Police chief blames state, doesn't address rise of violent crime in clip after OTR killing
Cincinnati Police Chief Teresa Theetge placed the blame for the fatal stabbing of an Over-the-Rhine man on the state for not telling them the accused killer, on probation, had broken off his ankle monitor months earlier.
Theetge said in a video released the evening of June 10 that her officers must be able to trust the people they arrest will be prosecuted and held accountable after they are released.
It's the first public comment by the chief since the killing of 46-year-old Patrick Heringer on June 4. Through her spokesman, Theetge has declined multiple requests for an interview with The Enquirer this past week.
The killing shocked the city and raised fears about crime and public safety, particularly in Heringer's Over-the-Rhine neighborhood.
Police say Heringer was fatally stabbed inside his East McMicken Avenue home by 38-year-old Mordecia Black, a recently released convicted felon who is now facing charges of murder and aggravated burglary.
Black, prosecutors said at his arraignment, was released from prison on probation with an ankle monitor in January. He cut off his ankle monitor a month later and has been on the run since.
Theetge and Cincinnati Mayor Aftab Pureval said city police were never notified when Black cut off his ankle monitor.
More: Mayor meets with wife of slain OTR man, says suspect 'should not have been walking free'
"Law enforcement is only one part of the public safety puzzle," Theetge said in the video statement. "When we arrest and charge violent offenders, there must be clear policies and procedures in place to manage their reintegration into society, and to ensure they are held accountable to the conditions of their post-release supervision."
JoEllen Smith, a spokeswoman for the Ohio Department of Rehabilitation and Corrections, said the state lost track of Black after he was released, Enquirer media partner Fox 19 reports. The Enquirer has reached out to the agency for more information about how that could happen.
The mayor echoed much of what the chief said earlier, telling The Enquirer in a statement he is ready to help "champion needed reforms at the state level."
In the video, Theetge also read the names of five homicide victims who have been killed within the past two weeks: Treasure Thomas, Laura Schueler, Jayshaun Cornelius, Jevon Kirk and Heringer.
"The truth is painful. We do not have a crystal ball. We cannot always predict when or where violence will strike," Theetge said. "What we can do and will do is continue to serve as a barrier between good and evil."
The second-year chief called for more officers, referencing a rising number of retirements to the roughly 1,000-person force. She touched on an uptick in certain property crimes, but did not address the state of violent crime in the city.
More: Cincinnati sees uptick in violent crime in 2025; all crime up in Over-the-Rhine
A review of city data by The Enquirer shows there have been more violent crimes citywide so far this year than in most recent years, according to year-to-date data since 2021. Only 2024 was higher.
City data shows there have been 778 violent crime incidents so far this year. On average, over the past four years, there were 732 violent crimes year-to-date.
Homicides and shootings are both down citywide. Fatal and nonfatal shootings are down by about 25% compared to the same time last year and are lower than they've been since at least 2022.
Homicides, including stabbings, are down about 15% and are at the lowest levels they've been at since at least 2021.
Ahead of their respective public statements on June 10, Theetge and Pureval both met privately with Heringer's wife, Sarah Heringer. In a letter she read to a Local12 reporter, Sarah said she watched her husband bleed out in front of her.
More: Mayor meets with wife of slain OTR man, says suspect 'should not have been walking free'
Pureval wouldn't discuss details of the meeting with Sarah Heringer but, in a statement, said the man accused of the crime "should not have been walking free."
In a Facebook post after the meeting, Sarah Heringer said she wants to know why there was "no system connecting the parole board with local law enforcement."
'I told him directly: that is something I hold him accountable for,' Sarah Heringer wrote on Facebook. 'I also told him he needs to find out what other holes exist in his system before another family pays the price. He agreed to do that.'
She vowed that she will work with the city on reforming the system and sharing the results with the public "every step of the way." Sarah Heringer said she wants to make sure this doesn't happen again to someone else.
Enquirer reporter Scott Wartman contributed to this story.
