Calls made to recognise Elizabeth Plunkett as a legal victim of Ireland's first serial killers
THE CASE OF Elizabeth Plunkett, the 23-year-old victim of Ireland's first serial killers, was raised today in the Dáil following the publication of a new podcast on her murder.
Elizabeth's family are seeking a cold case review into her death.
A new RTÉ podcast narrated by Roz Purcell was recently released which examines the 1970s murder.
In 1976, Elizabeth, from Ringsend, was murdered by Ireland's first serial killers, John Shaw and Geoffrey Evans.
The pair then killed a second woman, Mary Duffy.
Shaw was convicted of Mary Duffy's murder but was never convicted of Elizabeth's.
Elizabeth's sisters are now continuing their long fight for justice for their sister and want gardaí to open a cold case review and legally recognise them as victims.
Raising the matter in the Dáil today, Labour leader Ivana Bacik noted that the pair, Kathleen and Bernadette, are not regarded as victims of the Parole Board, an issue that came to light in 2023.
Advertisement
She asked the Taoiseach, Micheál Martin, to rectify this issue and help bring some closure to the family.
Responding to Bacik, the Taoiseach said he will ask the Minister for Justice to deal directly with her and with Elizabeth's family in an effort to bring closure.
The killers
In 1976, Englishmen John Shaw and Geoffrey Evans set out to rape and
murder women in Ireland.
The two men had fled to this island after being released from prison in the UK.
According to Stephen Rae's book, Killers: Murders in Ireland, the two men were subject of a manhunt by British forces in connection with the rape of three girls, one of whom was the 16-year-old daughter of a police officer.
They soon came to the attention of the authorities here and were up in court for a number of crimes including burglary. Shaw, already a father of three children at this point, had a string of convictions against him. He was previously imprisoned for attempted rape as well as for indecently assaulting a young boy.
His partner in crime Geoffrey Evans, a father of two, also had a remarkable rap sheet.
In 1975, Shaw was imprisoned for 18 months for burglary, while Evans served just three weeks. Upon their release in 1976, the two began to plan how they would go about finding, raping and murdering women.
The two men would go on to abduct, torture, rape and murder, Elizabeth Plunkett (22) and Mary Duffy (24) in Wicklow and Mayo later that year.
With reporting from Christina Finn
Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone...
A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article.
Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation.
Learn More
Support The Journal
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Irish Sun
3 hours ago
- The Irish Sun
Toddler, 3, horrifically mauled by cockapoo had her ‘arm ripped open' as dad ‘held her skin together'
A THREE-year-old girl has been mauled by a cockapoo in a vicious attack that saw the child's arm ripped open by the designer dog. The young girl, Bunnie, was 4 Bunnie had to undergo plastic surgery to repair her arm Credit: SWNS 4 The attack left the three-year-old with brutal wounds Credit: SWNS Bunnie's father, Rowen Skinley, witnessed the Rowen was walking his three children to school when the cockapoo lunged at his daughter. She suffered Bunnie underwent plastic surgery after being rushed to hospital with surgeons attempting to stitch her torn skin back together. Read more in News Kent Police have confirmed they are Dad Rowan recalled having to "hold the skin on [Bunnie's] arm together" while she waited for treatment. According to reports Bunnie was attacked by a small sandy-coloured Rowan said: "It happened parallel to the school on the main road. I was just walking home after the school run. Most read in The Sun "The path is quite narrow, and a woman was walking her dog on the actual road itself. "Then, out of nowhere, the Girl, 10, mauled by next-door neighbour's Chow Chow before dog RETURNED to owners leaving family 'petrified' "The owner managed to pull the dog off, but when she did that, it "I was so shocked. All I had to stop the bleeding was my hands. I had to basically hold her skin together." Witnesses to the vicious attack rushed over to help rowan and Bunnie but the owner of the dog quickly left the scene. 