Becoming a ‘learning church' in dialogue with Asian realities
What theologians need to do is to recognize the Canaanite woman in their midst and to let her speak May 26, 2025
Cardinal Luis Antonio Tagle of Manila sprinkles congregants with Holy Water after celebrating Mass in an urban poor community in the Philippine capital. (Photo: George Moya / UCAN files)
By Ruben C. Mendoza
People are comfortable listening to familiar stories that they immediately notice whenever there is a seeming deviation from what they are accustomed to. In those moments of dissonance, something seems to be off or worse, 'wrong.'
In the task of doing theology, particularly in my Philippine context, there is a particular need to listen to 'unfamiliar, dissonant' sounds. The dominant voice of theology — emanating from the Western center — speaks of realities that are vastly different from those on the ground.
While some concerns share resonances, other questions and issues are very much different, emanating from the peripheries.
Theologizing from the center seems to be concerned with maintaining the status quo of doing things and not rocking the boat. People on the fringes have a different voice — perhaps not mellifluous in the way that theologians have been trained to problematize such issues — but guttural and instinctive, yearning to be given the chance to be heard.
Theologians of Asia need to disabuse themselves of thinking about and responding to First World problems, be they social, pastoral, or theological. The starting points of doing theology in Asia are not the concerns of people in the center. However, this is not to say that those issues are not important or unrelated to local ones, but to genuinely privilege the local.
In my context, many of those who live privileged lives ask, 'Where will we go for dinner? What clothes will I wear? What latest mobile phone will I buy? Which car will I use? What kind of business will I establish? Where in the US or Europe will I study?' All of those questions presuppose that there are options available to the one asking the question, choices which ordinary Filipinos do not have.
In contrast to those First World concerns, the ordinary 'Filipino everyman' or 'Filipino everywoman,' Juan and Maria de la Cruz, would ask, 'How will I feed my family? Will I be able to buy the clothes I need? What time do I need to get up in the morning, take the public transportation system, and be on time for work? Will I be able to send my kids to school? Why can't the Church accept my being a homosexual? Why are women not treated equally in the Church? When can I be divorced from my abusive husband and receive support from the Church and society? What happens when I get sick? What will happen to my children? Is it really God's will that I am poor?'
If the Church is to be truly the 'field hospital' that the late Pope Francis desired it to be, then it is to such people that theologians need to listen and learn from. Instead of doing theology deductively, the challenge for theologians is to do theology inductively.
It is for those in the margins that one needs to make sense of the Christian faith. I know that it is so easy to be numb and desensitized to those questions, so perhaps a more provocative question to raise is how theologians internalize the Christian faith so that they are authentically humble and hearers of other people's realities rather than imposing on them what they think is best for the poor, forgotten flock?
That is why it is even more important that one keeps one's ear to the ground, listening openly and intently to the 'cry of the poor, the cry of the earth,' smelling like the sheep, to again use a metaphor that the late Pope Francis used, attuned to their needs and sensibilities.
This, I think, is at the heart of the Federation of Asian Bishops' Conferences' insistence on the need to engage in dialogue with cultures, religious traditions, and the poor.
For a longest time, in the Asian context (and I suppose everywhere else), the Church has acted as a teacher. The Asian bishops insightfully recognized the need to learn from the various ways of life of their peoples, the need to be enriched by the teachings and practices of Asian religious traditions, and the need to listen to the voices of those on the margins.
More recently, the Asian bishops, in line with Laudato Si' , have recognized the need to dialogue with our common home, a move away from a highly anthropocentric and androcentric understanding of creation. Listening and learning from the other is at the heart of becoming a synodal church.
The challenge now is for the Church to continue the process that was started by Pope Francis, especially the spiritual conversations that have been initiated in the local churches and continue to be conducted.
I know that it is easier to inhabit an echo chamber of comfortable theologizing and batting around the same ideas that are within one's expertise, which can give one a false sense of security.
The task then is to be aware of one's presuppositions and preconditioning and to let the Word of God that comes from the other — others — to challenge one and perhaps to convert one to greater fidelity to that Word.
What theologians need to do is to recognize the Canaanite woman (see Mt 15, 21-28) in their midst, and to let her speak and challenge their assumptions about God, faith and the Church. They need to let the faith of outsiders — the Esaus (see Gen 25-28.32-33.35), Tamars (see Gen 38), Rahabs (see Josh 2), Naamans (see 1 Kgs 5,1-19) and Ruths (see Ruth 1-4) in one's life — disturb them of their complacency and actually learn from them.
