Transfers are common across college sports. Athletes see irony in being criticized as disloyal
Hailey Van Lith was one year away from tying a bow on a traditional college career at Louisville and being cemented as one of the most decorated four-year starters in Cardinals history. She had just led her team to its third straight Elite Eight appearance and put up career-high numbers, including 19.7 points per game.
But the rising senior from Wenatchee, Washington, had other plans. With WNBA aspirations on her mind, Van Lith swapped Louisville red for LSU purple and gold and embarked on a new journey in Baton Rouge. Her lone season included another run to the Elite Eight and it was back to the transfer portal.
Coach Mark Campbell's pro-style offense caught her eye, and she decided her fifth and final year of eligibility would be spent at TCU.
College sports was once rooted in tradition, school pride and loyalty, but those expectations are changing if not fading in a landscape where athletes have won the ability to transfer season to season, year to year. Some are painted as disloyal or selfish but Van Lith and others don't see it that way.
'Whenever you transfer, you always expect pushback,' Van Lith told The Associated Press. 'I can't tell you how many podcasts I've seen on people discussing my choices to go to this school and that school, and the theories that are thrown out there are all wrong. But it's just, you learn to live in harmony with that, and at the end of the day, I just decided I'm no longer going to let false assumptions disrupt my peace.'
One of the biggest misconceptions, Van Lith said, is that her transfer decisions were guided by NIL compensation. She was able to look past accusations of being a 'money chaser' or a 'trophy chaser' and find solace knowing onlookers didn't have the full picture.
'Multiple of the schools that I went to, I actually never got a check from,' she said. 'I think that in transfer culture now, a lot of people automatically assume that it has to do with the collective money or now I guess it's revenue share. But it just depends on the person, and for me, it was all basketball decisions.'
A level playing field
Ann Skeet, senior director of Leadership Ethics at Santa Clara's Markkula Center for Applied Ethics, said all parties should be held to the same standards. Coaches and athletic directors take new jobs, navigating buyouts and ill will along the way.
'I do think one of the realities of sport in this day and age is that people are making changes more often than they used to,' Skeet said. 'How they communicate what their decision is, how much time they give people, how frequently they're changing teams, all of those things should be considered, and I think it's fair to hold the coaches and players to equal standards.'
Skeet acknowledged the pressure on athletes navigating a new, professional-like industry at a young age. Millions of dollars in name, image and likeness compensation is already flowing even before schools start cutting checks after July 1 under the NCAA antitrust settlement.
'The reality is, NIL is bringing market pressures to college sports in a way that we haven't experienced before, and so players are having to trade off and think about what serves their own personal interests vs. what serves the team interests in ways that they haven't had to consider in the past,' she said.
Complicated decisions
While Van Lith was deciding her future, running back Ray Davis was awaiting his. In his sole season at Kentucky, Davis rushed for 1,129 yards on 199 carries and led the SEC with 21 touchdowns from scrimmage. His production was enough to garner interest from NFL scouts.
Similar to Van Lith, Davis's winding road to the pros involved several stops. Before Kentucky, he had two-year stints at Temple (2019-2021) and Vanderbilt (2021-2023). Transferring to Kentucky meant Davis would suit up for his third team in five years, and he knew moving from one SEC school to the next could stir the pot. The decision wasn't an easy one.
'It was super difficult,' Davis said. 'It took days, literally almost weeks to just really make a decision. And when I made the decision, I just had to live with it. I couldn't think twice about it. I had to be confident.'
The move paid off. Davis gained national attention and was selected by the Buffalo Bills in the fourth round of the 2024 draft. But while his draft stock soared, the backlash from transferring a second time took a toll.
'Mentally it sucks because, you know, as a kid when you're 18, 19 or whatever, you're being told, 'Hey he's leaving because he's disloyal,' and that's not what it is,' Davis said.
He focused on what he could control.
'I think it's really about how you handle it yourself, how you internalize it yourself, and how you go about walking in the building each and every day. If you be like, `Ah, people are looking at me like I'm not an honest and disloyal person,' then that's going to hurt you mentally. But if you walk into a place where you're confident in who you are, then I think you'll succeed,' Davis told AP.
