Curiosity Finds First In Situ Evidence of Carbon Cycle on Ancient Mars
A surprise discovery in Gale Crater is the component that was missing in the puzzle of Mars's climate history.
There, embedded in the bedrock, the Curiosity rover has identified a mineral called siderite that can only have formed from the precipitation of carbon from the Martian atmosphere. In other words, billions of years ago, Mars had an active carbon cycle.
It's the first in situ evidence of the carbon cycle on Mars, and it represents an important clue about whether or not the red planet could ever have supported life.
"It tells us that the planet was habitable and that the models for habitability are correct," says geochemist Benjamin Tutolo of the University of Calgary in Canada.
One of the biggest questions about ancient Mars involves its water. All evidence points to a planet that was rich in bodies of liquid water on its surface, with lakes and oceans that sloshed and lapped and crashed in waves upon shorelines.
In order to be warm and stable enough for this liquid water, the atmosphere of Mars would have needed a significant amount of carbon dioxide, belched into the sky by the active volcanoes that were once rampant on the surface.
Much of this carbon dioxide would have leaked out into space, but enough would have remained to warm Mars, and leave traces in the minerals on the surface.
There's just one itty bitty problem.
"Models predict that carbonate minerals should be widespread, but, to date, rover-based investigations and satellite-based orbital surveys of the Martian surface have found little evidence of their presence," Tutolo told ScienceAlert.
The shock new discovery was found in data from 2022 and 2023, when the Curiosity rover, which has been beavering around Gale Crater for more than 10 years now, made X-ray diffraction analyses of minerals from different parts of the crater floor using its Chemistry and Mineralogy (CheMin) instrument.
Tutolo and his colleagues carefully analyzed the measurements made by Curiosity, and found remarkably pure crystalline siderite in three of the four drill holes bored by Curiosity. This siderite, mostly composed of iron and carbon trioxide, with trace amounts of magnesium, stunned the researchers.
"We were surprised to find carbonate minerals here because even the most detailed investigations of the orbital spectroscopy data acquired over these sedimentary rocks were unable to identify carbonate minerals," Tutolo said.
"It turns out that the presence of other minerals – particularly highly water-soluble magnesium sulfate salts – likely masks the signature of carbonate minerals in the orbital data. Because similar rocks containing these salts have been identified globally, we infer that they, too, likely contain abundant carbonate minerals."
So, not only does the discovery finally pony up the carbonate minerals scientists expected to find, it reveals why scientists have been unable to find them previously, and how to look for more of them across the red planet.
The siderite identified in Curiosity data helps confirm and refine models of Mars's early warm period, more than 3.5 billion years ago. It confirms that carbon dioxide was abundant in the Martian atmosphere, and helped keep the planet warm enough for water; and that carbon was extracted from the atmosphere and trapped in minerals on the surface.
But the formation of siderite, while good news for scientists studying Mars today, was part of the end of an era for Mars itself.
"The important feature of the ancient Martian carbon cycle that we outline in this study is that it was imbalanced. In other words, substantially more CO2 seems to have been sequestered into the rocks than was subsequently released back into the atmosphere," Tutolo explained.
"Because Mars is further away from the Sun than Earth, it needs substantially more CO2 in its atmosphere to maintain habitable conditions. The observation that geochemical processes were capturing and sequestering that CO2 suggests that this imbalanced carbon cycle may have challenged Mars's ability to remain habitable."
These results have several implications. Now that scientists know that siderite is effectively invisible to orbital instruments, they can go back over previous data and look for strange signs of its presence they may have overlooked. In addition, rover-collected data may have more evidence of carbonate minerals.
Now that researchers know mineral carbon sequestration took place on Mars, they can incorporate this information into models of the planet's climate history, and determine what role, if any, this capture played in the decline of Mars's habitability.
These minerals, so common and unremarkable on Earth, have opened up a whole new way of understanding Mars.
"I was trained as an aqueous geochemist and spent much of my career to date working on carbon sequestration as a solution for human-driven climate change. Working alongside the exceptionally talented and diverse expertise of the Mars Science Laboratory team, I was ultimately able to apply the knowledge I have gained from my climate change solutions work to interpret these mineralogical observations," Tutolo said.
"Frankly, if you told me about all of this when I was 15, I never would have believed it!"
