From mining real gold to digital gold

Listen to article
In March 2022, Pakistan made headlines when Mark Bristow signed a landmark agreement to launch the country's largest-ever copper and gold mining project—a symbol of traditional resource extraction. Three years later, in March 2025, a new frontier emerged with the formation of the Pakistan Crypto Council (PCC), aiming to mine a different kind of gold: digital. From proposals to use idle electricity for crypto mining to controversial links allegedly aimed at attracting US President Donald Trump's attention, Pakistan's crypto ambitions have taken on a complex and politically charged tone.
Currently, cryptocurrencies are banned in Pakistan, as confirmed by officials from the State Bank of Pakistan (SBP) and the Ministry of Finance during a recent National Assembly Standing Committee on Finance meeting. The SBP, in multiple statements, has reiterated that trading, holding, or promoting cryptocurrencies violates domestic law. Citing concerns over capital flight, money laundering, and terrorist financing, the SBP has warned financial institutions against engaging in crypto-related activities.
In early 2025, the finance ministry echoed these concerns, calling crypto ventures "misaligned with national economic goals." This has created internal contradictions, as other government bodies appear to be exploring crypto integration through unofficial channels. Until there is regulatory clarity—preferably through legislation or a policy framework—Pakistan remains a high-risk jurisdiction for any legitimate crypto activity.
The Pakistan Crypto Council (PCC) emerged in early 2025 as a private initiative with lofty ambitions. Branded as an innovation-driven entity, the PCC has signed non-binding agreements with international partners to promote blockchain use in Pakistan. However, many of these agreements and the entities involved have been criticised in both mainstream and social media for lacking transparency.
A major event triggering scrutiny was the visit of Binance founder Changpeng Zhao (CZ) to Pakistan. Convicted in the US in November 2023 for violating anti-money laundering laws, CZ's company also paid a record $4.3 billion penalty. His visit, reportedly facilitated by PCC intermediaries, was viewed by analysts as tone-deaf and damaging to Pakistan's international image.
Adding a geopolitical dimension is PCC's recent Letter of Intent with World Liberty Financial (WLF), a US-based crypto company in which the Trump family reportedly holds a 60% stake. The agreement proposes collaboration on blockchain, stablecoin, and decentralised finance projects in Pakistan.
Critics argue that the move is less about technology and more about political manoeuvring—an effort to curry favour with Donald Trump. The involvement of Steve Witkoff, a Trump ally now serving as a US special envoy, has further fuelled speculation of backdoor diplomacy disguised as financial innovation. Pakistan has over 10,000 MW of excess power generation capacity due to over-commitment in generation contracts and under-utilised industrial demand. But this surplus comes at a steep cost. Electricity remains expensive—10 to 15 cents per kWh for industrial users—making it non-viable for crypto mining, which thrives on rates below 5 cents per kWh in places like Venezuela, Kazakhstan, and Ethiopia.
While crypto mining could monetise some of this idle capacity, alternative uses offer better long-term value. Industrial and Special Economic Zones (SEZs) can justify higher tariffs through job creation and exports. Green hydrogen targets premium markets, while data centres and IT parks generate high income per energy unit. Cold storage facilities for agriculture are crucial for exports and reducing food waste. EV infrastructure can help lower fuel imports while promoting sustainability.
If the government is considering subsidised energy for crypto mining to attract global miners, then why not do the same for these sectors? These alternatives maximise economic utility by pairing energy use with employment, export potential, and long-term gains. In contrast, crypto is volatile and speculative, potentially locking Pakistan into low-return ventures while sidelining more transformative opportunities.
Amid rising interest in cryptocurrency, Pakistan's consideration of Bitcoin as a strategic reserve is fraught with significant risk. While countries like El Salvador have recently profited from such investments, Pakistan's volatile economy, regulatory vacuum, and legal bans make this approach dangerous. The IMF has already raised concerns over subsidised power tariffs. Meanwhile, any move to build Bitcoin reserves—especially from confiscated assets—could provoke renewed scrutiny from the FATF, jeopardising Pakistan's progress in exiting the grey list.
With limited reserves and a fragile economy, adopting crypto as a reserve asset may seem reckless. Instead, Pakistan must focus on financial stability and regulatory clarity, rather than speculative digital ventures.
Ultimately, the question isn't whether Pakistan can enter the crypto economy, but whether it should—and to what extent. In the absence of clear regulation, public consensus, and a sound economic rationale, the pursuit of crypto mining may cost more than it offers. As the world moves toward regulated, sustainable digital finance, Pakistan must decide whether chasing crypto-mining under uncertain pretences is worth the price of strategic credibility.
THE WRITER IS A FINANCIAL MARKET ENTHUSIAST AND IS ASSOCIATED WITH PAKISTAN'S STOCKS, COMMODITIES AND EMERGING TECHNOLOGY

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Express Tribune

24 minutes ago

• Express Tribune

EU seeks 'digital sovereignty'

The State Bank is working on a project to prevent digital frauds through deploying artificial intelligence. photo: file Listen to article At a market stall in Berlin run by charity Topio, volunteers help people who want to purge their phones of the influence of US tech firms. Since Donald Trump's inauguration, the queue for their services has grown. Interest in European-based digital services has jumped in recent months, data from digital market intelligence company Similarweb shows. More people are looking for e-mail, messaging and even search providers outside the United States. The first months of Trump's second presidency have shaken some Europeans' confidence in their long-time ally, after he signalled his country would step back from its role in Europe's security and then launched a trade war. "It's about the concentration of power in US firms," said Topio's founder Michael Wirths, as his colleague installed on a customer's phone a version of the Android operating system without hooks into the Google ecosystem.

