Wisconsin's tampering lawsuit against Miami, explained
College football's rules regarding tampering and the transfer portal are set to see their first major legal challenge.
The University of Wisconsin, along with its NIL collective, has filed a lawsuit in state circuit court against the University of Miami (Florida) alleging "tortious interference," according to court documents obtained by Yahoo Sports' Ross Dellenger.
Advertisement
The lawsuit stems from the departure of freshman defensive back Xavier Lucas, who attempted to transfer to Miami in January following the 2024 season but was blocked from entering the portal by the Badgers. He ultimately enrolled in Coral Gables for the spring semester.
Wisconsin's legal challenge is the first of its kind and could be a major precedent-setter for how transfer situations will be handled when college sports enters the revenue-sharing era on July 1, following the approval of the House v. NCAA settlement earlier this month.
Here's a full rundown of the wrongdoing Wisconsin is alleging and what it could mean for the future of college sports.
Who is Xavier Lucas?
A four-star recruit in the 2024 class from high school football powerhouse American Heritage in Fort Lauderdale, Florida, Lucas signed with the Badgers out of high school and appeared in 11 games with one start as a true freshman in Madison last fall. He totaled 18 tackles, a tackle for loss, an interception and three pass breakups in 2024.
Why did Wisconsin block Lucas from transferring to Miami?
Lucas' attempt to transfer to Miami in the spring was complicated by the fact that he had already inked a two-year revenue-sharing agreement with Wisconsin ahead of the anticipated approval of the House settlement. The Badgers used that contract to block Lucas from entering the portal.
Advertisement
However, that didn't stop him from seeking a transfer, and he ultimately unenrolled from Wisconsin in January after the transfer portal closed and signed up for classes at Miami. As of publication, there has not been an NCAA ruling regarding his eligibility in 2025, with the association stating in January that he did not violate any rules, and he is expected to suit up for the Hurricanes this fall.
Lucas' attorney, Darren Heitner, said at the time that any attempt to prevent Lucas from playing this season would be met with an antitrust lawsuit of their own.
Lucas' attorney, Darren Heitner, told Yahoo Sports in January that he planned to file an antitrust lawsuit against Wisconsin if Lucas was unable to complete his move to Miami. He accused Wisconsin of blatantly violating NCAA rules by not inserting Lucas' name into the portal as he requested and questioning the legality of the NCAA's transfer portal in general.
According to Heitner, Lucas requested a transfer from Wisconsin after learning that his father had contracted a "serious, life-threatening illness" after returning home to Florida for winter break.
What is Wisconsin seeking from the lawsuit?
At the most basic level, the Badgers' lawsuit centers around one of the most contentious topics in college sports at the moment: tampering. Under NCAA rules, schools are not permitted to contact players on other teams' rosters until they officially enter the transfer portal.
Advertisement
However, it's an open secret that contact often happens well before players officially opt to transfer, especially when they choose to do so with the eyebrow-raising "do not contact" tag.
Wisconsin alleges that Miami violated NCAA rules by having impermissible contact with Lucas despite its knowledge that he had entered into a revenue-sharing agreement with the school that included anti-tampering language. The university said it filed the lawsuit "reluctantly" due to its commitment to "ensuring integrity and fundamental fairness in the evolving landscape of college athletics."
The Badgers are not filing any lawsuits against Lucas, and they are seeking "unspecified damages, transparency and accountability" from Miami. It's unclear what a ruling against the Hurricanes would mean for Lucas' football-playing future.
'We stand by our position that respecting and enforcing contractual obligations is essential to maintaining a level playing field,' the Big Ten said in a statement of support for the Badgers. 'In addition to our legal action, we will continue to be proactive to protect the interests of our student-athletes, our program and the broader collegiate athletics community.'
What could this mean for the future of college sports?
At its heart, Wisconsin's lawsuit tests schools' ability to enforce anti-tampering elements of revenue-sharing agreements, a key element of the House settlement aimed at ending the perceived free-for-all when it comes to the transfer portal and player compensation.
Advertisement
Should the courts rule in favor of the Hurricanes, it would provide a critical blow to the settlement, which is already facing legal backlash on Title IX grounds.
The lawsuit will also help establish the credibility of the transfer portal. Since the NCAA has stated that there are currently no rules against players unenrolling from their current school and re-enrolling at a new one without entering the portal, its legitimacy could hinge on the success of Wisconsin's suit.
There are a lot of moving parts in college sports at the moment, and the House settlement has only complicated matters. Whether that settlement can operate as designed could largely depend on the success of Wisconsin's lawsuit.
