Texts, web search tie Zanesville woman to Christmas murder of father-in-law
COLUMBUS, Ohio (WCMH) – A Muskingum County woman could spend the rest of her life in prison after pleading guilty to killing her father-in-law on Christmas Day.
According to the Muskingum County Prosecutor's Office, Brittany Cole of Zanesville pleaded guilty to the murder and abuse of corpse of her father-in-law, David Cole Sr., who was found in a shed behind a home on Somers Street in Zanesville.
On Jan. 8, Zanesville police received a 911 call reporting a body behind the Cole residence, and officers found Cole Sr.'s body wrapped in a tarp and plastic mattress cover.
Fort Rapids waterpark may finally be sold after legal hurdle cleared
Initially an autopsy revealed that Cole Sr. died of natural causes related to heart disease or Parkinson's, but further investigation determined Brittany Cole's role in the cause of the death.
Detectives collected digital evidence, texts between Brittany Cole and her husband, David Cole Jr., prompting a more intensive investigation. Nearly three weeks after Cole Sr.'s death, Brittany Cole confessed to killing him during an interview on Jan. 13.
The prosecutor's office said that Brittany Cole gave Cole Sr. multiple Tylenol No. 3 with codeine tablets and a 'significant' amount of ZzzQuil on Dec. 24. When Cole Sr. complained of pain at 11 p.m. that night, she gave him additional doses of both medications, knowing it would be fatal.
Brittany Cole said she discovered Cole Sr. was dead on Christmas morning and instructed family members to say he had moved to Cincinnati. She told police the family then went on vacation to Orlando, Florida, returning on Jan. 1, leaving Cole Sr.'s body in the bedroom.
One week later, Cole Jr. and his son found Cole Sr. in the bedroom. Texts between Cole Jr. and Brittany Cole revealed plans to conceal and move the decomposing body. Evidence of an Amazon order for a mattress cover was discovered by detectives.
Additionally, Social Security payments in the amount of $2,300 per month were deposited into a Park National Bank account, managed by Cole Jr. After Cole Sr.'s death, the couple continued to deposit the funds, with Cole Jr. sending Brittany Cole her $200 in December and January via CashApp for the water bill, while using the remaining funds for household items.
Evidence collected also included camera footage of Cole Jr. finding the body, text messages about the smell and disposal plans, as well as a Google search by Brittany Cole entitled, 'when someone dies how long does it take for the body to start smelling.'
On Wednesday, Brittany Cole was sentenced to life in prison with the possibility of parole after 16 years.
Cole Jr., 44, was arrested on Feb. 20 and charged with two counts of tampering with evidence, processing criminal tools, abuse of a corpse, obstructing official business and endangering children. He has yet to face a judge in Muskingum County Court of Common Pleas.
Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
San Francisco Chronicle
17 hours ago
- San Francisco Chronicle
Letters: S.F.'s Pink Triangle symbolizes LGBTQ+ empowerment. Why vandalism won't change that
Regarding 'Man arrested in vandalism to S.F.'s Pink Triangle celebrating LGBTQ Pride Month' (Crime, June 19): The vandalism of the Pink Triangle on Twin Peaks this week is an example of the struggles our community has faced throughout time. The damage should remain because it sends a powerful message. We will wear this scar as a badge of resilience, courage and our continuing struggle for equality for the rest of Pride Month. For the past three decades, the Pink Triangle has been a symbol of what can happen if hatred is allowed to go unchecked. The graffiti and defaced panels of the Pink Triangle remind us of the ongoing discrimination and hatred experienced by many in the community. If this can happen here in LGBTQ+ friendly San Francisco, think what might happen in other less accepting places in the U.S. and around the world. This hate empowers us. We will remain our true selves, speak up and keep living our lives as joyfully as possible. There is no going back in the closet as some would like us to do. Patrick Carney, co-founder, Pink Triangle, San Francisco Don't wait I'm not a green card holder nor an undocumented immigrant. I'm not attending a university on a student visa. I'm not a corporate executive fearing my political views will bar me from federal contracts. I'm not a lawyer who's been coerced into performing pro bono work to undo diversity, equity and inclusion. I'm not connected to any university, museum or nonprofit organization that had its tax-exempt status and/or funding canceled for promoting policies inimical to government ones. I'm not employed by any federal, state or local government. I'm not a university professor, teacher or student. I'm not personally affected by rising consumer prices. I don't live near oil or gas drilling. I'm not worried about the financial stability of Social Security, Medicaid, Medicare and the Veterans Affairs Department. I'm not affected by dictates issued on and after Jan. 20. In 1946, German Pastor Martin Niemöller berated himself for failing to oppose Nazi attacks on Communists, Socialists, trade unionists and Jews, until he, too, was attacked and no one remained to speak on his behalf. I'm not waiting. Paul L. Newman, Merion Station, Pa. Trump keeps promise Nearly 80 million Americans voted for Donald Trump, including eight counties in California that were blue in 2020. President Trump is keeping to his promise to all Americans, even if you didn't vote for him. Trump is president of the United States, and that makes him accountable to U.S. citizens, not those who are here illegally. Christine Larson, Castro Valley
USA Today
a day ago
- USA Today
Customer data possibly leaked in Aflac cyberattack, the third insurance hack this month
The Aflac breach potentially impacted files with customers' Social Security numbers and health details. Insurance company Aflac disclosed this week that cybercriminals breached its U.S. network and may have accessed customers' personal information, the latest in a string of cyberattacks on insurance companies announced this month. Aflac, which provides home and life insurance and manages data for more than 50 million policyholders, said in a June 20 federal regulatory filing it identified suspicious activity on its U.S. network on June 12. The company said it believes it stopped the intrusion within hours of identifying it, calling the attack part of a 'cybercrime campaign against the insurance industry.' The breach potentially impacted files containing customers' personal information, such as Social Security numbers and health-related details. Aflac said it is investigating the breach with the help of third-party cybersecurity experts and has not yet determined how many customers were affected. An Aflac spokesperson told Reuters that the characteristics of the incident were consistent with the hacking group Scattered Spider, which has a reputation for targeting multiple companies in a single industry in waves. More: This is how you stop online trackers from collecting your health data Latest Tech News: Is TikTok getting banned? Trump says he'll 'probably' extend deadline again It's the largest insurance provider yet to disclose a breach this month, after cyberattacks on Erie Insurance and Philadelphia Insurance Companies disrupted their network operations. Aflac said the attack did not affect its systems and it is able to continue providing services as usual while it responds to the security breach. Contributing: Reuters. Kathryn Palmer is a national trending news reporter for USA TODAY. You can reach her at kapalmer@ and on X @KathrynPlmr.
