Mental Health Bill bypassing health committee ‘sets a dangerous precedent', says chair
Bringing the
Mental Health
Bill straight to the Dáil and bypassing the Oireachtas health committee is 'not in line with best practice' and 'sets a dangerous precedent for the rest of this term', its chairman has said.
Last week, Minister for Mental Health
Mary Butler
secured Cabinet approval of the Government's committee-stage amendments to the bill, which will significantly overhaul the State's mental health laws.
A spokesman for the Minister said 'given the already busy agenda' of the Health Committee, she decided to bring the Bill to the floor of the Dáil 'where every Deputy will have the opportunity to speak on the committee-stage amendments to the Bill'.
[
Admitting a patient without consent and not treating them isn't 'care' - it's imprisonment
Opens in new window
]
Pádraig Rice, chairman of the health committee, wrote to the Minister on Thursday criticising this decision.
READ MORE
Mr Rice, the
Social Democrats
' spokesman on health, said the committee had agreed to undertake extra sessions each week to progress the Bill.
'It is therefore with disappointment, and some frustration, that we learned [on Wednesday] of your plans to bypass the joint committee and bring the Bill straight to the Dáil,' his letter said.
'This Bill is of significant importance and deserves due consideration. Taking this Bill and the hundreds of amendments that are being proposed and expected in the Dáil is not in line with best practice, does the issue a disservice and sets a dangerous precedent for the rest of this term.'
Mr Rice said following his appointment as chair, he expressed an intention to 'work in a spirit of co-operation and partnership with Government and opposition alike'.
'I would appreciate if a similar approach was reciprocated,' he added, requesting the Minister to reconsider her decision.
A spokesman for the Minister said she is 'determined to ensure the Mental Health Bill progresses to enactment before the end of the year'.
'The Bill has been in development for many years, and received support from all sides of the house at second stage last autumn.
'This is far from unprecedented, and many bills have been taken through committee stage on the floor of the House. As Chief Whip, the Minister will ensure the Bill is afforded ample time on the Dáil schedule to allow all of the amendments to be debated fully,' the spokesman said.
If enacted, the new mental health bill will regulate the Child and Adolescent Mental Health Services (Camhs) and other community services for the first time.
It will also allow 16- and 17-year-olds the right to consent to mental healthcare as they already can for physical health.
Under amendments brought to Cabinet this week, an individual who is involuntarily admitted to an acute psychiatric unit can be detained for up to 42 days, an increase on the 21 days previously proposed under the bill.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
3 hours ago
- Irish Times
On Sanctuary Sunday, we share a responsibility to oppose hostility towards migrants and asylum seekers
Today many churches will be marking Sanctuary Sunday with prayer and action as part of their contribution to Refugee Week. The positive theme 'community as a superpower' stands in stark contrast to the examples of violence and hostility towards migrants and people seeking asylum we have witnessed across the island of Ireland in recent times. Violence and division harm communities, shattering the sense of safety and undermining efforts to address shared social and economic challenges. We all have a responsibility to speak out against these outrages, in particular our political leaders, who have been elected to serve the whole community. This year, we are encouraged to share the positive experiences of encounter and relationship-building with people who have come to our community from other backgrounds and cultures, particularly those who have come in search of safety. READ MORE Contributing to an informed and respectful public discourse about issues of migration and asylum is vital. No country should hesitate to answer the question of whether it will offer protection and safety to refugees. [ Ukrainians in Ireland succeeding in asylum applications at twice rate of other nationalities Opens in new window ] The UN Refugee Convention of 1951 is a universal obligation and affirms the need to work globally to protect refugees from violence and danger. The number of people seeking asylum in Ireland has been rising in recent years, as in other countries around the world, but is not disproportionate in European terms. As the UN High Commissioner for Refugees says, the vast majority of refugees displaced by the destruction and danger of war take shelter in neighbouring countries, and so what we are seeing in Ireland and the rest of the EU falls far behind the contribution that some Middle Eastern and African nations are making to the global response to the needs of displaced people. Ireland has the resources to respond with compassion to the desperate needs of people seeking asylum. This does not have to be at the expense of the wellbeing of local communities. The theme of 'community as a superpower' reminds us of the vital role of local communities as partners with the Government in this work, and of the importance of respect, consultation and engagement in that relationship. In my experience, local church congregations offer incredible strength in building community. We are neighbourhood based, we work at the street level and we know how to build partnerships. And we live where we work - we don't parachute in. We work with partners across all faiths and beliefs for community development and cohesion. [ Jim O'Callaghan's public theatrics mask the truth about asylum seeker deportations Opens in new window ] We know we are in for a long haul. We contribute to building better relationships and driving change. My current passion, working with Churches Together in Britain and Ireland, is the development of the idea of church of sanctuary. A church of sanctuary goes beyond welcome and stands with and supports vulnerable people such as those who are seeking asylum. It becomes part of the growing city of sanctuary and places of sanctuary networks in Ireland, a community-led movement committed to building cultures of welcome and hospitality with refugees. In a church of sanctuary all members of the congregation intentionally work together to learn about real-life stories of refugees and people seeking sanctuary, and engage with others to work from facts, not fiction and misinformation. They embed the values and cultures of welcome, hospitality and safety as part of being the congregation and use these to support refugees and people seeking sanctuary. They also share their vision, commitment and achievements, and let others know about the positive contributions of refugees to society and the benefits of welcoming others. At a time when vulnerable migrants and refugees are under attack, the church of sanctuary initiative is a constructive response that flows from the values of the Irish church as a Christian community. This Sanctuary Sunday, we pray for a renewed commitment to challenge hostility with hospitality, inspired by a strong local community vision and working together with people of all faiths and no particular religious belief. Inderjit Bhogal is founder of the City of Sanctuary and Church of Sanctuary initiatives
