Netflix's Fear Street: Prom Queen movie draws backlash from Fear Street book series fans: 'Disrespectful to the original trilogy'
Fear Street: Prom Queen, based on the 1992 book The Prom Queen by R. L. Stine, was released on Netflix over the weekend with much anticipation, thanks to the strong fan following of the Fear Street book series and the previously released film trilogy.
Directed by Matt Palmer, the film stars India Fowler, Suzanna Son, Fina Strazza, David Iacono, Ella Rubin, Chris Klein, Ariana Greenblatt, Lili Taylor, and Katherine Waterston. Set in 1988, the story follows a masked killer targeting prom queen candidates at Shadyside High.
Fear Street Part One: 1994, Fear Street Part Two: 1978, and Fear Street Part Three: 1666 were released on Netflix in 2021 on a weekly basis. While the film adaptation of the trilogy impressed fans with its mix of slasher horror and supernatural twists, this new entry has left many disappointed.
What's the premise of Fear Street: Prom Queen?
In 1988, Shadyside High's senior class gears up for prom, hoping to shake off the town's dark reputation. Lori Granger (India Flower), an outcast due to rumours surrounding her mother, runs for prom queen against the popular "Wolfpack," led by Tiffany Falconer (Fina Strazza). Vice Principal Brekenridge sees prom as a fresh start for the school, but the night before, candidate Christy Renault (Ariana Greenblatt) is murdered by a masked killer.
On prom night, Lori arrives with her best friend Megan (Suzanna Son). A prank gone wrong creates a rift between them. Meanwhile, members of the Wolfpack and their dates are picked off one by one, Linda and Bobby are murdered, and Debbie dies in the basement. Lori receives anonymous flowers, while Tiffany taunts her about her mother's past. A dance-off ends with Lori stealing the spotlight, embarrassing Tiffany.
After Tyler dumps Tiffany and flirts with Lori, he's murdered by the killer. Megan suspects the killer is Devlin, the vice principal's son, but Lori dismisses her theory. Megan discovers the bodies in the basement, and Lori narrowly escapes an attack. During the prom queen announcement, the killer strikes again, murdering students before Lori stabs him with her crown. He's revealed to be Tiffany's father, Dan Falconer.
Dan is arrested, and Lori spends the night at Tiffany's, but the nightmare isn't over. Tiffany and her mother, Nancy, reveal they were also behind the killings. Nancy confesses she murdered Lori's father out of jealousy. Lori kills both Tiffany and Nancy in self-defence. As Nancy dies, her blood forms the Witch's Mark, suggesting evil still lingers.
Why are fans disappointed by Fear Street: Prom Queen?
Despite trending globally on Netflix, fans have voiced strong criticism against Fear Street: Prom Queen. Many took issue with the film's deviation from the original book, from character name changes to altering the killer's identity. Some felt the film took too long to get going, with many calling the first 30 minutes boring.
One user wrote, "Why does Fear Street: Prom Queen not feel like Fear Street at all… It's not scary; everyone has iPhone faces, and everything they do is super cringe."
why does fear street: prom queen not feel like fear street at all… it's not scary, everyone has iphone faces and everything they do is super cringe 😭😭😭
Another added, "Fear Street Prom Queen was so bad at making their characters distinguishable bc how did I JUST find out Tiffany's dad was a teacher in the high school."
Fear Street Prom Queen was so bad at making their characters distinguishable bc how did I JUST find out Tiffany's dad was a teacher in the high school
"Rewatching the Fear Street trilogy to make up for the disappointment that Prom Queen was," wrote another fan.
rewatching the fear street trilogy to make up for the disappointment that prom queen was pic.twitter.com/jYOXtsTWRW
"Just finished FEAR STREET: PROM QUEEN. almost feels like it could be a decent, entertaining time for the first half hour but it has like two tricks up its sleeve and just gets incredibly dull for most of the runtime. the most annoying characters of the year also. bleugh."
