Doctor practices while suspended, Punjab Medical Council complains to cops but revokes suspension
Representative image
The
Punjab Medical Council
(PMC) restored the licence of a surgeon who continued to practice while under suspension. This, despite having urged the police to act against the doctor on the grounds that doing so was illegal. Yet, the National Medical Commission refuses to take up the patient's complaint against this decision of the PMC.
The PMC declined to reveal if the suspended surgeon fulfilled the conditions its ethics committee had recommended for him to be allowed to resume practice - a root cause analysis of the death of two patients who he operated on, and a certificate showing that he had got himself trained in
laparoscopic hysterectomy
.
Operation Sindoor
'Our job is to hit target, not to count body bags': Air Marshal Bharti on Op Sindoor
Precautionary blackout imposed across parts of Rajasthan, Punjab
'Indian Navy was in position to strike Karachi': Vice Admiral on Operation Sindoor
TOI asked PMC why its Dec 2024 order restoring the licence of
Dr Praveen Devgan
cited the high court order of Nov 20, 2024 when the court had not ordered restoration of licence. In response, it produced yet another council order dated April 25, 2025, which claimed that the decision to restore the licence was taken in the general body meeting on Sept 25, 2024 after receiving an application from Dr Devgan at the end of the six-month suspension period. PMC was mum on Dr Devgan continuing to practice during the period of suspension.
"The case filed by Dr Devgan in July 2024 against his suspension was still pending on Sept 25. How did PMC take a decision to restore his licence before the court had decided the case?" asked the complainant, Gokul Aneja, who has alleged medical negligence in the death of his wife Sunita Aneja. She was diagnosed with multiple fibroids and underwent laparoscopic hysterectomy by Dr Parveen Devgan on Oct 1, 2018.
Dr Devgan's petition in HC was "disposed of as withdrawn" on Nov 20 last year because he had moved an application seeking to withdraw the petition. The court had neither stayed his suspension nor examined its merits.
In PMC's general body meeting held on July 21, 2023 "all the council members unanimously decided that Dr Parveen Devgan failed to demonstrate due skill and care towards patients". PMC's final order on Dec 21, 2023, suspended his registration for six months and debarred him from practice. The order cited the ethics committee' recommendations. These included that he be restrained from performing any laproscopic procedure in his own hospital or in any other hospital till he submitted a root cause analysis of the deaths, done by a higher institute like PGI Chandigarh doing and imparting training in laparoscopic hysterectomy, and that he get trained in laparoscopic hysterectomy from a recognised institute and submit the certificate to PMC. The committee stated that Dr Devgan should be initially restrained for a minimum of six months that could be extended further till he complied with the two conditions of root cause analysis and certificate of training.
When Dr Devgan applied to Fortis Hospital, Noida for training in laparoscopic hysterectomy along with other procedures in laparoscopy, the hospital informed him that he could not be trained in laparoscopic gynae procedures "as by NMC guidelines you do not possess required qualification of post-graduation in Obs & Gynae". "It is unethical and unlawful for a general surgeon to do gynaecological training or procedures as he/she does not have the required qualification to do so," stated the hospital letter in May 2024.
On receiving information that Dr Devgan was practicing despite suspension of licence, civil surgeon of Amritsar inspected the hospital on April 5, 2024, and found that he was performing operations. She informed the PMC and the police in Amritsar. The PMC urged the commissioner of police in Amritsar to take action as practising while his licence was suspended was illegal, and against the Punjab Medical Registration Act and the National Commission Act.
Get the latest lifestyle updates on Times of India, along with
Mother's Day wishes
,
messages
, and
quotes
!
