CHAUDHRI: Too many tech layoffs blamed on poor performance

It was Mae West who said an ounce of performance is worth a pound of promises. Being able to focus, execute and 'perform' are good traits for anyone to have – particularly for employees.
But performance, or more specifically the measurement of it, can be a nebulous exercise. Some metrics of performance are cut and dry and clearly objective, while other elements can be entirely subjective.
Performance, like beauty, may lie in the eye of its beholder.
No doubt, two managers may have a very different view of the same employee's performance.
The very fact that performance can be measured differently by different people can give employers some broad discretion when it comes to assessing performance.
Some tech companies have harnessed the relative vagueness of performance assessment to support mass layoffs of employees. It's an alarming trend.
SFGate reported that Jack Dorsey, CEO of Block, laid off 931 workers earlier this year, including employees who were 'off strategy' and 'underperforming.' Dorsey told Business Insider in 2023 that he eliminated drawn-out performance improvement plans and preferred to terminate underperformers 'without delay.'
Terminating 931 workers at the same time for purported under performance seems staggering, particularly when the company abolished an important performance management tool. Was this a mass layoff masquerading as something else?
Microsoft and Meta have also reportedly tied large scale layoffs to alleged widespread employee underperformance.
Similarly, Business Insider reported recently that Salesforce has introduced a new 'PEP' or 'PIP' program. Under this program employees are offered a 'Prompt Exit Package' with less or lower severance. If employees refuse the PEP, 'they will be put on a PIP (Performance Improvement Plan),' according to the story.
Business Insider reported that the performance pressure at Salesforce was implemented 'as it executes its plan to reduce its workforce by 10%.'
CHAUDHRI: Court of Appeal sends warning to Ontario employers
CHAUDHRI: Can your employer force you back into the office?
CHAUDHRI: Are you being quiet-fired?
While it makes some sense for employers to apply a higher level of scrutiny on employees if a reduction in workforce is being considered, there are obvious issues with the approach.
Firstly, performance assessments should never be made arbitrarily. An employee should be rated in a good faith way, not in anticipation of a future demotion or termination. If an employee is slated to be terminated (or even being considered for termination) an employer should not arbitrarily tinker with the employee's performance rating in advance of the termination.
This should be obvious, but when mass layoffs are being tied to performance issues we must explore why an employer would be incentivized to do so.
Many employees receive raises, bonuses and commissions based on performance ratings. The higher the rating, the higher the bonus or raise. Now, if someone who is generally a high performer is terminated, they would expect a severance package that aligns with the compensation flowing from their high performance scores.
In order to reduce costs, some employers may, on a bad faith basis, be painting good performers as bad or mediocre performers to subsequently reduce bonus/commission payments on termination. For example, in anticipation of the termination, lower the performance rating so as to support lower payouts on bonuses or other incentives.
While one must be careful to call out employer practices, it seems implausible that there were, at the same time, 931 poor performers at Block who all had to be done away with at once.
Employees should not take a poor performance review lying down. If the review is not fair or reasonable, it is of vital importance that it is protested, in writing. Saying nothing will lead an employer to argue that you accepted your fate, unfair as it was.
Canadian courts must be prepared to explore poor performance ratings just prior to a termination, particularly when an employee is terminated as part of a larger reduction. It is a tool that is being used too often by powerful companies and should be explored, not ignored.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Yahoo

an hour ago

• Yahoo

AI is changing the tech job market, and Gen Z is struggling to keep up

This post originally appeared in the BI Tech Memo newsletter. Sign up for the weekly BI Tech Memo newsletter here. As my daughter can attest, it's a tough job market out there. She's a mechanical engineer, which seems steady demand-wise. But many of her college friends are struggling to find that crucial entry-level job or internship. Some are wondering if computer science and similar courses were the right decision, with AI automating software tasks at companies. Just look at what's happening at Amazon. CEO Andy Jassy said this week that his corporate workforce will shrink over the next few years as the company uses more generative AI tools and agents. Not so coincidentally, Business Insider just spent weeks interviewing Gen Z tech job seekers as AI transforms early-career experiences across the industry. Our findings are a must-read for anyone looking to break in here and find success. Jonathan, a 26-year-old software engineer, is emblematic of what we discovered. (He's not authorized to speak to the media, so we removed his last name.) After earning his degree in 2022, he sent out nearly 300 applications and got 12 responses. It took three months to land a full-time tech role. Less than a year later, he lost that job due to his employer shutting an office. Then, he found himself repeating the process, this time applying to 600 jobs and hearing back from only five. "Everyone tells you to get into computer science. That's where all the money is at, that's where the jobs are at," Jonathan told BI. "It's a lot harder than they make it out to be." He's not alone. Recent computer science grads face a 6.1% unemployment rate in the US, higher than the national average. Wow. I never thought I'd see a stat like that. Jonathan now works in defense tech, not the video game industry he originally aspired to join. Like many of his peers, he's focused on gaining experience — any experience. It's looking like a tech career is evolving from a sure thing into something similar to every other type of job: You have to hustle and network to get your foot in the door, and then work like hell to stay employed and build steadily from there. What else should you do as an aspiring tech worker? Our Gen Z survey story doesn't have all the answers, but there's great advice in here. Read the original article on Business Insider

