Superior Court judge denies city's request to dismiss portion of police officers wage theft lawsuit
SPRINGFIELD — A Superior Court judge has ruled against the city after denying its request to dismiss a complaint filed by 19 current Westfield Police Department officers alleging they should have been paid 'regular wages' when attending the police academy, according to court documents.
'After a hearing and consideration of the parties' submissions, the court denies defendant's motion to dismiss,' wrote Superior Court Judge Deepika B. Shulka when handing down his decision Wednesday.
Last September, Springfield-based attorney Jeffrey Morneau with Connor & Morneau representing the officers of the department filed a lawsuit against the city with three separate complaints.
Count I alleged that officers attending the police academy should have been paid the same wages as a regular officer.
Count II was that the city didn't pay the officers while they were attending the academy regular wages earned within seven days of the end of the pay period. Essentially, the second complaint is asking the court to find that the officers attending the academy should have been paid at least $21 an hour instead of $19 per hour within seven days of leaving the academy.
And in Count III the officers alleged the city was obligated to pay them because 'valuable services were provided to the city' by the officers — it is called a claim for quantum meruit.
In the court's decision to dismiss the first complaint of the lawsuit, the judge referred to case law and cited a 2008 decision and that she determined the officers had 'pleaded factual allegations plausibly suggesting (not merely consistent with) an entitlement' for relief. In this case, it would be back pay times three.
The city had argued in its request for dismissal that the court shouldn't accept 'legal conclusions cast in the form of factual allegations' and that the officers used the collective bargaining agreement between the city and Westfield Police Officers Coalition as a justification for relief.
While the city initially requested the court dismiss the second complaint, during a court hearing between the city and officers, according to the court documents, the officers agreed to seek payment for wages only while they were working in the academy, which was agreed to by the city.
'Therefore, the court leaves Count II undisturbed as pled,' Shulka wrote.
For Count III, the city argued in its answer to the original complaint that the officers were bound to the CBA, and they are 'not entitled to recovery … where a valid contract that defines the obligations of the parties.'
In the judge's decision, she noted the language of the CBA is 'not as clear as the city suggests.'
She said that while the words 'ACADEMY RATE $19.00' does appear in the agreement, there is also language in the agreement that a student officer is a full-time police academy student; they are not covered by the contract.'
The court also noted that the agreement between the city and the union specifically excludes student officers among the group of officers for whom 'the Union [is] the sole and exclusive bargaining agent with respect to wages, hours, and other conditions.'
The judge wrote that the language of the CBA was 'ambiguous at best as to whether the student officers are bound by the CBA, what rights the student officers had to challenge it, and whether the CBA prescribed an hourly pay rate for student officers.'
Based on that, the court also denied the city's request to dismiss Count III.
Morneau said Wednesday the next phase of the lawsuit includes the city answering the court's decision, discovery begins, and depositions being taken.
Morneau is also seeking the lawsuit be deemed a class action because of the potential the lawsuit will include at least 50 of the department's officers.
'The class allegations are brought on behalf of [the] plaintiff and all other members of the Westfield Police Officers Coalition who worked for [the city] … absent a class action, the class will continue to suffer injury, thereby allowing these alleged violations of law to proceed without remedy and allowing [the city] to retain the proceeds of its ill-gotten gains,' the lawsuit reads.
The city of Westfield's Law Department declined to comment on the decision.
Read the original article on MassLive.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Post
29 minutes ago
- New York Post
CAT-astrophe: NYC couple claims beloved rescue kitty crushed by self-cleaning litter box
A Bronx woman came home to a grisly cat-astrophe — her beloved feline was fatally crushed by a self-cleaning litter box. Stephanie Gomez knew something was wrong when she stepped off the elevator in her Williamsbridge apartment building and heard one of her two cats, Sebastian, crying from down the hall, she said. The medical assistant opened her door to find Sebastian frantic — and her other cat, Sarabi, dead, partially stuck inside her Autoscooper 11 litter box. 4 Sarabi was a friendly, playful cat, said Gomez, who rescued the furball after finding her crying on the street on a rainy night in the Bronx. 'I turned on the light. . . . I saw my cat being crushed by the machine,' an emotional Gomez, 35, told The Post of the gruesome Jan. 27 incident. 'It was making an awful sound. 'The machine is supposed to automatically stop when there is a body in it. The machine did not stop, it was still trying to close on her.' The tiny domestic shorthair's body was cold to the touch, with its rear and hind legs sticking out of the machine, according to Gomez and a $3 million Bronx Supreme Court lawsuit she and her partner, Frank Gueits, filed. 'It was completely devastating,' she said. 'I collapsed.' 4 Stephanie Gomez insists she'll never trust a similar automated device again. J.C. Rice She immediately called Gueits for help. 