San Francisco school district ditches proposed 'Grading for Equity' strategy after backlash from community
The San Francisco Unified School District will not be moving forward with a controversial equity grading strategy that was proposed this week after significant backlash.
The strategy, known as "Grading for Equity," was presented during a SFUSD Board of Education meeting on Tuesday, according to Superintendent Maria Su, with the goal of offering "professional development opportunity in standards-based grading."
Under the proposed standards, how a student scores on the final exam, which could be taken multiple times, would be what counts toward their grade for the semester, according to the Voice of San Francisco.
Homework and weekly tests would not impact the grade, and neither would late assignments, tardiness to class or absence from school.
College Dropouts Celebrate At Unconventional 'Graduation' Ceremony In San Francisco
The letter-grade system would also be significantly altered, allowing students who score an 80 to receive an A and students who score as low as a 21 to pass with a D, which models the "Grading for Equity" system in the San Leandro Unified School District, Voice of San Francisco reported.
Read On The Fox News App
The new system was supposed to be tested by 70 teachers in 14 SFUSD schools until the community, including the mayor and lawmakers, spoke out against the proposal.
San Francisco Mayor Daniel Lurie wrote on X that the younger generation is owed "an education that prepares them to succeed" and the "changes to grading at SFUSF would not accomplish that."
"I have conveyed our view to SFUSD. We are optimistic that there is a better path forward for our kids and their future," he wrote, in part.
Tensions Flare At School Board Meeting After Trans Athlete Wins Multiple Track Events
U.S. Rep. Kevin Kiley, R-Calif., called out the proposal, sarcastically describing it as a "brilliant solution."
"San Francisco has come up with a brilliant solution for its failing schools. Students simply won't be failed," Kiley wrote on X. "Under the new 'Grading for Equity' plan, Fs are now Cs; Bs are now As; homework and tests are ungraded; truancy is unpunished; and finals can be re-taken again and again."
U.S. Rep. Ro Khanna, D-Calif., also shared his opinion on the proposed grading system on his personal X account.
"My immigrant dad asked me where the missing 10% went when I scored a 90. He came to America for the chance to work hard & pursue excellence. Giving A's for 80% & no homework is not equity—it betrays the American Dream and every parent who wants more for their kids," he wrote.
A statement from Su on SFUSD's X account on Wednesday said that there have been no changes to grading practices within the school district and no action was taken at the meeting.
She said each student within the school district is held to a high standard and SFUSD's goal is to "support student success by prioritizing learning and mastery."
"It's clear that there are a lot of questions, concerns and misinformation with this proposal. We want to make sure any changes benefit our students," Su wrote, in part.Original article source: San Francisco school district ditches proposed 'Grading for Equity' strategy after backlash from community
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Boston Globe
9 hours ago
- Boston Globe
Still marching after all these years
Many of us have had a lot of practice: Vietnam, Afghanistan, Iraq. We protested every bad government action. Advertisement I learned nonviolent civil disobedience from my parents, growing up in Brooklyn. They were activists even before Vietnam. During the civil rights movement, in 1964, driving through St. Augustine, Fla., they attended a demonstration. When protesters refused to leave a sit-in attempting to integrate the Ponce de Leon Motor Lodge restaurant, some were arrested and jailed. My parents were not arrested, but they were present, in solidarity, as lifelong believers in human rights, in including Black Americans in the American Dream. What we now call DEI was already a good goal. Advertisement And me? Young as I was, my good-girl head was down, finishing my master's thesis on Proust, in graduate school far away. I was merely an educated girl, not political yet, not focused on the common good as they were. Both of them had been radicals in the 1930s, when Jewish leftists and others hoped that a popular front could remake US labor relations, control capitalist greed, and bring America closer to equality for women and people of color. Paul Robeson was one of their idols, along with Eleanor Roosevelt. Later, they opposed the Vietnam War, just as my husband and I did. In 1968, running against feckless Hubert Humphrey, treacherous Richard Nixon promised to end the war, and then prolonged it until more than 50,000 men my age died, as well as countless Vietnamese and Cambodians. In 1972 my father worked to elect Elizabeth Holtzman, also of Brooklyn, to Congress. So she was in the House of Representatives in time to vote to impeach the corrupt Nixon in the summer of 1974. My father, with ALS sapping his body, had followed the investigation and trial avidly from the green couch in the living room. But he missed out on the ending. By August he was in a coma; he died two days short of Nixon's ignominious exit. The night Nixon left, making his awkward, hypocritical peace signs, my mother and I were dining in the dim kitchen with my cousin Sherry, grieving and rejoicing. In that painful, complex mood, we poured some wine and drank to him: 'Marty should have been here to see this day.' 'Daddy should have been here.' Advertisement I know my parents would be out with me on the streets now. They were there, in a sense — at a #HandsOff rally on April 5 in Newton, at an April 19 event to celebrate the 250th anniversary of the beginning of the American Revolution in Waltham, and then at the 'No Kings' rally. The signs were clever and scathing at all these events; drivers going by were honking in approval, shouting, applauding. My laconic father's sign would have said, very big, in block letters, 'NO!' Once when my mother was in her 90s and had lost many memories, I asked her, 'What is wisdom?' She answered unhesitatingly: 'The greatest part of wisdom is kindness.' Her sign, which I saw an older woman hold at the Waltham rally, would have read 'Make America kind again.' 'Nothing is stranger than the position of the dead among the living,' Virginia Woolf wrote in her first, unpublished novel, 'Melymbrosia.' I find it marvelous that my parents can still stand by my side. The rest of our family is in the streets, too: our son and his children in New York City. That solidarity is so welcome to us — just as it must have been to my parents when we opposed the Vietnam War early on, when they felt alone and scorned, when so few Americans had yet come to their senses. Advertisement Intergenerational solidarity is precious. That preciousness includes not only the next generations, but the oldest, too. To all of us lucky enough to have older people in our lives, they comfort us by their presence. Repositories of family lore and legend, they dole out secrets and, for better or worse, guide us by their experiences. And sometimes by the energy of their activism, right now! I see my parents' faces vividly. I summon them and their will to do good, which survives them, in this national emergency. Their memory is a blessing in the here and now and the strife to come.
