Display of saint's remains draws huge crowds - but bishop says it 'encourages morbid curiosity'

Tens of thousands of people have flocked to see the remains of a revered Spanish saint, more than 440 years after her death, prompting debate over whether such displays "encourage morbid curiosity".
Catholic worshippers in their droves have travelled to Alba de Tormes in western to view relics of Saint Teresa of Avila, a 16th-century religious reformer.
Faithful lined up to see her, silent and wonderstruck as the remains of the mystic were put on display in a silver casket for the first time in more than 100 years.
"It gave me a feeling of fulfilment, of joy, and of sadness," said Guiomar Sanchez, who travelled from Madrid with her two daughters on Sunday, the last full day of the exhibit.
"Seeing her was an inexplicable experience," she added, praising the saint as being ahead of her time.
After weeks on display, the casket of Saint Teresa was resealed on Monday and carried through the streets with pilgrims following behind her.
Saint Teresa, who died in 1582, is a towering figure from Spain's Golden Age and 16th-century counter-reformation.
Her explorations of the inner life and meditations on her relationship with God were controversial, yet they have been held up over the centuries as a "profound treatise on spirituality," said Jose Calvo, a professor of theology at the Pontifical University of Salamanca who specialises in Medieval history.
Her admirers include Spanish dictator General Francisco Franco, who was rumoured to have kept a relic of the saint's hand next to his bed, and new , who visited her birthplace last year.
Read more from Sky News:
Some worshippers this month were visibly moved. On Sunday, a group of nuns from India wept as they looked upon the saint's remains behind a glass case.
But the exhibition has also provoked debate over the appropriateness of displaying the remains of long-dead people in public.
"It is not a good idea to display the body of Saint Teresa in this way," said nearby Bishop of Salamanca, Jose Luis Retana. "It only serves to encourage people's morbid curiosity."
But local church officials and experts downplayed such reactions, saying the display was nothing out of the ordinary for how Catholics have revered their saints for centuries.
"It was just something people always did when they thought somebody might be a saint," said Cathleen Medwick, who wrote a book about Saint Teresa.
"And the fact that her body hadn't decayed very much was also considered a sign of her sanctity," she added.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Washington Post

2 hours ago

• Washington Post

How Hawaii pushed out native Hawaiians

Sara Kehaulani Goo was 8 years old when she learned a secret. Deep in a swath of her family's ancestral land on the isolated eastern tip of Maui stood a 13th-century temple known as a heiau, perhaps the largest anywhere in Polynesia. Even as a girl, she understood the spiritual weight of this Hawaiian place of worship. At first sight, she was astonished by the 'tidal wave of black' before her eyes. Some of the heiau's walls were 50 feet high. Terraces facing north and southeast rose to a central platform measuring 3¼ acres. The people who built it, starting some seven centuries earlier, had carried each chunk of basalt to its final resting place, rock by rock, hand to hand, in a human chain. They used no mortar or bonding or cement. Visiting it, both as a child and then again as an adult, she felt herself in the presence of something sacred — 'mana' in the Hawaiian language. 'Kuleana: A Story of Family, Land, and Legacy in Old Hawai'i,' Goo's new book, is nominally about the 90-acre family property on which the heiau stands — and the fight to save it from the forces that have expelled Hawaiians from their land since first contact with Europeans. Yet it is the heiau, and her first experience of it, that is the central force of the story. It 'planted the seed for me to become a journalist,' Goo (who was previously a reporter and editor at The Washington Post) writes. 'This is where my curiosity was born.' It also started her on a quest to understand her family's history and to write this very book. The heiau, and its mana, would shape her entire life. The story begins with the Great Mahele, a land redistribution edict carried out by King Kamehameha III in 1848. Its intent was to give chiefs and commoners access to resources during the upheaval wrought upon Hawaii by disease, capitalism and the rise of American influence in the islands. Goo's ancestor, a man named Kahanu with links to area chiefs, was the recipient of 990 acres of land on the eastern end of Maui. Upon his death, Kahanu, who had no heirs, left the land in equal parts to his two brothers and an aunt, Goo's direct forebear. Within 20 years of the Mahele, Kahanu's successors had sold much of the property to sugar planters. The remaining acreage was divided into ever smaller fractions, generation by generation. Today, Goo's extended family possesses 'more than ninety acres' of the original allotment. Goo's close relatives own 10 of those acres. 'Kuleana' is structured around a threat to that land. In 2019, Maui County increased the family's property taxes by almost 600 percent. Though the Goos explored several options — including planting a small farm on the land so that it could be rezoned for agriculture — no solution seemed plausible or permanent. The pressure to sell grew heavy. Yet this storyline makes up but a thin slice of 'Kuleana,' and the book is better for it. Goo's explorations of the problems Hawaii faces raise the stakes. The state already has the highest housing costs in the nation, and on Maui, nonresidents own a significant portion of homes. Meta founder Mark Zuckerberg snapped up 1,400 acres on Kauai, then sued Hawaiians who held claims to some of these lands (he later dropped the suits). Before that, Oracle founder Larry Ellison purchased 98 percent of the 90,500-acre island of Lanai. For native Hawaiians, land displacement is present and ongoing: More than half of all native Hawaiians have left the islands. This might be the essential message in 'Kuleana.' Goo's motherly distress about raising her children in Washington, so far from their familial home, also feels vital. Even among her Hawaiian relatives, she writes, the fact that she grew up on the mainland has marked her for life. 'We were mainlanders who had plane tickets, not Native Hawaiians with residency.' Her prose is light and pithy, styled and structured like that of a newspaper reporter. This usually works in her favor. Yet her occasional reliance on cliché and tendency to use the same words repeatedly — often in a single paragraph, sometimes in a single sentence — slacken what could have been a tauter narrative. Small historical blemishes also appear in the book now and again. Goo writes, for instance, that Hawaiians killed Captain James Cook once they discovered he wasn't a god. This simplifies a more complex historical record. Misgivings aside, for too long most readers have looked to two or three titles to learn about the Hawaiian Islands. To this day, bookstores on the islands display gleaming stacks of James A. Michener's novel 'Hawaii,' 66 years after its publication and woefully out of date. To people with ties to Hawaii, Goo's story will already be familiar. But if just a fraction of the millions of annual visitors read 'Kuleana' and get a more subtle, more accurate understanding of these singular islands, it will be a cause for celebration. A serious book by a Hawaiian journalist, from a major publishing house, is a most welcome arrival. Makana Eyre is the author of 'Sing, Memory.' He was born and raised on the island of Oahu. A Story of Family, Land, and Legacy in Old Hawai'i By Sara Kehaulani Goo Flatiron. 351 pp. $29.99