'Stephanie was very frantic, very upset and crying,' he said, recalling Sarabi's body was so mutilated by the machine 'she looked like she was in an L shape. It was really heartbreaking to see.' The litter box, which retails for about $200, was a Christmas gift from Gomez' mother and advertised as 'remaining partially open at all times, with no complete enclosure that could entrap a pet,' according to the lawsuit, which names Pet Pivot, the California-based company which makes the Autoscooper 11, and Amazon, which sold the device. 'A catastrophic failure of the product's safety mechanisms' led to Sarabi's 'long, painful death,' Gomez and Gueits said in court papers. 4 The Autoscooper 11 advertises itself as safe and claims sensors prevent cats from being trapped inside. PetPivot/ Amazon The same night, Gueits, 48, found an Amazon review of the Autoscooper 11 from a cat owner who claimed the littler box 'nearly killed their cat,' but the review was later removed, the couple claimed. Gomez' mother got a full refund after Sarabi's death and a handwritten letter from PetPivot CEO Poppy Xie, which lacked company letterhead or an address, offering condolences and $10,000, Gomez said in legal papers. The couple believes 'the $10,000 offer was an effort to quietly settle or suppress claims relating to the product's fatal defect,' they contended. Sarabi, who weighed less than 10 pounds, 'was the sweetest little thing,' Gomez said. 'She was so wonderful, she was the friendliest kitty. She was . . . very talkative, and don't leave your plate of food unattended,' Gomez laughed. 'There's not a day that goes by that I don't mourn her.' 4 Sebastian still sleeps on the spot where Sarabi was killed, Gomez said. She rescued Sarabi more than a year earlier, after she heard the kitty crying on a rainy night outside her local laundromat, and followed the sound until she found the cat hiding under a van. She named the grey striped feline after a character in Disney's 'The Lion King.' Sebastian has been devastated by the loss, with Gomez hand-feeding him for weeks afterward. 'To this day, Sebastian sleeps on the spot where the Autoscooper had killed Sarabi,' according to the lawsuit. 'I will never trust an automated machine again,' Gomez said. 'I don't want this to happen to anyone else.' Amazon and Pet Pivot did not immediately respond to requests for comment. The device is still being sold — and advertised as safe, said Peggy Collen, the attorney representing Gomez and Gueits. 'Sarabi's death was not an accident,' Collen said. 'If this happened to Sarabi, it could happen to any cat.'
Yahoo
4 hours ago
- Yahoo
Israel-Iran conflict: List of key events, June 20, 2025
Here's where things stand on Friday, June 20: Israel said on Friday that it had struck dozens of military targets in Iran overnight, including Tehran's Organisation of Defensive Innovation and Research, missile production sites and military facilities in western and central Iran. The Israeli military said it struck surface-to-air missile batteries in western Iran, killing a squad of Iranian soldiers on the move during the operation, including a commander of an Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC) base. Israeli Defence Minister Israel Katz said he had instructed the military to intensify attacks on 'symbols of the regime' and 'mechanisms of oppression' in the Iranian capital, Tehran, aiming to destabilise it. Air defence systems were activated in Bushehr in southern Iran, the location of the country's only operating nuclear power plant, according to the Young Journalists Club, cited by state broadcaster IRIB. Iran's IRGC said it had fired its 17th wave of missiles at Israeli military facilities, including the Nevatim and Hatzerim bases. Iran fired missiles at Beersheba in southern Israel, with initial Israeli media reports also pointing to missile impacts in Tel Aviv, the Negev and Haifa. Iran said that the 'precise hits' demonstrated 'our offensive missile power is growing'. The Fars news agency quoted an Iranian military spokesperson as saying Tehran's missile and drone attacks on Friday had used long-range and ultra-heavy missiles against Israeli military sites, defence industries and command and control attack on Tehran's Organisation of Defensive Innovation and Research, which it says is involved in Iran's alleged nuclear weapons development, killed a nuclear scientist, according to Israeli media reports. Iranian media reported that an industrial plant involved in the production of carbon fibre in northern Iran was damaged in an attack. Iran's health ministry said a third hospital in Tehran had been struck by Israeli bombs, according to state news agency IRNA. At least five people were injured when Israel hit a five-storey building in Tehran housing a bakery and a hairdresser's, Fars news agency reported. Iranian news outlet Asriran said that a drone attacked an apartment in a residential building in the Iranian capital's central Gisha district. The Human Rights Activists News Agency, a US-based human rights organisation that tracks Iran, said that Israeli air attacks have killed 639 people in the country. Israeli authorities had previously said 24 civilians had been killed in Iranian attacks. Israel's Magen David Adom rescue service said its teams were providing treatment to 17 people, three in serious condition, after Iran's strikes. Israeli railway officials told local media that, due to the Iranian missile strike on Beersheba, the city's north station was temporarily closed. Afghanistan's agriculture minister said his country was in discussions with Russia to import certain foodstuffs as the conflict between Israel and Iran, one of its largest trading partners, risked cutting off of thousands of people attended anti-Israel protest marches in Tehran, as well as other major Iranian cities, including Isfahan, Shiraz, Mashhad and Qom. Demonstrators in southern Beirut, Lebanon held a pro-Iran rally after Friday prayers. Thousands of Iraqis gathered for Friday prayers in Baghdad's Sadr City, a suburb with a large Shia population, chanting against the US and Israel amid the attacks on Iran. Pro-Palestinian activists in the UK broke into the Royal Air Force Brize Norton base in Oxfordshire and damaged two President Donald Trump told reporters on Friday that his director of national intelligence, Tulsi Gabbard, was wrong to suggest there is no evidence Iran is building a nuclear weapon. 