Local official calls police on residents seeking public government records
Social Sharing
An official of a rural municipality outside Fredericton is facing charges after she called the RCMP on residents asking for public documents they were legally entitled to.
Marjorie Turner, the chief administrative officer for Sunbury-York South, was scheduled to appear in Fredericton provincial court on Wednesday on two charges of violating the Local Governance Act, which police officials called "extremely rare."
Turner was not present, but CBC News made a request for an interview through her lawyer, who was in court for the proceeding, which was adjourned without plea until May 28. Turner has not yet responded to the interview request.
Created under the province's 2023 municipal amalgamations, Sunbury-York South includes Nasonworth, Rusagonis, Waasis and Charters Settlement.
Mac Burns, who's lived in the community for 50 years, first took an interest in the new council after it proposed building an $8-million municipal complex last fall. Council later backed down after a public outcry.
"We were saying, if they're going to spend $8 million on a municipal building, where else are they spending the money?" he said in an interview earlier this week.
Burns started looking into how much the municipality had paid for land on Chaparral Road in Waasis for the proposed building and how much it was paying to rent a temporary office in neighbouring Oromocto.
CAO called police on two residents
Burns went to the municipal office on Dec. 19 to ask for records that would explain why certain matters had been discussed in closed session. Under the Local Governance Act, a council must record "the type of matter" discussed in closed session in their meeting minutes.
The act also states that most council documents "shall be available for examination by members of the public" in the clerk's office.
But the clerk told Burns several times it was not available. He said Turner then appeared and asked him to leave while she was on the phone to the RCMP. Burns recorded the audio of the interaction on his phone, which he shared with CBC News.
By that time, Turner had already called the RCMP on another resident, Melissa Gillis, who had also been seeking public records.
Gillis confirmed with CBC News that she was given a trespass notice on Nov. 27.
She also shared an April 11 email from Mayor David Hayward, who apologized for the notice and said it had been lifted.
When asked if he was concerned with what happened, Hayward said in an interview that he wanted to make clear that it was Turner as an individual facing charges, not the entire municipal government.
Hayward said Turner has been out of the office "for some time" and he hasn't spoken with her since the incidents.
When asked if he would support her employment if Turner is found guilty, Hayward said it would be a human resources matter to be discussed at that time.
RCMP confirms they were called to office twice
In an interview, RCMP Sgt. Stéphane Esculier of the Oromocto detachment confirmed the RCMP were called to the municipal office for "disturbances" on both dates and said a trespass notice was issued for the first incident but not the second, although it "had been considered."
Esculier said there is a "fairly low threshold" to issue a trespass notice to someone.
"It's something that was requested by the CAO at the time to avoid, I guess, further disturbances at the location," he said.
Esculier said the RCMP then investigated the incidents, which resulted in the charges the CAO now faces — two counts of failing to provide documents required for examination by members of the public. She faces a maximum fine of $5,200.
He said the Local Governance Act is not something the RCMP deals with very often, although it does have jurisdiction.
"Personally, that's the first time I've seen charges under that act," Esculier said.
Charges racked up at Costco, Amazon
Burns said his investigation revealed other concerns, completely separate from the charges Turner is facing.
Documents received through a right to information request show the municipality's bank card racked up charges for various items at Costco.
The receipts don't have a name attached and include office-type purchases like coffee pods and office supplies. But they also go beyond the expected, including gouda and havarti cheese, pickles, ramen, yogurt, peanut butter, fruit salad, dark chocolate, mozzarella bites and carrots.
There was also a receipt from the Costco food court for a chicken tenders meal — with extra gravy.
Receipts for Amazon were clearly addressed to Turner. They include a $26.44 microwave egg cooker and a $41.99 essential oil diffuser.
"I'm concerned with the administration office when you're buying peanut butter and Mr. Noodles, dill pickles and being charged to the taxpayers," Burns said.
He said he's kept on the case because he's retired and wants to hold municipal officials accountable.
"I think what we found was no checks and balances with the CAO," he said.
"So the message is to be diligent. See what your council is doing, see what the mayor is doing and that act — make sure they follow the act."
