TRG takeover battle: Zia Chishti lands favourable SHC ruling amid mounting financial pressure
The saga over the battle for control of Pakistan Stock Exchange (PSX) listed technology leader, TRG Pakistan Limited, took a new twist with an order by the Sindh High Court on a company petition filed by the company's former CEO, Zia Chishti, challenging the tender announced in January 2025 by the company's largest shareholder, Bermuda based Greentree Holdings Limited.
The tender was to remit up to $53 million to Pakistani shareholders of TRG Pakistan, and had been placed on hold pending the hearing of the petition.
SHC restrains Zia Chishti, wife from transferring shares of TRG Pakistan: notice
The judge ruled that the company violated Section 286 of the Companies Act relating to shareholder oppression and that such oppression took place with the purchase of shares of TRG Pakistan Limited by Greentree Holdings.
The judge has ordered the abatement of the Greentree Holdings tender, the conversion of the shares held by Greentree Holdings into treasury shares of TRG Pakistan and the holding of Company elections.
A successful completion of the tender would have accorded control of the company to Greentree Holdings, in addition to providing an exit to company shareholders.
In a notice to the PSX issued today, the company has stated that the judge's order contains 'various irregularities and infirmities' and is 'assessing legal options, including challenging the decision by filing an appeal before the Honourable Supreme Court of Pakistan'.
Market analysts believe that the company will appeal the ruling.
Market observers expressed disappointment at the ruling of the Sindh High Court, as the tender provided shareholders an opportunity to lock in a near 40% premium to the current share price.
The company's share price responded negatively to the news of the ruling, dropping 12% on the prospect of a lack of clarity on the company's future.
Since late 2021, the company has been mired in a takeover battle between Chishti and his allies and the current management of TRG.
Chishti resigned as CEO of the company following disclosure in US Congressional testimony of an arbitration award against him for sexual harassment and assault of an ex-employee, in which he had to pay the former employee over $5 million in damages.
TRG's management has held that any association of Chishti with the company would be fatally damaging to the Company's assets given his reputation.
Since his exit from the company, Chishti has filed several defamation suits relating to his sexual misconduct award.
US arbitrator orders Zia Chishti to pay $9.1mn to TRG International
In the United States, he sued the former employee for defamation but was dismissed by a US judge.
In the United Kingdom, Chishti sued The Telegraph for carrying an article that he deemed defamatory, and settled with the newspaper in March 2025 with The Telegraph providing an apology.
Meanwhile, in Pakistan, Chishti sued the board and management of TRG for defamation for referring to his arbitration award in court filings; those proceedings have been suspended by order of the Supreme Court.
Chishti's court victory comes against the backdrop of severe creditor pressure on him.
In January 2025, he lost an arbitration filed against him by TRG International for pledging his shares in TRG Pakistan for a loan extended to him by JS Bank, apparently for the purpose of building up his shareholding in the Company.
In its notice today, TRG has informed that this arbitration award, which included a $9 million payment order against him, has been confirmed for collection by a United States Federal judge.
In addition, in January 2025, Chishti defaulted on the above-mentioned Rs3 billion loan from JS Bank, which has attempted to seize his shares in the Company as collateral but has been prevented from doing so by several stay orders relating to the arbitration award enforcement.
Chishti's financial woes are further complicated by the recent disclosure of a tax lien of $10 million placed on Chishti's assets by the United States Internal Revenue Service, for unpaid United States federal taxes.
Industry observers have expressed dismay at the continuing upheaval within the country's leading technology player, especially since the tender was set to provide clarity to the future of the company.
With the recent ruling, the battle seems likely to continue.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
2 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Dost Steels to raise Rs4.45bn via rights issue to fund billet production
Dost Steels Limited, a Pakistani steel manufacturer, plans to raise Rs4.45 billion (USD 15.6 million) through a rights issue to fund the installation of a melting furnace. The listed company disclosed the development in its filing to the Pakistan Stock Exchange (PSX) on Monday. The quantum of the right issue is approximately 100% of the existing paid-up capital of the company, i.e. approximately 100 right shares for every 100 ordinary shares held by the company's shareholders. As per the filing, the company shall issue 444,695,577 ordinary shares, at par, that is at a price of Rs 10/- per right share, aggregating to Rs4.45 billion. The steel maker said that the purpose of the rights issue is to raise funds for the installation and commissioning of a melting furnace to produce billets. Additionally, the funds will be used to meet the company's working capital requirements. Dost Steels secures Rs2.08bn investment DSL shared that by setting up the melting furnace, the company will be producing billets, which are essential raw materials for producing the end product. 'This will significantly reduce raw material costs, leading to improved profit margins,' it said. Moreover, the project will boost operational efficiency, provide enhanced supply chain control, and support the business's long-term sustainability. 'These improvements are anticipated to result in increased profitability and shareholder value, thereby strengthening the company's financial position and competitive standing in the market,' it said. The company was of the view that the right issue is being carried out at a price, which is near the current market price, and hence, there is no major risk associated with it. However, normal risks associated with the business will remain. On Monday, the share price of DSL settled at Rs7.24, a decrease of Re0.18 or 2.43%.
