Bust attributed to Donatello splits Slovakia

The sculpture of Italian noblewoman Cecilia Gonzaga spent centuries in a manor house in central Slovakia, whose owners, the noble Csaky family, left it behind when they fled the advancing World War II front in 1945.
Moved about and ultimately forgotten in the aftermath, it was sitting in a depository at the Spis Museum in the eastern town of Levoca when art historian Marta Herucova stumbled across it.
The bust had been marked "unknown author". But Herucova noticed the base was inscribed with the words: "Ceciliae Gonzagae opvs Donatelli" (Cecilia Gonzaga, a work by Donatello).
If confirmed, it would be only the eighth artwork signed by the Italian Renaissance sculptor discovered worldwide.
Herucova made the find in 2019, but it was only announced in February -- surprising the country.
"Who would expect an original Donatello to appear in Slovakia?" former museum director Maria Novotna told AFP.
But the bust is now a subject of controversy.
Nationalist Culture Minister Martina Simkovicova decided to remove it from the museum and bring it to an unknown location in late May, citing security.
The move dismayed critics and art historians, who say the bust needs expert conservation and research to confirm if it is really by Donatello (1386-1466).
War story
The bust has an epic backstory.
After the Csaky family fled, Soviet troops looted their house, which then became a juvenile detention centre for girls after the communist government took over former Czechoslovakia in 1948.
The girls played with the bust and even defined its eyes with blue pen, said Peter Cizmar, the son of a former guardian.
In 1975, artwork still surviving at the centre was moved to the nearby Spis Museum.
Attributed to an unknown 19th-century artist, the bust "was put in a depository and had not left it since", said former director Novotna, an art historian.
Novotna was in charge of the museum catalogue as a young worker, and now bemoans a lack of time for research as she was swamped with work.
Dinner companion
In 2019, Herucova was working on the museum's 19th-century collection when she found the piece.
"The bust just came up," she said.
After noticing the inscription, she started in-depth research.
She suspected forgery, but the material, details and inscription were all too telling, she said.
"Even artists who made Renaissance-style busts never signed them in the name of the original author," Herucova told AFP.
She wrote about the finding in the French art history magazine Revue de l'Art, waiting for someone to contest the bust's origin -- which has not happened.
Herucova also contacted Count Moritz Csaky, who had no clear recollection of its origin either, as his family left for Vienna when he was 11.
But he did recall seeing the bust placed on the porch, where the family dined in summer.
"He said there used to be two original Gothic statues next to it, which are also in the museum today," Herucova said.
'Safe and protected'
Herucova also contacted Italian art history professor Francesco Caglioti, who voiced doubt about the authorship but declined to elaborate.
She is now pinning hopes on research in cooperation with foreign institutions.
But for now, the bust is hidden away.
Simkovicova, the culture minister who ordered it be moved with the help of a police commando, said it was "now safe and protected".
Police chief Jana Maskarova later said the bust was at an interior ministry centre in Topolcianky, central Slovakia.
Simkovicova promised to display the bust when "conditions are favourable".
Herucova hopes the ministry will not try to revamp the bust, which should retain its patina, she said.
"It's supposed to go to a professional place where they know how to do lab analyses."
Emancipated noblewoman
Research suggests the bust was made when Cecilia Gonzaga (1426-1451) became engaged to influential politician Oddantonio da Montefeltro.
Her father made the match, seeking to bolster relations between the families, but the well-educated Cecilia chose a life in a convent over marriage.
It is known that Cecilia's brother commissioned artworks from Donatello.
The Gonzagas later fostered strong ties with the imperial court of Vienna and were united by marriage with the Csaky family.
Some studies suggest the bust was made after Cecilia became a nun, possibly based on an earlier coin bearing her likeness.
Novotna said she believed the bust was Donatello's work.
© 2025 AFP

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

France 24

8 hours ago

• France 24

Malaysia's Dayaks mark rice harvest end with colourful parade

The Gawai Dayak 2025 Parade in state capital Kuching is the only annual gathering by representatives of around 11 of Sarawak's main Dayak groups -- which participants said helps to keep alive a unique part of the Southeast Asian nation's culture. Marchers gathered from early Saturday under the blistering tropical sun, many of them travelling long distances by bus to walk in the parade along the banks of the Sarawak River. "This gathering is something that is very important to me," said Joel Zacchaeus Anak Ebi, sporting the traditional Iban headgear worn by one of Borneo's best-known tribes. People "must know and realise that Sarawak has traditions and cultures that must be preserved," he told AFP ahead of the march, which was also attended by Sarawak Premier Abang Johari Tun Openg. "A day like this brings our people together, especially the younger people, who can easily lose touch with their roots when they move away from Sarawak," said Dayak village elder Ngindang Rambo, 61. Watching the parade, Masha Timosha, 34, a tour guide from Russia, said she was amazed by the costumes and atmosphere. "This is just very impressive. I even have my own Sarawakian costume but I didn't put it on," she told AFP. Malaysia's Dayak people are mainly riverine and hill-dwelling, made up of dozens of ethnic groups, each with their own distinct dialect, customs, laws and practices. Dayak communities however have become increasingly under threat from encroaching palm oil forestry and industrial logging, human rights groups and Indigenous groups have said. Many Indigenous communities in Sarawak face challenges in accessing basic services, Human Rights Watch said in a statement last month, including access to running water, electricity and land titles. Local groups and international observers have also called on the government to "urgently legislate Indigenous customs and traditions through which Indigenous people have acquired rights to their lands, territories and resources," the Sarawak Dayak Iban Association (Sadia) said last year. Rainforest-clad Borneo is the world's third-largest island and is shared between Malaysia, Indonesia and Brunei.