This article originally appeared on Cincinnati Enquirer: Cincinnati Police Chief blames state for Over-the-Rhine man's killing
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Post
2 days ago
- New York Post
Investigators reveal disturbing details surrounding private jet crash that killed The Devil Wears Prada drummer, 5 others
The runway lights that would have helped guide a doomed private jet carrying The Devil Wears Prada drummer Daniel Williams and music industry big shot Dave Shapiro before it crashed in San Diego hadn't been working since 2022, federal investigators revealed. The jet was also coming in too low in foggy weather and struck power lines as it attempted to descend into the Montgomery-Gibbs Executive Airport, according to the investigators. The details on the May 22 crash that killed all six passengers were laid bare in the National Transportation Safety Board's preliminary report published Wednesday. 4 Williams performs at the Rockstar Energy Drink Mayhem Festival at San Manuel Amphitheater on June 30, 2012, in San Bernardino, California. Getty Images In addition to the lower-than-average descent and non-existent runway lights, the NTSB determined several other factors also led up to the tragedy — including the pilot not discussing alternate airport weather conditions with the air traffic controller. The pilot had acknowledged that weather conditions weren't ideal and debated diverting to a different airport while discussing the visibility with the controller, according to audio. 4 Debris covers the ground after a small plane crashed into a San Diego neighborhood. AP 4 Authorities work the scene where a small plane crashed into a San Diego neighborhood, setting several homes on fire and forcing evacuations along several blocks early Thursday, May 22, 2025. AP But the pilot declared 'I think we'll be alright' before going ahead with the landing attempt. The FAA had posted an official notice for pilots that the runway alignment lights were out of service, but NTSB investigators noted that had been the case since 2022 due to delayed repairs. It wasn't immediately clear if the pilot, who had been based at the airport, knew the lights were out of service at the time. The NTSB added, too, that the plane was only about 60 feet above the ground — almost 200 feet lower than required — when it struck the power lines. 4 Former The Devil Wears Prada drummer Daniel Williams shared haunting photos to his Instagram story of the plane he was taking to California hours before it crashed. @xcadaverx/Instagram An official cause of the crash hasn't yet been determined. The NTSB's final report will be issued later this year. With Post wires
Miami Herald
3 days ago
- Miami Herald
Antonio Brown, Miami shooting victim entangled in years-long legal war, records show
Former NFL star Antonio Brown shot at a man outside a Miami boxing event last month, police say. Newly obtained court records reveal that the two weren't strangers: In fact, there's been a burgeoning beef between Brown and the victim, namely a lengthy legal battle that dates back to 2022 when the man spent a month behind bars in a Middle Eastern jail after Brown falsely accused him of stealing $3 million worth of jewelry. Zul-Qarnain Kwame Nantambu, a 41-year-old who designs and sells jewelry, met Brown in May 2022 when he was invited to accompany boxer Floyd Mayweather to an exhibition fight in Dubai, United Arab Emirates. Brown was there to promote his music career and was going to rap during Mayweather's ring walk before the fight. As the pair got to know each other, Nantambu let Brown sport a custom-made pendant with a diamond chain worth $122,000, which Brown posted to social media, court records reveal. On several occasions, Nantambu attempted to get the chain back, but Brown didn't return it; instead, Brown gave Nantambu two of his gold chains as collateral. Brown then contacted Dubai police and told them that Nantambu had stolen $3 million worth of his jewelry, according to the filing. Nantambu was arrested and held in jail without bond on theft charges. He was released a month later — and his charges were dropped — only after showing prosecutors evidence that Brown's claim was false. READ MORE: Where's Antonio Brown? Facing attempted murder, wanted NFL star left the country Three years after their ordeal, Brown, 36, shot at Nantambu after a dispute escalated on May 16 after an event hosted by social media influencer Adin Ross. After the shooting, Brown said on social media that he was attacked by