The impacts
Transfer decisions, regardless of the underlying factor, can lead to unfavorable public perceptions — or worse. A 2024 study found a cross-section of abusive content directed toward college athletes on social media.
'It certainly is their right to transfer, but then they will also develop whatever reputation they develop as a result of the choices they make. So people who transfer multiple times are going to be identified in that way,' Skeet said. 'It goes with the territory, as they say.'
Both Van Lith and Davis noted the irony in receiving blowback when team personnel can seek new ventures without repercussions.
'Coaches leave. Directors leave. Everybody has the opportunity to leave. So for players, we've got to have that opportunity too,' Davis said.
Added Van Lith: 'A lot of times, the loyalty is placed on the responsibility of the players, but you see coaches leave all the time to better their financial situation, to make more money, to do better for their family. When people talk about loyalty, I really challenge them to put into perspective, if they would feel the same if a coach left.'
___
AP college sports: https://apnews.com/hub/college-sports
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
USA Today
23 minutes ago
- USA Today
Complete preview: LSU baseball faces Coastal Carolina in College World Series final
Eight teams arrived at the College World Series in Omaha searching for a national championship. A week later, just two teams remain. LSU and Coastal Carolina are set to meet in the College World Series Final, a best-of-three series beginning on Saturday. LSU and Coastal both made it through bracket play without taking a loss. The Tigers came close, but stormed back to beat Arkansas with a three-run ninth inning, capped off by a Jared Jones walk-off single. Earlier on Wednesday, Coastal Carolina beat Louisville and extended its win streak to 26 games, the third-longest streak in D-I in the last five seasons. If LSU had lost, the Tigers would have been forced to play an elimination game on Thursday, giving the Chanticleers an extra day of rest. But now LSU and CCU will have had two days of rest before the CWS final begins. Here's a complete preview and schedule for the College World Series final between LSU baseball and Coastal Carolina. LSU vs. Coastal Carolina: Win probability Implied probabilities are sourced from BetMGM odds. LSU gets a fresh Kade Anderson in Game 1, Eyanson in Game 2 Kade Anderson, LSU's ace, started vs. Arkansas last Saturday and pitched seven innings of one-run baseball. He struck out seven and allowed just three hits. It's what we've come to expect from the lefty who has been one of college baseball's top arms and entered the conversation to be the No. 1 overall pick in the MLB Draft. And with LSU going 3-0 in bracket play, Anderson wasn't needed again. He'll take the mound on Saturday with a complete week of rest, the norm for college pitchers. Anderson has thrown 319 pitches in his last three outings. That's not a crazy amount, but this time of year can be taxing for pitchers. LSU doesn't have to worry about fatigue being an issue for Anderson on Saturday. Anthony Eyanson, LSU's ace 1B, is well-rested, too. Eyanson's start vs. UCLA was cut short after 48 pitches when weather forced the game to be suspended until the next morning. Eyanson was available if needed in LSU's win over Arkansas, but the Tigers' bullpen managed to get it done. Those 48 pitches are the only pitches Eyanson has thrown since his super regional start. Coastal Carolina's staff is also well-positioned, but if the series goes to a Game 3, CCU's Riley Eickhoff could be working on slightly shorter rest after throwing 98 pitches on Wednesday. Which starting rotation has the edge? The focus in this series will be on the pitchers. LSU boats Anderson and Eyanson while Coastal boasts Cameron Flukey, Jacob Morrison, and Eikhoff. All five are considered among the best pitchers in the nation. Coastal Carolina's staff ERA of 3.20 ranks second nationally and LSU isn't far behind, with the Tigers' 3.80 ERA sitting ninth. Coastal Carolina's strikeout to walk ratio is 3.07, seventh in college baseball. LSU's is 2.80, 12th. Coastal has a slight edge in most pitching stats, but given how similar the numbers are, and Coastal's easier conference schedule, the stats suggest these staffs are neck and neck. Cameron Flukey is the likely Game 1 starter for the