Kane Cornes wipes Port Adelaide and Carlton from AFL finals race after ‘line-in-the-sand' Round 8
Kane Cornes has declared the top seven teams in the AFL have already shown enough to be 'certain' of playing finals, while he has wiped Port Adelaide and Carlton out of the race.
An intriguing Round 8 saw Brisbane secure top spot with a win over top-four hopefuls Gold Coast after Collingwood lost a thriller to perennial contenders Geelong.
Hawthorn, Adelaide and the Bulldogs all solidified their places in the top eight with big wins over bottom-10 sides.
Among the top eight, only GWS truly lowered their colours with a loss to a Sydney side that entered their derby on a three-match losing streak.
And now the Giants' place in the top eight is the last up for grabs, according to Cornes.
'They talk about moving day in golf — Round 8 is moving round in the world of AFL football,' he said on Kane's Call.
'I think it's separated the best from the rest. The Giants are maybe the only vulnerable team in the top eight now. I think the rest play finals, I would be certain of that.'
If that proves to be the case, it would be a significant shift from the 2024 race.
Last year only five teams sitting in the top eight after Round 8 went on to reach the finals, after Brisbane, the Bulldogs and Hawthorn surged while Fremantle, Essendon and Melbourne collapsed.
Before that, six teams had held their spots and two had dropped out in each season since 2016 — when the top eight did not change after Round 6.
In 2011, seven teams in the top eight after Round 9 (when 13 of the 17 teams had played eight games) made the finals, though Essendon briefly dropped out during a losing streak before salvaging eighth place.
But not since 2010 has the race for the finals proved to be for just one spot this early in the season.
That year, seven of the top eight were set after Round 7 and the top eight did not change after Round 11.
While GWS could yet make it a 2016-style top-eight lockout, seven of the current bottom-10 teams will still hold out hope of making the 2025 finals.
Fremantle and St Kilda sit eighth and ninth after playing off against each other on Friday night, with the Saints coming up trumps.
Essendon sit 11th after winning four out of their past five but all came against fellow bottom-10 opposition.
The Bombers do, however, hold a positive win-loss record and still have a game in hand after their Opening Round clash with Gold Coast was postponed.
Below them, Port Adelaide and Carlton suffered heavy defeats in Round 8 despite entering on three-match winning streaks that included wins over Hawthorn and Geelong respectively.
The Blues' cause is helped by a 108.6 percentage, more than 10 points better than any other bottom-10 side and only 6.4 shy of the Giants.
Sydney and Melbourne, now on their own three-match winning streak, are the last sides in the mix.
'There's probably one spot up for grabs for the likes of Fremantle or the Saints if they make a charge, Sydney if they can do the same,' Cornes said.
'Not sure about Melbourne, I don't think Carlton are good enough. But this round's separated the best from the rest.
'Fremantle weren't good enough. Port Adelaide not good enough so we've seen that and that's been on full display. Adelaide too good, Carlton not good enough.
'I think we're going to look back at this round as a pivotal line-in-the-sand moment and say 'gee, this round separated the best from the rest'.
'Long way out, I get it, but you can see the quality rising.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Advertiser
7 hours ago
- The Advertiser
'A mile off September' - Bulldogs face Swans test next
Before they try to break their duck against teams above them on the AFL ladder, the Western Bulldogs are wary of the threat from below. Sunday's 79-point belting of Richmond, coupled with the huge win over St Kilda the week before, were two quick kills for the Bulldogs ahead of what looms as Friday night's more searching test against the resurgent Sydney at the SCG. While the 21.9 (135) to 8.8 (56) defeat of the Tigers at Marvel Stadium was the Bulldogs' largest score of the season and returned them to the top eight, they are yet to claim a major scalp. And coach Luke Beveridge is well aware the Swans, two games below them, are coming after Saturday's important away win over Port Adelaide. When asked a speculative question post-game about the finals, Beveridge retorted: "We are a mile off September ... you're not going to catch me out talking about September." "Will we be a team that is capable of beating anyone at the end of the year? Well I think so - we think that every week," Beveridge said. "Ultimately to get anywhere and achieve anything as the season rolls on, we're going to need to beat these teams above us. "In the past, Sydney have come at us really hard. As much as they're below us on the ladder, you can sense that they're coming. "They have a little bit of momentum, so we won't think they're below us on the ladder by any means." Tempering Sunday's win was another calf problem for All-Australian midfielder Adam Treloar, who was subbed out before half time. He has only managed four senior games this season because of injury. "For us to sub him out that early in the game, there's a degree of significant concern," Beveridge said. "I picked that up pretty quickly. No one's allowed to hobble, it doesn't matter who they are." As his contract talks ramp up, captain Marcus Bontempelli was best afield with 36 possessions - his highest tally this season - and three goals, while key forward Sam Darcy also starred with five majors. The Bulldogs tore Richmond apart with seven goals to none in the second term and while Beveridge was less than impressed with the Tigers' second-half rally, he described the win as "satisfying". He is optimistic James O'Donnell (groin) and Lachie McNeil (neck) will play against Sydney after being injured late on Sunday. Beveridge was particularly pleased with his side's scoring potency, noting attack has been their problem in a season in which their largest losing margin has only been 22 points. "We're not worried about courage and contest and the defensive side, it is offence that we continue to need to tidy up against the better sides," he said. Richmond coach Adem Yze lamented his team's poor second term. "You could sense that it had ripped the heart out of our team. The response was OK in the second half, but the second quarter flattened us pretty bad. "We have to dig in and understand why we lost spirit so easily in that second quarter. I'd be more worried if we turned our toes up and didn't try in the last half." The Tigers are second-bottom and are on a five-game losing streak. Yze said the only solution was to get back to work this week ahead of next Sunday's MCG match against Adelaide. "All we look to is Adelaide and that's all we can do," he said. Tigers defender Nick Vlastuin continued his impressive form, despite a couple of heavy knocks, while Tom Lynch kicked three goals. Before they try to break their duck against teams above them on the AFL ladder, the Western Bulldogs are wary of the threat from below. Sunday's 79-point belting of Richmond, coupled with the huge win over St Kilda the week before, were two quick kills for the Bulldogs ahead of what looms as Friday night's more searching test against the resurgent Sydney at the SCG. While the 21.9 (135) to 8.8 (56) defeat of the Tigers at Marvel Stadium was the Bulldogs' largest score of the season and returned them to the top eight, they are yet to claim a major scalp. And coach Luke Beveridge is well aware the Swans, two games below them, are coming after Saturday's important away win over Port Adelaide. When asked a speculative question post-game about the finals, Beveridge retorted: "We are a mile off September ... you're not going to catch me out talking about September." "Will we be a team that is capable of beating anyone at the end of the year? Well I think so - we think that every week," Beveridge said. "Ultimately to get anywhere and achieve anything as the season rolls on, we're going to need to beat these teams above us. "In the past, Sydney have come at us really hard. As much as they're below us on the ladder, you can sense that they're coming. "They have a little bit of momentum, so we won't think they're below us on the ladder by any means." Tempering Sunday's win was another calf problem for All-Australian midfielder Adam Treloar, who was subbed out before half time. He has only managed four senior games this season because of injury. "For us to sub him out that early in the game, there's a degree of significant concern," Beveridge said. "I picked that up pretty quickly. No one's allowed to hobble, it doesn't matter who they are." As his contract talks ramp up, captain Marcus Bontempelli was best afield with 36 possessions - his highest tally this season - and three goals, while key forward Sam Darcy also starred with five majors. The Bulldogs tore Richmond apart with seven goals to none in the second term and while Beveridge was less than impressed with the Tigers' second-half rally, he described the win as "satisfying". He is optimistic James O'Donnell (groin) and Lachie McNeil (neck) will play against Sydney after being injured late on Sunday. Beveridge was particularly pleased with his side's scoring potency, noting attack has been their problem in a season in which their largest losing margin has only been 22 points. "We're not worried about courage and contest and the defensive side, it is offence that we continue to need to tidy up against the better sides," he said. Richmond coach Adem Yze lamented his team's poor second term. "You could sense that it had ripped the heart out of our team. The response was OK in the second half, but the second quarter flattened us pretty bad. "We have to dig in and understand why we lost spirit so easily in that second quarter. I'd be more worried if we turned our toes up and didn't try in the last half." The Tigers are second-bottom and are on a five-game losing streak. Yze said the only solution was to get back to work this week ahead of next Sunday's MCG match against Adelaide. "All we look to is Adelaide and that's all we can do," he said. Tigers defender Nick Vlastuin continued his impressive form, despite a couple of heavy knocks, while Tom Lynch kicked three goals. Before they try to break their duck against teams above them on the AFL ladder, the Western Bulldogs are wary of the threat from below. Sunday's 79-point belting of Richmond, coupled with the huge win over St Kilda the week before, were two quick kills for the Bulldogs ahead of what looms as Friday night's more searching test against the resurgent Sydney at the SCG. While the 21.9 (135) to 8.8 (56) defeat of the Tigers at Marvel Stadium was the Bulldogs' largest score of the season and returned them to the top eight, they are yet to claim a major scalp. And coach Luke Beveridge is well aware the Swans, two games below them, are coming after Saturday's important away win over Port Adelaide. When asked a speculative question post-game about the finals, Beveridge retorted: "We are a mile off September ... you're not going to catch me out talking about September." "Will we be a team that is capable of beating anyone at the end of the year? Well I think so - we think that every week," Beveridge said. "Ultimately to get anywhere and achieve anything as the season rolls on, we're going to need to beat these teams above us. "In the past, Sydney have come at us really hard. As much as they're below us