Diver helps solve a nearly 20-year-old cold case involving a fellow diver gone missing

A nearly 20-year-old cold case involving a missing diver has been solved in Volusia County with the help of the County's medical examiner, who has expertise in diving.
The Volusia County Sheriff's Office says DNA testing from human remains that washed onto New Smyrna Beach in 2007 belong to Robert Martin, a diver who disappeared off ther coast of Ponce Inlet in 2006.
It wasn't until 2024 that the remains were submitted for advanced forensic testing under the Missing and Unidentified Human Remains grant program, when any progress was made.
Then, in May 2025, a match was made officially linking the remains to Martin who disappeared during a trip to the dive site known as the 'party grounds,' about 20 miles offshore.
The Volusia County medical examiner, Dr. James Fulcher, who was a certified diver for over 25 years, used his knowledge and experience to examine Martin's equipment and determined his death to be an accident, and no foul play was involved.
'With my diving background, I could examine the equipment and picture what he likely experienced,' Fulcher said in a news release. 'Based on the condition of the gear and known challenges of the dive site, we were able to pinpoint probable malfunctions and evaluate how his habits may have played a role. That helped us determine this was a tragic accident—not foul play.'
According to VCSO, Martin's next of kin was notified.
Click here to download our free news, weather and smart TV apps. And click here to stream Channel 9 Eyewitness News live.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

New York Post

3 days ago

• New York Post

Florida dad left toddler son to die in hot car for 3 hours as he got haircut, went drinking at bar: police

A Florida dad is accused of leaving his helpless toddler to die inside his hot car for hours while he got a haircut and stopped to grab a drink at a bar in blazing temperatures. Scott Allen Gardner, 33, allegedly locked his 18-month-old son, Sebastian, inside his sweltering truck when he freshened up his 'do and stopped at Hanky Panky's Lounge in Ormond Beach, Florida, on June 6, police said. The unaccompanied tot was left inside the blistering heat of the vehicle for over three hours as temperatures outside reached 92 degrees, the Volusia County Sheriff's Office said in a Facebook post. 5 Scott Allen Gardner is escorted by Florida police officers during his arrest on June 19, 2025. Volusia Sheriff's Office Medical examiners estimate the baby's body temperature reached a deadly 111 degrees as he sat in the truck. Law enforcement agents performed life-saving measures on Sebastian, but the baby ultimately succumbed to his injuries. The Volusia County Sheriff's Office alleges Gardner is responsible for little Sebastian's death as he enjoyed a day in the Ormond-by-the-Sea neighborhood, eight miles north of Daytona Beach. The heartless father allegedly gave multiple false accounts to police of the events leading up to his son's death, the sheriff's office said. Gardner was arrested on Thursday after police tracked him down to his mother's home in Ormond Beach. 5 Gardner was booked into Volusia County Jail and charged with aggravated manslaughter of a child and child neglect causing great bodily harm. Volusia Sheriff's Office 5 Hanky Panky's Lounge where Gardner went drinking, leaving his son outside in his truck. Fox35 Gardner was booked into Volusia County Jail and charged with aggravated manslaughter of a child and child neglect causing great bodily harm. He was handed a $100,000 bond. Bodycam footage from the sheriff's office captured the moment the deadbeat dad was detained inside an enclosed porch on the property. 'The same OBPD officer who tried to revive Sebastian placed Gardner in handcuffs today as he was taken into custody at his mother's home in Ormond Beach,' the sheriff's office said. 5 Bodycam footage from the sheriff's office captured the moment the deadbeat dad was detained inside an enclosed porch on the property. Volusia Sheriff's Office 5 Gardner is searched before being placed in the back of a cop car during his arrest. Volusia Sheriff's Office As Gardner was led away from the home, two unidentified people called out to the suspected killer, saying they loved him. 'I love you guys,' Gardner replied before one of the officers told him, 'Say goodbye, because you're not going to come back here again.'