just finished FEAR STREET: PROM QUEEN. almost feels like it could be a decent, entertaining time for the first half hour but it has like two tricks up its sleeve and just gets incredibly dull for most of the runtime. the most annoying characters of the year also. bleugh. pic.twitter.com/7rdhgRMHUy
One user wrote, "fear street prom queen was so ass... i can't believe they ruined the crazy run that the Fear Street trilogy laid down."
fear street prom queen was so ass... i cant believe they ruined the crazy run that fear street trilogy laid down
"Fear Street: Prom Queen is now streaming on Netflix.Fear Street Prom Queen was the most predictable cliché movie I've ever seen. The moment 2 killers were shown, I automatically knew it was the parents... disrespectful to the original trilogy," one mentioned.
fear street prom queen was the most predictable cliche movie ive ever seen 😭😭 the moment 2 killers were shown i automatically knew it was the parents... disrespectful to the original trilogy pic.twitter.com/vPladVW0wS
Fear Street: Prom Queen is now streaming on Netflix.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Pink Villa
34 minutes ago
- Pink Villa
K-dramas to watch on OTT this week, June 23-29: Lee Jung Jae, Lee Byung Hun-led Squid Game 3 to Head Over Heels
The first half of 2025 will end with the premiere of one of the most-awaited K-drama releases of the year— Lee Jung Jae, Lee Byung Hun's Squid Game 3. The gripping drama can be your perfect month-end watch. For a respite from the dark, intense content, you can opt for romantic dramas like Head Over Heels and Love Phobia. Additionally, fans can look forward to new episode releases of ongoing dramas like Our Unwritten Seoul, The First Night with the Duke, GOOD BOY, and more. New K-drama premieres Head Over Heels Starring Choo Young Woo and Cho Yi Hyun, this fantasy drama revolves around a high schooler shaman's attempt to save her crush, who is destined to die. It will premiere on June 23 on tvN. Squid Game Season 3 The last instalment of the survival drama will showcase Lee Jung Jae and Lee Byung Hun 's thrilling final showdown. With more blood, sweat and tears, the series will air on June 27 on Netflix. Love Phobia It stars Kim Hyun Jin and Yeon Woo as a tech CEO, who is skeptical of love and a romance novelist. Watch their intertwined lives as they work together on an app. The series premieres on June 27 on U+ Mobile TV and HiTV. Ongoing K-dramas Besides the above-mentioned ones, several ongoing series will be back with new episodes as well. Check the list below: Salon de Holmes In episodes 3 and 4, Lee Si Young, Jung Young Joo and squad will solve their community's problems together. Watch it on June 23 and 24 on ENA. Hunter With a Scalpel In episodes 6-9, Kang Hoon and Park Ju Hyun, will try to uncover the truth behind Park Yong Woo's serial killings. Watch it on 23-26 on Disney+ or U+ Mobile TV. The Woman Who Swallowed the Sun In episodes 7-11, single mother Jang Shin Young will plot revenge against a powerful chaebol family to get her daughter justice. Watch it on June 23-27 on Kocowa. Our Movie In episodes 5 and 6, Jeon Yeo Been and Namkoong Min's feelings for each other will grow while working on a movie together. Watch it on June 27 and 28 on Wavve. South Korean viewers can also stream it on Disney+. Spring of Youth In episode 9, Ha Yoo Joon and Park Ji Hu will make things better for their band, and Lee Seung Hyub will find himself still pining for her. Watch it on June 25 on SBS or Viki. The First Night with the Duke In episodes 5 and 6, Ok Taecyeon will go to great lengths to save sick Seohyun, while she realises his love for her. Watch it on June 25 and 26 on Viki. Oh My Ghost Clients In episodes 9 and 10, Jung Kyung Ho, Seol In Ah, and Cha Hak Yeon will navigate life while helping ghosts with legal cases. Watch it on June 27 and 28 on Netflix, Viki, Kocowa, or Wavve. GOOD BOY In episodes 9 and 10, Park Bo Gum ane team will set to find the kidnapped Kim So Hyun. Catch it on June 28 and 29 on Prime Video. Korean viewers can also watch it on Netflix, Disney+, or TVING. Our Unwritten Seoul In episodes 11 and 12, Park Bo Young's twin characters will navigate their relationship development with Jinyoung and Ryu Kyung Soo. Watch it on June 28 and 29 on Netflix.
