Sindh budget draws criticism over fiscal deficit, neglect of Karachi and local governance
The Policy Research and Advisory Council (PRAC) has raised serious concerns over the Sindh government's budget for fiscal year 2025-26, citing a widening fiscal deficit, underfunding of local governments, and insufficient allocations for Karachi's development.
According to PRAC, the Sindh budget projects a deficit of Rs38.5 billion, shifting from a balanced budget in FY24. While total receipts are expected to rise by 17% to Rs3.41 trillion, expenditures are projected to grow by 18.3%, reaching Rs3.45 trillion.
PRAC Chairman Mohammad Younus Dagha acknowledged the government's efforts to simplify taxation, including the removal of five levies such as the Professional Tax and Entertainment Duty. However, he said these reforms are not sufficient to meet the province's long-term development needs.
Budget FY2025-26: Sindh announces to expand sales tax to all major services
Dagha also expressed concern over the marginal increase in local government allocations, which rose from Rs162.5 billion in FY25 to Rs165 billion in FY26.
He noted that the share of local governments in Sindh's general revenue receipts has dropped to 5.8%, down from 6.7% last year and 16% in 2012, undermining fiscal decentralisation and service delivery.
Despite a proposed increase in the minimum wage to Rs37,000, PRAC highlighted challenges in enforcement, with many industries still failing to comply.
'The budget reflects the government's priorities, and it is clear that both the federal and Sindh budgets continue to neglect Karachi and its critical challenges,' Dagha said.
Although the Sindh government has increased its Annual Development Program (ADP) from Rs386.3 billion to Rs520 billion, the district-level development allocations remain unchanged at Rs55 billion.
Karachi's mega projects will receive Rs8.3 billion in FY26, up from Rs5.6 billion last year, but PRAC said this remains inadequate for addressing the city's infrastructure issues, including water shortages, poor road conditions, and limited public transport.
The Federal Public Sector Development Program (PSDP) allocation for Sindh also declined by 4%, from Rs79.7 billion to Rs76.6 billion.
PRAC further criticised the continued delay in implementing Provincial Finance Commission (PFC) awards and noted persistent issues in the education and health sectors. Sindh's school enrollment has declined, while the child immunisation rate stands at 61%, well below Punjab's 90%.
PRAC called on the Sindh government to adopt a more equitable and reform-oriented fiscal policy to ensure sustainable development and stronger local governance.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
4 days ago
- Business Recorder
Budget 2025-26: Senate panel opposes tax on imported solar panels
The Senate Standing Committee on Finance and Revenue opposed on Tuesday the government announced 18% tax on imported solar panels, calling for immediate withdrawal of the proposal made by Finance Minister Muhammad Aurangzeb in his budget 2025-26 speech last week. Aurangzeb proposed the budget for the financial year 2025-26 on June 10, revealing the government's intention to impose 18% sales tax on imported solar panels, arguing that the decision would help the local industry. However, the Senate panel strongly opposed the proposal in Tuesday's meeting chaired by Senator Saleem Mandviwalla. The meeting was also attended by Finance Minister Muhammad Aurangzeb, Minister of State for Finance Bilal Azhar Kayani, Chairman FBR Rashid Mahmood Langrial, and senior officials of attached departments. 'The committee strongly recommended withdrawing the proposed 18% GST on solar panels. Members observed that ahead of the budget, certain stakeholders had imported and dumped solar equipment in anticipation of the tax hike. The chairman emphasised the discriminatory nature of the move, saying the committee rejects the sudden imposition of GST on solar imports and urges immediate withdrawal,' a statement released by Senate Secretariat read. Such debate also took place in the National Assembly's Standing Committee on Finance and Revenue's meeting on Tuesday, according to sources. However, an official statement from the NA was awaited till the time of filing this report. Earlier, Sindh Chief Minister Murad Ali Shah has also condemned the federal government proposal to impose 18% tax on solar panels, calling that 'unjustified'. He presented the provincial budget for the fiscal year 2025-26 on Friday, with the budget size set at Rs3.45 trillion, representing a 12.9% increase compared to the estimated Rs3.05 trillion for the previous year (2024-25). 'This budget will play a key role in unleashing Sindh's untapped potential,' Murad Ali Shah said in the budget speech. 'It prioritises inclusive, sustainable, and robust development.' In the post-budget press conference on Saturday, the chief minister warned that the Pakistan People's Party (PPP) would withhold support for the federal budget if such regressive measures [tax on imported solar panels] were not withdrawn. Pakistan is rapidly emerging as a key leader in solar power deployment, and not just within emerging economies. The South Asian country has boosted solar electricity generation by over three times the global average so far this year, fuelled by a more than fivefold rise in solar capacity imports since 2022, according to data from Ember. That combination of rapidly rising capacity and generation has propelled solar power from Pakistan's fifth-largest electricity source in 2023 to its largest in 2025. Meanwhile, a recent research report stated that China exported more solar panels to Pakistan than to many G20 nations, with over 16 gigawatts (GW) imported in 2024 alone. The report titled 'Leader of One or Leader of None - China's Choice for Clean over Coal in Pakistan' published by think tank Renewables First said more than 39GW of solar panels, nearly all from China, entered Pakistan in the last five years.