on the ladder, you can sense that they're coming. "They have a little bit of momentum, so we won't think they're below us on the ladder by any means." Tempering Sunday's win was another calf problem for All-Australian midfielder Adam Treloar, who was subbed out before half time. He has only managed four senior games this season because of injury. "For us to sub him out that early in the game, there's a degree of significant concern," Beveridge said. "I picked that up pretty quickly. No one's allowed to hobble, it doesn't matter who they are." As his contract talks ramp up, captain Marcus Bontempelli was best afield with 36 possessions - his highest tally this season - and three goals, while key forward Sam Darcy also starred with five majors. The Bulldogs tore Richmond apart with seven goals to none in the second term and while Beveridge was less than impressed with the Tigers' second-half rally, he described the win as "satisfying". He is optimistic James O'Donnell (groin) and Lachie McNeil (neck) will play against Sydney after being injured late on Sunday. Beveridge was particularly pleased with his side's scoring potency, noting attack has been their problem in a season in which their largest losing margin has only been 22 points. "We're not worried about courage and contest and the defensive side, it is offence that we continue to need to tidy up against the better sides," he said. Richmond coach Adem Yze lamented his team's poor second term. "You could sense that it had ripped the heart out of our team. The response was OK in the second half, but the second quarter flattened us pretty bad. "We have to dig in and understand why we lost spirit so easily in that second quarter. I'd be more worried if we turned our toes up and didn't try in the last half." The Tigers are second-bottom and are on a five-game losing streak. Yze said the only solution was to get back to work this week ahead of next Sunday's MCG match against Adelaide. "All we look to is Adelaide and that's all we can do," he said. Tigers defender Nick Vlastuin continued his impressive form, despite a couple of heavy knocks, while Tom Lynch kicked three goals.
News.com.au
8 hours ago
- News.com.au
‘Outrageous': State of Origin move sparks furore as Ashley Klein set to be named for series decider
Ashley Klein is set to be handed the officiating reins for the State of Origin decider despite his controversial performance in Perth which left New South Wales fans and players outraged. The Blues were on the wrong end of an 8-0 first half penalty count in Game 2, which turned into 9-0 after 45 minutes. By that stage, Queensland were up 26-6. FOX LEAGUE, available on Kayo Sports, is the only place to watch every game of every round in the 2025 NRL Telstra Premiership, LIVE with no ad-breaks during play. New to Kayo? Get your first month for just $1. Limited-time offer. In the end, Queensland won 26-24, but the NSW camp felt they were officiated out of the game and scheduled a meeting with NRL management to seek an explanation for several of Klein's controversial calls. The Blues' main gripe was why Klein chose to ignore numerous clear indiscretions by Maroons players while penalising the Blues for similar offences. However, despite the Blues' protests, Code Sports reports Klein will again be in charge of the series decider. That is because the NRL referees are rated under a KPI system by the league and by the numbers Klein is at the top of the list. Categories measured include play-the-ball speed, decision-making, communication, game understanding, accuracy, communication with other officials, consistency, identifying infringements, positioning, game management, ruck communication, positioning, fitness and endurance. His appointment in Sydney will be under heavy scrutiny and will undoubtedly be met with fierce backlash. Speaking about his Game 2 performance earlier this week Buzz Rothfield tore into the veteran ref, saying his calls cost the Blues the game and series win in Perth. 'I think NSW were ill-disciplined and I don't have too many problems with the nine penalties they conceded. The problem I do have is that anyone can look at a replay of that first half and find 4-5 areas of the game where Queensland could quite easily have been penalised as well,' Rothfield said. 'In my eyes, he was refereeing one side for the majority of the first half. 'I know we were ill-disciplined and I'm not blaming it for the loss … but Gordie you cannot be perfect in Origin for 45 minutes. Impossible.' 'It's outrageous that Queensland can play 45 minutes in State of Origin and that intensity, mistakes are made, high speed, high intensity and not one penalty. That cannot happen.' He also went on to say NSW Blues coach Laurie Daley – who refused to answer any question on the officiating after the Game 2 defeat – was privately furious at Klein. 'Laurie will look at the video and find out what he wants to talk to the NRL about and then take it to adjudication,' Rothfield continued. 'He was furious after the game. Privately furious, but he knows he can't come out and say anything. Not just for the fine, but because it'll look like poor sportsmanship.' And as news of Klein's Game 3 appointment spread NSW fans were unsurprisingly annoyed. 'You've got to be kidding,' one fan wrote. 'What an absolute joke!' another added. While a third commented: 'Surely he's not the best ref we have.' NSW will have a home-ground advantage for the series decider, which will take place at Sydney's Accor Stadium on Wednesday, July 9.
News.com.au
8 hours ago
- News.com.au
Is a Florent-McKay trade win-win?
AFL: Jay Clark has raised the idea to the First Crack panel of a potential Ollie Florent-Harry McKay swap between Sydney and Carlton and whether it the perfect win-win for both clubs.
