North Korea's Covid-19 pandemic ‘miracle' was a deadly lie, report says
Pyongyang's repeated rejections of international help and its crackdown on the movement of people made their suffering worse, the report said. PHOTO: AFP
SEOUL - North Korea has long claimed that it defeated the Covid-19 pandemic without vaccines, losing only 74 lives in what it called 'a miracle unprecedented in the world's public health history.'
But a report released on June 17 said the government lied and left many of its people to die without proper health care or access to outside help.
As the pandemic raged, the already woeful economic and public health conditions of ordinary North Koreans rapidly worsened as a result of their government's efforts, especially in the first two years, to deny that the virus was spreading, according to a report compiled by the Washington-based Centre for Strategic and International Studies and the George W. Bush Institute.
Pyongyang's repeated rejections of international help and its crackdown on the movement of people made their suffering worse, the report said.
The authors said their report was based on rare interviews with 100 people inside isolated North Korea – conducted by an outside intermediary that engaged them in 'casual, in-person conversations.'
Their findings provide a rare glimpse into the scale of human distress inside the country during the pandemic.
One woman interviewed for the report said that there were so many deaths in nursing homes in the winter of 2020 that 'there weren't enough coffins'.
'Deaths and suffering due to suspected Covid-19 cases were widespread in North Korea starting in 2020,' well before it reported its first outbreak in May 2022, the report said.
'The government's negligence was nothing short of abominable,' it noted.
Citizens had virtually no access to vaccines, no anti-viral medications and minimal supply of personal protective equipment, although they had been available globally for more than a year, the report said.
Nearly 90 of the 100 interviewees said they had not been tested for Covid-19.
Nearly 40 reported not having received a vaccine during the pandemic.
And 92 said they suspected that they or people they knew had been infected, though there was no way to be sure.
Local health officials misreported Covid-19 deaths and diagnoses because of fear of punishment for not aligning with the government's claim that there were no cases, it said.
So did citizens, because reporting that they were sick did not bring help from the government but rather forced detention or even collective lockdowns, either of which would have worsened already-acute food shortages.
'This resulted in a doubling of misinformation whereby the government and citizenry each lied to the other, creating further spread of the pandemic,' the report said.
When the virus began spreading globally in early 2020, North Korea shut its borders and ordered troops to shoot to kill anyone trying to cross them.
It reported 'zero cases' of the virus until it admitted to an outbreak in May 2022.
But three months after that, North Korean state media declared a 'brilliant victory' in 'exterminating' the virus, thanking its leader, Mr Kim Jong Un, for 'his death-defying will for the people's happiness and well-being'.
Some nations like China helped contain infections, at least initially, by closing borders and enforcing lockdowns, as North Korea tried to.
But experts outside North Korea have long cast doubt on the North's pandemic-beating claims, in part because it lacked testing kits and laboratories to accurately track a major outbreak.
They have warned that the pandemic provided Mr Kim with excuses to tighten surveillance and control on his people even as his pandemic-related crackdown was bound to worsen the scarcity of food and medicine.
The report by the US research groups said that the interviews took place in the second half of 2023 through 'an organisation that has a successful track record of managing discrete and careful questionnaires in North Korea'.
Several non-governmental groups, some of them run by defectors from the North, gather information through informants inside North Korea.
The interviewees' accounts could not be independently verified in the famously closed-off country, but the assessment that the North's government shirked its responsibility echoed findings in a human rights report published by the South Korean government in 2024.
That report, based on the accounts of recent North Korean defectors, said that when North Korea began vaccinating pockets of its population starting in June 2022, health officials told them to thank Mr Kim's generosity because they said the vaccine 'cost as much as a cow'.
Mr Kim's regime sought to use the pandemic as political propaganda, the report by the two US research institutes also indicated.
Interviewees reported that state media reports often emphasised how bad outbreaks were in other countries, while claiming that North Korea was safe thanks to Mr Kim's leadership.
After finally admitting to an outbreak, North Korea accused South Korea of spreading the virus across the border.