The findings have been published in Science Advances.
There's A Sky Full of Meteors in April! Here's What's on This Easter Weekend
Meet Zhúlóng, The Milky Way 'Twin' That Shakes Up Our Cosmic Timeline
New Form of Dark Matter May Explain Milky Way's Core Mysteries
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
2 days ago
- Yahoo
How does a rockslide happen? 'The mountain that moves' was Canada's deadliest
A large rockslide in Banff National Park at Bow Glacier Falls left two hikers dead and up to 13 others injured Thursday, raising questions about how and why the disaster occurred. But a look at published research and archive news articles on rockslides provides some general information about the dangerous occurrences. A rockslide happens when a large chunk of rock detaches itself from the mountain where it sits and begins sliding down the slope. Why does this occur? Well, natural erosion or seismic activity can cause a rockslide, as can heavy rainfalls. Human activity such as excavation, construction or mining can also lead to a rockslide. As one chunk of rock begins its downward slide, it can quickly gain momentum and trigger massive amounts of other rock to also begin sliding, leading to devastating effects. notes a landslide or rockslide can occur 'when gravitational and other types of shear stresses within a slope exceed the shear strength (resistance to shearing) of the materials that form the slope.' Dr. Dan Shugar, a University of Calgary geoscience professor, said rockslides are a fairly common geological phenomenon, particularly in the Rocky Mountains, due to how steep the slopes are. The composition of rock is largely limestone, which is susceptible to water saturation, making the rocks heavier. 'Ultimately, the cause is gravity,' he said. 'Mountains get built up over geological time and then they get torn down. That's an entirely natural process. 'We see rockfalls, rock avalanches, rockslides — we see a variety of mass wasting in mountain environments all the time. They range from a small boulder that would hurt you if it hit you but wouldn't be that damaging to entire mountain sides collapsing, and everything in between.' A landslide occurs when sediment or loose dirt disengages from a hill or mountain and begins moving downwards. A rockslide, however, means solid rocks are also being swept down a slope during a similar type of event. Rockslides are also incredibly fast-moving, as they tend to move down a flat surface of a mountain. The Canadian Encyclopedia notes a rockslide can move up to 100 km/hr. The most horrific rockslide in Canadian history occurred in 1903 when a huge slab of Turtle Mountain crashed down onto the town of Frank and Crowsnest Pass (about 250 kilometres southwest of Calgary). At least 72 known residents were killed in the natural disaster, as were an undetermined number of others visiting or passing through the area. Some historians thus put the death toll closer to 90. An estimated 80 to 110 million tonnes of rock were involved in the deadly event that came to be known as Frank Slide. The rockslide only lasted about a minute and a half. Newspaper clippings and archive stories from the rockslide describe the horrific results that led to the deaths of men, women and children. As those clippings note, information about the state of some of the victims was disturbing, but shed light on how powerful the rockslide was: 'The leg and hip of a man was found lying fifty yards from the Imperial Hotel.' First Nations people in the area had noticed instability in the mountain decades earlier and even had a name for it that translated to 'the mountain that moves.' The geological structure of Turtle Mountain was said to be the primary cause of Frank Slide, but weather impacts and coal mining were also noted as factors in the deadly rockslide. An interpretive centre in Frank now tells the story of the slide and history of the area. Other Canadian rockslides of note include the 1841 rockfall in the Lower Town of Quebec City, killing 32 people and crushing eight homes, and the 1889 rockslide in the same area that killed more than 40, says the Canadian Encyclopedia. The worst rockslide worldwide was the Haiyuan Landslides of 1920 in China, when more than 200,000 people were killed. An earthquake caused those landslides. Apart from the Frank Slide, Shugar said Alberta has surprisingly not had that many significant rockfall events. He noted B.C. tends to get more, citing the Hope Slide of 1965 as an example. 'It certainly was a very big, impressive landslide right by the highway,' he said. The 680-tonne Big Rock, a type of quartzite, is an intriguing tourist attraction at Rocky Mountain House in Alberta, but how did this boulder measuring 9.7 metres by 9.4 metres by 5.5 metres get there? Well, the Rocky Mountain House Mountaineer reported the following 11 years back: 'Right around 20,000 years ago the Late Wisconsinan Glaciation was at its height; it was a glacier that could have been one kilometre thick. We know that all of the rocks in the Foothills Erratic Train come from the upper Athabasca drainage area south of Jasper,' said author and geologist Ben Gadd. 