Air India plane crash: Is flying risky business?

Catastrophic events such as the Air India crash affect us deeply. The thought of going down in an aircraft may feel more frightening than dying in other ways. All this taps into the emotions of fear, vulnerability and helplessness, and leads to an overemphasis on the risks. However, air travel is still arguably the safest method of transport read more
Members of Indian Army's engineering arm prepare to remove the wreckage of an Air India aircraft, bound for London's Gatwick Airport, which crashed during take-off from an airport in Ahmedabad, India. Reuters
On Thursday afternoon, an Air India passenger plane bound for London crashed shortly after takeoff from the Indian city of Ahmedabad. There were reportedly 242 people onboard, including two pilots and 10 cabin crew.
The most up-to-date reports indicate the death toll , including people on the ground.
Miraculously, one passenger – British national Vishwashkumar Ramesh – survived the crash.
Thankfully, catastrophic plane crashes such as this are very rare. But seeing news of such a horrific event is traumatic, particularly for people who may have a fear of flying or are due to travel on a plane soon.
STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD
If you're feeling anxious following this distressing news, it's understandable. But here are some things worth considering when you're thinking about the risk of plane travel.
Dangers of flying
One of the ways to make sense of risks, especially really small ones, is to put them into context.
Although there are various ways to do this, we can first look to figures that tell us the risk of dying in a plane crash per passenger who boards a plane. Arnold Barnett, a professor at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, calculated that in 2018–22, this figure was one in 13.7 million. By any reckoning, this is an incredibly small risk.
And there's a clear trend of air travel getting safer every decade. Barnett's calculations suggest that between 2007 and 2017, the risk was one per 7.9 million.
We can also compare the risks of dying in a plane crash with those of dying in a car accident. Although estimates of motor vehicle fatalities vary depending on how you do the calculations and where you are in the world, flying has been estimated to be more than 100 times safer than driving.
STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD
The tail of the Air India Boeing 787 Dreamliner plane that crashed is seen stuck on a building after the incident in Ahmedabad. Reuters
Evolution has skewed our perception of risks
The risk of being involved in a plane crash is extremely small. But for a variety of reasons, we often perceive it to be greater than it is.
First, there are well-known limitations in how we intuitively estimate risk. Our responses to risk (and many other things) are often shaped far more by emotion and instinct than by logic.
As psychologist Daniel Kahneman explains in his book Thinking, Fast and Slow, much of our thinking about risk is driven by intuitive, automatic processes rather than careful reasoning.
Notably, our brains evolved to pay attention to threats that are striking or memorable. The risks we faced in primitive times were large, immediate and tangible threats to life. Conversely, the risks we face in the modern world are generally much smaller, less obvious, and play out over the longer term.
The brain that served us well in prehistoric times has essentially remained the same, but the world has completely changed. Therefore, our brains are susceptible to errors in thinking and mental shortcuts called cognitive biases that skew our perception of modern risks.
This can lead us to overestimate very small risks, such as plane crashes, while underestimating far more probable dangers, such as chronic diseases.
STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD
Why we overestimate the risks of flying
There are several drivers of our misperception of risks when it comes to flying specifically.
The fact events such as the Air India plane crash are so rare makes them all the more psychologically powerful when they do occur. And in today's digital media landscape, the proliferation of dramatic footage of the crash itself, along with images of the aftermath, amplifies its emotional and visual impact.
The effect these vivid images have on our thinking around the risks of flying is called the availability heuristic. The more unusual and dramatic an event is, the more it stands out in our minds, and the more it skews our perception of its likelihood.
Another influence on the way we perceive risks relevant to flying is called dread risk, which is a psychological response we have to certain types of threats. We fear certain risks that feel more catastrophic or unfamiliar. It's the same reason we may disproportionately fear terrorist attacks, when in reality they're very uncommon.
Plane crashes usually involve a large number of deaths that occur at one time. And the thought of going down in a plane may feel more frightening than dying in other ways. All this taps into the emotions of fear, vulnerability and helplessness, and leads to an overweighting of the risks.
STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD
Another factor that contributes to our overestimation of flying risks is our lack of control when flying. When we're passengers on a plane, we are in many ways completely dependent on others. Even though we know pilots are highly trained and commercial aviation is very safe, the lack of control we have as passengers triggers a deep sense of vulnerability.
This absence of control makes the situation feel riskier than it actually is, and often riskier than activities where the threat is far greater but there is an (often false) sense of control, such as driving a car.
Passengers gather in front of the ticket counter of Air India airlines. File image/Reuters
In a nutshell
We have an evolutionary bias toward reacting more strongly to particular threats, especially when these events are dramatic, evoke dread and when we feel an absence of control.
Although events such as Air India crash affect us deeply, air travel is still arguably the safest method of transport. Understandably, this can get lost in the emotional aftermath of tragic plane crashes.
Hassan Vally, Associate Professor, Epidemiology, Deakin University
This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

News18

an hour ago

• News18

Lucknow-Bound IndiGo Flight Cancelled After Pilot Finds 'Technical Issue'

