School wrongly suspended student ‘trying to do the right thing,' judge rules
A Virginia Beach Catholic school's decision to suspend a student for not immediately reporting that a classmate had a bullet was 'appalling,' and violated the terms of his family's contract with the school, a judge ruled this week.
The decision was issued Monday by District Court Judge Vivian Henderson after she heard testimony from the student's mother, as well as the former principal of St. John the Apostle Catholic School, and the superintendent of schools for the Diocese of Richmond, according to a transcript of the hearing.
'The unfortunate victim in this matter was (the boy who reported the incident),' Henderson said in announcing her decision. 'Because to see him punished as the person who was trying to do the right thing is appalling … Especially in an environment where students are forced, younger and younger kids are being forced, to make adult-like decisions, without clear boundaries or parameters.'
Rachel Wigand sued St. John's in September after her 11-year-old son was suspended for 1½ days. The lawsuit claimed the school breached its contract with the Wigand family by punishing the boy for something not in the student-parent handbook.
The handbook doesn't say anything about needing to immediately report incidents in which a student has ammunition, according to the complaint. The only thing it says must be immediately reported is allegations involving sexual harassment.
In an interview with The Virginian-Pilot last year, Wigand said her son waited a couple of hours to come forward because he wanted do it when the other boy wasn't around. She also said her son couldn't understand why he was punished, especially when it was the same disciplinary action received by the student who brought the bullet to school.
In her lawsuit, Wigand asked that she be reimbursed for the $4,780 in tuition she paid for her son for the first half of the school year. But on Monday, her attorney Tim Anderson told the judge she was only requesting $81, as well as attorney's fees and other costs. The $81 represents about how much a day and a half of tuition amounted to, Anderson said.
'This wasn't about the money,' the lawyer said. 'It was about much more than that. What we wanted was a clear ruling from the court that this was a suspension and that it was not allowed under the contract.'
St. John's officials repeatedly claimed the punishment was not a suspension, Anderson said, and that it was allowed under the rules.
The Catholic Diocese of Richmond issued a statement Tuesday in which it said it stood by the school's decision.
'At St. John the Apostle School, we are dedicated to maintaining a safe and focused learning environment for our students,' the statement said. 'While we disagree with the court's decision, we respect the legal process. Our focus continues to be providing enriching and Christ-centered learning experiences for our students, and we are hopeful this conclusion will bring all parties involved an opportunity to move forward.'
Wigand applauded the judge's decision Tuesday. While her children still attend St. John's, she's considering sending them elsewhere next year.
'I truly appreciated having an independent third party recognize that the school's decision was wrong,' she said. 'After seven months, it was a weight lifted off my back for just trying to do what was best and right for my child.'
Jane Harper, jane.harper@pilotonline.com
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
10 hours ago
- Yahoo
Eight dead and 13 injured after hot air balloon crashes in Brazil
Eight people have died after a hot-air balloon caught fire and tumbled from the sky in Brazil. A further 13 people including the pilot were injured in the incident in the southern state of Santa Catarina on Saturday morning, according to local officials. Shocking footage shared by local news outlet G1 showed billows of smoke coming from the balloon, which was in flames as it hurtled towards the ground and crashed into a rural area near a health centre. Horrifying videos captured the moment the balloon appeared to crumple before plummeting down, with reports suggesting at least one person jumped to escape the blaze mid-air. Of the victims, four died after being burned in the basket and another four in the fall, G1 reported. Miraculously some survivors were all taken to hospitals, Santa Catarina's military fire brigade said, adding that 21 people were on board in total, including the pilot. According to Jornal Razao, a Brazilian outlet, the pilot told authorities: 'I don't know if it stayed lit or if it reignited on its own, but it was the torch that started it all.' 'We are in mourning. A tragedy has happened. We will see how it unfolds, what happened, why it happened. But the important thing now is for the state structure to do what it can,' governor Jorginho Mello said in a video on X. Mr Mello said he has asked authorities to head to the municipality 'to do as much as possible to rescue, to help, to take to hospital, to comfort the families'. He added: 'We continue to monitor the situation.' Three people died hugging each other, said Ulisses Gabriel, chief of Santa Catarina's civil police force, on X. "It hurts the soul." Authorities have opened an investigation and the results will be made public within 30 days, Santa Catarina's public safety secretary Flïvio Graff told journalists. According to the civil police, the pilot has given testimony and they will also gather statements from survivors, he added. The vehicle was run by Sobrevoar, the outlet reported, adding that it had the necessary licences. Last Sunday, a balloon fell in Sao Paulo state, killing a 27-year-old woman and injuring 11 others, G1 reported. Praia Grande is a common destination for hot-air ballooning, a popular activity in some parts of Brazil's south during June festivities that celebrate Catholic saints. Praia Grande City Hall said: 'The City of Praia Grande expresses its solidarity with the families involved in the balloon accident that occurred on the morning of Saturday, 21 June.' Last Sunday, a hot air balloon crashed in central Turkey, leaving its pilot dead and 19 Indonesian tourists injured, a local official said. In a statement, the governor's office said the balloon was affected by a sudden change of wind. It was trying to make a hard landing near the village of Gozlukuyu in Aksaray province, when the pilot fell out of the balloon's basket and his feet got tangled in a rope, Aksaray governor Mehmet Ali Kumbuzoglu said. 'Unfortunately, our pilot got stuck under the basket and died,' he said, adding that the injured tourists were taken to a hospital.
