Why are ungraded cards starting to sell for more than cards graded in mint condition?
Trading card collectors and dealers largely view grading as the ultimate arbiter of the condition and value of the card. In other words, if a company like leading card grader PSA says your card is a Mint 9 (on a 1-10 scale) even though you can't perceive any flaw, it's stuck there, encased for eternity like a prehistoric insect in amber. It's frozen in time in that eternal state.
Advertisement
It's at the point now that a modern card with a 'mint' grade (a 9) is often worth less than a card not graded at all. That's because the ungraded ('raw' in the parlance of the hobby) card holds the possibility of being a 10 if it gets graded. But a 9 will always just be a 9, the thinking goes. But what if the arbiter is arbitrary? A recent YouTube video by a Pokemon collector who believed many of his 9s deserved gem-mint 10s seems to prove that grading is quite subjective. Minor flaws that prevent a perfect grade initially can be overlooked when the card is cracked out of its plastic tomb and resubmitted. It's as if the flaw(s) were never there at all.
YouTube creator 'Pokemon Steven' sent 189 cards that he thought were perfect but were graded a notch below by PSA back for regrading after cracking them out of their slabs. Most were regraded the same way. But a couple were graded as altered/trimmed upon second look and others were graded lower/worse than a 9, sometimes by multiple grades. But 81 came back perfect 10s. That's 43 percent deemed worthy of a higher grade upon another look unbeknownst to PSA, of course.
And if you think that was some fluke, PokeTCGivaways showed on its X account a resubmission, with labels as proof, of 15 mostly 9s but two graded an 8 ('near mint-mint'). Of those, 11 came back with new grades — 10 upgraded to a 10 and one of the 8s downgraded to a 7.
When asked whether differences between a 9 and 10 are so minor that cards just teeter between them, the account responded, 'Maybe. I also think a lot of graders will have different opinions and it all depends on who you get grading your cards.'
If you're wondering why these examples are trading card game (TCG) cards and not sports, a big reason is the majority of the 100,000 cards graded daily (all graders, not just PSA) are TCG (most of those being Pokemon, according to GemRate, which tracks grading trends). But cardboard is cardboard, and if TCG grades are changing at such a high rate, there's no reason to think sports cards would not follow the same pattern.
Advertisement
This does not necessarily mean you should crack your 9s and resubmit, though.
'Under no circumstances, do not follow in my footsteps,' Pokemon Steven said on his video. 'This is reckless and a waste of money. Two grading fees. Shipping fees. (I paid) $40 per card. Some cards (I resubmitted) are not even worth $40.' He said he did it because he specifically collects 10s and felt those cards deserved the perfect grade; it had nothing to do with money.
But this admittedly crazy experiment that executor says should not be repeated shows that there may be a market inefficiency in dismissing cards graded less than gem mint as lower in value than ungraded ones. Sure, the raw card may be a 10; for Topps 2025 Baseball about 21 percent of submissions get the perfect grade. But that's less than half the rate of Mint 9s that get turned into a 10 on resubmission, according to these Pokemon collectors. So why not take the steep discount that's often 50 percent or more on a graded 9? If the market for the player explodes, the owner can release it from its slab and try again for a 10. If the card was bought graded, the resubmission is not a second grading expense for that owner. (Dealers told The Athletic that the cost of grading is not factored into the value of a card.)
PSA President Ryan Hoge questioned the validity of these types of experiments, though.
'We understand the allure of videos showing cracked PSA 9s coming back as 10s, but these often lack key context—and in some cases, accuracy,' he told The Athletic. 'We often see examples where entirely different cards are resubmitted under the guise of being the same. Our Brand Protection team monitors this kind of content carefully and handles those on a case-by-case basis.
'Every card that enters our facility is evaluated by multiple professional graders. When differences arise, our process ensures consensus before a final grade is issued. No grading company in the world holds itself to a higher or more consistent standard than PSA.'
Advertisement
While many modern mint cards do sell for more than raw, the difference is getting smaller and often does not justify the cost of grading. It's not difficult to find examples of inverted pricing, meaning the ungraded card goes for more money than Mint 9s.
For example, according to CardLadder, a 2013 Panini Select Giannis Antetokounmpo #178 sells for $100 in PSA 9 and $124 ungraded. Of course, it's an ungraded one with no obvious flaws but a PSA 9 can have no obvious flaws, too. There have been no recent sales of a PSA 10, according to CardLadder, but assume it would sell for at about twice as much as a PSA 9.
A 2018 Topps Chrome Sapphire Shohei Ohtani #700 rookie card sold for $2,075.50 in a PSA 9 grade on March 17, which was less than the last raw sale of $2,336. A PSA 10 last sold for $4,200.
