James Brayshaw takes public shot at AFL over 50-metre penalty ‘disgrace'
Former North Melbourne president James Brayshaw has fired a shot at the AFL for wildly inconsistent umpiring which culminated in an 'absolute disgrace' on Friday night.
The Channel 7 commentator was calling Brisbane's win over Geelong when Dayne Zorko gave away a 50-metre penalty that started a trend for the night that was an outlier to the rest of the season so far.
Zorko was penalised for running into the protected area when Geelong's Shannon Neale was going back to have a shot at goal, despite appearing to run through about 10 metres away from the kicker in an action that had no impact on the play.
Neale was taken to the goal line where he booted through Geelong's first goal of the game.
At the time, Matthew Richardson called the ruling 'nonsense'.
'It wasn't going to affect anything, I really don't like that, it's just a bit of nonsense there, really,' he said on Channel 7.
'Shannon Neale was just going back for a shot at goal, he wasn't affecting anything in-board of the ground there, Zorko.'
Speaking on Triple M the next morning, a frustrated Brayshaw said it started a trend for the night which is at odds with how the game has been officiated for the season at large.
'What I will say to this, and I don't dive into umps too often, but we haven't had a running into the protected zone infringement all season — has not been one for 13 weeks, suddenly they ping four in three quarters,' he said.
Bernie Vince added: 'We always say this, whenever they are hot on something, why don't they come out and tell us? Do they tell the teams? Do they tell us?
'Why does it just, all of a sudden, it just starts.
'So, you see that on a Friday night, does that continue across the weekend maybe? I don't know.'
Brayshaw was the Kangaroos president between 2008 and 2016, and saw first-hand the frustration that builds at AFL clubs over such blatant inconsistency.
'Having been inside the four walls, nothing drives footy departments madder than that,' he said.
'They're like, 'You have studiously ignored this rule for 13 weeks, and suddenly, on a Friday night, you ping four of them'.
'The one against Dayne Zorko was an absolute disgrace, and it marched the bloke to the line.'
The protected area infringements have been a contentious rule since their inception, particularly during periods where umpires seemed to be following a directive to be trigger-happy with them.
But Vince praised the AFL for how they had softened this season, paying less of them where play was not affected.
That's why it made Friday night's sudden escalation more peculiar.
'And that's what happens, quite often it's the 50-metre that puts you to the goal line, it's a certain goal,' he said.
'I actually haven't minded the way they haven't paid free kicks for it (this year). I think it hurts you too much, so I actually don't mind the way they've been doing it.
'Why they changed it last night — I didn't see any Thursday night either, so I don't know why Friday night they ping them all.
'I don't know, I can't talk for them.'
Brayshaw also added: 'And then we get a dissent (free kick) — we haven't had one of them for two months either.
'So therefore, what you said was ruder than what everyone else's said for 10 weeks? I don't get it, that's the stuff I don't get.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
7NEWS
32 minutes ago
- 7NEWS
John Longmire's audio from 2024 AFL grand final ‘gone' as former Sydney coach never returned SD card
Former Sydney coach John Longmire never handed back his audio data from last year's grand final, which was needed to produce the annual Sound The Alarm documentary on the AFL website. The yearly documentary series, which begun in 2019, recounts the biggest game of the season from the perspective of the coaches, who are mic'd up during the day, using audio from inside the coaches' box, changerooms, and huddles during breaks. WATCH THE VIDEO ABOVE: John Longmire blocks AFL Media grand final documentary. But Longmire never returned his audio from the 2024 decider, when the Swans were dismantled by Brisbane to the tune of 60 points, according to 7NEWS Melbourne's Mitch Cleary. 'It's a quirky anecdote from what happened on grand final day last year,' Cleary said on The Agenda Setter s on Monday night. 'As we know, on grand finals of recent years, one of the highlights has been the senior coaches and what they've been able to produce when they're mic'd up, post-script. 'We've seen plenty of the audio come out and it's been fantastic viewing. 'Last year's grand final, John Longmire was mic'd up on the day, had the pre-game address, the half-time address, the in-box — everything that came with it. 'But post-game, when he handed back the equipment to the AFL, he took the SD card and, to this day, the AFL don't have the SD card — he never gave it back. 'He took it, tried to get it working with his son during the week, couldn't do so, and has since never handed it back.' Cleary was at paints to say this wasn't necessarily unprecedented, given clubs always curate what makes the final cut anyway. 'I must stress, it's up to the clubs and the coaches, who have the final say on what finally goes to air, but the AFL never had the chance to spool through it,' he said. 'John Longmire, clearly some things were said in the box that he didn't want other ears to hear on the day.' In previous years, fans have got to hear from the likes of Chris Fagan in his side's losing grand final of 2023 and Luke Beveridge from 2021, for example. But 'the John Longmire audio doesn't exist. It's gone,' Cleary said. Asked if his failure to hand the SD card back was an accident or more deliberate, Cleary learnt towards the latter. 'I think there were things said in that coaches' box on the day that shouldn't see the light of day,' he said. 'I think there were some things said about players and some heat-of-the-moment conversations that people don't want to ever hear.' It's worth noting, Cleary added, that Sydney have 'gone out of their way' to compensate for the lost content. 'Typically what we see with this is the AFL get a cut, the club then has final say on what makes it to air or not in the final production,' he said. 'Now, the Swans have gone out of their way in the post-script of the grand final to provide more content for the AFL, from the week, from players on the day. 'But the John Longmire audio won't be part of it and it's gone.' The Lions' premiership victory would be Longmire's last game in the hot seat for the Swans after 15 years in charge. Having taken some time to consider his future in the wake of the grand final bloodbath, Longmire stepped down in November, two months after the game, despite having a contract for 2025. Longmire coached the Swans to their 2012 premiership in his third year and reached the decider another four times in 2014, 2016, 2022 and 2024, but went down in all of them, including heavy defeats in three. The 54-year-old remains at the club in a performance director role, but is far less involved, having handed the reigns over to Dean Cox.
