Analysts back Trump's USAID cuts in Africa, say increased trade will better benefit continent's poor

JOHANNESBURG: The key to Africa's future is in increasing trade with the U.S., not in receiving aid from it, a message key analysts told Fox News Digital in the wake of President Donald Trump's foreign aid freeze.
"U.S. trade dollars exchanged with Africa massively exceed aid dollars granted," South African-based Frans Cronje, an advisor for the Yorktown Foundation for Freedom, told Fox News Digital.
Some $11 billion of USAid funds were reportedly spent in Africa in 2024, but trade between the U.S. and Africa during the same period was seven times higher - $71.6 billion, according to the Office of the U.S. Trade Representative.
'Wasteful And Dangerous': Doge's Top Five Most Shocking Revelations
Cronje said "the idea of helping people with aid may be admirable, but in practice achieves little in Africa by way of addressing the structural factors that underpin poverty. Trade, on the other hand, is a more viable route by which the U.S. can build strong relationships with Africa, and is also in line with President Donald Trump's style of diplomacy through transactions."
Cronje elaborated, saying, "Aid acts as a subsidy to bad governments, and thereby keeps them in power despite an absence of reform - whereas trade requires reforms and improving governance to be sustainable."
Read On The Fox News App
Following the Trump administration's policy change, Ledama Olekina, senator for Kenya's Narok County, added, "We don't need aid in Kenya; we can do it on our own!" Posting on X on Jan. 28, Olekina wrote, "Relying on aid from the West limits our opportunities to be industrious and creative. From now on, we must learn to live within our means, eliminate corruption, and instill a spirit of patriotism in our citizens. Together, let's build a brighter future for our country. Thank you @realDonaldTrump and @USAID it's time!"
Anna Mahjar-Barducci, a senior research fellow at the Middle East Media Research Institute, told Fox News Digital that aid "does not help the needy, as foreign aid keeps the needy always being needy … international aid doesn't go directly to the starving population, but to governments. The direct consequence is the growth of the role of the State in the economy of the recipient country, which does not offer incentives to (the) private sector's development."
She added, "Foreign aid has been financing central governments, which (has) ended up promoting statism, and discouraging the creation of an entrepreneurial culture. As a result, government bureaucrats became richer, and regular citizens got poorer. As British economist Peter Bauer put it: "Aid is a process by which the poor in the rich countries subsidize the rich in poor countries."
Trump Freezes Aid To South Africa, Promotes Resettlement Of Refugees Facing Race Discrimination
Aid has other negative effects, according to Mahjar-Barducci, who added, "aid is providing governments, many of which are dictatorships, in Africa with freely usable cash, which not only discourages the creation of an entrepreneurial culture, but it also discourages steps toward peace in war-torn areas.
"While many Westerners (mainly belonging to the radical left) criticized President Donald Trump's decision to pause U.S. foreign aid, many African intellectuals welcomed the new administration's policy."
She pointed to a recent column by Nigerian expert Mfonobong Inyang, titled, "Wake Up Africa, Foreign Aid Is Not A Development Strategy." She said "in his article, he stated that foreign aid is meant to be a temporary relief and intervention, not an official policy of any country that seeks to assert its sovereignty."
Mahjar-Barducci said, "Many African economists are saying that the suspension of USAID funding, offers an opportunity to redefine the African countries' development strategy, and establish an 'Africa-first approach,' based on direct investments, innovation, partnerships, (and) empowering local governance."
On Sunday, The Associated Press reported that some 1,600 posts at USAID would be eliminated after reviewing notices that were sent to USAID workers.
Enter the dragon. China is whipping its Belt and Road Initiative into a virtual frenzy in Africa. Beijing has invested over $700 billion in infrastructure development on the continent in the decade up to 2023, according to China's commerce industry.
Cronje said that when it comes to Africa, China already believes in pushing trade, rather than aid, "in terms of both foreign investment flows and trade flows, China is a significantly more important economic partner for Africa than is the U.S. Since around 2010, Chinese trade with Africa escalated sharply in dollar terms whilst trade levels between the U.S. and Africa remained relatively flat."
Mahdar-Barducci borrowed Ghanian economist George Ayittey's phrase "Chopsticks Mercantilism" to describe China's policy in Africa, commenting on "China's dexterity in striking deals with African leaders that were stacked in its own favor. Chinese multinational companies are investing in the African continent, in exchange for access to natural resources."
Cronje stated that for the U.S., instead of aid, "trade is likely to be a more effective route to securing sound economic and diplomatic relations with Africa, as it helps to build sustainable African economies without being a direct cost to American taxpayers."
Additionally, on China, Cronje concluded, "In many respects, the U.S. is having to play catch-up in Africa. For American policy makers, the trade and investment deficit relative to China should be a more important concern than the question of future aid flows."Original article source: Analysts back Trump's USAID cuts in Africa, say increased trade will better benefit continent's poor