Business Recorder
5 days ago
- Business Recorder
Sindh budget draws criticism over fiscal deficit, neglect of Karachi and local governance
The Policy Research and Advisory Council (PRAC) has raised serious concerns over the Sindh government's budget for fiscal year 2025-26, citing a widening fiscal deficit, underfunding of local governments, and insufficient allocations for Karachi's development. According to PRAC, the Sindh budget projects a deficit of Rs38.5 billion, shifting from a balanced budget in FY24. While total receipts are expected to rise by 17% to Rs3.41 trillion, expenditures are projected to grow by 18.3%, reaching Rs3.45 trillion. PRAC Chairman Mohammad Younus Dagha acknowledged the government's efforts to simplify taxation, including the removal of five levies such as the Professional Tax and Entertainment Duty. However, he said these reforms are not sufficient to meet the province's long-term development needs. Budget FY2025-26: Sindh announces to expand sales tax to all major services Dagha also expressed concern over the marginal increase in local government allocations, which rose from Rs162.5 billion in FY25 to Rs165 billion in FY26. He noted that the share of local governments in Sindh's general revenue receipts has dropped to 5.8%, down from 6.7% last year and 16% in 2012, undermining fiscal decentralisation and service delivery. Despite a proposed increase in the minimum wage to Rs37,000, PRAC highlighted challenges in enforcement, with many industries still failing to comply. 'The budget reflects the government's priorities, and it is clear that both the federal and Sindh budgets continue to neglect Karachi and its critical challenges,' Dagha said. Although the Sindh government has increased its Annual Development Program (ADP) from Rs386.3 billion to Rs520 billion, the district-level development allocations remain unchanged at Rs55 billion. Karachi's mega projects will receive Rs8.3 billion in FY26, up from Rs5.6 billion last year, but PRAC said this remains inadequate for addressing the city's infrastructure issues, including water shortages, poor road conditions, and limited public transport. The Federal Public Sector Development Program (PSDP) allocation for Sindh also declined by 4%, from Rs79.7 billion to Rs76.6 billion. PRAC further criticised the continued delay in implementing Provincial Finance Commission (PFC) awards and noted persistent issues in the education and health sectors. Sindh's school enrollment has declined, while the child immunisation rate stands at 61%, well below Punjab's 90%. PRAC called on the Sindh government to adopt a more equitable and reform-oriented fiscal policy to ensure sustainable development and stronger local governance.
Express Tribune
7 days ago
- Express Tribune
CM outlines fiscal, development agenda
Sindh Chief Minister Murad Ali Shah outlined a fiscal and development agenda for the province while highlighting serious financial challenges and federal shortfalls. Addressing a post-budget press conference on Saturday, the CM criticised the federal government for failing to meet its financial commitments, revealing that Sindh was informed just one day before the budget presentation that Rs105 billion in expected funds would be withheld. Sindh has received Rs1,478.5 billion from the divisible pool since last year, but Rs422.3 billion remains outstanding. He expressed hope that the withheld amount would be disbursed by the end of June. Despite being under an IMF programme that demands strict fiscal discipline, the Sindh government will allocate Rs590 billion for development projects this year, with a total budget of Rs3.45 trillion, Rs1 trillion for development and Rs2.15 trillion for current expenditures. Notably, Rs1.1 trillion is earmarked for salaries and pensions, leading to salary increases of 12 per cent for lower-grade employees and 10 per cent for higher grades. Sectoral budget increases include an 18 per cent rise in education funding and an 11 per cent increase in health. Funding for agriculture, irrigation, and local government projects has also seen significant boosts. Furthermore, Rs236 billion has been allocated for infrastructure projects in Karachi, including public-private partnership initiatives. CM Shah highlighted Sindh's social welfare achievements, particularly in housing for flood victims, with 500,000 homes built and another 850,000 under construction, totalling 1.3 million. To enhance rural living standards, the CM announced a Rs600-billion-project for rural water and sanitation, benefiting 4.5 million villagers. Regarding taxation, Murad noted that no new taxes were introduced in the budget, with some taxes eliminated or reduced, including the abolition of the entertainment tax and cuts to restaurant taxes. The stamp duty on third-party vehicle insurance has been reduced to Rs50, with a drop in the insurance tax from 15 per cent to five per cent. To modernise governance, the Sindh government is digitising land records through block chain for easier access. The CM claimed that free laser levellers will be provided to small farmers, with subsidies for larger ones, alongside the implementation of cluster farming technology. The CM said that improvements in education and health include the establishment of 34,000 new caste centres and expanded support for persons with disabilities. Cognitive Remediation The CM outlined the K-4 water project structure, where the federal government is responsible for sourcing water from Keenjhar Lake, while the Sindh government manages distribution and has allocated necessary funds. A total of Rs20 billion is earmarked for the K-4 feeder, alongside plans for a costly five-million-gallon desalination plant. The CM also noted 20,000 to 25,000 job vacancies in grades I to IV, with plans for recruitment via IBA-administered tests for BPS-V to VII and filling higher Grade 16 positions. The CM mentioned Sindh's conditions for supporting the federal budget, emphasising equitable distribution of development schemes and the detrimental cut of university funding from Rs4 billion to Rs2 billion, which has sparked protests. On the critical Sukkur-Hyderabad Motorway, the CM expressed concern over the halving of federal funding from Rs30 billion to Rs15 billion. The CM emphasised that major projects are not included in the Federal Public Sector Development Programme (PSDP) and criticised the 18 per cent tax on solar panels as unjust. He warned that the Pakistan Peoples Party would not support the federal budget if unresolved.
