Hiqa to be quizzed by PAC about its oversight of nursing homes
Hiqa is set to face questioning from the Public Accounts Committee (PAC) on failures of oversight in nursing homes.
The HSE and senior health officials have also been called before the committee as a matter of urgency in an effort to uncover how the failures observed in a recent RTÉ exposé were allowed to persist and whether warning signs were ignored, overlooked or inadequately responded to.
Hundreds of millions of euro of the public's money is provided to the nursing home sector through multiple channels and taxpayers have the right to know that this money is used to provide the highest standards of care, chairman John Brady said.
"The PAC is committed to ensuring that this is not just another brief moment of outrage followed by inaction," Mr Brady said as the committee took the unanimous decision to call the bodies to appear.
Labour's Martin Wall told the Dáil that Hiqa has failed in its duty and is not fit for purpose.
Families who have contacted him over the last week have been failed by Hiqa reports which "painted a picture that was far from the reality" and led to families "unwittingly putting their relatives in harm's way".
Minister of state for older people Kieran O'Donnell said there has been continued "intensive engagement" regarding the two Emeis Ireland-run nursing homes featured in the RTÉ programme. Mr O'Donnell said:
It was identified, the issues in Portlaoise, in the two Hiqa reports. The Beneavin report did not highlight that fact. These are questions I have put to Hiqa.
He said an interim report on Emeis Ireland overall is expected by the end of the week with a final report due next week.
The over-reliance on private providers came under fire from backbench and Opposition TDs alike with the Government accused of a "specific, determined and protracted policy of privatisation of nursing home care" by Matt Carthy.
Mr Carthy said older people are being treated like a commodity in a "race to the bottom" in a largely privatised nursing home sector.
His party colleague Louise O'Reilly said a small number of private providers are cutting corners in the name of chasing a profit with the Government facilitating them in this pursuit. Ms O'Reilly said:
You are making millionaires on the back of human misery and indignity and poor treatment of our older people and vulnerable people.
Fianna Fáil TD and GP Martin Daly said there needs to be a move away from large, corporate congregated settings in favour of smaller, community-based homes.
"I am told it takes a congregation of 70 in a nursing home to make it profitable for private operators," Mr Daly said, noting the large number of small nursing homes that have closed in recent years.
Mr O'Donnell acknowledged that the sector has moved from predominantly State-led services to almost 80% being provided by the private sector but said there is continued investment into the community nursing unit programme including €4m to staff and the opening of 615 public community beds this year.
The Dáil also heard that an adult safeguarding policy is to be brought to Government before the summer recess next month.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RTÉ News
20 hours ago
- RTÉ News
At least 43 people killed by Israeli forces, say Gaza rescuers
Gaza's civil defence agency said Israeli forces killed at least 43 people today, including 26 who had gathered near an aid distribution centre, the latest in a string of deadly incidents targeting aid seekers in the Palestinian territory. "Forty-three martyrs have fallen as a result of the ongoing Israeli bombardment on the Gaza Strip since dawn today, 26 of whom were waiting for humanitarian aid," Mohammad Al-Mughayyir, director of medical supply at the civil defence agency in Gaza, said. Yesterday, the civil defence agency said Israeli forces killed at least 72 people, including 21 who had gathered near aid distribution sites. At least 300 Palestinians have been killed in recent weeks while trying to reach aid distribution points in Gaza, which is suffering from famine-like conditions, the Hamas-run territory's health ministry has said. Israeli restrictions on media in Gaza and difficulties in accessing some areas mean media outlets are unable to independently verify the tolls and details provided by rescuers and authorities in the Palestinian territory. In early March, Israel imposed an aid blockade on Gaza amid a deadlock in truce negotiations, only partially easing restrictions in late May. After Israel loosened its blockade, the privately run Gaza Humanitarian Foundation began distributing aid but its operations have been marred by chaotic scenes. UN agencies and major aid groups have refused to cooperate with the foundation - which has the support of Israel and its ally the United States - over concerns it was designed to cater to Israeli military objectives. Elsewhere in the Middle East, .