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Business Wire

23 minutes ago

• Business Wire

Naspers Accelerates Growth and Profitability, With 18X Improvement in Ecommerce Adjusted EBIT

CAPE TOWN, South Africa--(BUSINESS WIRE)--Naspers Limited (Naspers) (JSE: NPN) delivered a strong performance during a transformative year, as we build the leading lifestyle ecommerce company in Latin America, Europe and India, driven by AI and innovation. Ecommerce revenue growth of 21%, to US$7.0bn. Adjusted EBIT increased 18 times to US$430m. iFood aEBIT grew 178%, OLX aEBIT up 61% and eMAG achieved profitability. Free cash flow improved by US$263m, excluding Tencent. US$7.8bn 1 invested to strengthen our regional ecosystems and expand our portfolio of AI-native startups. Buybacks returned over US$50bn 2, driving 15% NAV per share accretion. Fabricio Bloisi, Group CEO, Prosus and Naspers said: 'Naspers is rapidly transforming into an operating technology company, focused on lifestyle ecommerce, and powered by innovation and collaboration. This past year, we announced two significant deals to strengthen our regional ecosystems. We completed the acquisition of Despegar in May 2025 and are already integrating its products into iFood's Clube membership. We are making good progress with the purchase of Just Eat which will create a new AI-powered tech champion in Europe. 'I believe that truly great companies are shaped by their culture. Through 'The Prosus Way', we've implemented a cultural model that empowers our teams to deliver exceptional customer experiences through discipline, innovation and adopting an AI-first mindset. In the face of unprecedented technological disruption, we are now more connected and innovative than ever before. I'm confident that our enhanced culture and ecosystem approach will fuel our journey to create the next US$100bn in value.' Nico Marais, Group CFO, Prosus and Naspers, commented: 'The Group has delivered a strong financial performance over the past year, with topline growth in our operating businesses at double the rate of our peers. Ecommerce profitability has improved meaningfully from US$24m in FY24, to aEBIT of US$430m. We expect this momentum to continue, and to add at least the same level of incremental aEBIT in FY26. Free cash flow excluding the Tencent dividend improved by US$263m. As our financial position strengthens, we're able to share more with our shareholders, and have proposed a 100% increase in the Prosus dividend, to €0.20. The Group's disciplined capital allocation and strong balance sheet positions us well to execute on our ecosystem strategy.' Phuthi Mahanyele-Dabengwa, South Africa CEO and Executive Director, Naspers, commented: 'Our South African businesses have delivered strong results while making everyday life simpler, more connected, and more accessible. I'm proud of the progress we've made in building digital platforms that meet local needs, support small businesses, and create new digital career pathways. This is evident in the continued growth of the Takealot Group, which has grown GMV 26-fold over the past nine years to become South Africa's leading ecommerce platform. It's also evident in our two leading classifieds platforms — Property24 and AutoTrader — which continue to serve millions of users with trusted, market-leading services. As South Africa continues its journey of economic renewal, Naspers remains a committed long-term partner in building a more inclusive, innovative digital economy.' Peer-leading growth and accelerating profitability across Ecommerce portfolio Food Delivery: iFood delivers world-class performance, exceeding growth and profitability targets and drives innovation and ecosystem expansion iFood delivered strong top line growth, with Gross Merchandise Value (GMV) up 32%, orders up 29% and revenue increasing 30%. iFood's core food delivery business grew aEBIT by 71% to US$306m, improving aEBIT margin to 27%; performance driven by higher ad revenues, increased order frequency and retention driven by iFood's Clube loyalty programme, and investments in its merchant platform. iFood's growth initiatives grew revenue by 34%, driven by strong performance in its groceries marketplace and credit businesses. Overall, iFood achieved a record profit, with aEBIT of US$226m, up 178%. Delivery Hero grew GMV by 8% for FY24, with revenue up 24%, boosting profitability to an adjusted EBITDA of €693m (from €254m in FY23). From January to December 2024, Swiggy grew Gross Order Value (GOV) by 29%, while adjusted EBITDA losses reduced to US$182m, from US$261m in the prior year. In Q125, Swiggy delivered GOV growth of 40% year-on-year, and quick commerce GOV growth of 101% year-on-year, with 316 new dark stores added in the quarter. 