Hans India
an hour ago
- Hans India
OTT Releases This Week (June 23–29, 2025): The ultimate binge guide
Get ready for a thrilling week of streaming. From heartwarming family dramas and clever comedies to pulse-pounding thrillers, high-concept superhero series, and gripping regional mysteries—this lineup has something for every kind of viewer. Bookmark this guide to stay on track with every major release, complete with important details and platform info. Let's dive in! PRIME VIDEO Panchayat – Season 4 (June 24, 2025) After winning over audiences with its charming depiction of rural life, Panchayat returns with Season 4, focusing on the heated panchayat elections in the fictional village of Phulera. Jitendra Kumar, Neena Gupta, Raghubir Yadav, Faisal Malik, Chandan Roy, Sanvikaa, Durgesh Kumar, and Pankaj Jha reprise their roles, offering their signature blend of humor and sincerity. Expect the same warm community spirit, relatable characters, and gentle drama that made the show a modern classic. Head Over Heels (June 23, 2025) This quirky American romantic comedy-thriller from director Mark Waters features an all-star cast including Monica Potter, Freddie Prinze Jr., Shalom Harlow, Ivana Miličević, Tomiko Fraser, China Chow, and Timothy Olyphant. When idealistic romantic turns complicated by unexpected suspense, the couple finds themselves on a rollercoaster of emotion, humor, and intrigue. Sharp dialogue, character chemistry, and comedic tension make Head Over Heels a lively watch ideal for a weekend binge. Countdown (June 25, 2025) Countdown delivers heart-pounding action in this crime thriller series from Derek Haas (Chicago and FBI franchises). Starring Jensen Ackles (Supernatural, The Boys), Eric Dane (Grey's Anatomy), and Jessica Camacho (The Flash), the plot centers on a covert task force racing against time to stop a catastrophic threat. Violett Beane, Elliot Knight, and Uli Latukefu round out the cast, ensuring a gripping narrative filled with moral dilemmas and explosive confrontation. NETFLIX Happy Gilmore 2 (July 25, 2025) The legend returns as Adam Sandler reprises his role in this long-awaited sequel. Now retired, Happy Gilmore returns to the green to fund his daughter Vienna's ballet tuition. Reunited with comedic favorites like Julie Bowen, Dennis Dugan, Christopher McDonald, Kevin Nealon, and Ben Stiller, the film delivers heartfelt jokes, family dynamics, and sporty misadventures. Happy Gilmore 2 is a nostalgic and feel-good ride perfect for fans of the original. Squid Game – Season 3 (June 27, 2025) The saga continues with Season 3, following Lee Jung-jae's Ha-jiung as he attempts to dismantle the deadly game from the inside. With a deeper dive into his past and renewed alliances, the stakes are higher than ever. Lee Byung-hun, Wi Ha-joon, Yim Si-wan, Kang Ha-neul, and Park Sung-hoon join the cast, bringing emotional depth, deadly tension, and philosophical reckoning to life. This final installment pledges a dramatic conclusion to the global phenomenon. JIOHOTSTAR Mistry (June 27, 2025) Ram Kapoor headlines this detective comedy wrap, playing Armaan Mistry, a former cop whose obsessive-compulsive personality helps solve baffling cases. Co-starring Shikha Talsania, Mona Singh, Abhijeet Chitre, and Kshitish Date, the show blends mystery-solving with slice-of-life humor. As Mistry tackles complex investigations using unconventional methods, the series balances procedural intrigue with witty banter, charming characters, and cultural nuances unique to Indian OTT storytelling. Ironheart – Episodes 1–3 (June 25, 2025) A new Marvel-verse entry arrives with Ironheart, featuring Dominique Thorne as Riri Williams, a genius inventor who emerges from the shadows of Black Panther: Wakanda Forever. As she constructs her own powered armor, Riri crosses paths with Anthony Ramos, Shea Couleé, Manny Montana, and Sacha Baron Cohen's