Irish Daily Mirror
a day ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Inspector who cleared nursing home with abuse allegations worked on same campus
The 'lead' HIQA inspector who cleared controversial Beneavin Manor twice last year, despite almost 200 notifications of alleged abuse, worked in a sister nursing home on the same campus for two years, the Irish Mirror can reveal. In a lengthy statement, the Health Information and Quality Authority (HIQA) denied any wrongdoing, saying that the nursing home had changed ownership between the time the person worked there and the completion of the inspections. Beneavin Manor and The Residence in Portlaoise, Co Laois, were featured in an RTÉ Investigates documentary earlier this month. The homes, which are run by Emeis Ireland, were widely criticised after the undercover footage of residents crying out for help, being left in soiled clothes, and being incorrectly handled. An interim report from HIQA, published on Tuesday evening, revealed that there have been 198 notifications regarding suspected or confirmed allegations of abuse to residents in Beneavin Manor between January 2022 and June 2025. The Irish Mirror can now reveal that a HIQA inspector who used to work in Beneavin House was involved in two inspections at Beneavin Manor last year, which found that the nursing home was mostly compliant. Beneavin House, Beneavin Manor and Beneavin Lodge are all situated directly beside each other in Glasnevin. All are now owned by Emeis. The inspector is listed as the 'lead' inspector in two inspections at Firstcare Beneavin Manor on May 15 2024 and November 7 2024. The May report found that Beneavin Manor was 'compliant' or 'substantially compliant' under most regulations. However, it was found non-compliant with three regulations, including governance and management, contracts for the provision of services, and food and nutrition. The November report noted they were 'compliant' and 'substantially compliant' on all regulations. According to LinkedIn, the person listed as the lead inspector on both reports worked as a Clinical Nurse Manager at Beneavin House Nursing Home between June 2015 and June 2017. They then worked as director of nursing in two other nursing homes before moving to HIQA to become an inspector in September 2020. In a lengthy statement, HIQA stated that the nursing home had changed ownership and the inspector had never worked for Beneavin House under the new ownership. A spokesperson said that HIQA has a conflict of interest policy and 'inspectors of social services employed to inspect nursing homes have often worked in nursing homes in the public or private sector or a combination of both' and that a 'key requirement of any applicant for a job as an inspector is at least three years' experience working in a supervisory or management position in a health or social care service, regulatory, or other setting deemed relevant by the Authority'. They continued: '[Name] commenced work as an inspector of social services in September 2020. 'As is standard practice and in line with our conflict of interest policy, she was not required to inspect or to have regulatory oversight of those centres where she worked previously. 'As [she] was employed by Beneavin House Ltd, (the then owner of Beneavin House between 2015 and 2017), this centre and the other Beneavin Centres were not included in [her] caseload at that time. 'Given the passage of time and the change in ownership of the nursing homes in 2024, the issue of a conflict of interest was discussed again by [name] and her line manager with both satisfied that there was no longer any conflict of interest or any reason why [she] would not inspect First Care Beneavin Manor or the First Care Beneavin Lodge. 'She has not inspected First Care Beneavin House, the centre where she used to work. 'To be clear, [she] has never worked for Firstcare Beneavin House Ltd, the company that currently owns First Care Beneavin House, which was acquired by Emeis in 2024. 'In addition, [she] has not worked in Beneavin Manor or been employed by Firstcare Beneavin Manor Ltd. '[She] has never been employed by Emeis or any of the companies that are owned or operated by Emeis.'
Irish Examiner
2 days ago
- Irish Examiner
'Trust is broken': Committee hears of calamity and failures by CHI over children's surgery controversy
Calamity, failures in care, broken trust, and stonewalling of parents were raised during an emotional Oireachtas Health Committee with Children's Health Ireland (CHI) which left many questions unanswered. The discussion focused on unnecessary hip surgeries at Temple Street and Cappagh hospitals, unapproved springs in spinal surgery, a toxic work culture, and delays in care identified in an unpublished report from 2021. Only 72 out of about 1,800 children affected by the hip surgery controversy have so far been seen, CHI clinical director Ike Okefor confirmed. He expects it will meet the six-month deadline. He apologised for how the opening review clinics were run, with one case involving a five-and-a-half-hour appointment. Sinn Féin health spokesman David Cullinane asked specific questions about care in oncology and urology in light of the unpublished 2021 report. He asked if parents of children referred to in that document as 'Crumlin orphans' were told about the alleged sup-optimal care outlined. Parents feel, he said, 'stonewalled, they feel they are meeting with a wall of resistance, they say they are being failed". When he was told information was not given to them, he said it is a "failure". CHI CEO Lucy Nugent said its legal advice remains not to publish the report. A HSE official – Kate Killeen White, regional executive officer for Dublin Midlands – said she referred concerns in that report about use of public money to gardaí. She said CHI had not considered the problems had met the threshold for garda involvement. Senator Tom Clonan and others asked about potential risks of infertility for children waiting too long for treatment of undescended testes, as described in that unpublished report. CHI was unable to say how many were affected. Ms Nugent said it sought advice on the potential impacts. 'They did not meet the threshold for open disclosure,' she said. Senator Maria Byrne raised the issue of national oversight for hip dysplasia care, asking why a Health Information and Quality Authority (Hiqa) review into this last year had not led to a national universal screening programme. HSE chief clinical officer Dr Colm Henry said Hiqa advised a more targeted screening programme, but said the HSE is 'trying to finalise a proposal' for universal screening. There is selected screening at 16 centres, he said, adding the HSE 'will certainly be making the case' for expansion to the National Screening Advisory Committee. Questions were asked about oversight of devices in light of Hiqa's report in April on use of unapproved springs in surgeries. Former CEO Eilish Hardiman was asked to comment in light of her continuing key role in the moves to the new hospital. 'Part of the accountability is being here today and answering the questions to the best of my ability,' she said. 'I accept that there were weaknesses, and I've apologised for those particular weaknesses, we have put in structures and processes to try and address them.' These changes include improvements in procurement. Committee chair Padraig Rice said he was not satisfied in general and particularly on the non-publishing of reports. He asked CHI to share their legal advice on the 2021 report. 'Trust is broken,' he said. Ms Nugent and Ms Hardiman apologised to families repeatedly during heated discussions, with the new CEO pledging a new culture will take them into the national children's hospital.
