IMF says talks on budget to continue
Listen to article
The International Monetary Fund (IMF) on Saturday returned to Washington without formally concluding discussions, saying that the talks would continue in coming days with a view to "agreeing on the budget", in a statement that shows gaps between the two sides.
"We will continue discussions towards agreeing over the authorities' fiscal year 2026 budget over the coming days," stated Nathan Porter, the outgoing Mission Chief to Pakistan, in a statement issued after the end of 10-day talks held on the contours of the new budget.
Porter said that the discussions focused on actions to enhance revenueincluding by bolstering compliance and expanding the tax baseand prioritise expenditure".
The IMF mission was scheduled to arrive in Pakistan on May 13 till May 23 but due to India-Pakistan tensions, it held the first round of talks from Turkyia. The face-to-face discussions began on May 19 from Islamabad but did not conclude within the pre-agreed timeframe.
The IMF said that its staff visit was focused on recent economic developments, programme implementation, and the budget strategy for fiscal year 2026.
The government sources said that there was broader understanding on the next fiscal year's overarching goal of primary budget surplus; however, there were gaps in the understanding of both sides, particularly over the modus operandi to reach the goal.
Porter said that the authorities concerned reaffirmed their commitment to fiscal consolidation while safeguarding social and priority expenditures, aiming for a primary surplus of 1.6% of GDP in FY2026.
At the next fiscal year's projected size of the economy, the surplus will be equal to nearly Rs2.1 trillion, which is slightly lower than what the Ministry of Finance stated last week.
Interestingly, the IMF said that based on the preliminary findings of this mission, the IMF staff will prepare a report that, subject to management approval, will be presented to the IMF's Executive Board for discussion and decision.
The government sources said still no consensus had been reached over the next fiscal year's tax target, some revenue measures and relief to certain sectors. They said that the target would depend on the spending outlays for the three major heads of the budget.
There were also gaps on the points of giving relief to the salaried class, the real estate sector and taxing of pensions, said the sources.
Last week, Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif termed the proposed relief for the salaried class by the FBR as insufficient and instead asked the tax machinery to secure more relief. The senior FBR and the finance ministry negotiators said that the quantum of the salaried class relief was not yet decided.
The sources said that the IMF asked Pakistan to propose alternate measures to provide relief to the salaried class. The Fund suggested imposing taxes on high-end pensioners and using the money for providing relief to the salaried class.
However, the IMF's condition to link relief for the salaried class with other measures which, in fact, is a reversal of injustice done to it in the last budget, was not justified.
The salaried class has already paid Rs437 billion in income tax compared to less than Rs4 million by the traders.
The IMF's statement on broadening the tax base seems cosmetic, as it did not do anything against the government's failure to collect due taxes from retailers.
The sources said that the government's view about taxing the pensioners was that it would be a politically difficult decision to tax the high-end pensioners.
The government is again inclined to provide relief to the realty sector, particularly reducing the transaction taxes, which is not in line with the IMF policy for the sector. The IMF had already agreed to abolish the federal excise duty, FBR Chairman Rashid Langrial said last month.
Nathan said that the IMF "held constructive discussions with the authorities on their fiscal year 2026 budget proposals and broader economic policy, and reform agenda supported by the 2024 Extended Fund Facility (EFF) and the 2025 Resilience and Sustainability Facility (RSF)".
Porter said that discussions also covered ongoing energy sector reforms aimed at improving financial viability and reducing the high-cost structure of Pakistan's power sector as well as other structural reforms which will help foster sustainable growth and promote a more level playing field for business and investment.
The sources said that the IMF did not agree to the Power Division to allocate nearly 1% of the GDP power subsidies and consented to give Rs1.04 trillion.
The government has already delayed the budget by over one week to June 10th after it could not timely sort out all the issues before approving the summary to announce the budget on June 2.
Porter said that Pakistan also emphasized their commitment to ensuring sound macroeconomic policy making and building buffers. "In this context, maintaining an appropriately tight and data-dependent monetary policy remains a priority to ensure inflation is anchored within the central bank's medium-term target range of 5-7%" said Porter.
Porter reiterated his earlier statement and emphasized that "rebuilding foreign exchange reserve buffers, preserving a fully functioning FX market, and allowing for greater exchange rate flexibility are critical to strengthening resilience to external shocks".
Despite the IMF programme, Pakistan this time is not able to fetch in major foreign loans due to a poor credit rating.