In this way, one's theology grows from the people and is reflective of God's voice through God's children and our common home. Perhaps they are the poor whose voices from the peripheries are disturbing a more authentic theology.--ucanews.com
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Herald Malaysia
a day ago
- Herald Malaysia
Filipinos celebrate independence with Mass
Ambassador Maria Angela Abrera Ponce and officials from the Philippine Embassy joined the Filipino Catholic community for Mass on June 8 at the Cathedral of St Johnto commemorate the opening of the 127th Anniversary of Philippine Independence. Jun 20, 2025 KUALA LUMPUR: Ambassador Maria Angela Abrera Ponce and officials from the Philippine Embassy joined the Filipino Catholic community for Mass on June 8 at the Cathedral of St Johnto commemorate the opening of the 127th Anniversary of Philippine on Pentecost Sunday, the Mass brought together Filipinos from across the city for a moment of prayer, thanksgiving, and national reflection. It was organised by Tahanang Pilipino, a Filipino Catholic community that regularly gathers for spiritual fellowship and priest, Fr Gerard Theraviam, presided over the Eucharistic celebration. The Philippine flag stood prominently beside the altar, symbolising unity and patriotism among overseas Filipinos. During the Mass, special prayers were offered for the Philippines, its leaders, and the millions of Overseas Filipino Workers (OFWs) around the world. The celebration served not only as a tribute to the country's independence but also as a reminder of the resilience and faith of the Filipino diaspora.
Herald Malaysia
a day ago
- Herald Malaysia
Papal diplomats reflect Church's universal mission of peace
Pope Leo XIV met Apostolic Nuncios and papal representatives from around the world on June 10 for the first time since the start of his pontificate. Jun 20, 2025 The ring bears the inscription 'Sub umbra Petri'. VATICAN: Pope Leo XIV met Apostolic Nuncios and papal representatives from around the world on June 10 for the first time since the start of his pontificate. Upholding tradition, he gave each a ring inscribed with 'sub umbra Petri,' a sign of their bond to the successor of Peter. In his address, Pope Leo urged them to remain closely united to the Pope and in communion with local bishops. 'Only in obedience and effective communion with the Pope can your ministry be effective for the Church,' he praised the Holy See's diplomatic corps as a global witness to the Church's unity and mission, calling them a symbol of human fraternity and peace. Off-the-cuff, he described their work, especially in helping select bishops, as 'irreplaceable.' Pope Leo thanked them for their pastoral spirit and diplomatic insight, quoting Pope St Paul VI, who said papal representatives allow the Pope to 'participate in the very life of his children.' Reflecting on the Acts of the Apostles, Pope Leo likened their mission to St Peter healing the lame man, saying papal envoys must offer not riches but Christ himself —building hope and relationships even in difficult places. He called on them to be 'Peter's gaze' and ambassadors of Christ's love, especially in regions marked by suffering, war, or injustice. Pope Leo concluded by encouraging them to be 'instruments of communion and unity' and witnesses of faith and dignity throughout the world. --Vatican News
Herald Malaysia
3 days ago
- Herald Malaysia
Pope Leo at Audience: Let us not be paralyzed by disappointment
During his weekly General Audience, Pope Leo XIV reflects on the passage of the paralytic at the pool of Bethesda, and warns against becoming "discouraged and falling into spiritual apathy.' Jun 18, 2025 Pope Leo greets hundreds of pilgrims for his weekly Wednesday General Audience (@Vatican Media) By Kielce GussieBefore beginning his Wednesday General Audience, Pope Leo XIV greeted the crowds gathered in St. Peter's Square in the popemobile. Then, in his catechesis, he continued reflecting on the Jubilee theme of 'Jesus Christ our Hope,' focusing on Jesus the healer. The Pope invited everyone to 'reflect on those moments when we feel 'stuck' and trapped in a dead end.' He explained that when hope seems useless and people want to give up the Gospel describes this through the image of paralysis. As an example, Pope Leo turned to the story of Jesus curing the paralytic at the pool of Bethesda. House of mercy When Jesus arrives in Jerusalem for a Jewish feast, He makes His first stop at a gate rather than the Temple. This gate is where everyone hoping for a miracle would wait to rush into the pool when it was stirred up—believing it had healing powers. But this created an unpleasant scene as there was a 'struggle among the poor.' People pushing, shoving, and trying to get into the water first. Pope Leo pointed out that Bethesda means 'house of mercy'—which can reflect an image of the Church, 'where the sick and the poor gather, and where the Lord comes to bring healing and hope.' No excuses Jesus encountered the man who had been paralyzed for 38 years and had become resigned to his fate. This disappointment, the Pope said, is precisely what paralyzes us, as we can 'become discouraged and risk falling into spiritual apathy.' The question then is this: 'Do you want to be healed?' Just as the paralyzed man in the Gospel, we can get stuck and 'the desire to get better can fade.' We can get comfortable in our illness and relying on others to take care of us. Pope Leo warned against letting this 'become an excuse to avoid making decisions about our lives.' The paralytic man's response to Jesus shows how the man chooses to see life. He argues there is no one to help him into the pool, 'so the blame is placed not on himself but on others who haven't helped him.' The Pope posed the question: 'Was it really true that he had no one to help him?' Reflecting on his spiritual father, St. Augustine, Pope Leo highlighted that the paralytic needed not just a helping hand but 'a man who was also God.' Write your own story Jesus helps the man turn his view of life from fatalistic—that things just happen due to bad luck—to personal responsibility. His mat becomes a symbol of his past illness and personal history. Yet, now, the man has the ability to walk and the mindset to write his own story. Closing, Pope Leo XIV encouraged everyone to ask God for the grace to recognize where we have gotten 'stuck' and urged them to voice their desire for healing.--Vatican News
