YouTuber Tests Tesla's Autopilot Against LiDAR System Musk Once Dismissed
⚡️ Read the full article on Motorious
Popular YouTube personality Mark Rober, a former NASA engineer and founder of CrunchLabs, recently compared Tesla's camera-based Autopilot system to a LiDAR-equipped vehicle, reigniting debate about the effectiveness of different autonomous-driving technologies.
Rober, known for engaging science-based experiments, tested the two autonomous technologies side-by-side to evaluate their abilities to detect obstacles on the road. Tesla CEO Elon Musk has previously dismissed LiDAR (Light Detection and Ranging), a system using laser sensors to map surroundings, famously calling it a "fool's errand." Instead, Musk argues that camera-based systems are sufficient and superior for self-driving capabilities.
However, Rober's test highlighted challenges faced by Tesla's Autopilot under difficult driving conditions. When subjected to dense fog, heavy rain, and unusual obstacles like painted walls, Tesla's camera-dependent system struggled to consistently recognize hazards. By contrast, the LiDAR-equipped vehicle reliably detected obstacles in nearly all test scenarios, demonstrating clear advantages under adverse conditions.
In one dramatic demonstration reminiscent of cartoon antics, Rober's setup featured brightly colored, cartoon-like obstacles intended to clearly challenge both systems' detection capabilities. While visually whimsical, the results were eye-opening, prompting a renewed discussion about the practical limitations of camera-only solutions for autonomous driving.
Tesla maintains that cameras and advanced software algorithms, coupled with artificial intelligence, provide sufficient real-world autonomous driving capabilities, avoiding the high costs associated with LiDAR systems. Critics, however, argue that relying solely on cameras compromises safety, particularly in low-visibility conditions.
Rober's findings underscore an ongoing technological debate within the automotive industry: is Musk's commitment to camera-based autonomy visionary or overly optimistic? For now, the experiment provides compelling evidence suggesting that LiDAR may offer critical advantages in ensuring safety and reliability in challenging driving scenarios.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Dow Jones Futures Fall, Oil Climbs After U.S. Bombs Iran Nuclear Sites; Tesla Launches Robotaxi Service
Dow Jones futures traded lower after President Trump announced the U.S. bombed Iran nuclear sites. The Tesla launched its robotaxi service.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Tesla Starts Long-Awaited Robotaxi Service With Low-Key Rollout
(Bloomberg) -- Tesla Inc. rolled out its long-promised driverless taxi service to a handful of riders Sunday, a modest debut for what Elon Musk sees as a transformative new business line. Bezos Wedding Draws Protests, Soul-Searching Over Tourism in Venice One Architect's Quest to Save Mumbai's Heritage From Disappearing NYC Congestion Toll Cuts Manhattan Gridlock by 25%, RPA Reports The first robotaxi trips were limited to a narrow portion of Tesla's hometown of Austin, with an employee in each vehicle keeping tabs on the operations. The carmaker hand-picked a friendly crop of initial riders, which featured investors and social-media influencers who live-streamed their trips. In one video, Herbert Ong, who runs a fan account, marveled over the speed of the vehicle and the ability to park autonomously. Another influencer with the @BLKMDL3 handle on X said the trip was 'smoother than a human driver.' Sawyer Merritt, a Tesla investor who runs an account focused on the company, called the experience 'awesome.' With no kickoff event and little in the way of formal announcements, Tesla has relied largely on word of mouth and media coverage ahead of the robotaxi launch, which comes about a decade after Musk began talking about the possibility. The unveiling was uncharacteristically low-key for a company that held a 'Cyber Rodeo' to mark a Texas factory opening in 2022 and an invite-only party near Hollywood last year to unveil autonomous products. Musk is reorienting the carmaker around hyped-but-still-unproven technologies including self-driving vehicles and humanoid robots. Some investors are counting on new markets to revive Tesla following a sales slump and consumer backlash against the chief executive officer. Its shares have tumbled 20% this year. 'Robotaxis are critical to the Tesla investment case,' Tom Narayan, an analyst with RBC Capital Markets, said in a note. About 60% of Narayan's valuation for the shares is attributable to the self-driving vehicles. The videos of the robotaxi launch posted Sunday were largely mundane, showing Model Y SUVs driving short distances, navigating intersections, avoiding pedestrians and parking — albeit with no one sitting in the driver's seat. There were some hiccups, like when one streamer tested a button to have the vehicle pull over and it instead briefly stopped in the middle of a road before the vehicle began moving again. The first riders are being charged a flat rate of $4.20 per trip, Musk said Sunday, though it's unclear what pricing will look like longer term. Robotaxis will be available between 6 a.m. and midnight daily within a geofenced area of the city, not including the airport, according to terms of use that some early riders posted. Service may be limited or unavailable in foul weather. The launch marks a crucial test for Tesla, which is using only 10 to 20 vehicles at first. It's aiming to show it can safely and successfully navigate real-world traffic, which has tripped up some other companies and brought regulatory scrutiny. Cruise, the now-defunct autonomy business of General Motors Co., grounded its fleet in late 2023 and had its operating license suspended in California following an accident that injured a pedestrian. Uber Technologies Inc. ceased testing self-driving vehicles after one of its SUVs struck and killed a pedestrian in Arizona in 2018. Less than three years later, the company agreed to sell its self-driving business. While Tesla hasn't said when the robotaxi service will open to the general public, Musk has pledged to scale up quickly and expand to other US cities in the near future. The company faces a crowded market in Austin. Waymo, which is owned by Google parent Alphabet Inc., is scaling up in the city through a partnership with Uber. Inc.'s Zoox is also testing there. Dan Ives, an analyst with Wedbush Securities who rates Tesla outperform, said he expects robotaxis to be competitive with Waymo from the start. After a member of his team rode in one Sunday, the analyst told Bloomberg the robotaxi user experience was 'better than expected.' Luxury Counterfeiters Keep Outsmarting the Makers of $10,000 Handbags Is Mark Cuban the Loudmouth Billionaire that Democrats Need for 2028? Ken Griffin on Trump, Harvard and Why Novice Investors Won't Beat the Pros The US Has More Copper Than China But No Way to Refine All of It Can 'MAMUWT' Be to Musk What 'TACO' Is to Trump? ©2025 Bloomberg L.P.
Bloomberg
2 hours ago
- Bloomberg
Tesla Starts Long-Awaited Robotaxi Service With Low-Key Rollout
Tesla Inc. rolled out its long-promised driverless taxi service to a handful of riders Sunday, a modest debut for what Elon Musk sees as a transformative new business line. The first robotaxi trips were limited to a narrow portion of Tesla's hometown of Austin, with an employee in each vehicle keeping tabs on the operations. The carmaker hand-picked a friendly crop of initial riders, which featured investors and social-media influencers who live-streamed their trips.
