‘Eleanor the Great' Review: Scarlett Johansson's Directorial Debut Is an Unconvincing Crowd-Pleaser, With June Squibb Doing Brash Shtick

June Squibb has become the female Alan Arkin. She's 95 years old, but onscreen she delivers her zingers with the crack timing of an old person whose perception of the world is ageless in its bombs-away, truth-telling joy. After years as a sneaky scene stealer, Squibb became a star in 'Nebraska,' the 2013 Alexander Payne film that turned her combination of homespun grandmotherly demeanor and ruthless wit into a crowd-pleasing force. Last year, she had her first leading role (in 'Thelma,' an action comedy!), and now her perky moon face is front and center again in 'Eleanor the Great,' the first film directed by Scarlett Johansson.
The movie is an awards-season wannabe in every sense. It totally plays up Squibb's tart-tongued Arkin-adjacent antique brash aplomb. But in addition, it's an attempt to tap into the poignant underside of a character who uses her wisecracks as weapons. Did I mention that it's also a sentimental Holocaust weeper?
More from Variety
Erin Kellyman on Starring in Scarlett Johansson's Directorial Debut 'Eleanor the Great': 'This Job Has Changed the Way I See Myself as an Actor'
Jafar Panahi and Saeed Roustayee Are Both in Cannes in Banner Year for Iranian Cinema on the Croisette
Jafar Panahi Speaks Out for First Time in 14 Years as New Film 'It Was Just an Accident' Premieres at Cannes: I Spent 'Eight Hours a Day Blindfolded' and 'Being Interrogated' in Iran Prison
When we first meet Squibb's Eleanor Morgenstein, who is 94 and still spry, she's waking up in the bedroom she shares with her oldest friend, Bessie (Rita Zohar), in an apartment in Florida. It's Friday morning, and they're undertaking their ritual weekly outing: a trip to the supermarket. That may not sound too dramatic, but there's rarely a dull moment with Eleanor, who will give anyone a piece of her mind, even when it's not a friendly piece. When she and Bessie arrive at the market's pickle-jar section, only to learn that the kosher brand they favor isn't there, Eleanor seizes the chance to dress down a stockboy who's utterly at sea about how to help them. That she has the awareness to skewer him as a clueless Zoomer is what's funny — that, and the fact that Squibb delivers her lines as if they were the opening monologue of her own talk show.
The script of 'Eleanor the Great,' by Tory Kamen, doesn't stint on the sitcom sarcasm, and that's both a plus and a minus. There's no denying that as a character, Eleanor plays, giving Squibb an opportunity to strut her granny-with-an-attitude stuff. But you're always aware that the movie is trying to squeeze a laugh out of you.
Bessie is a Holocaust survivor, with one of those old-world Eastern European accents and a woe-is-me shrug of a personality to match. She and Eleanor are presented as if they were two peas in a Jewish-retirement-community pod. But this gives us pause. June Squibb is a hell of an actor, but in 'Eleanor the Great' she doesn't exactly come off like a Jewish person from the Bronx (which is what the film first implies she is).
There is, however, a good explanation for that. The set-up for the movie is that Bessie, who has been Eleanor's soulmate for decades, dies quite suddenly. Eleanor has never lived alone, so she relocates to New York City to move into the East Side apartment of her daughter, Lisa (Jessica Hecht), and grandson, Max (Will Price), at which point it starts to become clear that 'Eleanor the Great' is no mere glorified sitcom. It's an investigation into the mystery of who Eleanor is.
'You cut your hair, I see,' says Eleanor to Lisa. 'I liked it better before.' That's the kind of line that gives Eleanor — and, indeed, the comedy of June Squibb — an anti-social edge. Eleanor isn't just sharp as a tack; she's got boundary issues when it comes to what she thinks she can say. She talks less to communicate than to entertain herself. And it's that what-the-hell mouthiness that gets her into trouble.
Dropped off at the Manhattan Jewish Community Center (a place where Lisa figures her mother can spend some time and make friends), she wanders into a group of people seated in a circle, and it turns out to be a support group for Holocaust survivors. A normal person would get up and leave, or maybe ask to listen. But neither of those options would satisfy Eleanor, who needs to be at the center of the action. So she starts to tell a story about how she's from Poland, and then this happened to her, and that happened, and we realize that she's making up who she is. She's telling Bessie's story and passing it off as her own. And, of course, doing a captivating job of it.
Nina (Erin Kellyman), a journalism student from NYU, is sitting in on the group to write an article for one of her classes, and she's struck by Eleanor's story. She wants to feature her in the article! And since Eleanor could use the company, she gets drawn into a connection with Nina — a standard buddy-movie trope. If there's any doubt about how much 'Eleanor the Great' often seems to have come out of a screenwriting processor, check out this Coincidence 101 contrivance: Back in Florida, Eleanor and Bessie were obsessed with Roger (Chiwetel Ejiofor), a handsome cable-TV newsman — and it turns out that Roger is Nina's recently widowed father.
The table is now set for Eleanor's fake Holocaust story to go very public.
That someone would appropriate her best friend's saga of wartime survival is clearly indefensible. Yet in a strange way I think 'Eleanor the Great,' to be true to the outrageousness of that premise, should have sharpened the comedy of it more. Johansson, however, while she does a perfectly efficient job of directing, doesn't hone the tone of her scenes. She keeps the whole thing earnest and rather neutral in a plot-driven way, with Squibb as her wild card. As Nina, Erin Kellyman has a wide-eyed precocity marbled with the sadness that has sprung from her mother's death. 'Eleanor the Great' very much wants to be a movie about grief. It tells us that grief is what's at the core of Eleanor's deception — the grief of Bessie's passing, the grief she couldn't bear. That's why she did it! But guess what? I didn't believe that for a moment. Not when June Squibb is having this good a time making herself the center of attention.
Best of Variety
The Best Albums of the Decade