Porter said that the IMF team will remain engaged and continue its close dialogue with the authorities and the next mission associated with the next EFF and RSF reviews is expected in the second half of 2025.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
4 hours ago
- Business Recorder
COAS Munir's praiseworthy ‘decisiveness'
That COAS Asim Munir is leading from the front is a fact that has found its best expression from the praise that he has earned from US President Donald Trump for his 'decisiveness' amid a profound crisis is a fact. Indeed, the COAS deserves such praise for his highly impressive leadership that he displayed during the four-day Pakistan-India conflict last month. No doubt, it is a fact that cannot be emphasized enough. In a related development, the COAS has made it clear to all and sundry Pakistan's approach to a variety of challenges facing the world in general and the region in particular. In his interaction in the US capital with prominent think tanks and the representatives of the strategic affairs institutions, the COAS has pointed out that there exists convergence of interests between the US and Pakistan, particularly in areas such as counterterrorism, regional security and economic development. In my view, therefore, the army chief has been receiving kudos for all the right reasons. He has done the nation and the institution that he heads proud. Samina Rahman (Karachi) Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Business Recorder
13 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Arrests for tax fraud: major changes made in sales tax law thru Finance Bill
ISLAMABAD: The Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) has introduced major changes in sales tax law through Finance Bill 2025 for the arrest of those involved in tax evasion or tax fraud. According to a statement issued by the FBR on Friday, Finance bill is currently being discussed in the National Assembly and among various business circles. An impression has been created that some of the amendments introduced in the Finance Bill are not understood well by the public at large. Arrest for tax fraud: Senate panel for defining a threshold For instance, the legal provisions for the arrest of those involved in a tax fraud have already been provided under Section 37A of the Sales Tax Act, 1990 along with an elaborate procedure to be followed after the arrest which involves intimating the Special Judge immediately and the production of such person before Special Judge within 24 hours. However, the proposed amendment now restricts the powers of the officer to arrest by making prior inquiry after approval of the Commissioner Inland Revenue (CIR). Only on the basis of the findings of the inquiry CIR will authorise the investigation which would give the investigation officer the powers of an officer in charge of a police station under Code of Criminal Procedure, 1898 (Act V of 1898). The arrest can only be made with the prior approval of CIR if the investigation officer has reasons to believe that a tax fraud may have been committed by a person. The FBR further stated that the new legal provision further provides that if the arrest is malafide, the matter will be referred to the Chief Commissioner for fact finding inquiry. This shows that in contrast to the earlier provision where an Assistant CIR could arrest an offender, the new provisions bring transparency in the process by a mandatory prior inquiry and investigation and finally permission by the CIR. Moreover, certain changes and amendments are also necessary to reassure the compliant taxpayers that those evading taxes or involved in tax fraud are dealt with by the state with an iron hand. FBR Chairman Rashid Mahmood Langrial has expressed his willingness to discuss the recent changes made in the tax laws and introduce changes wherever needed, for example, the provisions related to arrest could be revised to mandate the permission of multiple senior officers before any arrest. Furthermore, in order to ensure that these powers are not misused by the authorised tax officers against the compliant taxpayers and business community, Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif has formed a high-powered committee, which will be headed by Minister for Finance and Revenue, to re-evaluate the proposed amendments and suggest adequate safeguards to prevent potential misuse of powers. The other members of the Committee will include Ministers of Law and Economic Affairs Division, Minister of State for Finance, SAPM Industries and Chairman FBR. The Committee will also examine various options to ensure that legal economic activities are not stifled and propose additional protective measures against unlawful use of authority. The Committee will submit its recommendations to Prime Minister in three days. FBR is committed to safeguard the legal rights of the compliant taxpayers and to increase the tax collection and state revenues by discouraging non-compliant taxpayers and acknowledging those who are paying their due share to the state, FBR added. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Business Recorder
13 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Import of up to 5-year-old used vehicles allowed with 40% extra tariff
ISLAMABAD: The government has allowed import of up to five-year-old/used vehicles imported in commercial quantities along with 40 percent additional import tariff in budget (2025-26). During review of Finance Bill (2025-26) on Friday, Ministry of Commerce Secretary Jawad Paul informed Senate Standing Committee on Finance that the time period for the import of old/used vehicles under the baggage scheme has not been changed and overseas Pakistanis would continue to import three-year-old vehicles under baggage scheme. The facility of five years has only been extended on the commercial import of old and used vehicles. From September 1, 2025, the commercial import of five years old vehicles would be allowed. Tariff rationalisation: Rs500bn revenue loss estimated However, there would be an additional tariff protection of 40 percent on such vehicles in 2025-26. In the next four years, the 40 percent additional import tariff would be zero on the import of used and old vehicles. The 40 percent additional import duties during 2025-26 would be reduced to 30 percent in subsequent fiscal year and finally zero-percent duty in coming years. In future, the import of 6-7 years old vehicles would also be allowed. The quantity and standards would be maintained to ensure that old and used vehicles should not create environment related problems in the country. Chairman of the Senate Standing Committee on Finance Saleem Mandviwalla stated that the same time period of five years should apply on the import of vehicles under the baggage scheme as well as commercial import of vehicles. The government should give same treatment on the import of vehicles by overseas Pakistanis and commercial importers. However, the government must ensure that 40 percent additional tariff should not be applicable on the import of five years old vehicles under the baggage scheme. There should be no distinction between the vehicles imported under the baggage scheme and commercial imports, Mandviwalla maintained. The commerce secretary stated that the gift scheme is being misused on the import of old and used vehicles. The tariff reductions would be applicable on new auto sector policy after June 30, 2026, he said. Finance Minister Muhammad Aurangzeb said that we have given enough tariff protection to domestic sectors/industries. The FBR Member Customs Policy stated that the government has not touched auto sector during tariff rationalisation during 2025-26. The government has reportedly received No Objection from International Monetary Fund (IMF) for import of five-year old used cars in the country, sources in Commerce Ministry told Business Recorder. The import of used cars will commence from September 2025 on commercial basis as current regime of import of three-year old used cars by overseas Pakistan will be discontinued. The decision has been taken in light of proposals prepared by the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) which was making hectic efforts to allow import of five-year used cars aimed at increasing its revenue through imports. However, the issue of arrangement of foreign exchange will be a gigantic task as State Bank of Pakistan (SBP) will not remit forex for import of five-year used cars due to difficulties. Local auto industry, mainly dominated by the Japanese companies had opposed the proposal at every level but FBR did not agree citing different reasons. The government will gradually phase out regulatory duties and slash tariffs on Completely Built-Up (CBU) vehicles to below 10 percent, with a broader goal of bringing auto-sector tariffs down to single digits within five years. The personnel baggage scheme, transfer of residence and gift scheme were reportedly misused on the import of old and used vehicles. Under the law, overseas Pakistanis are entitled to import vehicles under personnel baggage scheme, transfer of residence and gift scheme who have not imported, gifted or received a vehicle during the last two years under Import Policy Order (IPO), 2022. The Customs department will not charge 18 percent sales tax on auction of serviceable old and used vehicles in case sales tax was paid at the time of local or import stage. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