19 hours ago
8 killed, 13 injured after hot-air balloon catches fire and falls in Brazil
RIO DE JANEIRO -- A hot-air balloon caught fire and tumbled from the sky on Saturday in Brazil 's southern state of Santa Catarina, killing eight people, firefighters said. Footage shared by local news outlet G1 showed billows of smoke coming from the balloon in flames as it hurtled toward the ground in the municipality of Praia Grande. Thirteen people survived and were taken to hospitals, Santa Catarina's military fire brigade said, adding that 21 people were on board including the pilot. 'We are in mourning. A tragedy has happened. We will see how it unfolds, what happened, why it happened. But the important thing now is for the state structure to do what it can,' Gov. Jorginho Mello said in a video on X. Mello said he has asked authorities to head to the municipality 'to do as much as possible to rescue, to help, to take to hospital, to comfort the families.' Praia Grande is a common destination for hot-air ballooning, a popular activity in some parts of Brazil's south during June festivities that celebrate Catholic saints such as St. John. Last Sunday, a balloon came down in Sao Paulo state, killing a 27-year-old woman and injuring 11 other people, G1 reported.
a day ago
Panama suspends constitutional protections in the northwest after destructive protests
PANAMA CITY -- Panama suspended constitutional protections, including the rights to assemble and of free movement, for five days in its northwestern Bocas del Toro province Friday after two months of protests and road blockades turned more destructive the previous night. Presidential Minister Juan Carlos Orillac said in a news conference that the move would allow the government to reestablish order and 'rescue the province' from 'radical groups.' He said the damage caused overnight was 'unacceptable and did not represent a legitimate protest.' What began as nationwide protests against changes to the social security system morphed Thursday night into people damaging the local airport and the facilities of banana giant Chiquita Brands, which fired thousands of striking workers in the province last month. Panamanian President José Raúl Mulino had said at the time that the banana workers' strike was illegal and included some 5,000 workers. On May 27, the government declared a state of emergency in the province without suspending constitutional protections. Last week, the government sent some 1,500 more police to the province with the objective clearing protest roadblocks. Security Minister Frank Abrego left open the possibility of sending more on Friday. But actions by masked people authorities described as criminals overnight led Mulino to announce Thursday night that he would meet with his Cabinet Friday to take action. The perpetrators forced their way into the airport in Changuinola, Bocas del Toro's main city, where they vandalized cars and started a fire in the local baseball stadium. They sacked Chiquita's shuttered facility and destroyed a local office of the National Civil Defense Service. Flights at the airport were still suspended Friday. Protests, marches and occasional roadblocks have stretched from one end of the country to the other as teachers, construction workers and other unions rejected changes the government said were necessary to keep the social security system solvent. Demonstrations have occasionally turned violent, but the forced entrance of people to the airport and banana facility overnight triggered Friday's government reaction. Earlier this month, Mulino brought in a Catholic archbishop and a rabbi to act as mediators with protesters. Last week, Panama's Congress approved a new law for the banana sector that was part of an agreement to end the strike by protecting workers' benefits like medical assistance and labor protections under the new social security regime.