Express Tribune

an hour ago

• Express Tribune

SBP seeks tax on foreign investment

Listen to article As the local currency comes under renewed stress, the State Bank of Pakistan (SBP) on Saturday proposed linking tax benefits with a minimum one-year retention period for foreign investments in government debt and equity markets to bring predictability in outflows. Dr Mohammad Ali Malik, an SBP executive, suggested the 10% reduced income tax rate should be tied to at least one-year retention of investment made through the Special Convertible Rupee Account (SCRA). He made the proposal during a meeting of the National Assembly Standing Committee on Finance, chaired by Pakistan People's Party (PPP)'s Syed Naveed Qamar. Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) Chairman Rashid Langrial said that investors were securing tax advantages by making short-term investments. He recommended a minimum six-month holding period for investments in Roshan Digital Accounts and other schemes to qualify for tax benefits. With this, the central bank seeks more predictable dollar outflows. However, the committee warned that such a move could deter investors, which the government could not afford. Dr Malik argued that the condition would not disrupt current inflows, as significant investments in treasury bills, government bonds, and SCRAs were not presently being made. He said linking tax incentives with long-term investments could help stabilise outflows. Under SBP regulations, non-residents may freely invest and trade in government marketable securities, including Pakistan Investment Bonds (PIBs), Treasury Bills (TBs), registered corporate debt instruments, and the Water and Power Development Authority (WAPDA)'s registered bonds through SCRAs. Following months of stability, the rupee has again come under pressure due to increased debt repayments. The rupee's value has depreciated to around Rs284 per US dollar in the interbank market, with even higher rates in the open market. A senior executive from a private commercial bank said large interbank transactions are being settled at nearly Rs3 above the average market rate. In an economic alert issued Saturday, advisory firm Tola Associates warned that ongoing unrest in the Middle East and Pakistan's reliance on imported oil posed serious risks of economic disruption. Crude oil prices, it stated, have surged over the past two weeks, rising from $63.76 on June 2 to $76.31 per barrel by June 19 due to the ongoing Gulf conflict. Tola Associates noted a dual inflationary impact on Pakistan's economy: higher crude prices widen the current account deficit and weaken the rupee against the dollar, which further fuels inflation. If crude oil hits $80 per barrel, the rupee may slide to Rs285.4 per dollar; if it rises to $100, the rupee could depreciate further to Rs292.1. In that case, local petrol prices may need to rise by Rs35 per litre, the firm said. The government has already formed a committee, chaired by Finance Minister Muhammad Aurangzeb, to review the implications of Israel's illegal act of war against Iran on Pakistan's economy and petroleum flows. Tola Associates said that the direct impact of higher crude prices on domestic petrol rates may further fuel inflation and make life more difficult for the people of Pakistan. It has estimated the additional impact of inflation by 1.8% in case crude oil price increases to $80 and 8.7% if the prices surge to $100. The current account deficit is also projected to widen to $4.3 billion in the next fiscal year, if crude oil hits $100 price. The standing committee also reviewed another proposal: taxing income from government debt investments even if withdrawn before maturity. Currently, some investors evade taxes by prematurely selling and rebuying securities — a tactic known as "coupon washing." The FBR proposed in the budget that tax be charged on the investment regardless of early withdrawal, estimating an additional Rs10 billion in revenue. However, the committee adjusted the proposal, reducing the required holding period from one year to six months. Last month, the FBR had discussed the coupon washing measure with the International Monetary Fund (IMF). But the IMF was sceptical that people who buy government securities do not pay taxes. Additionally, the committee approved raising the cash withdrawal threshold for non-filers — subject to a 0.8% tax — from Rs50,000 to Rs75,000. However, it rejected the FBR's recommendation to increase the tax rate to 1%, which had been 0.6% before the budget proposal.

Express Tribune

an hour ago

• Express Tribune

Court shields foreign students at Harvard

A federal judge on Friday indefinitely paused Donald Trump's bid to block Harvard from enrolling foreign students as the US president said a "deal" with the Ivy League school was in the works, reported AFP. The order by District Judge Allison Burroughs will allow international students to continue to attend the elite university while a lawsuit filed by Harvard plays out in the courts. Trump, who has cut federal grants for Harvard and tried a host of different tactics to block the institution from hosting international students, said that his administration has been holding negotiations with Harvard. "Many people have been asking what is going on with Harvard University and their large-scale improprieties that we have been addressing, looking for a solution," Trump said in a post Friday on Truth Social. "We have been working closely with Harvard, and it is very possible that a deal will be announced over the next week or so," he said. "If a settlement is made on the basis currently being discussed, it will be mindboggingly historic, and very good for our country." Trump did not provide any details about the purported "deal." The Trump administration has sought to remove Harvard from an electronic student immigration registry and instructed embassies to deny visas to international students hoping to attend the Massachusetts-based university. Harvard has sued the Department of Homeland Security and other agencies to block the efforts, arguing that they were illegal and unconstitutional. Harvard previously secured two temporary restraining orders from Burroughs against the government's move to bar international students, and the judge extended it with a preliminary injunction on Friday. International students accounted for 27 per cent of total enrollment at Harvard in the 2024-2025 academic year and are a major source of income. In court filings, Harvard argued that Trump's actions were "retribution for Harvard's exercising its First Amendment rights to reject the government's demands to control Harvard's governance, curriculum, and the 'ideology' of its faculty and students."