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
India Gazette
5 hours ago
- India Gazette
Yoga is a gift of Indian civilisation, celebrated globally due to PM Modi's efforts: Rajasthan CM
Jaisalmer (Rajasthan) [India], June 21 (ANI): Rajasthan Chief Minister Bhajanlal Sharma on Saturday participated in a state-level yoga event held in the sandy dunes of Jaisalmer on International Yoga Day and lauded efforts of Prime Minister Narendra Modi in popularising the ancient Indian practice globally. The Chief Minister said the theme of the Yoga Day 'Yoga for One Earth, One Health' conveyed the strong connection between humans and environment. He further stated that yoga represents harmony between humans and nature and also offers a holistic approach to health and well-being. Sharma also said that the state government was working with full commitment towards improving both individual and environmental health. 'Yoga is a gift from Indian civilisation to the world. It is not only a physical exercise but a holistic way of life that unites the body, mind, intellect, and soul. Yoga is the union of the soul with the divine, mind with peace, and energy with power,' Sharma said, according to a release. He also emphasised that yoga guides people to a healthy life amid the challenges of stress, pollution and irregular lifestyle. The Chief Minister also highlighted that yoga has always been a part of India's ancient culture. 'In the scriptures, Lord Shiva is regarded as the first teacher of yoga. Sages like Maharishi Patanjali and other yogic scholars helped establish yoga as a knowledge tradition through practices and literature,' the Chief Minister said. 'PM Modi believes that yoga is a journey from illness to wellness and from 'I to we'. The proposal (by India at UN) received overwhelming support, leading the UN to declare June 21 as International Yoga Day. It was because of PM Modi's efforts that Yoga Day has now become a global celebration,' he added. The Chief Minister praised Prime Minister Modi for spreading Indian cultural values worldwide. He credited PM Modi's determination and dedication for the grand Ram Temple in Ayodhya, the revamp of Kashi Vishwanath corridor, construction of Mahakal Lok in Ujjain, the Char Dham project, and the transformation of pilgrimage sites like Kedarnath and Badrinath. Rajasthan government is also working to develop major religious sites including Tanot Mata Temple and Ramdevra Temple. Sharma said that under PM Modi's leadership, India has emerged as a spiritual, economic, and military power. 'The world witnessed India's military might in the recent Operation Sindoor. To send a strong message to Pakistan, India has suspended the Indus Water Treaty. Now, under PM Modi, water from the Indus and Chenab rivers is planned to be diverted to Rajasthan, stopping the flow into Pakistan,' he said. (ANI)
Time of India
10 hours ago
- Time of India
Tamil Nadu: Defence personnel perform Yoga in front of Adiyogi at Coimbatore's Isha Yoga centre
Photo: Isha Yoga COIMBATORE: Defence personnel gathered at the Isha Yoga Centre in Coimbatore on Saturday to mark International Day of Yoga 2025 with a dedicated yoga session held in front of the iconic Adiyogi statue. The session, attended by around 200 armed forces personnel, was conducted under the guidance of trained yoga instructors from the centre. While speaking to ANI, Jayant, a yoga teacher at Isha Yoga Centre, said, "Today is the International Day of Yoga. It's not new; since its launch, it has been like a wildfire. The world now knows the importance of yoga." — SadhguruJV (@SadhguruJV) Talking about the special event, he added, "Right now, we are in front of Adiyogi. We just had a session for 200 or so armed forces personnel... They have come from nearby bases here, and we just conducted a short yoga session for them." Earlier in the day, Defence Minister Rajnath Singh led the 11th International yoga Day celebrations in Udhampur of Jammu and met the army personnel here in Udhampur, praised their efforts in Operation Sindoor . "Your bravery is widely admired across the nation. I salute the valour and courage of the Indian Army," Rajnath Singh said. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Eat 1 Teaspoon Every Night, See What Happens A Week Later [Video] getfittoday Undo He gave a clear message that Operation Sindoor was not just a reaction, and it is not over yet. Meanwhile, the Indian Army also organised a yoga session at the world's highest battlefield, in Siachen. Multiple soldiers, veterans, families and children participated in the session. Highlighting the theme of 'Yoga for One Earth, One Health' in a post on X, the Army wrote, "On the 11th International Day of Yoga IDY 2025, Indian Army conducted Yoga sessions from the world's highest battlefield Siachen to all the terrains and climatic conditions through the expanse of the country. IDY2025 witnessed enthusiastic participation from Serving Soldiers, Veterans, Families, Children & Civilians embracing "Yoga as a Way of Life".
