Canadian men, children held in Syria make human rights complaints against Ottawa
A dozen Canadian men and children detained in Syria are complaining to the Canadian Human Rights Commission that Ottawa is discriminating against them by not assisting their return to Canada.
The Canadians are among the foreign nationals who have endured squalid and dangerous conditions for years in camps and prisons run by Kurdish forces that reclaimed the war-ravaged region from militant group Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant.
Some Canadian women and children have been repatriated in recent years with help from Canadian officials and the co-operation of Kurdish authorities.
There are 12 complainants in the human rights commission case — five Canadian men and seven children aged five to 12.
Lawyer Nicholas Pope, who launched the complaints, said federal policy guiding the repatriation of Canadians from the region discriminates based on age, sex and family status.
Pope said the policy gives less favourable treatment to Canadian children whose mothers were not born in Canada.
Canada has insisted that the remaining detained Canadian children, who were born to three non-Canadian mothers, be forcibly separated from their mothers and become orphans in Canada in order to receive repatriation services, he said.
In addition, Ottawa has declined to help repatriate Canadian men.
"Every Canadian has the right to be treated equally," Pope said in a statement. "This is a rare situation in which the detaining authority holding Canadians abroad is actually pleading with us to end the detention, but it is Ottawa that is selectively refusing to let some Canadians return home."
Among the men complaining to the human rights commission is Jack Letts, who became a devoted Muslim as a teenager, went on holiday to Jordan, then studied in Kuwait before winding up in Syria.
The Federal Court of Appeal ruled two years ago that Ottawa was not obligated under the law to repatriate Letts and three other Canadian men. The Supreme Court of Canada then declined to hear an appeal of the ruling.
In accordance with the Canadian Human Rights Act, the human rights commission receives and screens complaints from people who believe they have experienced discrimination or harassment.
The commission helps resolve disputes through mediation or conciliation, and sometimes refers complaints to the Canadian Human Rights Tribunal, an independent body that can decide whether there is discrimination.
Pope said the commission "has put the files on a fast-track" and is requiring the government to participate in conciliation, which is in the process of being scheduled.
The human rights commission did not respond to a request for comment.
Global Affairs Canada spokeswoman Charlotte MacLeod said that due to confidentiality the department is unable to comment on cases before the human rights commission.
The complaint filed last August on behalf of Letts says he suffers from anemia and experiences considerable pain from a potentially life-threatening kidney disorder, but he cannot access adequate medical treatment.
"The Complainant is held in prison in a small cell that is overcrowded and unsanitary," the form reads. "He lacks adequate food and medical attention. He has never been given any legal process to challenge his detention."
It notes that Canada has repatriated women and children from northeastern Syria under federal policy, but not any men, even though their conditions are more dire than those of the repatriated women and children.
"The blanket ban on repatriating adult males perpetuates the stereotype that men are more dangerous than women and children," the complaint says.
In a response filed with the commission concerning Letts's case, the federal government says the commission should refuse to deal with the complaint because "the assessment of the complainant's situation is ongoing and a decision whether to provide extraordinary assistance has not yet been made."
The government also denies the allegation that Letts was not given repatriation assistance because of his sex or age.
A statement of reply to the commission on behalf of Letts says the government has twice made determinations to refuse him repatriation services.
In a response to the commission concerning the complaints involving children, the government denies the federal policy is discriminatory towards them on the basis of family status.
MacLeod said Global Affairs continues to evaluate the provision of extraordinary assistance, including repatriation to Canada, on a case-by-case basis.
"Canadian consular officials remain actively engaged with authorities and international organizations operating in Syria for information on and assistance to Canadian citizens in custody," she said.