fiendish character. The first three episodes set up a kinetic narrative grounded in tech, family dynamics, social justice, and identity. Expect Marvel-level action and emotional stakes. ManoramaMAX Azadi (June 27, 2025) This Malayalam thriller dives into a gripping prison-escape scenario centered around a pregnant inmate. Released from political and emotional trauma, she seeks freedom—but at what cost? With compelling performances, raw tension, and an introspective plot, Azadi explores autonomy, motherhood, and institutional violence through powerful storytelling. Brace for emotional resonance balanced with suspenseful pacing and moral ambiguity. ZEE5 Bangla Bibhishon (June 27, 2025) This psychological thriller mini-series stars Soham Majumdar as SI Bidhan Sen, who investigates a gruesome murder in rural Bolagarh. As secrets unravel and hidden motives surface, Bibhishon blends crime procedural elements with psychological depth. The six-episode arc promises unsettling revelations while challenging social structures. With tight pacing andintense narrative, it's a compelling addition to the Bangla-language OTT scene. With this stellar week of releases, your streaming app queue will be packed with drama, laughter, suspense, and action. Whether you're looking for nostalgia, emotional depth, or edge-of-your-seat thrillers—June 23–29 delivers. It's time to grab your snacks, choose your platform, and dive into a cinematic ride that spans worlds, genres, and emotions. Happystreaming!
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
The Great Indian Kapil Show 3: Kapil Sharma teases Navjot Singh Sidhu for his hefty fees; says ‘Grateful to the platform for a budget that could afford Sidhu Paaji'
The Great Indian Kapil Show made a grand return with its third season on June 21. The premiere episode featured Bollywood icon Salman Khan , who entertained the audience with intriguing stories from his life and a few surprising revelations. Season 3 also marked the much-anticipated return of Navjot Singh Sidhu , joining Archana Puran Singh on the judge's panel. Kapil opened the episode by welcoming the audience and Navjot Singh Sidhu, joking that the platform had to shell out a hefty amount to bring Sidhu back on the show. Kapil said, "I want to thank Netflix for giving us that much budget that we could afford Sidhu paaji." Kapil Sharma playfully asked Navjot Singh Sidhu about joining forces with Archana Puran Singh and his return to The Great Indian Kapil Show. He continued to tease Sidhu and joked, 'Paaji, you are back on the show after so many years, bhale hi gathbandhan ki sarkar bani ho (even though it is a united alliance). How are you feeling? Netflix is spending big, but how do you feel?' In response, Sidhu shared a shayari, saying that Dehradun could never come between the charm of two people from Amritsar. Kapil continued the banter by joking that Archana had been anxious ever since she heard about Sidhu's return and even consulted astrologers about it. He says, "Jyotish ko jaake kehti hai, Rahu aur ketu ko toh main sambhal lungi ye Sidhu ka koi upay batao..(I can handle Rahu and Ketu, but what do I do with Sidhu?). The popular comedian shared his excitement over Navjot Singh Sidhu's return to the show but couldn't resist cracking a joke, saying they had to take a six-month-long break because of him. Sidhu, quick with his wit, replied with a laugh, 'Be glad it was just six months—imagine what you'd do if it lasted nine!' Kapil seized the moment and fired back with another playful dig at Sidhu, saying, "Main toh phir break mein mere bacche hue, jab corona hua, aap toh chalte matchon mein kar gaye, dekho aap." (For the record, I had my kids during COVID, when the world was on a break. You had yours while the cricket matches were still going on). Navjot Singh Sidhu Reveals How He Helped Kapil Sharma Get His Show | Returns to Kapil Show
