'A huge relief': Man who feared fine or jail time over insulation added to house receives planning permission

A MAN WHO was threatened with jail or a €5,000 fine for retrofitting his home has been granted retrospective planning permission.
Clive Ryan had put new insulation in the wall at the front of his home in Kilnamanagh in the Ballymount area of Dublin in 2018.
Earlier this year
, he received a letter from South Dublin County Council telling him that he had to 'cease and discontinue the use of the insulation' and to 'remove the insulation and, in so far as is practicable, reinstate the facade to its condition prior to the commencement of the development'.
Otherwise, under the terms of the Planning and Development Act 2000, he could face a fine which can reach up to €5,000, or even a jail term for up to six months.
He had received a grant worth more than €4,000 to help pay for the costs from the Sustainable Energy Authority of Ireland. The other €13,000 came from his own pocket.
'Huge relief'
With the help of councillors, Ryan applied for planning permission, which has since been granted. He said it's a 'huge relief'.
Ryan believes the publicity around his case, as well as the support of local representatives, ultimately helped him.
'We tried ourselves and I don't think we would've got any further with it … I was down an avenue I'd never been.'
Advertisement
Ryan says, despite the arduous process to get planning permission, he still recommends people retrofit their homes.
'I think it's brilliant,' he said. 'It brought down our bills significantly.'
When Ryan spoke to The Journal in March, he said he found the case 'baffling', explaining that while the insulation expanded the facade of the house, it is not visible when looking at the home.
'It probably moves the house forward a few inches – that's what the insulation does. But that's the only logical thing I can come up with.
'The rest of the house is done like every other house. The insulation is just around the window. It's not a new structure, we tried to finish it as neat and as clean as we could.'
While some forms of insulation and solar panels are exempt from planning permission, the situation with insulation for external walls is not so cut and dried.
The Green Party is calling on the government to introduce further planning exemptions.
'It's hard enough for people to take time out of their busy lives to begin the process of a home retrofit. Government, including local councils, should be making it as easy as possible,' a spokesperson said.
As well as the planning exemption, Green Party want specific grants tailored for neighbours to retrofit together, to speed up retrofitting around the country and lower household energy bills.
Mark Lynch, a Green Party councillor for the Rathfarnham-Templeogue area said it needs to be made 'as easy as possible' for people to retrofit their homes.
Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone...
A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article.
Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation.
Learn More
Support The Journal

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Irish Examiner

an hour ago

• Irish Examiner

Politicians condemn attack on Belfast Islamic Centre while people prayed

An attack on the Islamic Centre in Belfast while people were praying on Friday has been condemned by politicians. A local MLA said a device was thrown inside the building during evening prayer and forced it to be evacuated. Police said they attended a security alert on University Road in south Belfast on Friday night. A number of cordons were put in place and members of the public were asked to avoid the area. A 34-year-old man was arrested and was taken into police custody. Alliance MLA for South Belfast Paula Bradshaw condemned the attack, which she said did 'not reflect the diversity of south Belfast in 2025'. 'This attack was again designed to cause fear among people inside the centre, who were at prayer at the time. 'Nevertheless, I am thankful for the intervention of a nearby passer-by and for the work of the police. Those were much more reflective of the true spirit of Belfast, where most people rejoice in diversity. 'I would like to express my solidarity with all those who were evacuated and my thanks to all those who worked to ensure their safety.' Sinn Féin MLA Deirdre Hargey said 'no-one should ever feel unsafe in their place of worship'. 'Acts like these, fuelled by hate, spread fear and division, and target people who have come to our communities to build a life and call this place home. 'It's vital that all political leaders speak out and stand united against this disgusting behaviour.' Green Party Councillor Aine Groogan condemned the attack as a 'cowardly and vicious act'. 'I am horrified to hear about the attack on the Islamic Centre during evening prayers,' she said. 'I want to pay tribute to the courageous passer-by who intervened and prevented what could have been a far more tragic outcome. 'It is terrifying to consider what might have happened and I sincerely hope that all those present are recovering from this traumatic ordeal.' She added: 'This attack is yet another reminder of the very real danger faced by our Islamic community. The recent rise in racist hate and violence on our streets is a shameful stain on our society. 'We must all take responsibility for actively challenging racism, misinformation and bigotry wherever it appears before someone is seriously hurt. 'I urge those politicians who continue to hide behind the notion of so-called 'legitimate concerns' around migration to reflect on the consequences of their words. 'Such narratives are as disingenuous as they are dangerous. They help foster a culture in which hate can thrive. Frankly, they should know better.'