Yahoo
15 hours ago
- Yahoo
Downtown San Francisco's home prices are surging — and not only because the new mayor is tackling quality-of-life issues
After years of declining property values, shuttered storefronts and a pandemic-driven exodus of remote tech workers, signs of life are reemerging in San Francisco's core. Median home list prices in one central ZIP code — encompassing neighborhoods like Nob Hill, Union Square and the Tenderloin — soared 51% in May compared to the same time last year, according to While those figures reflect list prices rather than final sale prices — and can swing based on the mix of homes entering the market — the sharp uptick points to renewed buyer interest in an area that, until recently, symbolized San Francisco's struggles. The shift comes not only as more workers return to their offices, but also as newly elected Mayor Daniel Lurie pushes a cleanup campaign aimed at reversing the city's declining reputation. Since taking office in January, Lurie has focused on curbing open-air drug markets, reducing homelessness and boosting sanitation, while proposing a budget centered on core services like public safety. 'The people of this city have called on us to rebuild a safer, cleaner, thriving San Francisco,' Lurie said last month. 'To do that, we must provide clean and safe streets, address the crisis of homelessness and addiction, and reinvigorate the spirit and strength of businesses and neighborhoods across this city.' Lurie, a political newcomer and heir to the Levi Strauss fortune, defeated incumbent Mayor London Breed in a campaign dominated by concerns over quality-of-life issues. His proposed $800 million budget includes controversial cuts to city staffing — roughly 1,400 positions — while expanding law enforcement and behavioral health initiatives. Among the measures already underway: targeted enforcement in drug hotspots and new rules requiring city-distributed drug paraphernalia to be paired with counseling referrals. Though some critics have protested the staffing cuts, Lurie's office touts early progress. Crime is down nearly 30%, car break-ins are at their lowest point in 22 years and street encampments have dropped to their lowest level since 2019, according to city data. 'We're definitely starting to see progress,' Steven Huang, founder of Ascend Real Estate and president of the San Francisco Association of Realtors, told 'Some of it is visible today, and I would say that even in Downtown, in Union Square, our famous shopping district, you're definitely going to see a lot more foot traffic already, but it's just the beginning.' The housing recovery remains uneven. In the broader San Francisco metro, the median home list price stood at $998,000 in May — still 4% lower than a year earlier. Most ZIP codes across the city continue to lag behind pre-pandemic pricing levels. The collapse began in earnest in 2022, when San Francisco home prices tumbled 12% over a nine-month stretch, according to the Case-Shiller Home Price Index. The hollowing out of downtown — fueled by work-from-home shifts, office vacancies and the fentanyl crisis — left once-busy corridors eerily quiet. 'Demand for homes in central San Francisco fell as office workers went remote and even relocated,' said Hannah Jones, senior economic research analyst at 'However, compared to last year, prices are on the rise again, suggesting demand for homes in the city is on the rise once again, perhaps prompted by return-to-office requirements.' Whether the current momentum can be sustained remains to be seen. The market is still navigating high interest rates, affordability challenges, and persistent concerns about public safety. But with AI companies clustering in the Bay Area and downtown's cleanup underway, some see the beginnings of a fragile rebound. Sign in to access your portfolio
Axios
18 hours ago
- Axios
"Zero tolerance": SF leaders denounce recent acts of antisemitism
Local officials and community leaders gathered Friday at City Hall to condemn a recent string of antisemitic incidents and to assure San Franciscans that perpetrators will be punished. Why it matters: The public stand comes after Jewish-owned cafe Manny's was vandalized and a man accused of a violent attack in the Marina was charged with a hate crime. What they're saying: "As a member of the Jewish community, these incidents hit close to home," Mayor Daniel Lurie said. "I want to be clear that we have zero tolerance for acts of hatred. ... If you commit a hate crime in San Francisco, we will find you and we will arrest you." There has been "a dramatic rise in antisemitism locally and nationally, on both polar extremes left and right of our politics," Tye Gregory, executive director of the Jewish Community Relations Council, said at the press conference. "This isn't about what's going on outside of the United States in the Middle East or anywhere else," district attorney Brooke Jenkins said. "This is about what we believe and who we are." State of play: Since the Oct. 7, 2023, Hamas attacks, the Bay Area Jewish Community Federation has recorded over 40 threats — including bomb threats to local synagogues, schools and community centers — and more than 220 incidents of harassment and intimidation, senior vice president Rebecca Randall said Friday. Manny's was hit with graffiti saying "F**k Manny" and "The only good settler is a dead 1" following a night of anti-ICE protests earlier in June. Meanwhile, the attack in the Marina occurred after a Jewish woman asked a group of people to stop shouting "F**k Jews, free Palestine," she told the San Francisco Chronicle. Juan Diaz-Rivas punched the woman's friend, repeating antisemitic remarks and causing him to lose consciousness, prosecutors allege. Diaz-Rivas has pleaded not guilty. The big picture: Jewish leaders across the nation have warned that President Trump's invocation of antisemitism to justify policies like slashing college funds and deporting student protesters risks making Jewish people scapegoats.