'A rockslide, almost certainly, dropped the rocks on the glacier. The glacier then eventually began to flow eastward until running into the Laurentide ice sheet (a glacier much larger than the one carrying the boulders) right around the Edson area. The larger glacier forced the smaller one to begin to move southeastward, right towards Rocky Mountain House.' Along with this Big Rock, another famous boulder that is part of the Foothills Erratic Train is the big rock in Okotoks, south of Calgary. The Okotoks Erratic is 16,500 tonnes in size, but was discovered in large pieces rather than a single stone. As the glacier, now on a new path, moved in the southeastward direction, it slowly began to melt. And as this process continued, the boulders that fell and became embedded in the glacier from the upper Athabasca drainage area began to drop from the flowing glacier. According to Shugar, the U of C geoscientist, the short answer is probably yes. The reason for that is due to how climate change is accelerating glacial retreat, which causes rock to become less stable. Temperature and precipitation changes are other components, as warmer temperatures can melt more ice and increased rainfall can change glacial mass or erode cliffs, making them steeper. 'These landscapes, as they become newly created or newly exposed by glacier retreat, they often are unstable,' Shugar said. 'There's a sort of relaxation time over which they adjust to this new paradigm, new reality for them. Quite often they're very steep because of glacier erosion and so they need time to relax back to a geographical equilibrium.' In glaciated mountains like in the Rockies, Shugar said that as glaciers retreat, we can expect to see more landslides. In the case of the Bow Glacier Falls rockslide, he suspects there have been side-effects due to the recent creation of a new proglacial lake, which formed just 70 years ago at the toe of the Bow Glacier. He suspects that over those seven decades, water from that new lake has been seeping into the rock, saturating it over the years and making it heavier. 'We see this all over the place,' he said. 'This isn't unique to this particular location, but I suspect part of the ultimate cause of this event yesterday (Thursday) was that saturated rock.'
Atlantic
2 days ago
- Atlantic
Three Giants, Talking While Hurtling Through Space
Space is where billionaires dream. Jeff Bezos thinks that we will soon move heavy industry and most humans off-planet onto massive revolving space stations, allowing the Earth to return to a pristine state. Elon Musk has famously argued that in order for humanity to survive all manner of calamities—asteroids, global warming, nuclear war—we must become an interplanetary species. He wants a million people settled on Mars by 2050. Larry Page has described this biosphere 'backup' as a 'philanthropical' act, and has invested in asteroid-mining ventures that will support it. Whatever their motivations—charitable, scientific, certainly commercial—their imaginations have long been fueled by science fiction. In stories such as Isaac Asimov's Foundation series and Star Trek, the genre has positioned outer space as the frontier that humanity must cross in order to transcend earthbound dilemmas. Musk, Bezos, and Mark Zuckerberg are all fans of Iain Banks's Culture series, which imagines a post-scarcity socialist utopia where all of our measly 21st-century problems have been solved by technological advancement. The arch-capitalists aren't deterred from pursuing it, though. They just want to have their hands on the controls. But what if space fails to live up to its billing? The technology for extraplanetary stations large enough to accommodate extensive human life remains theoretical. Martian soil is toxic, the air unbreathable, the atmosphere so thin that anyone who spent even a short time on its surface would be hit with massive doses of radiation. And our prejudices and hierarchies will almost certainly follow us to the stars. If, as seems likely, these planets are first populated by private companies such as SpaceX, then off-planet settlers would be dependent on their corporate sponsors for food, air, and life-sustaining technology. This skepticism has its own science-fiction tradition, in which space exploration follows the patterns of exploitation visible already on Earth. Ursula K. Le Guin's 1972 The Word for World Is Forest envisions space exploration as a recapitulation of earlier colonial conflicts. In Bong Joon Ho's most recent film, Mickey 17, a desperate space colonist volunteers himself to be cloned again and again, exchanging a lethal job for passage to another world. A similar cannon-fodder dynamic appears in Claire Denis' 2018 film, High Life, in which a group of criminals, sentenced to death on Earth, are enlisted in a suicide mission and directed straight into a black hole—space exploration as prison labor. And such fatal bargains are all over the work of the filmmaker Paul Verhoeven, who directed RoboCop and Starship Troopers, movies in which the bodies and souls of regular people are commandeered for the benefit of the powerful. In Pip Adam's extraordinary, humane novel Audition, recently released in the United States, space is both the dystopian place where humanity's worst impulses flourish and a site of uncharted possibility where humans can become something entirely new. The story follows three giants who are hurtling through space. Once, they were all regular-size humans, but then, for unknown reasons, they began to grow until they were at least three times the size of other people. They were feared, and then hated, and then, in their strange way, envied. As a result, they were packed off into spaceships and shot away from Earth—heading, like High Life 's prisoners, for a black hole. Their ship is designed according to a strange, symbiotic principle: It gets its power from the giants' speech, and the giants must speak so that they don't grow even more. Yet something has gone wrong. When the novel begins, Alba, Stanley, and Drew, the remaining crew of the Audition, are trapped throughout the ship—one crammed into a hallway, another wedged between the floor and ceiling of a basketball court. At one time, it seems, the giants had staged a sound strike, refusing to speak with one another or to the ship. Only too late did they realize that their silence made them grow much more rapidly than before, and now they barely fit aboard. So the trio speak with one another from where they're stuck, their voices carrying through the pipes and the walls. Pages and pages of dialogue go nowhere and carry no real meaning. They speak in the plural, almost as a collective, like a sci-fi variation on Virginia Woolf's The Waves. 