More than one-third of the 100 interviewees still believed that South Korea sent the virus to their country, the report said. NYTIMES
Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Straits Times
2 hours ago
- Straits Times
Allergic reaction aboard SIA flight: What major airlines do to guard against triggering allergies
SINGAPORE – A Singapore Airlines flight was forced to make an emergency landing in October 2024 after a passenger suffered a severe shellfish allergy on board and had to be rushed to hospital. Dr Doreen Benary, 41, a resident of Manhattan, was flying from Frankfurt to New York City when she 'fell violently ill' after allegedly being served a meal containing shrimp. The plane was diverted to Paris, France. Dr Benary, a paediatrician, was rushed to hospital and then a second medical facility, where she underwent 'painful emergency treatment', according to court documents. She is suing the airline for negligence, claiming that she had warned flight attendants about the severity of her allergy – specifically, to shrimp. The incident, she said, caused her 'great pain, agony and mental anguish'. This is not SIA's first incident with an allergy mid-air. In 2017, a toddler went into anaphylactic shock and started vomiting when too many passengers around him started eating in-flight peanut snacks. The drug epinephrine is the first-line treatment in cases of anaphylaxis or severe allergic reactions. However, under United States Federal Aviation Administration requirements, for instance, easy-to-use auto-injector EpiPens are not required in on-board first aid kits. Some airlines carry epinephrine, but a trained medical professional is required to administer the correct dosage. Most airlines declare that allergen-free environments on board cannot be guaranteed, but several accommodations for passengers with dietary restrictions are offered. The Straits Times rounds up the practices of several major full-service airlines to guard against food allergies: 1. Singapore Airlines Since the 2017 incident, SIA no longer serves peanuts as snacks on flights. It still, however, serves other nuts like cashews and almonds, and signature local meals, like nasi lemak and satay, still contain peanuts. SIA recommends passengers refer to the in-flight menu page, which can be viewed up to eight days before the flight, although not all ingredients and allergens are listed. Alternatively, specific special meals, such as gluten-intolerant (no wheat, rye, barley, and bran in any form), seafood-free or a general allergen-free meal, can be selected at least 24 to 56 hours before flight departure, depending on the destination. 2. Cathay Pacific Hong Kong-based Cathay Pacific offers complimentary nut packets as a snack on flights. Passengers with nut allergies can request nut-free snacks, subject to availability, by submitting a physician's statement declaring their nut allergy via a form on its website. Although special dietary meals can be requested up to 24 hours before flying, Cathay Pacific does not offer meals suitable for certain common allergies such as gluten and dairy, and offer only 'gluten-intolerant' and 'low-lactose' meals respectively. Cathay Pacific suggests that passengers with severe allergies bring their own meals on board, wear a medical alert bracelet and carry an EpiPen that can be administered by their travel companion. Additionally, for added safety, they may request for priority boarding to wipe down their seat before the flight. 3. ANA For international flights, Japan's All Nippon Airways (ANA) is one of the few airlines that offer both an 'eight allergen-free meal' and a '28 allergen-free meal'. The eight allergen-free option excludes eight major allergens such as shellfish, eggs and tree nuts, as defined by Japanese food safety guidelines. The 28 allergen-free option goes a step further by excluding 20 additional allergens such as specific fruits, other meats, and gelatin. These meals are prepared in separate facilities to minimise the risk of cross-contamination, and must be requested 24 hours to eight days in advance before departure. ANA also offers an allergy buffer zone, or a designated area created around the passenger to minimise the risk of exposure to severe allergens. This must be requested, by phone, at least 48 hours before departure. 4. Qantas Australian carrier Qantas says it no longer offers peanuts as bar snacks on both flights and lounges and is minimising the use of peanut-based products in their meals. Other nut products are still served. It offers a gluten- and lactose-intolerant special meal service that can be requested up to 24 hours before departure. However, following 2024 changes to the in-flight menu, only the gluten-intolerant option is nut-free; Qantas does not offer allergy-specific meal options such as nut-free, dairy-free, or seafood-free meals. Travellers who bring their own meals cannot store or reheat them on board due to contamination concerns. 5. Emirates Emirates serves nuts on all flights, either as a meal ingredient or as an accompaniment to drinks. Special meals like gluten-friendly and low-lactose options can be requested at least 24 hours before departure. However, Emirates does not offer allergy-specific meals such as 'nut-free', 'dairy-free', or 'seafood-free' options. Those with severe allergies are encouraged to bring their own meals on board. That said, Emirates does not provide refrigeration or reheating. The airline advises passengers to bring their own medications, such as EpiPens, and to consult a doctor before flying. 6. Qatar Airways Doha-based Qatar Airways does not offer nut-free meals, and serves both peanuts and tree nuts on board. Those with severe allergies must submit a medical form at least 48 hours and no more than seven days before departure. Approved requests may result in a general announcement or seating accommodations, but these are not guaranteed. Customers who do not submit the form to disclose their allergies and instead declare it at check-in or on board the flight may be denied boarding due to safety considerations. These passengers will be required to sign a waiver before boarding. Qatar offers gluten-free and non-lactose special meals, which need to be requested at least 24 hours before departure. However, passengers with severe allergies are advised to bring their own food and necessary medication. While seafood-free meals are not explicitly offered, several vegetarian options can be chosen instead. 