3 All growth percentages shown here are in local currency terms, excluding the impact of acquisitions and disposals (M&A), unless otherwise stated. 4 Nominal basis Expand Classifieds – OLX Group: Strong performance, with a significant jump in profitability and expanding margins OLX consolidated revenue grew 18%, with standout performances by motors and real estate verticals. Motors and real estate grew revenue 24% and 23% respectively, through improved monetisation, innovative product development and new trust-building initiatives within motors, and product enhancements within real estate. aEBIT accelerated by 61% to US$270m, with aEBIT margin up 10pp, to 35%. Payments & Fintech – PayU: Strong topline growth and improving profitability, despite challenging market conditions India payments TPV 5 increased by 17%, and revenues by 14%; aEBIT loss of US$12m reflects increased competition, resulting in lower take rates. India payments achieved breakeven in H2. India credit grew its loan book by 19% and revenues by 63%; aEBIT loss of US$32m impacted by higher costs and increased consumer loan book losses. Iyzico grew revenues 87% to US$288m, while aEBIT of US$18m at a margin of 6% reflected rising interest rates and investments in strategic growth initiatives. GPO revenues up 23% to US$340m, with aEBIT of US$12m; sale of GPO's LatAm and Africa operations completed in March 2025, while GPO Europe sale is ongoing. Overall, PayU's aEBIT losses improved by >100% to US$11m. Etail: eMAG achieved overall profitability target for FY25 and Takealot grew strongly, cementing its leadership position through innovation and customer focus. eMAG grew strongly with GMV up 9%, and revenue up 12% to US$2.5bn. eMAG aEBIT improved by US$40m to US$14m; includes one-off costs in Hungary in H1. eMAG improved performance due to good growth in Romanian etail, and emerging logistics and grocery businesses. Takealot Group grew GMV by 13% and revenue by 15%, driven by investments in logistics, enhanced customer offerings and the TakealotMore subscription service. orders increased 15%, GMV up 13% and revenues grew 17%, with growth underpinned by expansion in emerging product categories. Mr D: Revenue grew 8%, with an 81% increase in groceries GMV and an improved aEBIT of US$4m, despite tough trading conditions. Please note: Group results are shown on a consolidated basis from continuing operations, which reflect all majority owned and managed businesses. All OLX Autos business units are classified as discontinued operations, in line with IFRS disclosures. All growth percentages shown here are in local currency terms, excluding the impact of acquisitions and disposals (M&A), unless otherwise stated. Growth percentages shown here for all non-financial key performance indicators compare FY25 to FY24. Expand For full details of the Group's results, please visit 5 Total Payment Volume Expand About Naspers Established in 1915, Naspers has transformed itself to become a global technology company and one of the largest technology investors in the world. Through Prosus, the group is building the world's leading lifestyle ecommerce brands, across Europe, India and Latin America, unlocking an AI-first world for our 2 billion customers. Prosus has its primary listing on Euronext Amsterdam, and a secondary listing on the Johannesburg Stock Exchange and Naspers is the majority owner of Prosus. In South Africa, Naspers is one of the foremost investors in the technology sector and is committed to building its internet and ecommerce companies. These include Takealot, Mr D Food, Autotrader, Property24 and PayU, in addition to Media24, South Africa's leading print and digital media business. Naspers has a primary listing on the Johannesburg Stock Exchange ( and a secondary listing on the A2X Exchange ( in South Africa and a level 1 American Depository Receipt (ADR) programme which trades on an over-the-counter basis in the US. For more information, please visit Naspers Labs In 2019, Naspers Labs, a youth development programme designed to transform and launch South Africa's unemployed youth into economic activity, was launched. Naspers Labs focuses on digital skills and training, enabling young people to pursue tech careers.