'We were giant on Earth, and it was terrifying—for everyone,' Alba says, but her thoughts could well be the group's. They describe many things as beautiful, many times, and repeat the meal schedule: Monday is 'vegan superfood buddha bowl day.' Tuesday is 'Greek roasted fish with vegetables.' Whenever they try to tell stories about their own pasts, the events sound awfully like the plots of mediocre rom-coms such as Never Been Kissed and the Jennifer Lopez vehicle Maid in Manhattan. Whenever they approach something like the truth, their words do not seem up to the task of describing it, and they continue speaking in a roundabout, inane manner. Alba believes that she is in space simply because it 'is the biggest room so there is no reason for me to go anywhere else.' All this uninformative talk encourages the giants to attack themselves rather than whoever put them on the Audition. It becomes clear, although they are only intermittently aware of it, that before they took off, the giants were confined in an open-air stadium they call 'the classroom.' There, the giants gradually lost all sense of self. Their days were spent learning dull, repetitive tasks. Their life histories were replaced by those romantic-comedy plots. And they were made to think of themselves as essentially inferior. 'The best thing is to be stupid and we are stupid,' Alba says. 'It is a gift we needed to return to. It is better to be stupid and it is better to not try and work out things.' They repeat, to the point of absurdity, phrases such as I want to say and The story is. All those extra words filling the air don't just fuel the ship; they also prevent its inhabitants from realizing what has been taken from them. Adam is showing how even language, the medium of the novel, can be polluted, corrupted, and transformed into a means of exploitation. Words turn from meaningful communication into pure, distracting noise. In a rare silent moment, the group reflects on how cheeseburgers sound: on the grill, as they're being put together, and especially in the mouth. This inspires another thought: that despite remembering the meal schedule, the giants have not eaten in a very long time, and, incarcerated in the ship, they might well starve to death. But their trained language distracts them. 'They really have nothing to complain about because really a bit of discomfort isn't so much,' their collective thought goes. 'Really. Like not so much.' They cannot be silent long enough to actually think, and they have been transformed into their own hall monitors. They are heading toward the event horizon of a black hole, a natural phenomenon that the Harvard astronomer Avi Loeb, in an epigraph, describes as 'the ultimate prison wall—one can get in but never get out.' Clearly, Adam is investigating what happens to the incarcerated, and as time passes, her main trio's confinement begins to look more purposeful than before. When, about halfway through the book, they pass through the event horizon, time distends, and realization floods through them all about how they knew one another before the classroom—even before becoming giants. They're marked and bonded by shared damage, violence, and shame; this might even, Adam implies, be the source of their growth. This realization reconfigures the entire book, recasting their ongoing dialogue and seemingly cordial relations as an interstellar jail—and the novel itself into an extended, especially cruel prison sentence. Audition can be a caustic, biting book, full of insights into the many cages we construct for the unwanted. But the event horizon, which at first represents their permanent banishment, becomes a frontier of hope when they finally cross it. They find themselves in an endless space beyond, which imposes no limit and seems to shape itself around them and their needs. There, they encounter other life-forms, and are offered some kind of status as visitors. Life in this new world comes with its own struggles and demands and obligations, yet without the divisions and distinctions that trapped them within the ship. After so much speaking, they find themselves deciding on what to do next, then acting together, not as opponents confined within a closed system but as participants in something huge and fluid and vitalizing. 'They're all inside her and she's inside all of them,' Alba thinks, 'although maybe inside and outside are pointless at this stage.' Only through the achievement of some new, unheard-of association can they hope to be free of their past shame, and discover as-yet-unknown pleasures. Like the billionaires and their sci-fi dream weavers, Adam is using outer space to imagine alternative forms of human relation. But with Audition, she wants to escape the gravitational trap of Earth's prejudices and hierarchies, its forms of ownership and exploitation. Rather than making space a lockup for the unworthy, or a new frontier upon which to exert our will, she searches for something far more expansive among the stars. We must move, she suggests, beyond the hard borders that separate, isolate, and constrain life on Earth today. Across the event horizon lies true possibility. But first we must find our way out of the cage.