France 24

2 days ago

• France 24

Cheap alms bowls imports hit Sri Lanka makers, monks

The village of Panvila has long been associated with craftsmen who produce the humble "paathra", the special bowl that forms part of the eight essentials donated to monks and which is used to ask for food. Thenuwara Badalge Sarath, 65, says he is the only blacksmith left in a village that once supplied much of the country. "When I learnt the craft from my father, there were more than 10 families in the neighbourhood who made these bowls," Sarath told AFP, while hammering a piece of scrap metal into a holy utensil. "Today, I am the only one keeping up the tradition. My son died recently in a road accident, and there is no one to carry on this line of work after I am gone," said the fourth-generation craftsman. He spends about a week producing a batch of five to six bowls from discarded steel barrels. He sells each for 600 rupees ($2), but competition from cheap imports is tough. "There are aluminium bowls that come from abroad. They are cheaper and lighter -- we can't compete," Sarath said at his village smithy, near the southern tourist resort of Hikkaduwa. Karma drives demand The Buddhist-majority nation of some 22 million people has just over 42,000 monks, but the demand for bowls is disproportionately high because of the positive karma attached to offering them to temples. Kirinde Assagi, a leading Buddhist monk, said the alms bowl forms part of the eight items for a monk to lead an ascetic life and spread the teachings of Buddha, along with two robes, a razor, a straining cloth, a needle and thread, and a belt. "The bowl is his livelihood. When a monk goes out begging with his bowl, he gets sustenance", Assagi said. "Because gifting 'ata pirikara' to monks brings enormous good karma, devotees clamour to donate this," said the monk, in reference to the eight-item package. At his Gangaramaya temple in the capital Colombo there were nine such packages donated within an hour one weekend. 'Mountain' of discarded pots Assagi says most of the bowls however are of poor quality, made out of aluminium and unfit to serve food in. In a storeroom at the back of his temple, there is a huge pile of bowls that monks say are not suitable even for offering food to household pets. "I will show you a mountain of begging bowls that we have discarded. We make holes at the bottom and repurpose them for potted plants." Monks in Thailand, Myanmar, and Laos traditionally seek alms every morning, underscoring their simple life and demonstrating that their livelihood depends on others. But the influx of cheap bowls is impacting the dawn ritual. "We see the practice of monks begging slowly dying off as the quality of the bowls goes down," he said. The Gangaramaya temple in Colombo has campaigned to improve the quality of utensils offered to monks and revive the ritual of seeking alms. Assagi said the Thai royal family has in recent years gifted more than 27,000 high qualitiy stainless steel bowls to Sri Lankan monks, most of whom are followers of the Siam sect of Buddhism practised in that nation. Unlike the financially well-off Gangaramaya, smaller temples are known to sell their excess bowls back to the market in a move that undermines traditional craftsmen such as Sarath. "When the bowls go back to the shop from a temple, we find it difficult to sell our produce," Sarath said. He is trying to convince devotees that there is less merit in offering bowls that are being regifted.

AFP

2 days ago

• AFP

Video shows hospital in Lebanon, not hostel struck in Air India crash

"CCTV footage from BJ Medical College Hospital captures the terrifying moment an Air India plane crashed into the hospital premises, bursting into flames in just seconds," reads the caption of the shared June 14, 2025 on Facebook. The compilation shows an explosion near a building that showers an adjacent car park with rubble. Shots from what appears to be the inside of the building show people taking cover as the ceiling collapses. Superimposed text in the top-left corner reads "srhuhospital", and a logo with the initials "SRHUH" appears in the bottom- . The footage circulated two days after a Boeing 787-8 Dreamliner bound for London ploughed into a residential area of India's Ahmedabad city (archived link). The fiery crash killed all but one of the 242 passengers and crew on board, as well as at least 38 people on the ground. Image Screenshot of the false Facebook post captured June 16, 2025 The same video also spread in similar Facebook and X posts. While Air India flight 171 did crash through a hostel for medical staff from a nearby hospital, leaving its tailpiece jutting out of the building's second floor, the video has circulated online since . A reverse image search on Google using keyframes from the video led to the same footage posted February 5 on Instagram by the Lebanon-based Ragheb Harb University Hospital (archived link). The clips appear in a longer video detailing the hospital's restoration after being damaged. The "SRHUH" logo and "srhuhospital" are visible in the Instagram page's bio. Image Screenshot comparison of the falsely shared video (L) and the Instagram video from February, with elements highlighted by AFP Images of the hospital on Google Maps also correspond to the footage circulating online (archived link). Image Screenshot comparison of the falsely shared video (L) and an image of the hospital on Google Maps, with similarities highlighted by AFP local media reports and a post on the hospital's Facebook page, the hospital was damaged in November 2024 (archived here, here and here). At the time, border clashes between Israeli forces and the Lebanese armed group Hezbollah had escalated into all-out war (archived link). A US-mediated ceasefire requiring Hezbollah to withdraw its fighters from the border strip ended the war in November 2024. Israel has repeatedly bombed Lebanon since the ceasefire went into effect, with no response from Hezbollah. previously debunked false claims that the clip shows an Iranian strike on Israel. More reporting on misinformation about the Air India crash is available here.