Mayor stands by staff, council
Hayward said he was aware of the receipts and that they led the municipality to start working on a new spending policy for employees.
"Without that structure in place, if there isn't a rule, then you're not breaking the rule," Hayward said.
"I want to be be very clear that I don't believe any member of our council or staff have any nefarious plans or there's been any extraordinary expenditures outside of the norm."
Retired mountie says situation is 'nonsense'
Gilles Blinn, a retired RCMP staff sergeant who's lived in Nasonworth for 30 years, said he's concerned about "a lack of accountability."
He called the trespass warnings nonsense and said citizens are entitled to public information "because we pay their wages, right? It's a government organization. They have to provide it. There's no two ways about it."
Blinn echoed what Esculier said about charges under the Local Governance Act being rare.
"I don't know if we've ever laid one in this province, ever," Blinn said.
He admitted that it's "not the crime of the century," likening it more to a speeding ticket than a criminal offence. But Blinn said it was serious enough to warrant a charge and that the CAO is ultimately beholden to residents.
"These people request something, you have to provide it, right?" he said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBC
an hour ago
- CBC
2nd body found in Banff rockfall
June 20, 2025 | Searchers recover the body of a second victim after a deadly rockfall in Banff National Park. Israel and Iran trade more airstrikes as nuclear talks stall. And, why summer jobs are so hard to find for young Canadians.
National Post
an hour ago
- National Post
In Alberta, separatism is on the ballot in a rural byelection on Monday
OTTAWA — Cameron Davies, the leader of the separatist Republican Party of Alberta and the party's candidate for Monday's Olds-Didsbury-Three Hills byelection, admits that his party's name and MAGA red branding are causing some confusion at the doors. Article content 'It certainly has come up in conversation,' Davies told the National Post on Thursday. Article content 'People want to know more about it, what it means and that's just an opportunity to explain why the word 'republican' and why a constitutional republic is something we want to look at.' Article content Davies' Republican party isn't formally aligned with the more well-known one south of the border — notably swapping out the latter's elephant for a more local buffalo as its logo — but it does aspire to make Alberta an independent republic governed similarly in principle to the U.S. Article content 'The form of government Canada has doesn't work for Alberta, and the form of government we have here in Alberta doesn't work for Alberta,' said Davies. Article content Davies, an ex-UCP organizer, is one of two separatist candidates who'll be on the ballot in Monday's byelection in the south-central Alberta riding, where the governing United Conservative Party won more votes than anywhere else in the province in 2023's provincial election. Article content The other is employee benefits specialist Bill Tufts, running under the banner of the Wildrose Loyalty Coalition. Article content Under normal circumstances, the byelection would be a tap-in for first-time UCP candidate Tara Sawyer. But these are anything but normal circumstances, with support for Alberta separatism spiking on the heels of the federal Liberals fourth straight election win. Article content Article content What's more, Davies and Tufts have a fortuitous piece of Alberta election lore to point to. Article content Western Concept candidate Gordon Kesler notched a surprise 1982 byelection win in predecessor riding Olds-Didsbury, briefly becoming the first and only separatist to hold a seat in Alberta's legislature. Article content Kesler is still active in the area's politics and is backing Davis in the byelection. Article content Ex-Alberta MLA Derek Fildebrandt, whose now-defunct riding of Strathmore-Brooks crossed into the riding's east end, says he expects the Republicans to place a strong second, possibly even pushing the UCP below a majority vote share. Article content 'Based on my gut, nothing hard,' said Fildebrandt.