The Topps Chrome Ohtani #150 Refractor sold for $466 ungraded in June, a week before it sold for $355 in PSA 9. The raw buyer was hoping for a PSA 10 that last sold for $820; but the PSA 9 could potentially have at least as good a chance at grading a 10 if it was cracked and resubmitted.
Rob DeMay, creator of the NEO Cards & Comics YouTube channel which regularly produces videos on grading and the card industry, advocated buying 9s for the value before these regrading results were made public.
'They're the ultimate collector card. It's not perfect. (The PSA 9) has an issue. But you're getting a steep discount. If you're keeping it, it limits the downside risk because the card is less expensive.'
But now those 9s could end up being 10s.
'I'm not surprised by (these results),' he recently told The Athletic. 'We're paying a human for an opinion, and until they figure out some sort of AI grading, you're going to see things like this. Could you blindly buy all PSA 9s and repeat this result? I don't think so. However, if you were very selective, I could see you having some success with this strategy.'
The Athletic maintains full editorial independence in all our coverage. When you click or make purchases through our links, we may earn a commission.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
16 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Get to know Providence Journal summer intern Bella DeCrescenzo
This summer, The Providence Journal is excited to welcome Bella DeCrescenzo to the newsroom as an intern. A West Bay resident, Bella started on June 2 and will be a full-time presence in our newsroom through mid-August, when she will head back to the University of Maryland to continue her academic career. We talked to Bella about her early experiences in journalism and how she hopes to grow in the profession. Why are you interested in journalism? What topics are you most interested in? I am interested in journalism because I want to aid members of the community by amplifying their voices to make sure that their stories are told. I think that many people's experiences can be overlooked, yet are shared by others and often deserve to be recognized. I want to share these important stories with the community. I also know how important having informed community members is to the strength of our democracy and I want to help provide people with timely news. I am most interested in writing about local politics and the local impacts of federal politics. I also enjoy covering local events and writing features about local community members and businesses. I have some experience with environmental reporting, which I would enjoy exploring more. I really want to explore as many different topics as possible this summer so I can gain a variety of skills and figure out what I enjoy reporting on the most. What are you hoping to get out of your internship with The Providence Journal? Through my internship with The Providence Journal, I hope to get more consistent reporting experience to help strengthen my newswriting skills and gain confidence as a reporter. I hope to report on a variety of beats and cover many topics to figure out which beats I want to focus on in the future. Compiling clips across many beats will also allow me to build a strong portfolio to reflect my time at The Providence Journal. I also hope to cultivate strong professional relationships with my colleagues this summer. I want to spend time shadowing the experienced journalists within the newsroom and hearing about their journalistic processes. From writing tips to career advice, I want to take this opportunity to learn from the professionals around me and forge meaningful connections that last beyond this internship. Tell us about some of your favorite journalism-related experiences from the University of Maryland. Through my classes and extracurriculars at the University of Maryland, I have gained some exciting journalism-related experiences that have continuously made me more confident in my career path. During a broadcast writing class I took this past year, my professor gave us the opportunity to attend Sen. Angela Alsobrooks' campaign headquarters on election night. Alongside journalists from Fox 5 and other well-known stations, we had an amazing experience filming speeches for our package and interviewing very passionate, emotional supporters of Alsobrooks. This past year, I also covered a weeklong environmental-justice symposium where we interviewed the heads of the event about their experience spreading awareness about the effects of climate change on marginalized communities. While I have had the opportunity to cover many more exciting topics and events, the journalism program at the University of Maryland has also given me the opportunity to work with many experienced journalists. Due to the journalism college's impressive staff, I have the support and guidance of Washington Post and CNN reporters who have pushed me to improve as a journalist. What are some things you want readers to know about you? I want readers to know that while I am still a student and am still learning, they can trust my work to be timely and accurate. I hope that they know how seriously I take this opportunity and how excited I am to be able to provide them with important local news. I also want readers to know that while I go to school in Maryland, I am a Rhode Island resident and have stayed up to date on the current issues and happenings in Rhode Island. Overall, I want them to know that I am excited to report on the issues that they want to read about. Their experiences and what they want to learn more about are what will influence me as I look for stories to write and news to cover. I look forward to jumping into local reporting. This article originally appeared on The Providence Journal: Bella DeCrescenzo to serve summer internship with Providence Journal
Yahoo
35 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Couple at Odds After Husband Refuses to Let Wife Ground His Son