7. British Airways British Airways asks that passengers notify staff about any food allergy so they can inform passengers of any allergens contained in meals. In some instances, this information may also be available on the meal packaging. Its in-flight meals do not contain peanuts or peanut products, but may contain other nuts. Passengers with nut allergies can request the cabin crew to make an announcement, asking nearby passengers to refrain from eating nuts. BA offers a range of special meals, such as gluten-free, low-lactose and vegetarian for those sensitive to seafood. These need to be booked at least 48 hours in advance, or 24 hours if departing from London's Heathrow Airport – its main base. While there is no formal buffer zone or cleaning protocol, passengers with allergies are welcome to board early to wipe down their seating area. Carrying an EpiPen and bringing one's own food is strongly advised, though BA will not reheat personal meals. 8. Lufthansa German airline Lufthansa does not typically serve peanuts on its flights. It offers several special meal options, such as gluten- and lactose-intolerant, as well as vegetarian for those allergic to seafood. These special meals need to be requested at least 24 hours before departure and are generally offered only on longer-haul flights. In the event of severe allergic reactions during a flight, the airline states that its trained cabin crew are always equipped to provide emergency medical care. 9. Delta Airlines Delta from the US offers a formal allergy accommodation process through its Accessibility Service Request form. Although the cabin is not completely nut-free, if notified of a peanut allergy, the crew will refrain from serving peanut products during the flight. For food, animal or other allergies, passengers can board early to wipe down their seat area, or request a seat change. Other special meals, like gluten-free and diabetic-friendly meals, can be ordered at least 24 hours before departure, but allergy-specific meals are not available. Travellers are encouraged to bring their own food and carry necessary medication, including EpiPens. 10. United Airlines United does not serve peanuts in its meals or snacks. Passengers with severe food allergies are advised to notify a flight attendant, who can then ask nearby passengers to avoid consuming foods that may contain allergens. Special meals include vegan, gluten-friendly, kosher (food that adheres to Jewish dietary laws) and Asian vegetarian. They can be requested up to 24 hours before departure but are limited and not guaranteed on every flight. Passengers may also request to board early and wipe down their seat. Join ST's WhatsApp Channel and get the latest news and must-reads.
Straits Times
12 hours ago
- Straits Times
SAMH launches festival to raise mental health awareness among seniors
SINGAPORE – While some seniors blended tea and others came together in a drumming circle, Madam Kamala Devi Marimuthu was rolling dice in a game of mental wellness snakes and ladders. This adapted version of the childhood game encourages self-reflection by prompting players to answer questions related to everyday mental health challenges, and was among the 10 activities that seniors could partake in at an outreach festival organised by the Singapore Association for Mental Health (SAMH) on June 20. Madam Kamala found the game to be a dose of positivity. 'The volunteer who played the game with me was very friendly, he cracked a lot of jokes and made me really happy,' said the 80-year-old. The inaugural SAMH Golden Connect festival, being held at the non-profit's Space2Connect integrated wellness centre in Jalan Besar, is aimed at raising awareness of challenges faced by senior citizens, such as social isolation and mental health issues . Seniors aged 60 to 74 are the least likely age group to seek mental health support, whether from professionals or from their informal support networks, according to the 2023 National Population Health Survey conducted by the Ministry of Health and Health Promotion Board. At the event, Central Singapore District Mayor Denise Phua underscored the importance of maintaining mental health as a person ages, given the close connection it has with physical well-being. She highlighted instances of elderly loneliness in Jalan Besar, and encouraged seniors both to look out for one another and to tap the support of organisations such as SAMH, especially for cases that do not require institutionalisation. 'As we get older, so do our neighbours. So please be more compassionate...(not) every time something happens, we must send them to the Institute of Mental Health,' she said. The festival also saw the debut of a mental health screening application powered by artificial intelligence that can detect symptoms of anxiety and depression for early intervention. The application, developed by Singapore-based company Opsis Emotion AI, involves a series of questions and video clips to be watched. As a person undergoes the 10-minute evaluation, the application assesses his emotional state through real-time analysis of facial expressions and body language, and produces a report for SAMH professionals to interpret. Ms Jane Goh, deputy director of creative services and youth at SAMH, said the tool complements the association's existing face-to-face screening processes. 'This is useful for clients who might not be able to articulate their emotions very well but might still want to convey certain things,' she said. The tool will be rolled out at SAMH's premises from June 20, and will eventually be extended to other age groups that SAMH supports, such as youth and adults. Among the 200 people that attended the festival on its opening day was Mr Hassan Arshad, 76. He felt that the activities were very meaningful, and looked forward to joining more of SAMH's programmes. Adjunct Associate Professor Lee Cheng, president of SAMH, said community outreach has been at the heart of the association's work since it was started in 1968, and remains a vital part of its efforts to support mental wellness across people's life stages. He noted that the two-day festival involved numerous community partners, including the Jalan Besar Active Ageing Centre, Kallang CC Community Drumming Circle, and student volunteers from Republic Polytechnic, the Singapore University of Social Sciences, and Raffles Girls' School. 'Through strong community partnerships, we can bridge gaps, build trust, and make support more accessible,' he added. 'We want every senior to know they are not alone, and that care and joy are within reach.' Join ST's WhatsApp Channel and get the latest news and must-reads.