CBC
an hour ago
- CBC
The U.S. is cutting billions from science. Canadian researchers say it's time to step up
Social Sharing Scientists in Canada are scrambling. Over the past few months, the U.S. government has cut billions of dollars in funding from scientific research as part of sweeping cost-cutting measures. "It's really shocking. It's really like this big cloud over science," Kate Moran, CEO of Ocean Networks Canada, told Quirks & Quarks. Ocean Networks Canada participates in a project called the Argo system, an international program that collects information from on and under the ocean using a fleet of robotic instruments that drift with the ocean currents. But that program, which is led by researchers in the U.S., could be at risk. Many Canadian research groups rely heavily on U.S. partners for support and data. But since Donald Trump was elected president of the United States, that support has taken a massive hit. The New York Times reported in March that the administration plans to reduce the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration's (NOAA) workforce by up to 20 per cent, which Moran says could have a direct impact on their work. Some of those staffing cuts at the NOAA have already happened. "Because the U.S. is such a big player, I'm not sure we could step up and be like the U.S.," said Moran. And cuts are happening across the board. The administration terminated $1 billion US in cuts to the National Institutes of Health, a move ruled "void and illegal" and blocked by a district judge earlier this month. The government has also been in a battle with Harvard University, putting billions of dollars of potential funding in jeopardy. Layoffs across a number of government agencies have been put on hold by a federal judge in California. In an executive order issued by the White House in May, Trump said that "over the last 5 years, confidence that scientists act in the best interests of the public has fallen significantly." "My Administration is committed to restoring a gold standard for science to ensure that federally funded research is transparent, rigorous, and impactful, and that Federal decisions are informed by the most credible, reliable, and impartial scientific evidence available." Environment and Climate Change Canada told CBC in a statement it "has a long-standing relationship with the U.S. National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) on operational and research activities related to weather, climate, satellites, and water monitoring," and that the "department has not been formally informed of any changes to its collaboration with NOAA." The trickle-down effect of cuts has left Canadian researchers trying to figure out how to adapt to these uncertain times, while others say it's now Canada's responsibility to step up. Targeting climate science Environmental science and diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) efforts seem to be a direct target of the Trump administration's cuts. More than 1,000 scientists and other employees are set to be laid-off from the Environmental Protection Agency's research office. The effects have been felt in Canada. Researchers here filling out forms for U.S. government grants have had to answer questions such as "Can you confirm this is not a climate or 'environmental justice' project or include such elements?" and "Can you confirm that this is no DEI project or DEI elements of the project?" The political climate has Deborah Wench on edge. She relies heavily on information from long-term monitoring projects to fuel her research into the carbon cycle. Wench studies how carbon flows between different climates. To do that, she needs long-term data sets collected from satellites. Wench says the U.S. operates a lot of the satellites used in her research. "I'm not really sure how to express this. It's mostly, for me, a sense of impending doom," said Wench, an associate professor at the University of Toronto. "It's taken decades and the careers of thousands of people to build up these measurement records, and it looks like it will take months to destroy them." Though she didn't want to specify which specific instruments she uses, she says she's concerned it's on the chopping block in the U.S., which would mean a loss of long-term monitoring. Then there's HAWC, a project that will use three Canadian-built instruments to measure the amount of aerosols, water vapour and thin ice clouds in the upper troposphere and lower stratosphere. The information could be used to improve future climate projects, assuming it continues to receive NASA support. Trump's 2026 budget, released in May, proposed a $6 billion US funding cut to the space agency, amounting to 24 per cent of NASA's current budget. WATCH | Canadian scientists trying to keep world's ocean sensors afloat: Canadian scientists trying to keep world's ocean sensors afloat 12 minutes ago Duration 1:32 These robot scientists dive deep into the ocean to measure the vital signs of planet Earth. But proposed funding cuts in the U.S. could mean critical climate data is on the chopping block. "Much of it is just so speculative, right?" said Chris Fletcher, an associate professor at the University of Waterloo. "We're still kind of on the descent.... So it's unclear yet exactly how all of this will shake out, and it's quite unsettling." One of the HAWC instruments was supposed to be attached to a NASA satellite. But Fletcher says that's now in question. "I'm confident from the Canadian side that because of this tremendous investment that Canada has made, that our instruments will fly. The question is about which