4 Bunnie was rushed to hospital after the attack Credit: SWNS 4 She has now had several x-rays and plastic surgery Credit: SWNS Rowen said: "People who saw what happened came over and said that my daughter hadn't even put her hand out to the "The woman just disappeared. She didn't leave any details or anything." He added: "She's doing well now. She's just a bit shaken and keeps talking about how "She also has a lung condition and really bad asthma so she had to be marked down as a high-risk category for sedation. "It's really upsetting that the woman didn't stop because it makes you fear for the Bunnie was rushed to Medway Maritime Hospital and then transferred to St Thomas' in Westminster on the morning of June 18. She had several X-rays to ensure the puncture hadn't hit her bone, before undergoing Bunnie will have to go back to the hospital within a week for a check-up, and to assess whether she will need further work done. Which dog breeds are banned in the UK? THERE are specific regulations in place that prohibit certain dog breeds from being owned or bred in the UK. So what are the Which dog breeds are illegal in the UK? People tend to think of large, vicious dogs when they imagine being bitten by one. But the truth is that many types of dogs are known to bite humans, whether provoked or not. However, it's important to remember that just because a breed tends to bite humans, that doesn't mean that they all do. British law determines five breeds of dog are illegal to own, breed, sell or give away. These are an XL Bully, Pit Bull Terrier, Japanese Tosa, Dogo Argentino and Fila Brasileiro.
Sunday World
7 hours ago
- Sunday World
Kneecap fans charged €30 for balaclavas and ‘free Mo Chara' tshirts at Dublin gig
Fans who did buy them at official merchandising stalls may feel they got a bit of a bargain as the same items are fetching over €110 online. KNEECAP fans are not only lapping up their music but also their imaginative merchandising. Woolen Irish tricolour balaclavas, as famously sported by band member DJ Provai, were on sale at last night's gig in Dublin's Fairview Park for €30. Many fans took delight wearing them, with security signs on nearby entrances earlier anticipating the craze by signalling: 'Balaclavas may be worn but please show your face if asked by security staff'. Kneecap News in 90 Seconds - June 20th Fans who did buy them at official merchandising stalls may feel they got a bit of a bargain as the same items are fetching over €110 online. Kneecap t-shirts, primarily in black, were also generally priced at €30. The most popular one being snapped up had 'Free Mo Chara' on its front, in obvious reference to band member Liam Óg Ó hAnnaidh's current court case in London. Tshirts on sale at the gig This was the group's first show since Liam's appearance at a magistrates court in London on Wednesday on alleged incitement of terrorism charges (for displaying a Hezbollah flag at a gig in the British capital several months ago), with his case being put back until August while he's released on unconditional bail. Other t-shirts read 'Kneecap: England get out of Ireland' and 'Take these yokes and we'll go for a dance'. A Kneecap hoodie was on sale for €70 and shorts for €40. There was also a separate stall selling pro-Palestinian items. Much of the marketing ideas are originated by the band's enterprising Dubliner manager Daniel Lambert. Daniel is also the C.E.O. of Bohemians FC, where he has had a phenomenal success of bringing sales of merchandising of replica jerseys from just over €100,000 a year to an estimated €2 million. A sign on display at the gig The jerseys, many of which are bought online from abroad, have already have themes such as Bob Marley (who played in Dalymount Park in 1980), 'Refugees Welcome' and 'Fontaines DC'. Environmentalist Greta Thunberg was spotted wearing a Bohs' Fontaines DC on her recent attempted boat trip to Gaza. 'I'm a free man', announced Liam as he took to the stage last night, to whoops of support from the sold-out crowd of 8500 who packed out a giant marquee. Free Mo Chara tshirts were on sale Liam also later wryly stressed that 'I'm not the first lad from west Belfast' that ended up in a British court. The band also highlighted that while their fans got to enjoy an exhilarating show they should also contemplate about Palestinians being slaughtered in Gaza and the West Bank. Balaclavas on sale online The group too paid a touching tribute to their late lightning designer Conor Biddle, offering sympathy to his family and husband Sean. Kneecap will play Glastonbury on Saturday of next weekend, where they're expected to have one of the biggest crowds of the famous festival given not just the curiosity, they're attracting for being perhaps the most high-profile anti-establishment act at the moment but also because their catchy and thought-provoking music is attracting a growing army of fans.