New York Post
2 days ago
- New York Post
CAT-astrophe: NYC couple claims beloved rescue kitty crushed by self-cleaning litter box
A Bronx woman came home to a grisly cat-astrophe — her beloved feline was fatally crushed by a self-cleaning litter box. Stephanie Gomez knew something was wrong when she stepped off the elevator in her Williamsbridge apartment building and heard one of her two cats, Sebastian, crying from down the hall, she said. The medical assistant opened her door to find Sebastian frantic — and her other cat, Sarabi, dead, partially stuck inside her Autoscooper 11 litter box. 4 Sarabi was a friendly, playful cat, said Gomez, who rescued the furball after finding her crying on the street on a rainy night in the Bronx. 'I turned on the light. . . . I saw my cat being crushed by the machine,' an emotional Gomez, 35, told The Post of the gruesome Jan. 27 incident. 'It was making an awful sound. 'The machine is supposed to automatically stop when there is a body in it. The machine did not stop, it was still trying to close on her.' The tiny domestic shorthair's body was cold to the touch, with its rear and hind legs sticking out of the machine, according to Gomez and a $3 million Bronx Supreme Court lawsuit she and her partner, Frank Gueits, filed. 'It was completely devastating,' she said. 'I collapsed.' 4 Stephanie Gomez insists she'll never trust a similar automated device again. J.C. Rice She immediately called Gueits for help. 'Stephanie was very frantic, very upset and crying,' he said, recalling Sarabi's body was so mutilated by the machine 'she looked like she was in an L shape. It was really heartbreaking to see.' The litter box, which retails for about $200, was a Christmas gift from Gomez' mother and advertised as 'remaining partially open at all times, with no complete enclosure that could entrap a pet,' according to the lawsuit, which names Pet Pivot, the California-based company which makes the Autoscooper 11, and Amazon, which sold the device. 'A catastrophic failure of the product's safety mechanisms' led to Sarabi's 'long, painful death,' Gomez and Gueits said in court papers. 4 The Autoscooper 11 advertises itself as safe and claims sensors prevent cats from being trapped inside. PetPivot/ Amazon The same night, Gueits, 48, found an Amazon review of the Autoscooper 11 from a cat owner who claimed the littler box 'nearly killed their cat,' but the review was later removed, the couple claimed. Gomez' mother got a full refund after Sarabi's death and a handwritten letter from PetPivot CEO Poppy Xie, which lacked company letterhead or an address, offering condolences and $10,000, Gomez said in legal papers. The couple believes 'the $10,000 offer was an effort to quietly settle or suppress claims relating to the product's fatal defect,' they contended. Sarabi, who weighed less than 10 pounds, 'was the sweetest little thing,' Gomez said. 'She was so wonderful, she was the friendliest kitty. She was . . . very talkative, and don't leave your plate of food unattended,' Gomez laughed. 'There's not a day that goes by that I don't mourn her.' 4 Sebastian still sleeps on the spot where Sarabi was killed, Gomez said. She rescued Sarabi more than a year earlier, after she heard the kitty crying on a rainy night outside her local laundromat, and followed the sound until she found the cat hiding under a van. She named the grey striped feline after a character in Disney's 'The Lion King.' Sebastian has been devastated by the loss, with Gomez hand-feeding him for weeks afterward. 'To this day, Sebastian sleeps on the spot where the Autoscooper had killed Sarabi,' according to the lawsuit. 'I will never trust an automated machine again,' Gomez said. 'I don't want this to happen to anyone else.' Amazon and Pet Pivot did not immediately respond to requests for comment. The device is still being sold — and advertised as safe, said Peggy Collen, the attorney representing Gomez and Gueits. 'Sarabi's death was not an accident,' Collen said. 'If this happened to Sarabi, it could happen to any cat.'