Hamilton Spectator
2 days ago
- Hamilton Spectator
Researchers discover ancient predatory, fanged fish that swam in Nova Scotia waters
HALIFAX - Researchers have discovered a new species of ancient fish with hooked front fangs that made them a fearsome and effective predator. A paper published in the Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology this week says the long, curved jaw of the animal sheds light on how fish were evolving smaller, front teeth that acted like fishing hooks, about 350 million years ago. Meanwhile, the centimetre-long back fangs were used to chew the catch before digestion into a body that may have been almost a metre long. They hunted for prey in the inland waters of Nova Scotia, in what was likely a vast inland lake. Lead author Conrad Wilson, a doctoral candidate in paleontology at Carleton University, said in an interview Friday that the fish has been named Sphyragnathus tyche, with the first phrase meaning 'hammer jaw.' 'I would say it's a fairly fearsome looking fish. If its mouth is open, you would see those fangs in the jaw,' he said. But the fossil is also significant for the clues it offers to the evolution of ray-finned fish — a huge and diverse vertebrate group that occupies a wide range of aquatic and semi-aquatic environments around the globe. 'These fish were the last major group of vertebrates to be identified and we still have big gaps in our knowledge about their early evolution,' said the researcher, who published his paper with Chris Mansky, a fossil researcher at the Blue Beach Fossil Museum in Hantsport, N.S., and Jason Anderson, a professor of anatomy at the veterinary faculty at the University of Calgary. 'The fossils are telling us about what the fish existing right after a mass extinction looked like,' said Wilson, referring to the transition from the Devonian to the Carboniferous periods. Wilson says paleontologists have wondered how ray-finned fish recovered from the extinction period as other groups of fish, such as the heavily armed category referred to as placoderms, were disappearing. 'The beach where this fossil was discovered tells us is ... this is a group of animals that is doing well, pretty quickly, after a mass extinction,' he said. The paper theorizes that the feeding methods of the evolving teeth may have played a role, creating an evolutionary advantage for the species. Wilson noted 'that particular feature of the curved and pointy fang at the front and processing fangs at the back became a feature of many species in times to come.' The area where the fossil was found — at Blue Beach on the Minas Basin, about 90 kilometres north of Halifax — was believed to be part of a vast freshwater lake not far from the ocean. The research team's paper credits Sonja Wood, former director of the Blue Beach Fossil Museum, for finding the fossilized jaw by urging Mansky to check along a creek that flowed onto the beach. Wood, who died last year, was in a wheelchair and had urged her colleague to search the area. 'She had a good feeling about what could be found ... and she said he should go and have a look,' said Wilson. 'He went down and sure enough it (the jaw fossil) was sitting right there,' said the researcher, adding that Mansky managed to recover the fossil before a storm rolled through that night. Wilson said more discoveries are possible as examination of the fossils from the Blue Beach area continues. 'We have lots of different anatomies that simply haven't been described yet. And we'll be working on that in a paper that's coming up in a few months,' he said. This report by The Canadian Press was first published June 21, 2025.