Sunday World
7 hours ago
- Sunday World
Family fulfil Ian Bailey's last wish to have his ashes spread in west Cork
Bailey collapsed and died from a heart attack while out walking in Bantry on January 21, 2024. THE family of Ian Bailey (66) held a special memorial ceremony to spread his ashes in his beloved west Cork - a place they said he adored above all others. The memorial was led today by Mr Bailey's sister, Kay Reynolds, who said her brother adored the area above all others and his family felt it was appropriate that his final resting place should be by Roaringwater Bay. "We wanted to do right by Ian," she explained. "He absolutely loved west Cork with a passion. There was the (European Arrest) warrant which meant he could not leave the country but he said he would not want to be anywhere else. Ian Bailey was the chief suspect for the murder of Sophie Toscan du Plantier. Photo: Getty "It was very appropriate that this is where we spread his ashes. It is something he wanted. It came up in conversation with him." His family said he spent the bulk of his adult life in the area around Schull and it had inspired much of his prose and poetry. Mr Bailey collapsed and died from a heart attack while out walking in Bantry on January 21, 2024. The Manchester-born journalist and poet was the chief suspect in the Sophie Toscan du Plantier (39) murder investigation. Ms du Plantier, a French film executive, had tried to flee from an intruder at her home but was caught and savagely beaten to death on December 22/23, 1996. British journalist Ian Bailey. Photo: Collins News in 90 Seconds - June 20th Mr Bailey had reported on the killing for Irish, British and French newspapers before becoming a Garda suspect. Ms Reynolds said she believes the stress her brother was under from being wrongly associated with the crime for almost 30 years took a toll on his health. "Without question - I don't think there would be any doubt about that,' she said. "He had been quite fit until the last couple of years. It finally got to him. He was not taking care of himself but it was all to do with the pressure. It had been relentless for almost 30 years. It took its toll on him. "There were times he did not help himself. I think if he had kept quiet it would have been better but that was not Ian's style. "He had nothing to hide and he would not hide. He confronted his challengers face on." Ms Reynolds said her brother was a hugely talented journalist - and regularly obtained details on stories that other journalists did not. She said she believes his abilities as an investigative journalist most likely brought him to Garda notice because of the information he obtained about the case. "Garda felt there were things that only somebody involved in the crime would have known. I don't think that helped,' she said. "But as a family we never thought that he had done this. That was Ian's style of journalism - in Gloucester he did stuff about GCHQ that other journalists didn't. He thought outside the box. "I think that was what happened there and became his downfall. That is how he became a suspect. "From the moment he told us - he phoned us to let us know we would start to see things in the paper about him - we never doubted him that he had been involved in this." Ms Reynolds stressed that her family have enormous sympathy for the du Plantier family and what they have gone through over the past 29 years. "This is not to forget that a very young mother was brutally murdered. I feel so sorry for the family because of the misguided belief that Ian committed the murder they have just had so many years of torture,' she said. "I just wish them peace around this. Hopefully the cold case will throw up something that will be of help to them.' The ceremony was attended by around 40 people including members of the legal profession who had worked with Mr Bailey, journalists and local friends. Mr Bailey, a freelance journalist, 'New Age' gardener and wood turner, collapsed and died while out walking on Barrack Street in Bantry. He was pronounced dead before he could be transferred to Bantry General Hospital with his collapse coming just weeks after he had suffered a series of heart attacks. Mr Bailey died just one week before his 67th birthday, having been warned before Christmas that he needed to get stronger before doctors would proceed with planned bypass and stent surgery. His remains were cremated in a private ceremony at the Island Crematorium in Ringaskiddy, Co Cork, with the