CBS News

17 hours ago

• CBS News

Parishioners say final goodbyes to late Bishop Lawrence Brandt

At Blessed Sacrament Cathedral in Greensburg on Thursday, people were stopping by to pay their respects to the former leader of the diocese, Bishop Lawrence Brandt. Bishop Brandt died of natural causes on June 8 at age 86. On Wednesday, Brandt's body arrived at the cathedral for the final goodbye to parishioners and clergy alike. Since then, his body has been lying in state for those who wished to come to pay their respects. The current bishop, Larry Kulick, says that his predecessor lived a good and devout life, and that for him, part of Bishop Brandt's legacy is the kindness with which he listened to people and how he made everyone feel heard. "I would always say to people, sometimes the public perception was, 'Oh, Bishop always knew what he was doing,' and that is exactly what he would do," said Bishop Kulick. "And I would say for those who worked with him behind the scenes, how many times we saw him in that listening, in that discerning, we saw his mind change. And he was someone who understood the importance of taking counsel and could take counsel." Bishop Brandt was Greensburg's fourth bishop, serving from 2004 to 2015. Before that, however, he served in the Vatican's Diplomatic Corps for several years before being made Chancellor of the Diocese of Erie. "His dignity and the way he carried himself," Kulick said. "As I will say tomorrow in the homily, his courage to move forward was rooted in a deep faith and a man of the church." On June 20, additional viewing will occur from 10:00 a.m. until 1:00 p.m. at the cathedral. A funeral mass will be celebrated at 2:00 p.m. Interment will follow in the Greensburg Catholic Cemetery. The diocese says that if people can't make the funeral, it will be live-streamed on their website, YouTube, and social media pages. More information can be found here.