Straits Times
16 hours ago
- Straits Times
New initiative to help young people with poor mental health when ‘red flags' appear
Minister of State for Health Rahayu Mahzam (third from right) at the launch event for the new initiative. ST PHOTO: AZMI ATHNI New initiative to help young people with poor mental health when 'red flags' appear SINGAPORE – Young people with poor mental health will get more help through a programme that trains school counsellors and social workers to spot red flags and tackle distress before it escalates. The initiative launched on June 20 addresses a mental health crisis among Singapore's adolescents, which had brewed silently until the Covid-19 pandemic, said Dr Angelina Ang, a senior consultant in the emergency department of KK Women's and Children's Hospital (KKH) who heads the programme. It comes after the hospital studied patients aged 10 to 19 who had been admitted to its emergency department in 2021 for trying to harm or kill themselves. The study, published in February, found that about one in five of these adolescents had visited a hospital or polyclinic for medically unexplained physical symptoms like headaches and stomachaches within the year prior to attempting self-harm or suicide. Said Dr Ang: 'Medically unexplained symptoms are red flags – symptoms of distress, anxiety, or maybe even abuse, and if we continue to sweep them under the carpet, they will crash on the child.' Difficulties sleeping, dealing with family conflict and anxieties related to academic performance were the top challenges faced by these adolescents. More than half the patients who attempted self-harm or suicide said they were confused or unsure about whether they truly wanted to end their lives, which suggests that their decisions can be driven by impulse and inability to process their emotions. The price paid for ignoring such signs is huge, said Dr Ang, citing a 2023 report by Duke-NUS Medical School and the Institute of Mental Health estimating that the cost to treat a child for depression and anxiety here averaged $10,250. To plug these gaps, the programme developed by psychologists from KKH and James Cook University (JCU) teaches community groups how to intervene when young people display these physical symptoms and have difficulty managing emotions. Since October 2024, more than 300 school counsellors and community mental health practitioners have been trained, KKH and Temasek Foundation, said in a joint statement. Parked under the Temasek Foundation Youth Connect programme, the initiative is complemented by screening at KKH's emergency department that coordinates care for these young people with schools and communities. KKH chief executive Alex Sia said since such screening was implemented since October 2022, it has assessed more than 2,500 young people, and provided support to over 1,300 of them . In addition, Dr Ang said the collaboration between KKH and JCU is developing a programme to tackle sleep habits of the young, which is an easier topic to broach than mental health. The programme remains in the works, but the team has started training community groups and professionals to deliver these interventions. Minister of State for Health Rahayu Mahzam said at the launch event at KKH that the Youth Connect Programme allows for a seamless care system that can minimise the risk of young people falling through the cracks. She added: 'Today's launch is more than just a new programme for mental health support. 'It represents our collective commitment – regardless of our area of work – to support young people that we meet, in ways that best suit them.' The programme joins a nationwide push for more to be done to address the mental health crisis plaguing Singapore's teens, with one in three young people reporting severe symptoms of depression, anxiety or stress, according to a recent nationwide survey. Mental disorders are the leading cause of disability and death among those aged 10 to 14 in Singapore, according to a study published in The Lancet Public Health medical journal in May. The study also ranked Singapore top in Asean for the impact of mental distress on its population. Despite many of Singapore's adolescents reporting signs of mental distress, a nationwide study of youth mental health by the National University of Singapore flagged a gap in their parent's understanding of the issues that their children faced. The study released in 2023 found that only about one in 10 parents observed signs of distress in their children, despite one in three reporting symptoms like depression and anxiety. Helplines Mental well-being Institute of Mental Health's Mental Health Helpline: 6389-2222 (24 hours) Samaritans of Singapore: 1-767 (24 hours) / 9151-1767 (24 hours CareText via WhatsApp) Singapore Association for Mental Health: 1800-283-7019 Silver Ribbon Singapore: 6386-1928 Chat, Centre of Excellence for Youth Mental Health: 6493-6500/1 Women's Helpline (Aware): 1800-777-5555 (weekdays, 10am to 6pm) Counselling Touchline (Counselling): 1800-377-2252 Touch Care Line (for caregivers): 6804-6555 Counselling and Care Centre: 6536-6366 We Care Community Services: 3165-8017 Clarity Singapore: 6757-7990 Online resources (for those aged 13 to 25) (for those aged 12 to 25) Join ST's WhatsApp Channel and get the latest news and must-reads.
