pandemic-driven drop in demand in 2020 ushered in a wave of US refinery closures that pulled nationwide capacity below 18 million barrels a day for the first time since 2014. Since then, ExxonMobil Corp., Valero Energy Corp, Marathon Petroleum and Citgo undertook major expansion projects that boosted capacity closer to pre-pandemic levels. Now, fuelmaking is once again in decline. Since January, LyondellBasell Industries NV's 264,000 barrel-a-day Houston refinery permanently ceased operations, and Phillips 66 will close its 139,000 barrel-a-day Los Angeles plant at the end of this year. Valero is set to close its 145,000 barrel-a-day Benicia refinery in California's Bay Area in early 2026, continuing a decades-long trend of smaller, logistically and financially challenged US refineries pulling the plug. Those two California refinery closures may push America's fuel making capacity back to pandemic lows of around 17.8 million barrels a day. While smaller refineries have closed, mega plants on the Gulf Coast have boosted capacity, making less complex facilities uncompetitive. Motiva's refinery in Port Arthur, Texas, grew to an operating capacity of 641,000 barrels a day in 2024, vaulting it over Marathon's nearby 631,000-barrel Galveston Bay plant to become the largest in the nation, according to the EIA annual report. Saudi Aramco-owned Motiva continues to push capacity higher at its Texas plant, the only refinery it owns in the US, and processed as much as 651,000 barrels of oil a day in December. More stories like this are available on
Time of India
4 hours ago
- Time of India
Cryptocurrency Live News & Updates : Bitcoin Dips Below $103K Amid Market Volatility
21 Jun 2025 | 02:05:12 AM IST Over 35 million Ether is now staked, leading to tighter liquidity as investors favor passive yields over trading. Corporate treasuries, including SharpLink, are driving this trend. The cryptocurrency landscape is witnessing significant developments as staked Ether (ETH) has surpassed 35 million tokens, accounting for over 28% of Ethereum's circulating supply. This trend reflects a growing preference for passive yield strategies among investors, particularly corporate treasuries like SharpLink, which recently staked a substantial portion of its ETH holdings. Meanwhile, optimism is rising around the approval of various crypto exchange-traded funds (ETFs), with Bloomberg analysts estimating a 90% or higher chance for many filings, including those for XRP, Solana (SOL), and Dogecoin (DOGE). The SEC's recent engagement is seen as a positive sign for these approvals. Additionally, Solana continues to thrive, reporting over $1 billion in app revenue for two consecutive quarters and attracting a significant number of developers. As the crypto market evolves, the interplay between staking, institutional investment, and potential ETF approvals will be crucial in shaping the future of digital assets. Show more
Mint
6 hours ago
- Mint
AQR's Cliff Asness Sides With Jim Chanos in Critique of Michael Saylor's Strategy
Bloomberg Published 21 Jun 2025, 01:26 AM IST (Bloomberg) -- AQR Capital Management's Cliff Asness says he's in agreement with famed short seller Jim Chanos when it comes to his criticism of Strategy founder Michael Saylor's claim that the use of convertible debt affords the leveraged Bitcoin proxy downside protection while continuing to accumulate the cryptocurrency. The critique is centered around whether there is 'recourse' for the company formally known as MicroStrategy Inc. to pay back holders of its convertible bonds, through which Strategy raised roughly $10 billion to fund Bitcoin purchases. While Saylor said this type of debt 'is not going to get called' and can be paid off with stock if the price of Bitcoin tumbles, both Asness and Chanos disagreed. In a Friday post on social media platform X, Asness said Chanos 'is of course right.' It is yet another twist as the back and forth between Chanos and Saylor is becoming a Wall Street battle for the ages. In separate Bloomberg interviews last week, Chanos said the Saylor's model to value the crypto-treasury firm is 'financial gibberish' while Saylor argued that Chanos just does not understand it. Earlier, Chanos recommended an arbitrage trade to short the shares of Strategy and buy Bitcoin, betting the large premium the stock commands over the value of its token holdings will shrink. Shares of Strategy were little changed on Friday, and have risen 27% so far this year. The stock had surged more than 3,000% since Saylor began buying Bitcoin in the middle of 2020. More stories like this are available on