This article originally appeared on For The Win: Explaining Wisconsin's tampering lawsuit against Miami
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBS News
19 minutes ago
- CBS News
Wisconsin and NIL collective sue Miami, allege tampering and NIL inducements to land football player
The University of Wisconsin and its NIL collective VC Connect filed a joint lawsuit on Friday against the University of Miami, alleging it knowingly induced one of the Badgers' football players to abandon a lucrative name, image and likeness contract to play for the Florida this upcoming season. Allegations of tampering rarely get to this level and the 23-page lawsuit, which was filed in state court in Wisconsin and obtained by The Associated Press, is unusual. Depending on its resolution, it could have a a wider impact on future NIL deals across college athletics. The player in question in the filing is referred to only as "Student-Athlete A." But the case summary describes facts that line up with the situation involving cornerback Xavier Lucas, who last December announced his plans to enter the transfer portal. Shortly afterward, Darren Heitner, who has been representing Lucas, indicated that Wisconsin was refusing to put Lucas' name in the portal and that it was hindering his ability to talk with other schools. In January, Heitner announced that Lucas would be playing for Miami this fall. The situation is fallout from the rapid changes engulfing college athletics, specifically a combination of two things: Athletes went to court and won the ability to transfer with much more freedom and the 2021 NCAA decision clearing the way for them to strike NIL endorsement deals now worth millions of dollars. That has changed the recruiting landscape and forced the issue of contracts and signed commitments to the fore. "Indeed, student-athletes' newfound NIL rights will be rendered meaningless if third parties are allowed to induce student-athletes to abandon their contractual commitments," a portion of the lawsuit reads. Miami and Lucas were in talks before transfer decision, Wisconsin says Wisconsin said in January that it had credible information that Miami and Lucas made impermissible contact with each other before the former Badgers cornerback decided to transfer. Wisconsin and VC Connect allege that the inducement for Lucas to attend Miami happened within days of him entering his NIL agreement to play for the Badgers, and that they incurred substantial monetary and reputational harm. The lawsuit seeks unspecified monetary damages and "a declaration that Miami's conduct directed towards Student-Athlete A constituted tampering." A message left with the University of Miami seeking comment was not immediately returned. In a text message Friday, Heitner declined to comment on the lawsuit but he said that Lucas still plans to attend Miami and play football. Wisconsin said it had the support of its leadership and the Big Ten Conference in filing the lawsuit, noting its commitment to "ensuring integrity and fundamental fairness in the evolving landscape of college athletics." "While we reluctantly bring this case, we stand by our position that respecting and enforcing contractual obligations is essential to maintaining a level playing field," the statement said. "In addition to our legal action, we will continue to be proactive to protect the interests of our student-athletes, our program and the broader collegiate athletics community. Lucas, who is from Pompano Beach, Florida, had 12 tackles, an interception and a sack as a freshman for Wisconsin last season. Heitner said that Lucas hasn't received any money from Wisconsin and therefore owes no money to the school. Heitner also argued that Wisconsin had violated an NCAA bylaw by not entering Lucas into the transfer database within two business days of the player's request. Wisconsin issued a statement at the time saying it hadn't put Lucas' name in the portal because he had entered a two-year binding NIL agreement. In April, the surprise transfers of brothers Nico and Madden Iamaleava from Tennessee to UCLA prompted fresh questions about contracts and buyouts. Nico Iamaleava, who led Tennessee to the College Football Playoff last season, walked away from a reported $2.4 million NIL contract. Arkansas freshman quarterback Madden Iamaleava entered the portal after spring practices wrapped up. Arkansas athletic director Hunter Yurachek released a statement indicating he would support efforts by the Razorbacks' NIL collective to enforce buyout clauses in athlete contracts. Iamaleava reportedly had a contract valued at $500,000 upon signing with Arkansas.
