Driver who killed eight-month-old baby in pram has sentence reduced

A driver who struck and killed an eight-month-old baby in her pram outside a hospital has had her prison sentence reduced at the Court of Appeal, in what judges described as a 'truly tragic' case.
Bridget Curtis pressed down on the accelerator of her automatic BMW 520d car after stopping outside Withybush Hospital in Haverfordwest, Pembrokeshire, on June 21 2023, causing it to mount a kerb and collide with the pushchair of Mabli Cariad Hall.
Mabli, who had just said a final goodbye to her paternal grandmother Betty Hall, who was receiving end-of-life care at the hospital, sustained fatal head injuries and died in hospital days later.
Curtis, who was 69 at the time of the offence and is now 71, pleaded guilty to causing death by dangerous driving last September and was jailed for four years at Swansea Crown Court in January.
At the Court of Appeal on Tuesday, her barrister said the sentence was 'manifestly excessive' and should be reduced, stating that the case concerned a 'lapse of concentration'.
Three senior judges ruled that Curtis's sentence was 'manifestly excessive' and reduced it to one of three years, while reducing her disqualification from driving from eight years to seven and a half years.
Mr Justice Butcher, sitting with Lord Justice Bean and Judge Richard Marks KC, said: 'We say at once that this is a truly tragic case.
'We have read the very moving victim personal statements of Mabli's parents, expressing their grief at the death of their beloved baby.
'No one could fail to sympathise with them for the appalling loss that they have sustained.'
Curtis, who attended the appeal via video link from HMP Eastwood Park in Gloucestershire and sat in a wheelchair throughout, had no previous convictions at the time of the incident and had held a clean driving licence for more than 50 years.
Her sentencing hearing at Swansea Crown Court heard that on the day of the collision, she had driven her daughter to an outpatient appointment at the hospital.
When her daughter struggled to find her handbag in the rear of the car, Curtis unlocked the door and turned around to assist her.
But as she did so, she pressed down on the accelerator of her car, which had been left running and was not in park mode.
The car reached speeds of more than 29mph and travelled 28 metres in around four seconds, mounting the kerb of a grass seating area and causing Mabli to be thrown out of her pushchair.
The car only stopped when it collided with a tree, having also caused injuries to Mabli's father Rob Hall.
Mabli, the youngest of six siblings, received treatment at the Withybush Hospital, as well as hospitals in Cardiff and Bristol, dying in the arms of her parents on June 25.
Her mother, Gwen Hall, told the sentencing hearing that her daughter was 'so bright, so beautiful, so full of love and life'.
She said: 'She hadn't crawled yet. She had said 'Mama' for the first time only the day before. We had so much planned with her.
'It was nowhere near the time for her to be taken away from us. She was my baby. My eight-month-old baby.'
John Dye, for Curtis, told Swansea Crown Court that she was a mother-of-four and grandmother of 10, who was 'absolutely devastated' by the incident.
Appearing again for Curtis at the Court of Appeal on Tuesday, Mr Dye said: 'This is a tragic case, but the issue really was one of pedal confusion.'
He continued: 'Objectively, this is clearly dangerous driving, but in terms of culpability, these four seconds of driving were more akin to, maybe not a momentary lapse, but a lapse of concentration.'
Craig Jones, for the Crown Prosecution Service, made no oral submissions to the court.
Reducing the sentence, Mr Justice Butcher said: 'True it is that the appellant did not intend to cause any harm, and true also that the mistake was of a short duration, but the driving was well over the threshold of dangerousness.'
He continued that Curtis would have known that she had stopped 'in a busy area outside a hospital with potentially very vulnerable pedestrians around', and that four or five seconds 'is far from being a negligible duration'.
He added that the court accepted that Curtis's remorse was 'genuine', stating: 'It was inattention and confusion as to which pedal she was pressing that caused this tragedy.'

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

BBC News

2 hours ago

• BBC News

Marius Ionut Dencea jailed after killing partner in M180 crash

A father who killed his partner and left their toddler with a brain injury after a high-speed crash on a motorway has been jailed for nine Pitigoi, 34, and their 18-month-old son were in the back of a car driven by Marius Ionut Dencea when the vehicle left the M180 and hit a tree near Barnetby, North Lincolnshire, at 11:15 GMT on 5 mother and son were not wearing a seatbelt and the toddler was not in a child seat, Hull Crown Court 35, of Berkeley Street in Scunthorpe, previously pleaded guilty to causing death by dangerous driving and causing serious injury by dangerous driving. The court heard the car had been travelling at 88mph (141km/h) and was not Jeremy Evans said Ms Pitigoi died in hospital from her injuries, while their son was in intensive care for 10 family were driving home after spending the night at a relative's in Grimsby following a party. Mr Evans said the road conditions were poor with "slush present on the third lane" in which Dencea was driving at excessive footage played in court showed Dencea's black Mitsubishi travelling on the outside lane and then moments later was seen off the carriageway on the embankment, next to the hard shoulder, flipped on its emergency services arrived, one officer "located a small child as he reached through a hole in the wreckage to the nearside", Mr Evans added."It became apparent there was no child seat or safety restraint in the vehicle."Mr Evans said the child suffered multiple serious injuries, including a traumatic brain injury, a broken jaw in two places and a skull fracture. History of offences Dencea's barrister, Dale Brooks, told the court his client had made "desperate attempts to try to help his family" at the scene."He is utterly distraught by what happened on that day and by what he did," said Mr Brooks."Undoubtedly, the greatest punishment on him is living with the guilt of what he's done, it will be a substantial burden he will have to carry."The barrister told the court the child had made a "miraculous recovery".However, passing sentence, Judge Mark Bury said the two-year-old had a "significant risk of developing neurological conditions".The court heard Dencea, who was also banned from driving for 12 and a half years, had a history of road traffic offences - six in the UK and one in Spain. Listen to highlights from Lincolnshire on BBC Sounds, watch the latest episode of Look North or tell us about a story you think we should be covering here.