people trying to steal his jewelry. Brown is wanted on an attempted murder charge, according to a seven-page warrant signed on June 11 by Miami-Dade Circuit Court Judge Ariel Rodriguez. When Brown is arrested, his bond will be set at $10,000 plus house arrest. The Herald's review of Brown's latest posts indicate that he has been in Dubai. Miami Police Chief Manny Morales told the Herald that detectives have been in contact with Brown's attorney and expect him to be taken into custody once he returns to South Florida. In August 2022, Nantambu took Brown to Broward circuit court, seeking the return of the diamond chain and pendant as well as damages for his wrongful detention in Dubai. Brown, the lawsuit says, was the last person seen with the jewelry and wore it at the Mayweather fight — while Nantambu sat in jail. The suit also accuses Brown of taking the items that were on Nantambu's person when he was arrested, which comprised of a gold chain and $6,000 in cash. A judge awarded Nantambu just under $970,000 in damages after Brown failed to respond to the lawsuit. That judgment, however, was overturned after a procedural issue. Brown filed for bankruptcy in May 2024, barring a retrial of Nantambu's lawsuit. A copy of Nantambu's lawsuit was attached to a filing in Brown's ongoing bankruptcy case in Fort Lauderdale federal court. Records show Brown stated that he has less than $50,000 in assets and owed anywhere from $1 million to $10 million— the bulk of the listed debt in damages stemming from lawsuits. The Miami Herald reached out to Nantambu and his attorney but hasn't received a response as of Wednesday afternoon. An attorney for Brown couldn't be reached. On social media, Brown has accused police of 'making up fake charges to get publicity.' 'Tried to steal my jewelry' The day after the shooting, Brown said in a post on X that he was 'jumped' by people 'who tried to steal my jewelry and cause physical harm to me.' Brown was detained — but not arrested — after the gunfire outside the venue, a warehouse located at 221 NE 67th St. in Miami's Little River neighborhood. 'Contrary to some video circulating, Police temporarily detained me until they received my side of the story and then released me. I WENT HOME THAT NIGHT AND WAS NOT ARRESTED,' Brown said in the post. 'I will be talking to my legal council and attorneys on pressing charges on the individuals that jumped me.' Video posted to social media showed the All-Pro wide receiver appearing to hold a gun and running out of frame. Seconds later, gunshots were heard. Detectives reviewed security footage that captured Brown and two others attacking Nantambu before the shooting, according to the warrant. Security broke up the fight, and Nantambu walked away. Then, Brown took a gun from a security guard before running after Nantambu. Video captured Brown chasing Nantambu to the sidewalk and firing two shots from close range. Nantambu, the warrant says, ducked as shots rang out. When searched, no firearm was found on Brown, although police found two spent shell casings and a damaged right-handed holster outside the venue, according to the warrant. Brown was released because the man shot, later identified as Nantambu, was no longer at the venue. Nantambu told police he left to seek medical attention. Per detectives, Nantambu said he tried to leave after Brown attacked him. But Brown, he asserted, chased him with a gun and fired at him — possibly grazing his neck. The two struggled over the gun before ending up on the ground, Nantambu told police. When officers arrived, Nantambu said Brown hid the weapon under a dark piece of cloth and walked away. READ MORE: Ex-NFL star Antonio Brown is no stranger to police, discipline in his career Over the years, Brown — a Super Bowl champion wide receiver who was in the NFL for more than a decade — has been enmeshed in a litany of bizarre on-field incidents and off-field controversies, some of which led to legal woes. Most notably, in 2020, Brown pleaded no contest to assaulting a moving truck driver over a payment dispute at his Hollywood home. He was sentenced to two years of probation and was ordered to undergo a psychological evaluation and to participate in a 13-week anger management program. Two years after the attack, a civil court jury ordered Brown to pay the truck driver $1.2 million in damages Brown, a Miami Norland High graduate, had his NFL career abruptly ended in 2021 when he ran off the field while suiting up for the Tampa Bay Buccaneers against the New York Jets.