Hamilton Spectator

25 minutes ago

• Hamilton Spectator

The Latest: Trump muses about regime change in Iran after U.S. strikes on nuclear facilities

Israel's military said Monday it was striking around Iran's western city of Kermanshah, as fears of a wider regional conflict loomed large after the United States inserted itself into Israel's war by attacking Iranian nuclear sites. The operation raised urgent questions about what remained of Tehran's nuclear program and how its weakened military might respond. The price of oil rose as financial markets reacted. Iran lashed out at the U.S. for crossing 'a very big red line' with its risky gambit to strike the three sites with missiles and 30,000-pound bunker-buster bombs . President Donald Trump, who has warned of additional strikes if Tehran retaliates against U.S. forces, has mused about the possibility of 'regime change ″ in Iran, despite administration officials earlier indicating they wanted to restart talks with Iran. U.S. Secretary of State Marco Rubio, in an interview with CBS, said: 'Let's meet directly.' Ali Akbar Velayati, an adviser to Iran's supreme leader, said any country used by the U.S. to strike Iran 'will be a legitimate target for our armed forces,' the state-run IRNA news agency reported. Tens of thousands of American troops are based in the Middle East. Here is the latest: North Korea condemns U.S. strikes on Iran North Korea says it 'strongly condemns' the U.S. attack on Iranian nuclear facilities, calling it an egregious violation of Iran's territorial integrity and security interests. North Korea's Foreign Ministry said in a statement Monday that the United States and Israel were escalating tensions in the Middle East through the use of military force, and called on the 'just-minded international community' to raise a unified voice against their 'confrontational behavior.' During his first term, U.S. President Donald Trump met North Korean leader Kim Jong Un three times in 2018 and 2019, but their diplomacy collapsed over disagreements in exchanging the release of U.S.-led sanctions against North Korea and the North's steps to wind down its nuclear and missile program. Kim has since accelerated his arms development while ignoring talk offers by Washington and Seoul. He has shifted the priority of his foreign policy to Russia, sending thousands of troops and huge shipments of military equipment to fuel Russian President Vladimir Putin's war on Ukraine. Trump claims 'monumental damage' inflicted on Iranian nuclear sites President Donald Trump asserted on his Truth Social platform that Iran's nuclear sites sustained 'monumental damage' in the American attack, though a U.S. assessment on the strikes is still underway. 'The biggest damage took place far below ground level. Bullseye!!!' he wrote. U.S. defense officials have said they are working to determine about just how much damage the strikes did. Iran as well has not said how much damage was done in the attack, though Tehran has not offered any details so far on the strikes it has faced from Israel in its war with that country. Iran likely filled in tunnels at nuclear sites ahead of U.S. strikes An analysis of satellite photos by a nuclear nonproliferation group based in Washington shows Iran likely filled in tunnels at its nuclear site at Isfahan ahead of U.S. strikes early Sunday. The Washington-based Institute for Science and International Security published satellite images taken by Airbus it assessed showed trucks dumping soil into tunnels at the site on Friday. The U.S. attack likely targeted the tunnel entries, the group said. 'At least three of the four tunnel entrances are collapsed,' it said. 'The status of the fourth one is unclear.' Error! Sorry, there was an error processing your request. There was a problem with the recaptcha. Please try again. You may unsubscribe at any time. By signing up, you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy . This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google privacy policy and terms of service apply. Want more of the latest from us? Sign up for more at our newsletter page .