Last Updated: The problem in the Lucknow-bound IndiGo flight was detected before the aircraft began taxiing, and all passengers were deboarded safely. An IndiGo flight en route to Lucknow from Chandigarh was cancelled after the pilot identified a technical issue during pre-flight checks, marking yet another instance of flight cancellations. Flight delays or diversions have come under intense scrutiny after the devastating Air India plane crash in Ahmedabad on June 12, which killed 241 out of the 242 passengers on board, along with over 30 others on the ground. The incident took place on Friday (June 20). The problem in the Lucknow-bound IndiGo flight 6E 146 was detected before the aircraft began taxiing, and as a precautionary measure, all passengers were deboarded safely, sources told news agency ANI. The issue was identified prior to departure, and the aircraft did not proceed with takeoff. The affected passengers were either accommodated on alternate flights or offered a full refund. This happened a day after an IndiGo flight on its way to Chennai from Guwahati, carrying with 168 passengers on board, had to make an emergency landing at Kempegowda International Airport in Bengaluru after issuing a mayday call as it 'ran out of fuel". The A320 aircraft, operating as flight 6E2006, had taken off from the national capital and remained airborne for more than two hours before the issue was detected. According to data from flight tracking platform Flightradar24, the plane turned back mid-air and safely landed in Delhi. 'The incident occurred on June 19. The flight was scheduled to arrive in Chennai at about 7.45 pm, but due to bad weather in Chennai, it could not land. The pilot opted to divert the flight to Bengaluru, but realised they ran out of fuel. So, he alerted the airport with a mayday call," the airline spokesperson told PTI. On Friday, a Madurai-bound flight suffered a technical snag mid-air on Friday and returned to Chennai after flying for about 30 minutes. (with inputs from agencies) First Published: June 22, 2025, 14:47 IST

Hindustan Times

an hour ago

• Hindustan Times

Indian man pens heartbreaking farewell after losing job in Dubai: ‘Completely finished savings'

An Indian man has shared a deeply emotional account of his sudden departure from Dubai after five years of living and working there. In a Reddit post, he recounted how an unexpected job termination left him financially drained and heartbroken, forcing him to return to India, an outcome he described as 'the end of his dream.' The user had been living in Dubai since 2019, working hard to support himself and his family back home. (Pexel) 'My heart is breaking into million pieces… I have to leave Dubai tomorrow. Fired. Broke. Empty,' he wrote, describing how a single HR meeting led to the collapse of the life he had built. 'One meeting. Security walked me out like a criminal. Five years hard work, overtime, skipping holidays for project, poof! Gone.' The user had been living in Dubai since 2019, working hard to support himself and his family back home. But with rising costs and no new job prospects despite sending 'literally hundreds' of applications, his savings eventually ran out. 'Dubai salary sounds big but rent? DEWA? Grocery? School fee for sister back home? Petrol? All eating money like monster,' he explained. Even selling off his belongings, 'my small TV, my mattress, my little plant' wasn't enough to get by. 'Feels like selling pieces of my life,' he said. Despite the pain, his farewell was laced with bittersweet nostalgia. 'Oh Dubai… how can I leave you? The smell of karak chai in morning… the crazy beautiful light show on Burj Khalifa… even the stress of Sheikh Zayed Road traffic jam! All gone.' Also read: Noida man dies in cab accident, family claims driver fell asleep at wheel The post also highlights the immense emotional toll of job insecurity. 'What hurts most? Failure. Feeling like I failed myself. Failed my family… Going back to village with empty hands… shame is heavy stone in my stomach,' he wrote, adding, 'My father voice on phone… trying to be strong, 'Come beta, home is home.' But I hear the disappointment.' Take a look at the post: Many took to the comments section to respond. One user wrote, "You're not a failure, you have sustained your family back home for many years. They should be proud of you. DXB isn't the be all and end all of life, you can shine in India or anywhere in the world. If you love living in Dubai then coming back is also an option when you manage to find a role" Another added, 'I'm really sorry you're going through this. But this isn't the end. Take this as your new challenge and be determined. You can start again, stronger than before. Dubai is just one place. You have it in you to persevere anywhere.'

Indian Express

3 hours ago

• Indian Express

‘Rape, crime, terrorism': US advises citizens to exercise ‘increased caution' on trip to India

In an updated travel advisory for its citizens, the United States has urged those travelling to India to 'exercise increased caution' due to heightened risks from crime, terrorism, and sexual violence, including rape, which it notes is among the 'fastest-growing crimes in the country'. The Level 2 advisory, updated by the US Department of State, outlines: The advisory mentions 'violent crime' and the risk of terrorist attacks, noting they can occur 'with little or no warning', even in locations frequented by tourists such as transportation hubs, markets, and government facilities. It adds that rape and sexual assault are a serious concern, and advises women to not travel alone. The advisory outlines a list of regions marked 'high-risk' areas, warning the US citizens against travelling there: In addition, US government employees need special authorisation to travel beyond capital cities in several Indian states, including parts of West Bengal, Chhattisgarh, and Odisha. The US advisory also reminds travellers to strictly follow Indian laws. It warns against carrying illegal devices like satellite phones and mentions that overstaying a visa could lead to detention, fines, or deportation. It also notes that the US government's ability to provide emergency support is limited, particularly in rural and high-risk regions. Travellers are advised to: It also encourages respect for local laws, religious sensitivities, and dress codes, especially in conservative areas. LGBTQ+ travellers are advised to exercise discretion due to conservative social attitudes in some regions. (Source: US Department of State)