This report by The Canadian Press was first published June 5, 2025.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Winnipeg Free Press
31 minutes ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
First Nations youth say they're ‘starting a movement' against major projects bills
OTTAWA – First Nations youth leaders are warning Canadians can expect a long, tense summer of protests as governments push forward with plans to fast-track major projects — and young people will be leading the charge. 'You will see us in your cities, your city's hubs,' said Ramon Kataquapit, a youth councillor with the Chiefs of Ontario and Nishnawbe Aski Nation and a member of Attawapiskat First Nation in northern Ontario. The federal Liberal government's Bill C-5, which passed through the House of Commons Friday night, allows cabinet to quickly grant federal approvals for big industrial projects like mines, ports and pipelines. It sailed through a Commons committee in the early hours of Thursday with support from the Conservatives. And in Ontario, Premier Doug Ford's Conservatives have passed legislation allowing his government to designate 'special economic zones' where the provincial cabinet can exempt companies or projects from having to comply with any provincial law, provincial regulation or municipal bylaw. Both pieces of legislation have met with fierce resistance from First Nations leaders who accuse Ottawa and Queen's Park of trampling on their rights and failing to consult with them in good faith. Kataquapit said First Nations youth are 'starting a movement' to protect their cultures and lands from what they see as increasing encroachment by governments looking to build major projects in a hurry. He compared both pieces of legislation to a rock falling off a mountain. 'You don't know how much momentum it's going to build,' he said. 'It might cause a mudslide and turn into something like an avalanche. 'This can turn into something much bigger, and a lot of our people — a lot of the youth — we see that.' While chiefs have been the most prominent First Nations voices in news coverage of the legislation, Kataquapit said young people were the driving force behind recent rallies against the fast-track bills in northern Ontario, at Queen's Park and on Parliament Hill. He said they draw inspiration from the Anishinaabe Seven Fires Prophecy, which speaks of a 'seventh fire' generation that will bring back traditional knowledge and ways of living after a period of cultural dislocation. 'We were raised to be the seventh generation,' Kataquapit said. 'What I've been taught was that it's my role to wake people up and to really show just how much colonization has affected us, but (also) how much strength we have in our traditional identity, culture … 'The seven fires are ready to take the steps that our leadership are falling back on because they fought a good fight for their entire lives. It's just nature that you grow tired, scarred, traumatized.' Terra Roy, another youth councillor with Chiefs of Ontario, said First Nations youth can do more than just protest — they can engage with the land and with traditional knowledge as an act of resistance. 'We have young people in Attawapiskat taking the rivers,' Roy said. 'I'm happy that we're returning to the land and continuing to occupy it.' Roy, who works as a liaison between Beausoleil First Nation and the private sector, spoke to The Canadian Press while attending a project management training session in Edmonton. Roy said the federal and provincial legislation makes their own work seem almost futile. 'I was like, 'Well, what the heck did I just get hired for then if (governments are) just going to bulldoze over everything I say?'' Roy said. 'I'm here trying to create a whole department for my community so that we can have a greater say in our treaty area and then (governments) are like, 'Oh, just kidding.' 'I'm angry. I'm frustrated, heartbroken, annoyed.' Much of that frustration comes from a sense of déjà vu. First Nations say they've been in this position before, when legislation introduced by the Stephen Harper government to allow governments and businesses to push through projects without strict environmental assessment triggered the countrywide protest movement known as Idle No More. Roy vividly remembers sitting with their mother as a child as they took part in an Idle No More protest at a mall. 'It's frustrating that at 11 years old I was doing that, and now again at 23,' Roy said. 'If I'm tired of having to fight this again, I can only imagine how my grandmother feels.' Hanna Sewell, a nurse and a member of Batchewana First Nation near Sault Ste. Marie, Ont., said young people have to lead this fight because they're the ones who will have to live with the impacts of accelerated development. 'If the land is sick, we're going to be sick as well,' she said. 'We don't want this bill, and we are the future generations that are going to govern this land and save it.' Pierre Debassige, a member of M'Chigeeng First Nation and youth councillor for Anishinabek Nation, said First Nations won't be the only ones to experience those impacts. 'If they start development in the Ring of Fire in the Far North, all those lakes, rivers all come down to the Great Lakes,' he said. Weekly A weekly look at what's happening in Winnipeg's arts and entertainment scene. 'If there's that contamination that comes down from the North, it's going to affect not only their communities, but here in southern Ontario.' Debassige said it's his generation's turn to step up. 'United we stand and we conquer, but divided we fall one by one,' he said. 'I'm always thinking of that seven generations behind me (and) what my great-great-great-great grandchildren are going to be doing. Maybe they'll see the work that I've done as a young person, (that I) fought for all of this.' This report by The Canadian Press was first published June 21, 2025.