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Cosmopolitan

30 minutes ago

• Cosmopolitan

Is 'The Waterfront' Happening? Here's What We Know

POV: you spent all weekend dissociating and watching The Waterfront on Netflix, and now there's nothing left to do but obsesses over a (potential) second season. Here's what we know about the future of this show, which is best described as one part Outer Banks hijinks, two parts Yellowstone family drama, and one million parts Topher Grace delivering the most deranged (compliment) performance of his career. But creator Kevin Williamson (who blessed us with Dawson's Creek and The Vampire Diaries) tells ScreenRant that he has plans for multiple seasons drawn up. "I've just sort of figured out who these actors are in these roles, and I would love a chance to write for them, and lean into them, and I think the show can just go up," he said. "There's a whole second season that I have planned out, and a third season, quite frankly. So I'm hoping I get the chance to tell those stories. I do think it's a fun show, and it's unlike anything I've ever done, and I just hope people enjoy it." Season 1 was filmed from August to December 2024, so if Netflix follows the same schedule, it seems fair to assume we could get season 2 this time next year. Stream Now! Cane kicked off the season being a pretty reluctant participant in his "life of crime" (the man just wants to run his fishery and flirt with his ex), but he'd literally shot Grady through the face by the season finale. In other words, Cane has officially embraced being a drug dealer. However, season 2 will find him more confused than ever. "He doesn't really wear crime well," Williamson tells Variety. "His father does. His father's really good at it. By returning to a life of crime, Harlan finds himself again. He finds his purpose, and he actually becomes a better person. I don't think that's necessarily true for Cane. Cane's going to have to stumble a bit. I don't think he's ever going to wear it well, and everything's going to be a compromise for him, and everything's going to be a moral dilemma." The Buckleys are getting a new boss. No offense to Harlan, but he and Cane don't exactly excel at being criminals (see: literally everything that happened this season), while Belle seems made for it. The season ended with her making a deal with Emmett (Harlen's business parter / biggest rival), and Williamson tells Variety that "She's just going to push him aside and do what she needs to do. The one thing that she states very clearly is she has earned the Buckley name, and she's right." He also went ahead and confirmed that the major "conflict" of season 2 will be Harlen vs Belle fighting for control over the family dynasty. Williamson tells IndieWire that "Of course, we have the Parkers who they're now beholden to, and I think there's a whole family there of interesting people. We had one, Topher Grace, this year. I think we're going to have a few more next year." Shawn mentioned that he has a boyfriend, but sadly we didn't get meet him in season 1. Expect that to change in season 2. As Williamson put it to Variety, "It'll be really interesting for that character to show up and what is his response to this Buckley family when he figures out who they are. It's gonna be fun to watch him navigate all the different characters in this new family dynamic." Peyton found out her husband cheated on her and reacted out with him and ominously saying "Everything's fine. You and me. We're fine. I'm gonna see to it." the stage for some weird vibes next season, to say the least. Williamson tells Variety "She had that moment where she could run, she could leave, and she almost does. But I think she has a better plan. She loves this man, and they say you can't change someone. Well, we're gonna watch her do it." Meanwhile, Danielle Campbell (who plays Peyton) tells Us Weekly, "She sets herself up as being aware of the family business and all of its flaws. I would like to see her be a powerhouse and take on a role inside of it where she would be very well-utilized as somebody who no one would initially perceive as being someone who's taking part in it. Just like you really wouldn't initially see Belle being involved. Women are so powerful and they have a completely different way of going about working than men. I think there's something really exciting about watching that on screen." All the major players in the Buckley family ended this season alive and well, so chances are we'll see them return for season two. And clearly there will be some new faces—including members of the Parker family, not to mention Shawn's boyfriend. We'll be updating this with more info as it drops, so stay tuned.