Business Recorder
3 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Pakistan's ‘first operator-led angel investing network' launched
A private, invite-only angel investing network called Dastak has been launched by entrepreneur Saif Ali, designed to support high-growth Pakistani startups across tech, direct-to-consumer (D2C) brands, and services businesses. According to a statement, Dastak brings together seasoned operators, corporate executives, and investors from Pakistan and the diaspora to back 'ambitious founders with more than just capital.' Pakistan's startups face capital crunch, need urgent reforms: i2i report 'I'm not here to chase unicorns. I'm here to help a generation of Pakistanis build companies that put food on the table, pride in the product, and power back in the hands of young people,' Ali told Business Recorder. 'Pakistan will continue to face economic headwinds in the years ahead. The only way our youth can create real change is by building new companies, hundreds or even thousands of them,' he said, adding: 'this can only happen if we mobilize both local capital and local experience.' As per the release announcing the statement, Dastak is built on a premise that has talent but needs 'deeper backing' and it wants to curate a network of strategic angels, thereby simplifying the path to early-stage investment. The network is sector-agnostic with a focus on tech and SaaS; direct-to-consumer brands and modern services - margin-rich services businesses which it said are often overlooked by traditional venture capital investors. Rather than functioning as a fund or platform, Dastak says it facilitates direct investments. Startups gain exposure to operator-angels who have built and scaled companies themselves, while angels get access to vetted deals, legal coordination, and a streamlined investment process. The current group includes founders, C-level operators, and investment professionals spanning fintech, logistics, consumer technology, SaaS, and IT services, both within Pakistan and the diaspora abroad. While individual names are not being disclosed publicly at this stage, access to the network is currently limited to those who bring deep operational experience alongside capital. To ensure regulatory clarity, Dastak says it does not offer investment advice, manage funds, or guarantee returns. It facilitates access to vetted startup opportunities and provides advisory support where helpful. Investment decisions are made solely by individual angels. The initiative's aim is to lowers the barrier to angel investing while helping startups benefit from the mentorship and expertise of experienced professionals.
Business Recorder
5 hours ago
- Business Recorder
TRG takeover battle: Zia Chishti lands favourable SHC ruling amid mounting financial pressure
The saga over the battle for control of Pakistan Stock Exchange (PSX) listed technology leader, TRG Pakistan Limited, took a new twist with an order by the Sindh High Court on a company petition filed by the company's former CEO, Zia Chishti, challenging the tender announced in January 2025 by the company's largest shareholder, Bermuda based Greentree Holdings Limited. The tender was to remit up to $53 million to Pakistani shareholders of TRG Pakistan, and had been placed on hold pending the hearing of the petition. SHC restrains Zia Chishti, wife from transferring shares of TRG Pakistan: notice The judge ruled that the company violated Section 286 of the Companies Act relating to shareholder oppression and that such oppression took place with the purchase of shares of TRG Pakistan Limited by Greentree Holdings. The judge has ordered the abatement of the Greentree Holdings tender, the conversion of the shares held by Greentree Holdings into treasury shares of TRG Pakistan and the holding of Company elections. A successful completion of the tender would have accorded control of the company to Greentree Holdings, in addition to providing an exit to company shareholders. In a notice to the PSX issued today, the company has stated that the judge's order contains 'various irregularities and infirmities' and is 'assessing legal options, including challenging the decision by filing an appeal before the Honourable Supreme Court of Pakistan'. Market analysts believe that the company will appeal the ruling. Market observers expressed disappointment at the ruling of the Sindh High Court, as the tender provided shareholders an opportunity to lock in a near 40% premium to the current share price. The company's share price responded negatively to the news of the ruling, dropping 12% on the prospect of a lack of clarity on the company's future. Since late 2021, the company has been mired in a takeover battle between Chishti and his allies and the current management of TRG. Chishti resigned as CEO of the company following disclosure in US Congressional testimony of an arbitration award against him for sexual harassment and assault of an ex-employee, in which he had to pay the former employee over $5 million in damages. TRG's management has held that any association of Chishti with the company would be fatally damaging to the Company's assets given his reputation. Since his exit from the company, Chishti has filed several defamation suits relating to his sexual misconduct award. US arbitrator orders Zia Chishti to pay $9.1mn to TRG International In the United States, he sued the former employee for defamation but was dismissed by a US judge. In the United Kingdom, Chishti sued The Telegraph for carrying an article that he deemed defamatory, and settled with the newspaper in March 2025 with The Telegraph providing an apology. Meanwhile, in Pakistan, Chishti sued the board and management of TRG for defamation for referring to his arbitration award in court filings; those proceedings have been suspended by order of the Supreme Court. Chishti's court victory comes against the backdrop of severe creditor pressure on him. In January 2025, he lost an arbitration filed against him by TRG International for pledging his shares in TRG Pakistan for a loan extended to him by JS Bank, apparently for the purpose of building up his shareholding in the Company. In its notice today, TRG has informed that this arbitration award, which included a $9 million payment order against him, has been confirmed for collection by a United States Federal judge. In addition, in January 2025, Chishti defaulted on the above-mentioned Rs3 billion loan from JS Bank, which has attempted to seize his shares in the Company as collateral but has been prevented from doing so by several stay orders relating to the arbitration award enforcement. Chishti's financial woes are further complicated by the recent disclosure of a tax lien of $10 million placed on Chishti's assets by the United States Internal Revenue Service, for unpaid United States federal taxes. Industry observers have expressed dismay at the continuing upheaval within the country's leading technology player, especially since the tender was set to provide clarity to the future of the company. With the recent ruling, the battle seems likely to continue.