News.com.au
an hour ago
- News.com.au
‘Gross': AFL broadcaster under fire for showing young Carlton fan sobbing
The AFL world is divided after Fox Sports decided to showcase a distraught child during Carlton's embarrassing eleven-point defeat to North Melbourne on Saturday. The Kangaroos, one of the league's weakest teams, sprung a huge upset over the Blues on the weekend much to the anger of fans, with a chorus of boos sounding out around the MCG at several points in the match. FOX FOOTY, available on Kayo Sports, is the only place to watch every match of every round in the 2025 Toyota AFL Premiership Season LIVE in 4K, with no ad-breaks during play. New to Kayo? Get your first month for just $1. Limited-time offer. There was no shortage of sad or dismayed Blues fans in the stands as their side was dominated for large parts of the game but many felt one move by the AFL broadcaster went too far. With Carlton down 84-45 in the final quarter, Fox Sports' decision to pan to a young distraught Blues fan drew the ire of many watching at home. 'That is a summation of what's happened for the Blues with that poor young fella. Mum and Dad have brought him to the footy today, full of hope,' commentator Mark Howard said. While Brisbane Lions great Jonathan Brown quipped: 'That's just bad parenting'. However, many footy fans didn't see the light side of it, slamming the broadcast giant on social media. 'Fox needs to stop zooming in on upset fans. It's not just uncomfortable, it's invasive and exploitative. You don't know why someone's crying. Maybe it's not even about the game. And filming crying kids for broadcast? That's not storytelling, it's just gross,' one angry viewer wrote on social media. 'They should be zooming in on fans but kids crying is not right,' another added. While a third said: 'That poor little fella who is a Carlton supporter & was crying is about to become a meme. He doesn't deserve that. His day is bad enough as it is!' But others didn't see the fuss. 'It's part of the entry policy you accept when buying a ticket. Unlucky, just bottle it up like the rest of us,' one fan wrote. Others commented 'Australia is the land of snowflakes, grow up' and 'They're at a live football match ffs in the public eye how can it be invasive if you don't want people to see your emotions then stay home lol'. After the loss, Carlton coach Michael Voss was equally dismayed, but his anger was shared between his team's performance and the fans' decision to boo. 'It's not time to isolate, it's time to come together,' Voss said in regard to the booing. 'We love coming to the ground and having the supporter base we have and the passion that our supporters have, but we share in their disappointment.' But fans were not done complaining, with 3AW in Melbourne bombarded by angry Blues fans after the game. Eddie called in and said: 'I'm 57 years old and I've been watching Carlton for many years and we still lack heart. 'I'm pleased for North Melbourne, but we were absolutely done in the third quarter. I'm calling it out Voss, sorry mate, you've got to go. It's time for a change.' While Adrian said: 'They show a bit of spine in the last quarter so they can get selected again and not get dropped. 'There's no heart and Michael Voss, you've got no idea what you're going to get from that coach. 'You've got to take most of the blame Michael and we want you out of the football club. Time is up.'
News.com.au
an hour ago
- News.com.au
AFL 2025: Goalkicking great Lance Franklin calls for urgent change at Carlton
AFL great Lance Franklin has urged Carlton to swing the axe on embattled coach Michael Voss 'ASAP'. The Blues went down to the Kangaroos by 11 points on Saturday afternoon – a stunning 93-point turnaround from their Good Friday win in the earlier fixture. The defeat has increased pressure on Voss, prompting captain Patrick Cripps to throw his support behind the Carlton coach on Monday morning. But Franklin sees the situation differently, saying the Blues aren't getting the best out of their list and need urgent change. 'I'm going to put this out there, I know this is a big call, I don't think he sees out the year,' Franklin told The Buddy & Shane Show. 'I think they've got a pretty good list, I do, I think the issue is the messaging is not getting through to the players. 'I think there needs to be change and we've said it before, we're all about the players and coaches, but I think this is a change that needs to happen and it needs to happen ASAP because the messaging is not getting through. 'All of the Carlton supporters would probably say the same. I'm probably speaking on behalf of them. I think there needs to be a change and it'll probably happen in the next few weeks is my tip. 'It's a big call, but that's what I think will happen.' Cripps defended Voss, saying there needed to be greater responsibility on the players. 'I couldn't speak highly enough of Vossy as a coach, also as a mentor and a friend,' Cripps said. 'He puts a lot of work into it along with the whole (coaching group) … that group's very aligned. 'We're in it together – we're not going to point blame at anyone else, we're going to take complete ownership, especially as players. '(Voss) has done a great job for us for a long time now, and I feel like as players, we need to aim up a bit more.' The Blues went into round 15 with a shot at moving closer the top eight but left the MCG to a chorus of boos from their own supporters. Cripps said Carlton was at its best when it was 'stronger together' and pleaded for the frustrated fans to 'buy in and get behind' the Blues. 'I don't want to divide us versus the fans – I feel like it's really important we stay together,' Cripps said. 'When times are tough, it's the most important time to stay together and stay united. 'For a lot of years now, we've had that 'stronger together' mindset, and it's easy to do that when we're winning … it's bloody hard to do that when you're having tough losses. 'We're sticking fat together … buy in and get behind us, we'll turn it around. It's going to take a lot of work and a lot of effort, but we're going to stay united.' Carlton has a short turnaround between games with Port Adelaide on the road this Thursday night.