Chanticleers. The 6-foot-6 sophomore has a 3.29 ERA in 95.2 innings. Flukey dominated Sun Belt competition, but has a 5.91 ERA when facing Power Four lineups. The stuff is good, but he's not unhittable. LSU will counter Flukey with Kade Anderson, the nation's strikeout leader and a consensus top-five draft prospect. Saturday could be a pitcher's duel, but I give LSU the edge with Anderson on the mound. It's hard to beat Anderson without home runs, and Coastal doesn't hit many of those (more on that later). On Sunday, I expect to see LSU's Eyanson vs. CCU's Morrison. Opponents are hitting just .194 vs Morrison in 2025 and he's only walked 22 batters in 104 innings. He owns a 2.08 ERA, and unlike Flukey, his Power Four vs. Sun Belt splits aren't drastic. It doesn't matter who Morrison has faced in 2025 -- he's been dominant. But LSU is tough to beat when Eyanson pitches. The Tigers have won eight straight games where Eyanson appeared, whether as a starter or out of the pen. He's one of the best strikeout pitchers in the country with 143 K's in 101.2 innings. Eyanson has allowed seven earned runs in his last eight innings pitched, but was beginning to settle in vs. UCLA until the weather hit. If both Eyanson and Morrison have their best stuff. I give LSU the slight edge on Sunday. But I trust Morrison's consistency, right now. We'll chalk this one up as a tie. If a Game 3 is necessary, Coastal could benefit from having three full-time starters. LSU probably won't be saving Casan Evans for a Game 3 start if he's needed for a win in Game 1 or 2. But overall, Anderson and Eyanson are the two best pitchers in this series when it comes to stuff. They're battle-tested vs. the best lineups in the SEC, and I'm giving LSU's rotation the edge. Coastal Carolina's bullpen is loaded The LSU pitching staff has stepped up in Omaha with guys like Chase Shores, Zac Cowan, and Jaden Noot making big-time pitches. But Coastal Carolina's bullpen is one of the best in the sport. Chanticleers' reliever Ryan Lynch has a 0.58 ERA in 31 innings. The last time he allowed a run was March 22. In 27 appearances, he's allowed an earned run just twice. Those are video game numbers. Dominick Carbone, Matthew Potok, Darin Horn and Hayden Johnson all boast ERAs of 3.00 or less in 20+ innings pitched. LSU doesn't lack talent, and the recent performances are promising, but the bullpen has faltered at points this season. When it gets away from the LSU pen, it's rarely because the Tigers are getting hit. It's usually about an inability to throw strikes. Chase Shores can touch 100, but you don't always know where it's going to go. Lately, Shores has been executing though. If Shores continues this run, LSU has another high-leverage arm to count on. LSU's top arm out of the pen is Casan Evans. The true freshman is an emerging star and entered LSU's starting rotation late in the year, but with LSU lacking quality arms in the pen, Evans has been Johnson's go-to reliever in the postseason. Another positive development was the re-emergence of Zac Cowan. For much of the season, Cowan was unhittable out of the pen, but he struggled to locate over the last month. He got the start for LSU vs. Arkansas on Wednesday and pitched 5.1 innings without allowing a walk. LSU lineup: Tigers continue to be clutch Situational hitting has been the story for LSU throughout the postseason. Whether it's with runners in scoring position or keeping an inning alive with two outs, LSU is coming through when it matters. Look no further than the Tigers' ninth inning vs. Arkansas. LSU's lineup does a little bit of everything. The Tigers have the power to hit balls out of the park, but can play small ball too. The Tigers take walks, and when pitchers issue too many free passes, LSU makes them pay with clutch hits. Derek Curiel and Ethan Frey, LSU's typical No. 1 and No. 2 hitters, have been pivotal in getting rallies going. Coastal Carolina's pitchers are tough to hit. It will be key for Curiel and Frey to deliver quality at-bats at the top of the order. If Curiel and Frey make CCU work, there's bound to be a mistake at some point. LSU has the bats in the middle of the lineup to make the Chanticleers pay. Jared Jones has homered in back-to-back games for the Tigers. His homer vs. UCLA gave LSU, his homer vs. Arkansas tied the game, and his walk-off single won the game. Not many guys have the power to hit it out of Charles Schwab Stadium, but Jones does. If