Daily Mail​

2 hours ago

• Daily Mail​

Chilling footage shows car chasing e-bikes before horror crash which killed mother-of-one, 25: Drug dealer is cleared of murder

A mother and her boyfriend are chased along a road on their e-bike by a Land Rover which was used as a 'weapon' to knock them off, killing her and seriously injuring him. The footage of Keaton Muldoon at the wheel of the two-and-a-half tonne 4X4 was released yesterday after the drug dealer, who has previously admitted death by dangerous driving and causing serious injury by dangerous driving, was cleared of Alana Amrstrong's murder. The mother-of-one died last November in a country lane outside Pleasley, Derbyshire, when she 'went over the whole car' after Muldoon, 23, made five attempts to ram the bike she was riding, a jury heard. Det Con Natalie Barnett, from Derbyshire Police's major crime unit, told the court a doorbell camera captured Ms Armstrong, 25, and Mr Newton-Kay leaving an address in Tibshelf, Derbyshire, that evening on one electric bike, with another man, James Gilbert, on a separate bike. The two CCTV clips released by police were shown to the jury at Derby Crown Court and show the two bikes being 'followed' by the vehicle on the unlit lane. The court heard the last piece of footage was captured one minute before GPS from Mr Newton-Kay's phone showed his bike had stopped at the site of the crash. DC Barnett said the GPS data showed that Mr Newton-Kay's bike, with Ms Armstrong riding pillion, went past Muldoon's vehicle,which was stopped in a layby, just before 20:00 GMT. The officer said: 'The movements show that the phone has then gone back towards the lay-by. 'The phones and the bikes are then beginning to move back down Sampsons Lane towards the incident.' Ms Armstrong, who had a six-year-old son, suffered catastrophic injuries and was pronounced dead at the scene. Mr Newton-Kay, was taken to hospital where he later had to have his leg amputated below the knee. Following the incident, Muldoon drove off from the scene without stopping, juors heard. He handed himself into police the following week after a police media appeal. During his police interview he denied being the driver at the time of the collision and named another person he said was responsible. Muldoon, 23, of Mansfield, Nottinghamshire, was cleared of murder and causing Mr Newton-Kay grievous bodily harm with intent. He pleaded guilty to causing death by dangerous driving and causing serious injury by dangerous driving before his trial began in May. His sentencing date has not been fixed by the court. Muldoon, who the court heard was a drug dealer, told the jury of 11 women and one man on Tuesday that he 'did not know' he had hit anyone on the evening of November 26 last year, and thought he had overtaken Mr Newton-Kay's bike at a passing point. But the prosecution alleged that Muldoon 'pursued' the couple, and Mr Gilbert on the second electric bike after the trio had stopped near the defendant's 4x4 at the lay-by. Sally Howes KC, prosecuting, said Muldoon then started chasing the two bikes. She said the 'close pursuit', which lasted for 1.1 miles, ended up with Muldoon using his 'much larger, heavier' Land Rover Discovery Mk3 as a 'weapon' and knocking his victims from the bike before leaving them for dead. Jurors were told that in the immediate aftermath of the collision, he was heard by a woman he had earlier been selling the drugs to saying: 'Oh s***. Oh for f**** sake. I was only meant to knock them off the bike.' Mr Newton-Kay told police Muldoon rammed his bike four times before succeeding in knocking them off on the fifth attempt. Describing his recollection of the collision, Ms Howes told the court: 'He said he watched Alana go over the bonnet and roll over the whole car, and she had ended up flying backwards and watched her go over the whole car.' Mr Newton-Kay said the vehicle then drove over him, before continuing its pursuit of Mr Gilbert. Ms Howes said he told the police he managed to just avoid also being knocked off by riding up grass banking at the side of the road, with the Land Rover Discovery then 'flying past' and driving away. She added: 'He managed to gather his wits and flew back down the lane in search of friends', where he found the pair lying in the road. The defendant told the court he feared he was going to be robbed but did not 'chase' the Sur-Ron off-road bike for more than a mile from the lay-by in Sampsons Lane, Pleasley. Muldoon, who was father to a newborn baby at the time of the collision, told the court he lied to police that his uncle had possession of the Land Rover at the time of the collision because he was 'scared' about the murder investigation. He told the jury earlier this week: 'My head was all over, I didn't know what to think. 'I knew I wasn't going to see my children for a bit. I just had a newborn baby. I promised I would always be there.' Detective Constable Stevie Barker, of the East Midlands Special Operations Unit, who was the officer in the case, said: 'Alana was just 25 when she died, leaving her son without his mum, and her family grieving the loss of a young woman who had so much life ahead of her. 'The consequences of Muldoon's behaviour on that night have led to the death of Alana and a lifetime of grief for her family. In addition, Jordan, the rider of the bike, also suffered life-changing injuries. 'He then didn't even have the decency to admit what he had done in interview, instead trying to put the blame on someone else. It was months later before he accepted that he was the driver of the vehicle. 'My thoughts – and those of all of the officers involved in this tragic case- remain with the families of Alana and Jordan.'

BBC News

3 hours ago

• BBC News

Four charged with arson after Llangefni fire at ex-council headquarters

Four young people have been charged with arson in connection with a fire at former council headquarters. The blaze caused significant damage to Shire Hall, Llangefni, in Anglesey in December 2023. At the time there were four arrests, but it has taken 18 months for anyone to be charged. North Wales Police did not provide any information on the youths' ages or where they are will appear at Caernarfon Youth Court on Wednesday, 9 July.