Yahoo

42 minutes ago

• Yahoo

Emerging Assets Drop as US Strike on Iran Fans Worries About Oil

(Bloomberg) -- Asian currencies and stocks fell at the start of the week, as US strikes on Iran rattled investors and pushed up the price of oil. Bezos Wedding Draws Protests, Soul-Searching Over Tourism in Venice One Architect's Quest to Save Mumbai's Heritage From Disappearing NYC Congestion Toll Cuts Manhattan Gridlock by 25%, RPA Reports South Korea's won led the drop among currencies, contributing to the 0.3% fall in the Bloomberg Asia Dollar Index. Indonesia's rupiah also declined, and the country's central bank confirmed it had intervened both on- and offshore to arrest the slide. On the equities front, MSCI's EM equities gauge dropped 1%. President Donald Trump's decision to attack three Iranian nuclear sites opens a new front in the conflict between Israel and Iran, which has stoked concerns fears that energy supplies from the Middle East will be disrupted. That's a particular concern for economies in Asia, many of whom import the lion's share of their fuel supply. 'Our analysis shows that the Philippine peso, Korean won and Thai baht are more vulnerable in Asia' to oil-price spikes, Mitsubishi UFJ Financial Group, Inc. analysts led by Michael Wan wrote in a note. 'Further increases in oil prices could start to impact the policy space of the Philippines and Vietnam, and to a smaller extent India,' delaying central bank interest rate cuts. The moves also risk upending the rally in local currency bond markets, which registered strong inflows as global funds shied away from US assets and the dollar weakened. The Strait of Hormuz is a choke-point for Mideast oil, and investors are watching for any signs it gets blocked. Tehran has warned of retaliation. Reflecting the potential fallout, the 30-day correlation between Brent oil futures and the Asia Dollar Spot Index is now at its most negative since March 2022, with a reading of -0.45, according to Bloomberg calculations. Wells Fargo & Co. sees the Indian rupee, as well as the won, baht and peso, as potentially the worst hit. Long positioning potentially is most extended for the won, followed by the baht, which could contribute to a relatively poor performance in the short term, said Chidu Narayanan, head of macro strategy for APAC at the firm. On the equities front, Taiwan's exchange posted some of the biggest declines. Chip stocks sold off on fears the US may revoke waivers allowing firms to ship American technology to China. Investors were 'running full tilt in the direction of EM' at the time Trump announced the US strikes, Robin Brooks, a senior fellow in the global economy and development program at the Brookings Institution, wrote in a note. 'This heightens the risk of a violent reversal in these flows, which could cause EM currencies to weaken sharply.' --With assistance from Jaehyun Eom, Swati Pandey and Bhaskar Dutta. Luxury Counterfeiters Keep Outsmarting the Makers of $10,000 Handbags Is Mark Cuban the Loudmouth Billionaire that Democrats Need for 2028? Ken Griffin on Trump, Harvard and Why Novice Investors Won't Beat the Pros The US Has More Copper Than China But No Way to Refine All of It Can 'MAMUWT' Be to Musk What 'TACO' Is to Trump? ©2025 Bloomberg L.P. Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data