he keeps swinging the bat like this, LSU will score enough runs to win this series. How does Coastal Carolina score runs? Coastal Carolina doesn't rely on the long ball. With 66 homers on the year, the lineup isn't absent of power, but it's not the Chanticleers' identity. Coastal Carolina does two things really well: Get hit by pitches and steal bases. CCU leads the nation in HBPs and led the Sun Belt in stolen bags. And while they don't smash a ton of homers, the Chanticleers led the Sun Belt with 123 doubles. Catcher Caden Bodine leads the team in hits and on-base percentage. He's one of the draft's top prospects, for what he does at the plate and behind it. Sebastian Alexander is a key piece too, scoring 59 runs. He's second on the team with 10 homers and leads the group with 27 steals. In Omaha, Colby Thorndyke has been Coastal Carolina's top run producer with 8 RBI in three games. LSU baseball vs. Coastal Carolina: College World Series Schedule Here is the schedule for the final series as LSU looks for its eighth national title in program history. The series will begin Saturday at 6 p.m. CT. LSU will be the home team, and ace Kade Anderson is expected to get the start. Game 2 is set for 1:30 p.m. CT. LSU is expected to start Anthony Eyanson and be the visiting team. If necessary, the squads will play a decisive Game 3 at 6:30 p.m. CT on Monday. LSU's CWS final vs. Florida went to three games in 2023. LSU and Coastal Carolina have history LSU met Coastal Carolina in the 2016 super regional. An unseeded team nationally, Coastal Carolina came into Alex Box Stadium and knocked off an LSU squad ranked inside the top-8 in front of one of the most intimidating crowds in the country. The Tigers suffered an 11-8 loss in game one, then in game two, suffered a defeat in walk-off fashion that ended their season. Coastal Carolina defeated Florida, TCU and Arizona en route to hoisting the trophy in 2016. Current LSU head coach Jay Johnson held the same role at Arizona at the time. The upset was a shock at the time, especially to LSU fans, but CCU has since gone on to be one of the sport's most consistent programs.
USA Today
23 minutes ago
- USA Today
Caitlin Clark, Napheesa Collier lead in WNBA All-Star Game fan voting
Indiana Fever guard Caitlin Clark and Minnesota Lynx forward Napheesa Collier are the lead vote getters in the 2025 WNBA All-Star Game after the first returns of fan voting, the league announced. The 2025 WNBA All-Star Game will be played on July 19 at Gainbridge Fieldhouse in Indianapolis, Indiana. WNBA players and media will join fans in selecting the All-Star starters, with fans accounting for 50 percent of the vote, and all current players and a media panel will account for 25 percent each. The league's coaches select the reserves after voting for the starters has been tallied. CAITLIN CLARK: New line of Wilson reflect who star is off the court The two players with the most fan votes will be the captains and will draft from the remaining pool of eight players as starters and 12 reserves. Clark, the reigning Rookie of the Year, is averaging 19.9 points, 8.7 assists, and 5.7 rebounds, despite missing five games with a leg injury. Collier, the Defensive Player of the Year, leads the WNBA in scoring with a 24.4 points per game average. Top 10 after first fan voting update
USA Today
37 minutes ago
- USA Today
USC women's basketball's Kennedy Smith named to Team USA AmeriCup roster
Beginning next week, the 2025 Women's AmeriCup basketball tournament will take place in Santiago, Chile. On Thursday, Team USA released its roster for the tournament. Making the team was USC rising sophomore Kennedy Smith. Smith is coming off an impressive true freshman season at USC. On the year, she averaged 9.5 points, 4.3 rebounds, 2.2 steals, and 2.0 assists per contest. 'Kennedy. Smith,' USC head women's basketball head coach Lindsay Gottlieb wrote on social media following the announcement. 'So dang proud. Great roster.' The AmeriCup tournament will run from June 28 through July 6. The U.S. teams consists of the top women's college basketball players in the country. (WNBA players are not able to participate due to it taking place in the middle of their season.) Were she healthy, USC's Juju Watkins would have likely been the headliner of the team. With Watkins currently recovering from the ACL tear she suffered during the NCAA Tournament, Smith is the only Trojan headed to Santiago.