USA Today

an hour ago

• USA Today

Bruce Springsteen is releasing his 'Lost Albums': The songs you haven't heard but need to

There are musicians, and there is Bruce Springsteen. There are songwriters, and there is Bruce Springsteen. There are singers, and yes, you get the point. But there are also box sets, and there is 'Tracks II: The Lost Albums,' seven genre-specific collections that span 1983-2018, a period that witnessed the arrival of 'Born in the U.S.A.,' 'The Ghost of Tom Joad,' 'The Rising,' 'Wrecking Ball' and eight other chameleonic Springsteen releases. The set arrives June 27 in several forms – nine LPs, seven CDs and digital as well as a 20-song highlight version ('Lost and Found: Selections from The Lost Albums') on two LPs and one CD. That an artist crafted 83 songs of divergent styles – garage rock, country, Mexican ranchera and lush pop – as his leftovers illuminates Springsteen's musical brilliances as well as the epic scope of this set. And let's not forget this is the sequel. In 1998, Springsteen unloaded the 66-song 'Tracks' box set. But where that assembly corralled many demos and alternate versions of Springsteen favorites, 'Tracks II' presents completed masterworks that probe Springsteen's hallmark topics of redemption and romance while continuing down the path of enlightenment. Here's a look at the seven additions to the Springsteen catalog. 'LA Garage Sessions '83' Springsteen calls these 18 tracks 'a critical bridge between 'Nebraska' and 'Born in the U.S.A.,'' and of the magnificent seven 'lost' albums, only this collection contains several songs previously heard as B-sides ('Johnny Bye-Bye' as the flip side to 'I'm On Fire,' 'Shut Out the Light' backing 'Born in the U.S.A.') or on anthologies ('County Fair' landed on 2003's 'The Essential Bruce Springsteen'). In the early '80s, the King of New Jersey holed up in a small house in the Hollywood Hills. It was shortly after his timeless 'Nebraska' arrived and he was keen to expand his sound yet unsure if he'd wrangle the E Street Band for a rock album (spoiler: he did, in 1984). The lo-fi recordings include an eventual hit from 'Born in the U.S.A.,' a thinner version of its final track, 'My Hometown.' Springsteen's voice is a combination of Tom Petty lilt and Tom Waits grit on the original form of the ballad, one of many vocal styles he samples on the album. Springsteen is also transparent in his influences, saluting Buddy Holly with the quick bop, 'Little Girl Like You' and nodding to Elvis Presley on 'Follow That Dream.' It's a musically scattered collection, but foreshadows the genre-hopping Springsteen would soon explore. Standout track: 'Don't Back Down on Our Love' – Borrowing a guitar tone from The Beach Boys and filling the song with a charmingly repetitive chorus, this is both a throwback and evidence of Springsteen striding forward. He eagerly tinkers with soul, pop and rock while encouraging strength amid struggles. 'Streets of Philadelphia Sessions' Recorded during the same period as his Oscar and Grammy-winning title track from 1993's Tom Hanks-fronted 'Philadelphia' movie, the album that fans affectionately call Springsteen's 'loops record' is a sonic time capsule. The shuffling electronic beat under 'Between Heaven and Earth' is similar to Soul II Soul's 'Keep On Movin'' and PM Dawn's 'Set Adrift on Memory Bliss,' hits in the late-'80s and early '90s timeframe Springsteen has referenced as his influence for the record. Springsteen completed these 10 songs for a 1995 release. But instead of dropping new music, he shelved the album and reunited with the E Street Band for the first time in seven years. The only previously released song is the enigmatic 'Secret Garden,' which hasn't lost the seductive luster provided by Springsteen's murmured lyrics coated in innuendo. Originally released on his 1995 'Greatest Hits' album, the ballad didn't hopscotch up the charts until two years later, when it was included on the 'Jerry Maguire' soundtrack and peaked at No. 19 on the Billboard Hot 100. It remains Springsteen's last U.S. Top 40 hit to date. Standout track: 'Waiting on the End of the World' – Awash in keyboards and a chugging backbeat, the midtempo song offers a trademark lyric ('We hide from the truth in our hearts'), a singsong guitar solo and a dreamy outro that dissolves like a jet's vapor trail. 'Faithless' Written for a film that has yet to be made, 'Faithless' has smatterings of family influence. Springsteen says he penned the 11 songs during two weeks in Florida when he and his brood were there to watch daughter Jessica, an Olympic equestrian, on a trip related to her vocation. When it came time to record, wife Patti Scialfa (whose voice appears on several tracks) and their sons Evan and Sam offered a choir of background vocals on 'Where You Goin', Where You From?' The musical shading of the album is influenced by the recording window – between the 2005 Devils & Dust tour and the release of 'We Shall Overcome: The Seeger Sessions' in April 2006 – that found Springsteen in an acoustic and spiritual state of mind. Those emotional generators are apparent on the title track, a minimal hymn of salvation wrapped in Springsteen's quivering voice. He's much bolder on 'All God's Children,' his foot stomping and his voice ragged as he morphs into preacher mode through lyrics such as 'I scratched me a grave with my own hands/and you can bury me deep in the blood of the land' and a chorus of 'Glory, hallelujah.' But it's the closing 'My Master's Hand (Theme),'' a purposeful march on which Springsteen handles nearly every instrument, including the shuffling snare drum, organ and harmonica, that sounds primed for the end credits of a film that might still hatch. Standout track: 'God Sent You' – It's easy to glean from the title that the potent ballad will be rooted in the idea of, as Barbra Streisand tells us, people who need people. Organ chords provide a gospel tinge, but piano drives the song as Springsteen dispenses his gratitude for a savior as he sings, 'God sent you to me/a prayer of safety and salvation/God sent you to me/when faith was so hard to see.' 