Toronto Star
an hour ago
- Toronto Star
Canada-Europe security and defence pact to be signed Monday in Brussels
KANANASKIS, ALBERTA - JUNE 16: (L-R) Heiko von der Leyen, Diana Fox Carney, European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen and Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney pose for a photo at the official welcome ceremony during the G7 Leaders' Summit on June 16, 2025 in Kananaskis, Alberta. Canada is hosting this year's meeting of the world's seven largest economies. (Photo by) Chip Somodevilla Getty Images flag wire: true flag sponsored: false article_type: : sWebsitePrimaryPublication : publications/toronto_star bHasMigratedAvatar : false :
Winnipeg Free Press
4 hours ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Winnipeg conference explores need for fostering hope
How can we tackle the challenges facing the world today and work towards a more positive future? How do we find hope to promote and sustain collective action? What role can diverse faith traditions play in helping Canada face the most pressing demands of our time? Those were topics addressed at the June 15-17 Our Whole Society Conference at the Canadian Museum for Human Rights here in Winnipeg. The theme of the conference, which was sponsored by the Canadian Interfaith Conversation, was Fostering Hope in a Divided World. For Héctor A. Acero Ferrer, one of the conference organizers, the event was an opportunity 'to build robust dialogue between religious traditions about their role in society' and a way to 'build connections across divides in the world.' Rocky Baronins is the community relations committee chair for the Manitoba Multifaith Council and one of the supporters of the conference. For him, the conference was a way to bring thought leaders from across Canada together for 'deep conversations about the challenges facing the world today.' One of those thought leaders was Payam Akhavan, a Canadian human rights lawyer. Speaking at the opening plenary, Akhavan said the world is facing an onslaught of rage that is imperiling a 'vision for a shared humanity.' Despite this, Akhavan said he sees hope as people work together to defuse anger and resist efforts to dehumanize others. These 'actions on the ground,' where people actively reach out to others, can counter fear about the future — despite how challenging the situation seems to be. 'We discover resilience when we confront despair,' he said, noting people must resist messages that dehumanize others like refugees and immigrants, or those who have different political opinions. This dehumanization 'needs to be confronted more than ever,' Akhavan said. A member of the Baha'i faith, Akhavan added that spirituality is an important part of that confrontation — through service. 'We must show compassion and concern for others,' he said, adding that by serving others we can 'save our own souls.' Lloyd Axworthy, long-time federal politician and the Minister of Foreign Affairs from 1996-2000, spoke the following day about finding hope in a fractious world. For him, hope is a 'moral summons, an imperative' that grows out of core beliefs such as his Christian faith as a member of the United Church of Canada. One of those core beliefs for Axworthy is the requirement to serve others and seek the best for them — something that helped guide him when making difficult decisions on the international stage. When it comes to bringing faith into politics, Axworthy said he was not 'naïve' about how challenging that can be. But, he said, 'we need courageous people' who are willing to go into politics and 'make choices based on their faith or spirituality.' Despite the challenges facing the world today, 'we still have to commit to building a better future,' he stated, adding it is an unsettling time for many since the old world order is disappearing, partly due to the actions of Donald Trump, 'while the new one is not yet born.' It won't be easy to see this new order be born, Axworthy said, but he believes it can be done as people 'exercise their faith and hope in a risky way.' The final keynote speaker was Elin Kelsey, author of the book Hope Matters: Why Changing the Way We Think Is Critical to Solving the Environmental Crisis. She spoke about finding hope despite the current environmental crisis. Citing a survey that showed nearly half of people 16 to 25 reported feeling distressed or anxious about climate change in a way that was affecting their daily lives and functioning, Kelsey placed fault at the feet of the media for mainly reporting on the detrimental effects of climate change while ignoring the many ways people around the world are addressing it and finding solutions. 'Less than three per cent of media stories about climate change even include a mention of a solution,' she said, adding this kind of reporting can lead to anxiety, cynicism and apathy. For her, the climate crisis is as much a 'crisis of hope' as it is about the actual challenges posed by a changing climate for the planet. And, she added, when people feel hopeless they then feel disempowered. But, Kelsey said, when people are offered stories about positive ways climate change is being addressed, they feel hopeful about the possibility of change. This doesn't mean ignoring what she called 'pain stories' about the negative impact of climate change. 'We can tell those stories, but we don't need to stop there,' Kelsey said. 'We should also look for stories about where things are moving in a positive direction.' At the same time, Kelsey didn't minimize the nature of the climate crisis. But she chooses to be hopeful. 'It's a choice,' she said, that can translate into action. 'Hope is not complacent. It is a powerful political act.' faith@ The Free Press is committed to covering faith in Manitoba. If you appreciate that coverage, help us do more! Your contribution of $10, $25 or more will allow us to deepen our reporting about faith in the province. Thanks! BECOME A FAITH JOURNALISM SUPPORTER John LonghurstFaith reporter John Longhurst has been writing for Winnipeg's faith pages since 2003. He also writes for Religion News Service in the U.S., and blogs about the media, marketing and communications at Making the News. Read full biography Our newsroom depends on a growing audience of readers to power our journalism. If you are not a paid reader, please consider becoming a subscriber. Our newsroom depends on its audience of readers to power our journalism. Thank you for your support.