'Well, my intelligence community is wrong,' he replied when asked about Gabbard's position. Trump also said that while he 'might' support a ceasefire deal between Israel and Iran, 'Israel's doing well in terms of war, and I think you would say that Iran is doing less well'. Iranian President Masoud Pezeshkian said the only way to end the conflict was for Israel to stop its air attacks, warning that 'failure to do so would result in a far more forceful and regrettable response from Iran'. Russian President Vladimir Putin said in St Petersburg that Moscow was sharing ideas with 'our Israeli and Iranian friends' about how to end the bloodshed and said he believed there was a diplomatic solution. US Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent announced new Iran-related sanctions aiming to disrupt Tehran's efforts to 'procure the sensitive, dual-use technology, components, and machinery that underpin the regime's ballistic missile, unmanned aerial vehicle, and asymmetric weapons programs'. Qatari Prime Minister Sheikh Mohammed bin Abdulrahman Al Thani said in a phone conversation with Norway's Foreign Minister Espen Barth Eide that Israel targeting economic facilities in Iran could lead to catastrophic regional and international repercussions. French President Emmanuel Macron said there was 'no justification' for strikes on civilians and on civilian infrastructure in the weeklong conflict, adding that Tehran should show its willingness to return to the negotiating table concerning its nuclear programme. Kremlin spokesperson Dmitry Peskov said in comments carried by state news agency TASS that potential use of tactical nuclear weapons by the US in Iran would be a catastrophic development. German Chancellor Friedrich Merz and Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan discussed the ongoing conflict between Israel and Iran over a phone call, a German government spokesperson said. UK Foreign Secretary David Lammy said his country was working with Israeli authorities to arrange charter flights for British nationals from Tel Aviv when Ben Gurion International Airport reopens. The United Nations Security Council met at its headquarters in New York to discuss the situation between Iran and Israel. Rafael Grossi, director of the International Agency for Atomic Energy, warned against attacks on nuclear facilities at the meeting, saying a strike on the Bushehr nuclear plant could cause 'radioactive releases with great consequences' beyond Iran's borders. He called for 'maximum restraint'. UN Secretary-General Antonio Guterres said at the meeting that expansion of the Israel-Iran conflict could 'ignite a fire no one can control', calling on both sides to 'give peace a chance'. Iran's UN ambassador Amir Saeid Iravani urged the Security Council to take action, saying the country was 'alarmed by credible report[s] that the United States … may be joining this war'. Israel's UN ambassador, Danny Danon, pledged at the UNSC that there would be no letup in attacks on Iran. 'Not until Iran's nuclear threat is dismantled, not until its war machine is disarmed, not until our people and yours are safe,' he said. Russia's envoy Vassily Nebenzia stressed that Israel attacked Iran on the eve of a round of nuclear talks and accused Israel of showing a blatant disregard for attempts to find a diplomatic solution to end the conflict. Iraq's representative to the UN, Abbas Kadhom Obaid al-Fatlawi, said 50 Israeli warplanes from the Syrian-Jordanian border areas violated Iraqi airspace shortly before the Security Council meeting. Iranian Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi attended a meeting in Geneva with France, the United Kingdom, Germany and the European Union's foreign policy chief, which appeared to yield no breakthrough. Araghchi told reporters in Geneva that Iran would be ready to consider diplomacy 'once the aggression is stopped and the aggressor is held accountable for the crimes committed'. Earlier, he accused Israel of a 'betrayal of diplomacy' in a speech to the UN Human Rights Council. French Foreign Minister Jean-Noel Barrot told reporters after the Geneva talks that Araghchi had signalled 'his willingness to continue these discussions on the nuclear programme and, more broadly, on all issues'. British Foreign Minister David Lammy said European ministers in Geneva had made it clear that 'Iran cannot have a nuclear weapon'. Germany's Defence Ministry said that it had flown 64 people out of Israel, describing the flights as a 'diplomatic pick-up' and not a military evacuation mission, which would have required parliamentary approval. Ireland's Foreign Minister Simon Harris announced his country would temporarily relocate embassy personnel from Tehran 'in light of the deteriorating situation'. The UK said it was temporarily withdrawing staff from its embassy in Iran, saying the embassy continued to 'operate remotely'. Switzerland's Federal Department of Foreign Affairs said it had decided to temporarily close its embassy in Iran, citing intense military operations there. Australia also said it had suspended operations at its embassy in Iran. Foreign Minister Penny Wong said a 'crisis response team' was being sent to neighbouring Azerbaijan to support Australians departing Iran by road. Slovakia and the Czech Republic also announced the temporary closure of their embassies in Tehran. British police arrested eight men on Friday, including seven on suspicion of grievous bodily harm, following reports of an altercation involving pro and anti-Iranian protesters at a location close to the Iranian embassy in London.