Yahoo
28 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Jesús Luzardo Discusses Playing 'Real Baseball' With Phillies
Jesús Luzardo Discusses Playing 'Real Baseball' With Phillies originally appeared on Athlon Sports. As with most arms in the Philadelphia Phillies' rotation, Jesús Luzardo is having a mostly successful 2025 campaign. Advertisement Since being acquired from the Miami Marlins for two prospects, Luzardo has struck out 97 batters in 83.2 innings. He had carried a 2.15 ERA through May 25th before two starts of his went sideways fast. Aside from those hiccups, he's been a valuable addition to the club - and Luzardo isn't taking the change for granted. "I didn't know what to expect coming into a team with such high expectations," Luzardo said during an interview on The Phillies Show. "It's blown me away how welcoming everyone is. How the guys who are 'Superstars' are just really down to earth guys... It's been awesome to be a part of it." Jesús Luzardo started the year off so strong that he was a dark horse Cy Young candidate. While the two blowouts dismissed that, he is still putting together a good Streicher-Imagn Images Originally from Peru, Luzardo went to high school between Fort Lauderdale and Boca Raton, just north of Miami. So while the trade took him much farther from home - albeit with the benefit of traveling back twice a year in divisional series - he's embraced the new culture in Philly. Advertisement "Playing in Miami - it was home for me, so that was great," Luzardo said. "But at the same time, when you're not pitching in front of 40,000 (fans) like you are here every night... That's something you don't really see all the time and it's some of the most fun I've had playing baseball since I was in high school." "This is real baseball. Not a knock on anywhere else that I've been, but you could feel the atmosphere, the home field advantage, the buzz around the city. Going into a game, you just see the streets flooded with Phillies gear. The stadium's packed with everyone walking in. It's a good time." With the season approaching its halfway point, Luzardo is tasked with helping a suddenly short-staffed group of starters maintain a playoff position. And unlike in 2023, when the Marlins had shut him down for Tommy John surgery by the time they made it to the Wild Card, he looks to stay healthy and contribute into the Phils' latest October push. Advertisement Related: Phillies' Matt Strahm Claps Back at Fan Amid Callout for Recent Struggles Related: Phillies GM Preston Mattingly Reveals MLB Draft Plans This story was originally reported by Athlon Sports on Jun 19, 2025, where it first appeared.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Wisconsin, NIL collective sue Miami, allege tampering and NIL inducements to land football player
FILE - Camp Randall Stadium is seen during an NCAA college football game between Wisconsin and Miami of Ohio, Sept. 12, 2015, in Madison, Wis. (AP Photo/Aaron Gash, File) The University of Wisconsin and its NIL collective VC Connect filed a joint lawsuit on Friday against the University of Miami alleging it knowingly induced one of the Badgers' football players to abandon a lucrative name, image and likeness contract to play for the Florida this upcoming season. The 23-page suit, which was filed in state court in Wisconsin and obtained by The Associated Press, could have a a wider impact on future NIL deals across college athletics. Advertisement The player in question in the filing is referred to only as 'Student-Athlete A." But the case summary describes facts that line up with the situation involving cornerback Xavier Lucas, who last December announced his plans to enter the transfer portal. Shortly afterward, Darren Heitner, who has been representing Lucas, indicated that Wisconsin was refusing to put Lucas' name in the portal and that it was hindering his ability to talk with other schools. In January, Heitner announced that Lucas would be playing for Miami this fall. The situation is fallout from the rapid changes engulfing college athletics, specifically a combination of two things: Athletes went to court and won the ability to transfer with much more freedom and the 2021 NCAA decision clearing the way for them to strike NIL endorsement deals now worth millions of dollars. That has changed the recruiting landscape and forced the issue of contracts and signed commitments to the fore. 'Indeed, student-athletes' newfound NIL rights will be rendered meaningless if third parties are allowed to induce student-athletes to abandon their contractual commitments,' a portion of the lawsuit reads. Advertisement Wisconsin said in January that it had credible information that Miami and Lucas made impermissible contact with each other before the former Badgers cornerback decided to transfer. Wisconsin and VC Connect allege that the inducement for Lucas to attend Miami happened within days of him entering his NIL agreement to play for the Badgers, and that they incurred substantial monetary and reputational harm. The lawsuit seeks unspecified monetary damages and 'a declaration that Miami's conduct directed towards Student-Athlete A constituted tampering.' A message left with the University of Miami seeking comment was not immediately returned. In a text message Friday, Heitner declined to comment on the lawsuit but he said that Lucas still plans to attend Miami and play football. Wisconsin said it had the support of its leadership and the Big Ten Conference in filing the lawsuit, noting its commitment to "ensuring integrity and fundamental fairness in the evolving landscape of college athletics." Advertisement 'While we reluctantly bring this case, we stand by our position that respecting and enforcing contractual obligations is essential to maintaining a level playing field,' the statement said. "In addition to our legal action, we will continue to be proactive to protect the interests of our student-athletes, our program and the broader collegiate athletics community. Lucas, who is from Pompano Beach, Florida, had 12 tackles, an interception and a sack as a freshman for Wisconsin last season. Heitner said that Lucas hasn't received any money from Wisconsin and therefore owes no money to the school. Heitner also argued that Wisconsin had violated an NCAA bylaw by not entering Lucas into the transfer database within two business days of the player's request. Wisconsin issued a statement at the time saying it hadn't put Lucas' name in the portal because he had entered a two-year binding NIL agreement. Advertisement In April, the surprise transfers of brothers Nico and Madden Iamaleava from Tennessee to UCLA prompted fresh questions about contracts and buyouts. Nico Iamaleava, who led Tennessee to the College Football Playoff last season, walked away from a reported $2.4 million NIL contract. Arkansas freshman quarterback Madden Iamaleava entered the portal after spring practices wrapped up. Arkansas athletic director Hunter Yurachek released a statement indicating he would support efforts by the Razorbacks' NIL collective to enforce buyout clauses in athlete contracts. Iamaleava reportedly had a contract valued at $500,000 upon signing with Arkansas. ___ Get poll alerts and updates on the AP Top 25 throughout the season. Sign up here. AP college football: and