components of the proposed NASA mission will fly," said Fletcher. CBC reached out to the Canadian Space Agency, but did not recieve a comment before publication. What happens next Canada's Department of Innovation, Science and Industry did not provide an interview or comment to CBC about how Canada plans to respond to funding cuts in the U.S. Frédéric Bouchard says the turmoil in the U.S. means a greater responsibility for Canada to assert its scientific sovereignty. He was part of the federally funded Advisory Panel on the Federal Research Support System, which, in 2023, took a deep dive into how Canada could better support scientific research. "It's our own responsibility to make sure that we have a strong and generous science capacity so we have access to the experts we need, when we need them," said Bouchard, a philosopher of science and dean of the faculty of arts and sciences at the Université de Montréal. "We shouldn't wait for other countries to do all the hard work and hope that we can benefit from it." He says that as American scientists leave the United States, Canada could welcome some of those researchers. He also said it will be important to invest in the future, including support for graduate students both in Canada and abroad in the United States, to make sure they're able to continue work in their field. Even so, Bouchard says, what's happening in the U.S. is going to have an impact — there's no stopping that. "What's happening is destabilizing science across the world," said Bouchard. "We need to make sure we play a larger role and that we build our own muscle mass, if you will, to be able to withstand more of the disruption." Moran says Ocean Networks Canada, and other organizations like it, are ready to do so. She says they are prepared to do simple things, such as download data to protect the long-term data sets. And if there are more cuts in the U.S., she says she's prepared to make the case to the Canadian government and request more funding. "We're talking about what we could do to fill those gaps," said Moran. "Canada has all the skills and knowledge and scientists." Politically-driven chaos is disrupting U.S. scientific institutions and creating challenges for science in Canada. Science is a global endeavour and collaborations with the U.S. are routine. In this special episode of Quirks & Quarks, we explore what Canadian scientists are doing to preserve their work to assert scientific sovereignty in the face of this unprecedented destabilization. Canadian climate scientists brace for cuts to climate science infrastructure and data U.S. President Donald Trump's attacks on climate science are putting our Earth observing systems, in the oceans and in orbit, at risk. Canadian scientists who rely on U.S. led climate data infrastructure worry about losing long-term data that would affect our ability to understand our changing climate. With: Kate Moran, the president and CEO of Ocean Networks Canada and Emeritus Professor of Oceanography at the University of Victoria Debra Wunch, Physicist at the University of TorontoChris Fletcher, Department of Geography and Environmental Management at the University of Waterloo U.S. cuts to Great Lakes science and monitoring threaten our shared freshwater resourceU.S. budget and staffing cuts are jeopardizing the long-standing collaboration with our southern neighbour to maintain the health of the Great Lakes, our shared resource and the largest freshwater system in the world. With: Jérôme Marty, executive director of the International Association for Great Lakes Research and part-time professor at the University of OttawaGreg McClinchey, policy and legislative director with the Great Lakes Fishery CommissionMichael Wilkie, Biologist at Wilfred Laurier UniversityBrittney Borowiec, research associate in the Wilkie Lab at Wilfred Laurier UniversityAaron Fisk, Ecologist and Canada Research Chair at the University of Windsor Unexpected ways U.S. culture war policies are affecting Canadian scientists One of the first things President Trump did after taking office was to sign an executive order eliminating all DEI policies in the federal government. This is having far-reaching consequences for Canadian scientists as they navigate the new reality of our frequent research partner's hostility against so-called 'woke science.'With:Dr. Sofia Ahmed, Clinician scientist, and academic lead for the Women and Children's Health Research Institute at the University of Alberta Angela Kaida, professor of health sciences and Canada Research Chair at Simon Fraser University in VancouverDawn Bowdish, professor of immunology, the executive director of the Firestone Institute for Respiratory Health and Canada Research Chair at McMaster UniversityKevin Zhao, MD/PhD student in immunology in the Bowdish Lab at McMaster UniversityJérôme Marty, executive director of the International Association for Great Lakes Research Canada has a 'responsibility' to step up and assert scientific sovereigntyA 2023 report on how to strengthen our federal research support system could be our roadmap to more robust scientific sovereignty. The Advisory Panel on the Federal Research Support System made recommendations to the federal government for how we could reform our funding landscape. The intent was to allow us to quickly respond to national research priorities and to make Canada a more enticing research partner in world science. With: Frédéric Bouchard, Dean of the Faculty of Arts and Sciences and professor of philosophy of science at the Université de Montreal. Chair of the Advisory Panel on the Federal Research Support System.