Indian Express
15 hours ago
- Indian Express
NEET UG 2025 Result: Getting a seat in India seems difficult? Here's how to choose the right medical college abroad
– Abhijit Zaveri With NEET UG 2025 results declared and 12,36,531 students clearing the exam, the limited availability of just 1.25 lakh MBBS seats in India is compelling many qualified candidates to explore alternative options — ranging from allied health science streams like dentistry, pharmacy, public health, and biotechnology to pursuing MBBS degrees abroad. Given the rising competition, limited government seats, and the high cost of private medical education in India, overseas medical education is no longer seen as a fallback, but a strategic choice. Countries like Russia, Georgia, the Philippines, and Hungary offer globally recognised programs that are often more affordable, provide international exposure, and follow curricula aligned with global standards – making them increasingly attractive for thousands of students each year. Timely planning is key, as aspiring students must begin applications, complete documentation, and prepare for visa processes by mid-summer. Importantly, a Supreme Court ruling from February 2025 and NMC (National Medical Commission) guidelines mandate that all students – whether studying in India or abroad – must qualify NEET-UG for admission into any medical program and to gain eligibility for practice in India. Key Factors in Choosing a Country, or University Affordability vs Quality: Private MBBS programs in India can cost upwards of Rs 60–80 lakh. In contrast, countries like Russia and Georgia offer tuition in the range of Rs 15–40 lakh for the full course duration. Monthly living expenses range from Rs 10,000 – Rs20,000, depending on the country. While affordability is a key factor for many families, it should not be the sole criterion. A lower fee structure may sometimes come at the cost of compromised academic standards or inadequate clinical training, both of which are crucial for a successful medical career. One reliable way to assess the quality of education offered by foreign institutions is by looking at the pass rates of the Foreign Medical Graduate Examination (FMGE), a mandatory licensure test in India for students who have earned their MBBS degrees overseas. The upcoming National Exit Test (NExT) will serve a similar purpose. High FMGE or NExT pass rates are a strong indicator of a university's academic rigour and how well it prepares students for medical practice in India. Ultimately, affordability must be weighed against long-term value – including educational quality, clinical exposure, and the ability to secure a medical licence upon returning home. Accreditation and Curriculum Compatibility: A critical aspect often overlooked is program recognition. Students must ensure that their chosen foreign university is approved by the NMC. With the impending transition from FMGE to NExT (National Exit Test) from 2024–25, aligning the curriculum with Indian licensure requirements is essential. Programs with strong clinical rotations, English-medium instruction, and hospital tie-ups tend to better prepare students for these assessments. Language, Culture, and Student Support: Even in English-taught programs, basic proficiency in the local language is crucial for everyday interactions, especially during clinical postings. For example, learning languages like Russian or Georgian can greatly enhance the clinical experience, allowing students to communicate more effectively with patients and healthcare staff. Additionally, quality-of-life factors such as climate, food, culture, and safety play a significant role in choosing a destination. Countries like Georgia offer milder climates and cultural proximity, making it an appealing option for many students. On the other hand, Russia's harsh winters might present challenges for those unaccustomed to extreme cold. These considerations are essential for making an informed decision about studying abroad. Licensing Outcomes and Pass Rates: Pass rates for exams like the FMGE and the upcoming NExT are strong indicators of a country's medical education quality. Georgian medical universities consistently report high FMGE success rates, ranging from 60% to 80% at leading institutions, compared to much lower rates in countries like China and Ukraine, where success often falls below 20%. These figures are important factors students should consider when choosing where to study Popular destinations: Pros and cons Russia: Russia has long been a popular choice for Indian students pursuing MBBS. The 6-year program, which includes an internship, is offered in both English and Russian, providing a unique opportunity to learn the local language. Tuition fees are affordable, ranging from Rs 3–5 lakh per year, with moderate living costs. The visa process is efficient, and many Russian universities collaborate with Indian agents, making it easier for students to navigate