'Somewhere North of Nashville' Springsteen's 1995 album, 'The Ghost of Tom Joad,' spotlighted his folk instincts, sometimes to dreary effect. But Springsteen wasn't spending all of his time ruminating. This barnburner recorded at the same time as 'Joad' confirms that he saved plenty of energy to tear through 12 songs with the band live in the studio. The result is Springsteen unleashed. He's joined by E-Streeters Danny Federici (who died in 2008), Garry Tallent and Soozie Tyrell, as well as drummer Gary Mallaber and pedal steel ace Marty Rifkin as they embark on a jaunty tour of country, honky tonk and rockabilly. Springsteen's voice veers from sandpapery growl ('Repo Man,' 'Detail Man') to silky twang ('Poor Side of Town,' 'Silver Mountain'), while the music audaciously mashes pedal steel guitar, boogie woogie piano, harmonica and string orchestrations as seamlessly as if that collective sound is routine. Standout track: 'Repo Man' – The first song on the album bursts with natural electricity. Springsteen's wink-and-smile delivery of amusing lyrics ('A repo man lives by a code/you don't pay and I own your little piece of the road'), Rifkin's skilled dance on pedal steel guitar and a final, fluttering cymbal crash collide for one hell of a boot-stompin' party. 'Inyo' During the 1990s, Springsteen headed west of his beloved New Jersey and spent time driving his motorcycle throughout the Southwest and California. He took long drives along the California aqueduct through Inyo County and into Death Valley and writes strikingly about the immigrant experience, particularly the generational erosion of shared culture between Mexico and the U.S. The 10 vivid recollections on the album, which Springsteen calls one of his favorites, shudder with sadness. Many of the songs feature only Springsteen with Soozie Tyrell's weeping violin or light instrumentation from coproducer Ron Aniello on bass, guitar and drums. Springsteen also turned to the roots of his album, notably on 'Adelita,' which features mariachi musicians to complement his rich storytelling talent. 'Your portrait I carry deep in my breast pocket/my rifle firing into the campaña/I ride with you 'round my heart/protected from this death by beauty,' he sings. Standout track: 'The Lost Charro' – Springsteen isn't celebrated for having a particularly pretty voice. Rugged character is more his thing. But he locates a rarely heard upper register here as he takes on the persona of a proud former 'charro' (cowboy) who misses his past while picking fruit in fields in his current life. The full chorus of mariachi band members at the end completes this tale of a spiritual dreamer. 'Twilight Hours' Springsteen says he saved these dozen songs recorded during his 'Western Stars' era because they were 'intentionally middle of the road.' It might sound like a slight, but what Springsteen crafted is an album that pulls from '70's California pop and the melodic songwriting of Burt Bacharach and Jimmy Webb. Songs such as 'I'll Stand By You' and 'Dinner at Eight' were born with a softer touch, nudged along by a sumptuous assembly of strings, piano and polished choruses. This is the closest we've heard Springsteen to pure pop music – the kind with complex elements that sound effortless in the hands of a pro – and it's a suit that fits him well. Standout track: 'Two of Us' – A sweet love song spiked with strings, a gently plucked Glockenspiel and glorious key changes. It's Springsteen at his most Bacharach-ian, winding through a swoony melody as he stretches his voice to sing, 'Through one more mile, one more town/there's one heart, I can trust/so we'll keep moving for the two of us.' 'Perfect World' The opening swing of piano and guitar on first track 'I'm Not Sleeping' is a signal that these 10 songs will embody the E Street Band style not heard as palpably on the other albums. It's a mostly fair indicator. 'Idiot's Delight' clip-clops through rowdy harmonica that suits the song's bitter lyrics ('The jackals leave here laughing as they slip into the night/how did something so beautiful turn into an idiot's delight') and a towering chorus and gritty guitar power 'Another Thin Line' into familiar E Street territory (and yes, that is cowbell you hear). There are several stylistic shifts throughout the release that Springsteen says is the only one of the 'lost' seven that wasn't conceived as an album. That is evident in the title track that returns him to piano-backed twang, balanced by the soulful pop singalong, 'You Lifted Me Up.' And hello, Steven Van Zandt on background vocals, whose appearance aptly encapsulates the album's intent. Standout track: 'Rain in the River' – Squealing guitar notes lead the song into one of Springsteen's most muscular vocals. Recorded around the same time as 'Western Stars' (2010-11), the swelling anthem is all Springsteen, with an assist from Ron Aniello on organ and drums, but sounds like the work of 100 men.