A man shared that his wife tried to ground his son, and he had to set a boundary with her The son went to the gym instead of tidying up the house as asked The wife insisted her husband undermined her parenting decision, but the internet sided with the posterA man got into a big fight with his wife after she tried to ground his son for not doing what she asked, when she asked. In a Reddit post, the man explained that he has a 17-year-old son from a previous relationship, as well as three sons with his wife, who "are all much younger" than his eldest. "My son is starting his senior year of high school next year and hoping to get an athletic scholarship," the man explained, noting that the teen "plans to spend all summer practicing" as "he's trying to achieve something that can make or break his future." One day, his wife asked the teenager "to tidy up the living room," but he said he was "already on the way to the gym." 'She told him that he could go after tidying. He said he would do it when he got back and left without giving her time to reply,' the dad wrote. 'She sent him a text saying he is grounded and then called me to let me know.' His wife insisted that the aspiring athlete disrespected her, and the poster told her that they "would have a conversation about that, but there would be no grounding." 'She was very upset. I texted my son that he wasn't grounded, but that we wanted to talk to him when he came home," the man shared. "When he got back we sat down and talked. He said he didn't mind helping out, but that he was a busy person with a busy schedule and wasn't at our beck and call," the poster continued. "He said if he is asked in advance to do something he will, but he isn't available to us at the drop of a hat.' While the poster "said that was fine," his wife "didn't like that." "I asked him if he would be willing to clean the living room, and he said he would after taking a shower. While he was in the shower my wife and I got into a big fight,' the man shared. 'She said I undermined her and all the kids will respect her less. I said she isn't my oldest's mother and the final say goes to me with him. She was very angry and said she needed space from me.' He noted that his eldest has always respected his wife, but thinks "it's fair that we stay consistent with her not being his mom." The couple barely spoke in the following days, leading the dad to question if he was in the wrong. Never miss a story — sign up for to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories. While people in the comments section had mixed reactions, most agreed that the dad is allowed to set a boundary when it comes to parenting his son. However, the vast majority of commenters also noted that the couple needs to set firm guidelines about their respective roles as parents. 'You and your wife need to discuss rules for your son and appropriate discipline. She should not be grounding him without discussing it with you; you should not be negating her punishment without reaching an agreement with her," one user wrote. "The two of you need to find a common parenting strategy and stick with it." 'These discussions need to take place in private, where your son cannot hear," they continued. "The rules need to be explained carefully to him. He doesn't have to like them, but he has to know what they are. Ad hoc disciplines should be avoided.' Read the original article on People
New York Times
36 minutes ago
- New York Times
For Black Women, Life in America Has Always Been a Crossroads
MISBEHAVING AT THE CROSSROADS: Essays & Writings, by Honorée Fanonne Jeffers There's a difference between being at a crossroads — weighing an important decision at a crucial moment — and being at the crossroads: a fabled space in the Black diasporic tradition where powers can be granted, whisked away or reclaimed by the spirit world, sometimes for the price of a soul. With her nonfiction debut, Honorée Fanonne Jeffers comfortably inhabits this mythic juncture, telling the stories of Black women in her genealogy with a literary style that joyfully resists easy categorization. 'Misbehaving at the Crossroads' is a matrilineal memoir that reaches back to the 1830s while incorporating slices of social history, political commentary and poetry. Jeffers uses census records and oral histories to excavate the stories of her foremothers, alongside wide-ranging essays on subjects like the 1965 Moynihan report on 'The Negro Family,' Roe v. Wade and the election of President Obama. The result is two parallel accounts of the American patriarchal project that, in Jeffers's words, was designed not to 'cover any Indigenous peoples, or white women, or Black folks with the grace of liberty.' If the earlier chapters struggle to find their intended audience — sometimes she seems to be addressing young students who don't know much about early American history, other times her Black female peers or white liberals — Jeffers's limber prose finds its stride when she talks about her mother. Dr. Trellie Lee James Jeffers was a politically active writer and educator 'who grew up in tangled country woods' in Eatonton, Ga., 'a place of red dirt, slavery, Jim Crow — and Indigenous echoes.' The author recalls her mother taking her canvassing through Black neighborhoods near their home in Durham, N.C., when Jeffers was 9; introducing her to James Baldwin (who knew her father, the poet and academic Lance Jeffers) as a teenager; and giving her impromptu sex ed lectures in their Dodge Dart. Jeffers also depicts darker memories — of her father's abuse and her mother's failure to protect her from it — with equal precision and clarity; but in keeping with her Southern Black upbringing she never descends into prurience. 'While pondering whether she'd lied all those years,' she writes of her mother, 'saying that she didn't remember my calling to her in the night during one of my father's visits to my bedroom, another snippet of memory came to me: … the prescription bottles of Valium in her bathroom.' For Jeffers, revealing her mother's painful, all-too-common story — a brilliant woman living under the shadow and thumb of a man who is publicly lauded while privately terrorizing her and their young daughters — carries the taint of misbehaving, of failing to live up to the codes of Black respectability, even after both of her parents have died: 'I waver in telling this: Which version of the truth will indict my mother further — which one will save her legacy?' Want all of The Times? Subscribe.