USA Today

4 days ago

• USA Today

Woman allegedly married ex-boyfriend without his consent, police say

Woman allegedly married ex-boyfriend without his consent, police say A central Texas woman is facing a stalking charge and has been ordered to stay away from her ex-boyfriend after authorities say she married him without his consent and then left a copy of the marriage certificate at his home. Kristin Marie Spearman, 36, was arrested and charged with third degree felony stalking, the Beverly Hills Police Department in Texas said in a news release. As of Wednesday, June 18, Spearman has been released on bond and an emergency protective order was put into place, according to Beverly Hills Police Chief Kory Martin. "Making sure this situation does not escalate has been a primary focus," Martin said in a statement on June 18. USA TODAY has reached out to the McLennan County District Attorney's Office to see if the reverend involved will face charges. It was not immediately clear on June 18 if Spearman has legal representation. Police said she got a local reverend to sign the marriage license, which she then filed with the local clerk's office. The reverend involved is fully cooperating with law enforcement and "has expressed his sincere remorse for the occurrence," Martin said. "To assist with public knowledge regarding this, we never discuss assumed or pending charges prior to their execution," Martin said. Here's how the case has developed so far. 'Congrats, maybe call your wife' The victim, a 42-year-old man, contacted Beverly Hills police in Texas on June 13, police said in the news release. He said he had been away and when he returned home, he found a Bath & Body Works gift bag with products inside. According to a complaint obtained by USA TODAY, there were two documents inside the bag, including: A picture of his ex-girlfriend, Spearman, holding a marriage certificate showing the pair had been married. A certified and embossed copy of the marriage license, which had been filed with the county clerk's office. There was also a tag that read "Congrats, maybe call your wife," according to the complaint. The man said he had been in a relationship with the victim and the couple took steps to get a marriage license in June 2025, per the complaint. The pair then got into an argument and the man ended his relationship with Spearman, told her to stop contacting him, and changed his number. Spearman allegedly got the local reverend on June 13 "to certify the victim and Kristin in the Holy Union of Matrimony," according to police. The man wasn't at the ceremony and didn't know it was happening, police said. Spearman then went to the county clerk's office and filed for a certificate of official marriage. Police still collecting information Spearman was arrested at her home near Hewitt, about 10 miles southwest of Waco. She was taken to the McLennan County Jail and then released. As of June 18, police are still collecting information. Spearman's ex-boyfriend has had to "take a lot of steps to fix the problem along with costs," Martin said. The Beverly Hills Police Department said it is working with the McLennan County District Attorney's Office to see if any other laws were broken. Saleen Martin is a reporter on USA TODAY's NOW team. She is from Norfolk, Virginia – the 757. Email her at sdmartin@

Miami Herald

5 days ago

• Miami Herald

Man fatally shot girlfriend while she FaceTimed her mom, Tennessee officials say

A 28-year-old man is going to prison after being convicted in the killings of two women, Tennessee prosecutors said. Jair Romario Martin pleaded guilty to murder, aggravated kidnapping, criminal impersonation and evading arrest, the Knox County District Attorney's Office said in a June 16 news release. He was sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole, prosecutors said. In May 2023, Martin was at a home in Knoxville with his girlfriend when he 'became aggressive,' according to the district attorney's office. The girlfriend, later identified as 21-year-old Madison Johnson, called her mom on FaceTime to let her know she didn't feel safe, officials told WATE. That's when the woman's mom saw Martin holding a gun, so she called 911 while still on the phone with her daughter, prosecutors said. He refused to let Johnson leave and said, 'I'm going to murder you,' prosecutors said. Johnson was fatally shot at the home in front of another woman, later identified as 20-year-old Heidi Johnson, then Martin shot the other woman dead, officials told WATE. Madison Johnson was shot multiple times and had been stabbed in the head with a carving fork, prosecutors said. Martin left the scene but was arrested days after, officials said. Martin said he killed the women because they 'kept stealing drugs from him,' officials told WATE. 'I was wondering if there is something profound that I could say, but it's just sad. It's tragic. Two young women gunned down and killed in the prime of their life. They should have been able to experience their lives,' Judge Scott Green said during the hearing streamed by WBIR. 'It's just all so senseless.'