Buzz Feed

2 hours ago

• Buzz Feed

Rachel Zegler On Snow White Backlash And Palestine

At this very moment, Rachel Zegler is earning what seems like well-deserved raves for her turn in the title role of the West End production of Andrew Lloyd Webber's classic musical Evita. Suffice to say, it's a nice change of pace after the exhausting discourse around her appearance in Disney's ill-fated live-action remake of Snow White — which reached a fever pitch after Variety published a widely-derided report claiming that the film's troubles stemmed from Rachel's vocal support for the Palestinian people, as well as her opposition to current US President Donald Trump. In a new interview with i-D, Rachel addressed the effects that all the backlash had on her, as well as her commitment to speaking her mind on the matters that mean the most to her. 'My fucking psychiatrist has seen me through all of it,' she said, adding that it was necessary for someone to remind her that, ''What you're going through isn't normal'...That sentence did such wonders for me in multiple situations in my life.' During that time, Rachel was also prescribed medication to treat anxiety, which she describes as a "game-changer." "I just wasn't functioning," she explained, "and I wanted to function in a way that made me feel confident in the way I was moving through the world.' 'I think a victim mindset is a choice, and I don't choose it," she added. "I also don't choose nastiness in the face of it. I don't choose negativity in the face of it. I choose positivity and light and happiness. And I do believe at times, happiness is absolutely a choice, and every day I wake up and I think I'm very lucky to live the life I live.' In the interview, Rachel also addressed her support for the Palestinian people amidst the ongoing genocide taking place in Gaza, gesturing towards Hacks star Hannah Einbinder's recent comments: 'I can really only echo Hannah Einbinder in saying that a platform becomes a responsibility, and that responsibility is ours to use as we please,' she said. 'My compassion has no boundaries, is really what it is,' she added, 'and my support for one cause does not denounce any others. That's always been at the core of who I am as a person. It's the way I was are obviously things that are at stake by being outspoken, but nothing is worth innocent lives. My heart doesn't have a fence around it, and if that is considered my downfall? There are worse things.' Hear, hear. You can read the entire interview with Rachel right here.