Sunday World

7 days ago

• Sunday World

Hotel manager ran red light and crashed into parked car after drinking bottle of wine

Jennifer Ryan of Butterfield, Rathfarnham, Dublin 14, pleaded guilty at Tallaght District Court to drink-driving at Butterfield Park on February 10, 2024. A 55-year-old hotel manager who was observed running a red light and colliding with a parked car after drinking a bottle of wine has been banned from driving for three years and ordered to complete a restorative justice programme. Jennifer Ryan of Butterfield, Rathfarnham, Dublin 14, pleaded guilty at Tallaght District Court to drink-driving at Butterfield Park on February 10, 2024. Garda Ciarán Kelly told the court that at around 8.45pm, his attention was drawn to a car stopped at the top of a queue of traffic lights on Butterfield Avenue. The vehicle had reversed slightly towards the car behind. Stock image: Getty Today's News in 90 Seconds - June 14 2025 When gardaí pulled alongside, he said the driver slowly proceeded through a red light and did not stop when directed. The court heard the driver turned onto Butterfield Park and collided with a parked car, causing damage to both vehicles. Garda Kelly approached the driver's side and instructed the woman to turn off the engine. He noted a strong smell of alcohol and slurred speech from the driver. The court heard that a urine sample later returned a reading of 347 milligrams of alcohol per 100 millilitres of urine, well over the legal limit. The court heard that Ryan had no previous convictions. Her defence counsel, Lauren Flanagan BL, said that Ryan was 'desperately sorry' and had been under significant emotional strain at the time. She told the court that her client had consumed a full bottle of wine in one sitting and had since voluntarily given up driving, prompting Judge John O'Leary to ask: 'Would it not be easier for her to give up alcohol than driving?' Ms Flanagan said her client accepted she had an issue with alcohol and was actively engaging with support services. She said Ryan is currently receiving treatment through St John of God's addiction programme. Judge O'Leary convicted the defendant, imposed a €400 fine with six months to pay and disqualified her from driving for three years. He also ordered that she complete a restorative justice programme under the supervision of the Probation Service, and adjourned the case to September 5 next for a progress review. If the fine is paid and the restorative justice programme is completed, the court indicated no further penalty will be imposed. Funded by the Courts Reporting Scheme.

The Irish Sun

13-06-2025

• The Irish Sun

Olympic rider, 66, filmed striking horse '40 times' in ‘most awful video' banned a year on from Charlotte Dujardin shame

FORMER Olympian Heath Ryan has been suspended following the emergence of a distressing video in which he can be seen whipping a horse around 40 times. Ryan, 66, represented Australia in dressage at Beijing 2008. 3 Footage showed Heath Ryan repeatedly whipping a horse Credit: 3 Ryan, 66, competed at Beijing 2008 Credit: Getty Equestrian Australia have since suspended the Sydney-born rider, while launching an official investigation into the online video. Their statement read: "Equestrian Australia is extremely alarmed and concerned by the treatment of the horse shown in this footage. "Our policies include high standards to protect all participants and their horses against any adverse physical, social, and emotional conditions." In a lengthy Facebook post, Ryan claimed that he had been trying to save the horse, named Nico, from being put down - and that the footage was taken around two years ago. READ MORE SPORT NEWS An excerpt of his post read: "Oh my goodness! The most awful video of me on a young horse has just surfaced. "This horse was dropped off at my place on his way to the knackery. His name is Nico. He was 6 years of age. A beautiful type. "(After the events of the video) I rode Nico for another couple of days and he responded very well. "All of this transpired sincerely with the horse's best interests the sole consideration. Most read in Olympics "I need to add that this happened about two years ago…..and the video has been posted by an unhappy ex-employee. "All I can say is that this awful video was collateral damage of me from the bottom of my heart launching a rescue mission." Dressage trainer at centre of Charlotte Dujardin vid leak unmasked and says Team GB star 'threw her under bus' Ryan went on to add: "I am so sad this was caught on video. If I had been thinking of myself I would have immediately just gotten off and sent Nico to the knackery. "That video was a life or death moment for Nico and I genuinely had to try my very hardest to see if Nico would consider other options. "All of this transpired sincerely with the horse's best interests the sole consideration. Unbelievably it was so successful for everyone except me with the release of this video." DUJARDIN CONTROVERSY Last summer, decorated British Olympian Dujardin, 39, was subsequently The three-time Olympic gold medallist subsequently released a statement, in which she revealed that she was pregnant. It read: "I fully respect the verdict issued by the Federation for Equestrian Sports (FEI), released today. "As the federation has recognised, my actions in the video do not reflect who I am and I can only apologise again. "I understand the responsibility that comes with my position in the sport, and I will forever aim to do better. This has undoubtedly been one of the darkest and most difficult periods of my life, and I would like to take this opportunity to thank everyone who has supported me during this time. "To those of you who have sent messages, emails and tried to reach me to check in on how I am – thank you. Every kind word truly has made a difference, more than you'll ever know. "What I was unable to share at the time is that I am currently pregnant, with my baby due in February. "This was planned well before the Olympics and something my partner Dean and I have been excited about for a long time. "At the moment, the energy I have is focused on Dean and our daughter Isabella, and we are all very much looking forward to the arrival of our new family member." 3 Charlotte Dujardin was suspended last year Credit: PA