Yahoo
4 days ago
- Yahoo
Emerson Colindres, detained soccer star, is scared for his future, fellow ICE inmates
CHEVIOT, Ohio ‒ About a week ago, Emerson Colindres was thinking about applying for college. Now he fears being deported to Honduras, a country he left when he was just 8 years old and barely remembers. "I'm scared because I don't know what's going to happen, not to me or anybody here," he told The Enquirer by phone from jail after calling his mom. Colindres, who is 19 years old, lived with his mom and 16-year-old sister in a duplex in Cheviot, a Cincinnati suburb. Now, he's sleeping in a bunk bed in a housing block with other ICE inmates at the Butler County Jail in Southwest Ohio, which has a contract with U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement. It's been eight days. He hasn't eaten much besides Cup Noodles soup. He's a picky eater, he said. And he's calling his mom a lot. It's the only thing that's helped him feel better. "At first I was struggling a lot. I've been calling my mom a lot. Calling her has helped," he said. "It's been hard. I can't see her. I've never not seen her – not even on FaceTime, nothing like that ‒ for so long. So, it's been hard, and the mental aspect of it has been pretty hard." Colindres, whose full name is Emerson Colindres Baquedano, was arrested by ICE on June 4, jail records show. His mom, Ada Bell Baquedano Amador, has been able to speak to him by phone, but she hasn't visited him. She's afraid to go to the jail because she and her daughter also lack legal immigration status. ICE officials told Baquedano Amador she and her daughter have 30 days to leave the country. In the days since Colindres' arrest, hundreds of people in Greater Cincinnati have protested the standout soccer player's detention. He's heard about the protests and said other ICE detainees at the jail have, too. "I'm really grateful," he said. "I know it's for me, but it's not just for me. A lot of people here are in the same situation. Some are in worse ones. "They're feeling sad because they've been separated from their babies, their wives, their families. So, they're feeling sad," he said. "That's what they tell me; that's what I see in people's faces." "It helps me mentally," Colindres said, "knowing there are people out there who care about me." Colindres was scheduled to meet with ICE agents at their suburban Cincinnati office in Blue Ash last week to get a GPS ankle monitor, an alternative to detention that ICE uses to track immigrants. "We showed up. They put my mom and me in a room," he recalled. "There were ICE officers there, and they said, 'We've got to take you right now.' Not 30 days to get out of the country or anything ‒ right now." In her living room, surrounded by photos and posters of her son, Baquedano Amador said she felt that ICE agents "deceived" him. "He told me, 'Mom, don't leave me here. I don't want to be locked up,'" she told The Enquirer tearfully in Spanish. "No one, especially as a mom, can imagine seeing your child go to a place where people that cause harm deserve to be," she said. Colindres has no criminal record. When he was arrested during his ICE check-in, he became part of a national trend that ramped up after the Trump Administration raised daily arrest quotas for ICE. "When people go for their check-ins, they're being arrested. When people go to their court hearings, they're being arrested," said Cincinnati immigration attorney Nazly Mamedova. "Sometimes ICE is waiting for you, even if your case has not been completed yet, they're waiting for you behind the court doors." Mamedova said there have been many arrests at the ICE office in Blue Ash. ICE did not respond to The Enquirer's emailed questions about arrests at the office. Colindres' mom said his cellmate was also arrested at the office that day. He was called there to have his ankle monitor removed. 'I ask for (Butler County) Sheriff Richard Jones to be a little more pious with immigrants," Baquedano Amador said. "Even for criminals, the treatment should be better, as well as the jail's conditions.' Fleeing persecution from gangs in Honduras, Colindres' mom applied for asylum when she arrived in the United States with her two small children in 2014. A judge denied her application. Asylum seekers must prove their government is persecuting them or that they're being persecuted by someone who the government is unable or unwilling to stop. If an application is denied, asylum seekers can appeal that decision, and those appeals can take several years. Baquedano Amador's appeals were unsuccessful. The family of three was given a final order of removal in August 2023, she said, which meant they were considered deportable by ICE. But before President Donald Trump entered office, Colindres would have been a low-priority case to ICE because he has no criminal record. That's changed since Trump promised to deport millions of people and his administration set a 3,000 daily arrest goal for ICE agents. "In the last administration, they (ICE) were more going after people with criminal records and people who posed a danger to the community," Mamedova said. "With this administration, they're no longer prioritizing. They're just going after everyone." While his mom and sister have been given 30 days to leave the United States, it's unclear when Colindres could be deported. Before his arrest, Bryan Williams, Colindres' coach on the Cincy Galaxy soccer club, was helping him get offers to play soccer at colleges. Since then, he said, "the focus has shifted." But even with Colindres in jail, Williams is still working to get him college soccer offers. "If he gets offers to go to school and play soccer, we hope that means he'll be able to live and remain here," he said. "He's got potential to do big things in soccer. We want to take advantage of that." The weekend after his arrest, some of Colindres' Cincy Galaxy teammates talked to him on the phone. Preston Robinson, his teammate since 2019, told Colindres about the NBA Finals, since he hadn't been able to watch it. "We would always goof around," Robinson, 18, said about his friend. "I'm not very outgoing myself, but he talks to everyone, and he talked to me." On June 8, after talking to Colindres on the phone, Robinson and other teammates joined a protest for him in front of the Butler County jail. "He was just expecting to go to a check-in," Robison said. "And then he was taken away." This story was updated to add a video. This article originally appeared on Cincinnati Enquirer: Ohio man arrested at routine ICE check-in part of national trend