Miami Herald

2 days ago

• Miami Herald

Are Pope Leo's ancestors from Cuba? Genealogy researchers in Miami think so

It has become an old joke in the Cuban-American community to note that Cubans seem to be everywhere. And so, when Pope Leo was elected to lead the Catholic Church and traces of his rich heritage began to emerge, including an ancestor who had been born in Havana, a Cuban genealogist in Miami rushed to figure out if this was just an isolated case or, if, by any chance, the first American Pope had Cuban roots. As it happened, the pope has several generations of Cuban ancestors. Robert Francis Prevost, the American cardinal who became Leo XIV after Pope Francis' death in April, was born in Chicago to a father with Italian and French ancestors and a mother with French, Canadian and Black heritage. But there was much more. The Cuban Genealogy Club of Miami tracked several generations of Cuban ancestors on his mother's side, dating back to the 17th Century, who themselves descended from Spanish and Italian families. In total, five generations in the pope's family tree on his mother's side were connected to Cuba, starting with Diego de Arana Isla, a Spanish captain who settled in Havana as an accountant for the Spanish Crown, and Juan Gonzalez Vazquez, a settler who farmed animals on land he owned in Pinar del Río in western Cuba. A century later, one of their descendants, Manuel José Ramos y Bastos, born in Havana in 1755, would travel to the United States and marry María Catalina Guesnon, a woman from New Orleans. He is one of the great-grandfathers of the pope's great-grandmother, Marie Rosa Pantaleón Ramos. The findings were first published by Mirelis Peraza, one of the Genealogy Club's directors, who said she was immediately curious when she learned about Ramón y Bastos' existence from another researcher who had traced the pope's roots in New Orleans. 'I was surprised, I didn't think I'd ever heard that there would be a pope with Cuban roots, and I made a mental note,' Peraza said. Then she found one of the surnames already linked to the pope in sources she was consulting to establish her family's own genealogy. From there, things went fast. Lourdes del Pino, the club's first vice president, picked up where Peraza left off and found Diego de Arana Isla's Spanish ancestors in the 1500s, 15 generations back in the pope's family tree. She also identified the Italian ancestors of Diego's Spanish wife, Ana Tadino, who lived in the Duchy of Milan, now part of Italy, at the time under Spanish rule. Their findings were reflected in the fascinating pope's family tree recently published in The New York Times. The Club, which has collaborated in the past with PBS's show 'Finding Your Roots,' once again partnered with Harvard University professor Henry Louis Gates Jr. for the Times story. The pope's family tree 'is the perfect representation of the Americas,' said Del Pino. 'What fascinates us and we are delighted with is the diversity that the pope's genealogy has shown. An impressive diversity that the vast majority of Hispanics carry.' Del Pino said she had been surprised at how much ancient relatives traveled around the world. 'Spending two months on a ship? I'd go crazy, but for them, it was part of their lives,' she said. 'Once you start researching, you realize people in those times moved around much more than we thought.' Overcoming challenges Researching Cuban genealogy presents particular challenges, given the limited availability of digitized sources and Cuban government restrictions on accessing archives. But Peraza had a stroke of luck when she found out many of the records she was looking for were in one of the few early historical sources still available: a rare book of marriages that took place in the late 1600s and early 1700s at the Iglesia del Espírito Santo (Church of the Holy Spirit), Havana's second Catholic church. 'One of the things we have against us is that many of those books have been damaged over time; they are no longer available,' Peraza said. 'We were lucky that the pope's ancestors we found were all concentrated in the same area, that of the Church of the Holy Spirit, and coincidentally, almost everything fell into the same book, which luckily still survives.' The researchers' good fortune continued. Because Diego de Arana Isla wanted to become a knight of the Order of Santiago, a highly prestigious and selective appointment at the time, he underwent a thorough background check that was documented and is available in digital archives from Spain, making it easier for Del Pino to locate his ancestors. Diego became, in fact, a knight of the Order of Santiago in 1678. 'His service record and list of merits depict 40 years of devout service to the crown with multiple military and administrative posts throughout the colonies,' Peraza wrote. He died in Cuba in 1684. Incidentally, Diego's sister Catalina, whose children were born in Venezuela, would become the great-great-grandmother of Antonio José de Sucre, one of Latin America's independence leaders. The Aranas came from Isla, a small village in Cantabria in northern Spain. Diego's father, Diego de Arana Valladar, was born in 1595 and lived an adventurous life as the captain of a galleon in the Spanish Royal Navy, defending Portuguese settlements in the Caribbean and South America from Dutch corsairs, said Marial Iglesias, a Cuban historian and Harvard University researcher who collaborated on the Times story. (Portugal and Spain were united for about 60 years until 1640.) A final mystery As the surnames of the ancestors began to pop up, Iglesias realized that there is a chance the pope's Cuban ancestors might be connected to one of the most iconic places in Havana: La Plaza de la Revolución, or Revolution Square, where Pope Jean Paul II and Pope Francis had held mass during historic trips to the island. The landmark, topped with a massive obelisk and a statue of José Martí, Cuba's independence hero and most famous writer, was built under Fulgencio Batista's government in the 1950s as the 'Civic Plaza' in an elevation known as the Catalans' Hill. But in the past, that spot had a curious name: Loma de Tadino, or Tadino's Hill. 'I haven't had time to find out why it's called Loma de Tadino, but that's a very rare surname. The family lived in Cuba for generations, and it could have been their property,' Iglesias said. 'Imagine if the pope's Italian branch of the family, who moved to Cuba in the 1600s, gave name to the place where the statue of José Martí stands. How about that?'