arrangements handled by an undertaker from outside west Cork. Ms Reynolds is Mr Bailey's next of kin and gave evidence in 2015 during his High Court action for wrongful arrest against the State as to the impact on her brother of the French arrest warrant and his inability to leave Ireland even to visit his dying mother. Mr Bailey's long-time solicitor, Frank Buttimer, who attended the memorial service, said he remained convinced that Mr Bailey "had nothing whatsoever to do with this crime". He also said he was convinced that being wrongly associated with the crime for so many years "was a major factor in his ill health'. Award-winning Irish film director Jim Sheridan (74) produced a Sky TV documentary, 'Murder at the Cottage,' on the Toormore killing. He got to know Mr Bailey during the years of its production. The documentary series was launched in 2021, the same year as a major Netflix series on the murder. Mr Sheridan has previously insisted that all his research led him to believe that Sophie was killed by someone she knew. "I genuinely believe the answer to the murder will be found in France,' he said. "My conclusion is that in many ways Ian Bailey has been punished for this crime. He has been marked down as a killer for over 25 years and found guilty in a French courtroom, so he has suffered, even if he never faced a jury in a criminal case." Mr Bailey was arrested twice by gardaí in 1997 and 1998 for questioning in respect of Sophie's murder. He was released without charge on both occasions and has vehemently protested his innocence for the past 27 years. No one has ever been charged in relation to Sophie's death in Ireland. Mr Bailey sued eight Irish and British newspapers for libel in 2003 after claiming he was branded as the murderer. He also took an action - which he lost - against the State for wrongful arrest in 2014/15. After an eight year French investigation, he was prosecuted for Sophie's murder at a Paris trial in May 2019 and convicted of her murder. He was sentenced to 25 years in prison - but had to be tried in absentia after he refused to attend the French hearing which he dismissed as "a show trial" and "a mockery of justice". Mr Bailey warned the Irish Independent in April 2019 that he was "being bonfired". The French failed on three separate occasions since 2010 to have Mr Bailey extradited to France. The Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) studied the Garda case file but ruled out any charges in 2000/2001 citing lack of evidence. A Garda cold case review is currently underway and has continued despite Mr Bailey's death. The Garda investigation into Sophie's death has been open and active over the past 28 years. It is planned that a revised and updated file will be submitted to the DPP. The campaign group which secured the French prosecution of Mr Bailey for Sophie's murder vowed to continue their campaign to secure justice for the mother-of-one despite his death 18 months ago. ASSOPH, the association for the truth about the murder of Sophie Toscan du Plantier, vowed that they will continue to campaign amid hope that "new elements" will finally reveal the precise circumstances of the death of the French film executive in the early hours of December 23, 1996. Sophie was battered to death as she apparently tried to flee from an intruder at her isolated Toormore holiday home - running over fields before her clothing snagged on barbed wire allowing the killer to catch her. ASSOPH claimed that Mr Bailey had "taunted" the police over the past three decades - and claimed that the Irish judicial authorities never wanted to extradite him to France despite three attempts to do so since 2010. "On January 21, 2024, Ian Bailey passed away, 27 years after the horrific murder committed in Ireland against Sophie Toscan du Plantier, born Bouniol," they said. "The Paris Criminal Court sentenced him in absentia on May 31, 2019, to 25 years in prison for murder. "Despite this trial and France's repeated requests for his extradition, Ian Bailey remained free, never facing charges from the Irish justice system. "With Bailey's death, Sophie's family and our association will never be able to obtain a confession from Ian Bailey. "We continue our efforts for truth and justice. An investigation is underway in Ireland, and we are confident that the discovery of new elements, the hearing of new witnesses, and the revelation of possible complicity will enable Irish police to close the case, years after the murder."