Yahoo

8 hours ago

• Yahoo

The clock is ticking on Tesla's mysterious new cheaper models

Fans and investors are still in the dark about Tesla's mysterious new "affordable" EVs. Tesla said new models would start production in the first half of 2025, but it has yet to reveal any details. Tesla faces slow sales and fierce competition, with analysts saying its fundamentals are worse than expected. Tesla is gearing up to finally launch its robotaxi service, but the company is drawing close to another equally important deadline. As Elon Musk gets set to begin offering robotaxi rides to a select group of invitees in Austin this weekend, Tesla fans are still waiting for news about the company's long-awaited low-cost electric cars. In January, Tesla said that it would start production on new models, "including more affordable models," in the first half of 2025. In the automaker's earnings in April, Tesla reiterated this timeline, with Vice President of Vehicle Engineering Lars Moravy saying the company was working through "last-minute issues" on the new cars. That deadline is fast approaching, and there is little sign that Tesla is gearing up for a major product launch. Tesla did not immediately respond to a request for comment from Business Insider. The stakes for the EV giant are high. Tesla has seen its sales collapse across the globe so far this year, as it grapples with consumer backlash over CEO Musk's politics and production disruptions due to a refresh of its best-selling Model Y EV. Analysts previously told Business Insider that Tesla's stale product lineup is not helping matters. The carmaker has not launched a new vehicle since the Cybertruck in 2023, and the angular pickup's sales have been underwhelming. Even as Tesla's product lineup has stagnated, its rivals have launched a flurry of new electric models. Much of this competition has come from China, where a brutally competitive EV market has pushed Chinese companies like BYD to launch new models at rock-bottom prices. Data from industry group EV Volumes found that although Tesla's Model Y and 3 were still the top-selling electric cars in the world in the first four months of the year, their sales are coming under pressure from BYD's Seagull and the Wuling Mini, two affordable, compact city cars that sell for the equivalent of less than $10,000 in China. Some analysts have already begun to sound the alarm bells. In a note this week, Wells Fargo analysts Colin Langan and Kosta Tasoulis said that Tesla's business fundamentals were worse than expected, with deliveries failing to recover in the second quarter. The analysts also warned that the recent Senate ruling to end California's zero-emission rules would remove the need for automakers to buy regulatory credits from Tesla, which they estimated could cut Tesla's earnings before tax and interest by as much as 16%. Langan and Tasoulis said demand for the refreshed Model Y, which Tesla began rolling out earlier this year, "appears weak," adding that the mysterious affordable models were the only apparent driver of sales in the second half of the year. Despite their importance, it's still unclear what the new models hinted at by Tesla will look like. Tesla has said they will be produced on the same manufacturing lines as its current vehicles and will use aspects of the same platform. Reuters has reported that the new models will include a stripped-down version of the Model Y, production of which has been delayed by several months, according to anonymous sources. For now, it seems Musk and Tesla are mostly focused on the 10 or so robotaxis set to launch in Austin, leaving a major question mark over the rest of the company's product roadmap. Read the original article on Business Insider Sign in to access your portfolio

Business Insider

11 hours ago

• Business Insider

The Israel-Iran conflict is likely bad news for Russia's reliance on Shahed drones, UK intel says

As aerial strikes between Iran and Israel continue, Russia may be feeling the ripple effects across the Black Sea. "The conflict will likely negatively impact the future provision of Iranian military equipment to Russia," the UK Ministry of Defence said in an intelligence update on Thursday. The UK MOD said that "Iran has supplied significant quantities of one-way attack uncrewed aerial systems" to Russia, as well as having provided "extensive support" to its production of these drones. For the Kremlin, the timing of the latest Middle East conflict isn't entirely unwelcome; with global attention shifting to the Iran-Israel standoff, pressure on Russia over its invasion of Ukraine could ease. However, the conflict could also spark long-term issues for Russia, which continues to depend on Iran for Shahed drones and their parts. Iran has also supplied Russia with ballistic missiles and other munitions, the MOD said. Iran's Shahed drones have become a key weapon in the war in Ukraine. The Shahed-136, an Iranian-designed weapon that Moscow now also produces, has been at the heart of Russia's drone attacks on Ukraine, being used against cities and critical infrastructure. These drones can fly at speeds of over 115 mph with a nearly 90-pound explosive warhead. It's not clear what percentage of the drones Russia now produces itself, and how much it still relies on those coming from Iran. Friends in need The war in Ukraine has dragged on for more than three years, with Western nations continuing to funnel weapons and aid to Kyiv. Meanwhile, Iran has been one of Russia's most important military partners, and Tehran has played a crucial role in helping Russia scale up its domestic drone production, providing both equipment and technical expertise. A wide-ranging strategic partnership deal signed between Russia and Iran in January strengthened cooperation in areas like defense, energy, and trade, but it didn't commit either side to come to the other's aid in a conflict. That stands in sharp contrast to Russia's mutual defense arrangements with countries like Belarus and North Korea. If Iran becomes increasingly bogged down in a direct confrontation with Israel, its ability to keep any supply lines open to Russia would likely be compromised. A full-blown war might stretch Iran's military production capacity or expose it to international sanctions and strikes that disrupt its defense industry sector. Russia has already been weaning itself off Iran's Shaheds. Business Insider has reported on multiple attempts by Russia to build Shahed-like drones domestically. These include Russia's Geran-2 drones, which are similar to Shahed-136s but made with different materials, researchers at Conflict Armament Research told The New York Times last year. For now, the Kremlin is staying quiet — a likely sign it's trying to keep its options open. But as the latest Middle East conflict heats up, Russia may soon find that one of its closest alliances is less helpful than it once was.