RTÉ News
8 hours ago
- RTÉ News
Up to 1,000 people partake in Raise the Roof rally in Cork
Up to 1,000 people took to the streets of Cork this afternoon calling for urgent Government action to end homelessness and the housing crisis. The rally, under the umbrella of the Raise the Roof campaign, followed last Tuesday's protest outside the Dáil in Dublin. The national campaign is organised by a coalition of trade unions and Opposition political parties. Among the unions present were SIPTU, Fórsa, the Irish Nurses and Midwives Organisation and the Community Action Tenants Union. Joe Kelly of the Cork Council of Trade Unions said it was great to see people coming out in force to demand that there is a change to the housing policy of the Government. "People are very angry. We have workers on all sides of the economy and they are just priced out of housing. People have good jobs and they still can't a roof over their head," he said. TDs and councillors from Sinn Féín, the Green Party, the Labour Party and the Social Democtrats marched as did members of People Before Profit, the Socialist Party, the Irish Traveller Movement and Derelict Ireland. Jude Sherry and Frank O'Connor of Derelict Ireland carried a banner showing dozens of photographs of derelict homes from across the country. Ms Sherry said: "The whole of the country is crumbling. Every town, village and city has vacant and derelict properties in it. "So we have enough homes in Ireland to meet the emergency of getting everyone a home, even just the amount of council homes in the country is enough to ensure there is no child in emergency accommodation or going without a home." Labour Senator Laura Harmon said the State has to step in to build houses. "Something absolutely has to be done, we are losing teachers, gardaí, nurses, key workers from this country because of the housing crisis. I believe the housing crisis is the biggest threat to our economy here in Ireland, we need to treat it like an emergency," she said. Social Demoncrats TD Pádraig Rice said their message is that the Government's housing policy have failed and they need to change, while Sinn Féin's Thomas Gould said the clear message from today's rally is that "we need homes, and we need them now".
Irish Times
10 hours ago
- Irish Times
Rathmines locals protest over An Post move to sell ‘cultural icon' later this year
Protesters gathered outside Rathmines post office on Saturday morning in a demonstration against its relocation and planned sale of the building. The protest came after An Post this week confirmed its plans to move the Rathmines branch by September, paving the way for the sale of one of the most prominent buildings in the south Dublin suburb. Labour leader and local TD Ivana Bacik organised Saturday's demonstration, alongside local councillors Fiona Connelly and Dermot Lacey. Speaking at the protest, she said the building should be kept 'in community usage', adding that 'our priority is to keep the postal service in the retail hall'. Labour leader Ivana Bacik at the protest in Rathmines on Saturday. Photograph: Ella Sloane The imposing 1934 art deco building will be sold with two other Dublin post offices – Phibsborough and Tallaght – as well as a further three across the State, as part of the 'transformation of the national post office network,' An Post said previously. READ MORE At present, 95 per cent of the country's post offices are already contracted out to independent business owners, who often run post office services as part of a local shop. It is understood the Rathmines post office will move to a Centra store in the locality. Ms Bacik described the demonstration as 'a last-ditch appeal' to Minister for Communications Patrick O'Donovan and Minister for Expenditure Jack Chambers to not sign off on the property's divestment. 'The post office is a very well loved, much-used building. This is very much from the heart.' Ms Connelly stressed the importance of public buildings such as the post office 'as a community asset and a community resource'. Cllr Fiona Connelly at the protest. Photograph: Ella Sloane 'It's really sad to see a resource like the post office, that's in such demand and so heavily used, closing.' Enid O'Dowd, a local and regular user of the postal service, said the decision to sell the building was 'just ridiculous', expressing concern at the pressure the branch's relocation would place on the post office in Ranelagh. Speaking of the branch's speculated move to a nearby Centra, she said the shop 'is going to be a very crushed place with queues spilling out on to the pavement'. 'What's going to happen is people are going to start using the one in Ranelagh but that isn't big enough for the demand. They've only two cashiers there.' Enid O'Dowd at the protest. Photograph: Ella Sloane Cliona Buckley, who grew up on Leinster Road said: 'The last thing they [An Post] should be doing is shutting down memorable, protected, built for purpose buildings. What they should be doing is spending money cleaning up the front of it or they could have lovely potted plants or flower baskets and make it a feature.' She said the post office's planned closure and sale showed a failure by An Post 'to serve the Irish citizens'. Andrew Folan, Mary Freehill and Cliona Buckley at the protest. Photograph: Ella Sloane Another local demonstrator, Andrew Folan, said he felt 'absolutely outraged' by An Post's decision, adding that it was indicative of 'the digitalisation of our culture'. 'The analogue thing of writing letters, posting letters, distributing parcels and meeting the community while you do it is an essential part of our life. I think that the gradual shutting down of post offices is a very negative thing.' Mr Folan pointed to the need for 'a spacious building' due to demand for the service. 'This is a fantastic cultural icon, beautiful design and art deco, well built and a landmark for Rathmines. I think we should celebrate what we've got and show a bit more regard for our culture and our heritage,' he said. Former Labour councillor Mary Freehill, from Rathmines, said the recent loss of the suburb's citizen's information centre in 2022 had already taken a toll on the community. 'There isn't a place for people to come together.' 'Rathmines has very few publicly owned buildings,' said Ms Freehill, adding 'this is the only thing built by the Irish State in Rathmines. All of our other public buildings were built by the British.'