American Press
10 hours ago
- American Press
Columbia protester Mahmoud Khalil freed from immigration detention
Palestinian activist Mahmoud Khalil was released Friday from federal immigration detention, freed after 104 days by a judge's ruling after becoming a symbol of President Donald Trump 's clampdown on campus protests. The former Columbia University graduate student left a federal facility in Louisiana on Friday. He is expected to head to New York to reunite with his U.S. citizen wife and infant son, born while Khalil was detained. 'Justice prevailed, but it's very long overdue,' he said outside the facility in a remote part of Louisiana. 'This shouldn't have taken three months.' Email newsletter signup The Trump administration is seeking to deport Khalil over his role in pro-Palestinian protests. He was detained on March 8 at his apartment building in Manhattan. Khalil was released after U.S. District Judge Michael Farbiarz said it would be 'highly, highly unusual' for the government to continue detaining a legal U.S. resident who was unlikely to flee and hadn't been accused of any violence. 'Petitioner is not a flight risk, and the evidence presented is that he is not a danger to the community,' he said. 'Period, full stop.' During an hourlong hearing conducted by phone, the New Jersey-based judge said the government had 'clearly not met' the standards for detention. The government filed notice Friday evening that it's appealing Khalil's release. The Department of Homeland Security said in a post on the social platform X that the same day Farbiarz ordered Khalil's release, an immigration judge in Louisiana denied him bond and 'ordered him removed.' The decision was made by Judge Jamee Comans, who is in a court located in the same detention facility from which Khalil was released. 'An immigration judge, not a district judge, has the authority to decide if Mr. Khalil should be released or detained,' the post said. Khalil was the first person arrested under Trump's crackdown on students who joined campus protests against Israel's devastating war in Gaza. U.S. Secretary of State Marco Rubio has said Khalil must be expelled from the country because his continued presence could harm American foreign policy. The Trump administration has argued that noncitizens who participate in such demonstrations should be deported as it considers their views antisemitic. Protesters and civil rights groups say the administration is conflating antisemitism with criticism of Israel in order to silence dissent. Farbiarz has ruled that the government can't deport Khalil on the basis of its claims that his presence could undermine foreign policy. But the judge gave the administration leeway to continue pursuing a potential deportation based on allegations that he lied on his green card application, an accusation Khalil disputes. The international affairs graduate student isn't accused of breaking any laws during the protests at Columbia. He served as a negotiator and spokesperson for student activists and wasn't among the demonstrators arrested, but his prominence in news coverage and willingness to speak publicly made him a target of critics. The judge agreed Friday with Khalil's lawyers that the protester was being prevented from exercising his free speech and due process rights despite no obvious reason for his continued detention. The judge noted that Khalil is now clearly a public figure. Khalil said Friday that no one should be detained for protesting Israel's war in Gaza. He said his time in the Jena, Louisiana, detention facility had shown him 'a different reality about this country that supposedly champions human rights and liberty and justice.' 'Whether you are a U.S. citizen, an immigrant or just a person on this land doesn't mean that you are less of a human,' he said, adding that 'justice will prevail, no matter what this administration may try to portray' about immigrants. Khalil had to surrender his passport and can't travel internationally, but he will get his green card back and be given official documents permitting limited travel within the country, including New York and Michigan to visit family, New Jersey and Louisiana for court appearances and Washington to lobby Congress. In a statement after the judge's ruling, Khalil's wife, Dr. Noor Abdalla, said she can finally 'breathe a sigh of relief' after her husband's three months in detention. 'We know this ruling does not begin to address the injustices the Trump administration has brought upon our family, and so many others,' she said. 'But today we are celebrating Mahmoud coming back to New York to be reunited with our little family.' The judge's decision comes after several other scholars targeted for their activism have been released from custody, including another former Palestinian student at Columbia, Mohsen Mahdawi; a Tufts University student, Rumeysa Ozturk; and a Georgetown University scholar, Badar Khan Suri. ___ Marcelo reported from New York. Jennifer Peltz contributed from New York.