the application process. Russia also boasts excellent infrastructure and a sizable Indian community. However, it's important to note that FMGE pass rates typically range from 40–55%. Georgia: Georgia's 6-year MBBS programs, taught in English, are approved by both WHO and NMC. Tuition ranges from Rs 4 – 6 lakh per year, with hostel expenses between Rs 16,000 – Rs20,000 per month. Several universities report FMGE success rates above 60%, and the country is known for its welcoming environment, mild climate, and European lifestyle. Due to limited university options, students must apply by June–July for September intake. Philippines: Adopting a US-based system, medical education in the Philippines consists of a 2-year BS (pre-med) and a 4-year MD program. All courses are taught in English, and tuition is affordable (Rs 2.5 – 6 lakh per year). Living costs are comparable to India. The American-style curriculum is ideal for students planning to take USMLE or NExT. However, students must clear NMAT and hold a bachelor's degree, adding 2–3 years to their timeline. While NMC approval exists, FMGE eligibility has sparked debate—although recent data shows improved licensing outcomes for Philippine graduates. Other Countries: Hungary's leading institutions, such as Semmelweis and Debrecen, offer 6-year English-language MBBS programs with annual tuition around Rs 13–15 lakh. FMGE pass rates average about 50%. Slovakia's Comenius and Pavol Jozef Šafárik Universities charge Rs 8,80,000- Rs 10,27,000(€9,000–€10,500) annually, with living costs ranging from Rs 49,000- Rs 78,000(€500–€800) per month. Though FMGE data for Slovakia is limited, these universities meet NMC norms and are becoming increasingly popular among Indian students. Immediate Abroad vs gap year Once the NEET results are declared, students are required to choose whether to go abroad or take a year off. Applying as soon as the results of NEET are out means students are in line with the academic calendar abroad (applications in summer, visas in fall, and classes in winter). This way, students don't have their education slowed by unexpected events. However, quick decisions require preparedness in documentation, finances, and visa procedures. Reappearing for NEET offers candidates another opportunity to secure a government medical seat in India. During this period, students can also explore foreign institutions more thoroughly, learn a new language, and plan their finances. At the same time, taking a gap year can be both tough emotionally and academically. Delays in starting medical education may impact future practice timelines—a concern backed by studies that show delayed NEET success pushes career start dates further. –A hybrid approach can work well: Students who are NEET-eligible and do not secure seats could take advantage of approved foreign programs, so they don't waste time. Common Pitfalls and Best Practices –Skipping NEET: Any Indian student planning to pursue medical degree overseas is required to have NEET qualification. –Overlooking NMC Approval: Always verify that both the university and its medical program are officially recognised by the National Medical Commission (NMC) for eligibility to practice in India. –Basing Decisions Solely on Cost: Lower fees in a medical program might mean sacrificing either the infrastructure or clinical quality. Looking at the past performance of FMGE/NExT can give you a clear picture of long-term worth. –Ignoring Language and Culture Barriers: English-medium classes don't eliminate the need for daily communication in local languages. Cultural compatibility impacts comfort and success. –Trusting Unverified Agents: Trust the resources given by embassies, well-known education portals, and comments from your peers. –Missing Application or Visa Deadlines: Students should mark all important dates—NEET application (Feb–Mar), results (June), international college deadlines (July), visa approvals (August–September). –Underestimating Total Expenses: Apart from tuition, students are required to cover costs for housing, meals, insurance, traveling, and unexpected emergencies. Visa applications often require proof of funds. Pursuing medical studies in a foreign country can have a major impact when planned well. Student should realize that low price does not always show the entire picture and think about the degrees they'll earn, quality of the institution, and their own qualifications. Because of programs like NExT as well as new opportunities worldwide, Indian medical students have a wide range of options, but they are responsible for making smart, forward-looking choices. If students consider the details of tuition, how the curriculum matches their needs, the university's accreditation, the place to live, and the influence on their future, students can chart a path that not only leads to a degree, but also a successful and fulfilling medical career. (The author is the founder and director of Career Mosaic)
