Redacted version of CHI report could be published this week, Health Minister says
THE MINISTER FOR Health has indicated that a version of an unpublished report detailing concerns at Children's Health Ireland (CHI) may be published this week.
The internal investigation, the details of which were first reported by the Sunday Times and subsequently seen by
The Journal
and other media outlets, came about after concerns were raised about how waiting list initiatives were being carried out at a hospital run by CHI.
It detailed how a consultant was paid €35,800 by the hospital after money was received from the National Treatment Purchase Fund (NTPF) to help cut long waiting lists.
The HSE has
referred the report to gardaí
and the Irish Medical Council.
Jennifer Carroll MacNeill has
previously called
for a redacted version of the report to be published.
Speaking on Newstalk's Anton Savage Show this morning, she said she had not published the report after checking with the Attorney General because she has 'no legal basis' to do so.
'This was an internal human resources-type report going into some very serious cultural issues, and the people who participated in it, nurses, junior doctors and so on, they participated in it on that basis, in a confidential way,' she said.
Carroll MacNeill said the report reflects what some staff said in confidence and that some of them would be identifiable
In the normal course, you'd never publish something like that, but the issues in this are of such seriousness that in the broader public interest, a version of it must be published.
She said that CHI are reflecting on how to publish the report 'responsibly' so that it 'tells the maximum story behind it and the steps of what has been taken next'.
Advertisement
When asked if she knows when this will be published, she said: 'I suspect it will be this week.'
The Fine Gael TD said it is important that the people 'who might have given descriptions about what they were feeling and perhaps some of the pressures they felt' are appropriately protected.
On hospital governance, Carroll MacNeill said she had a lot of questions about the different governance structures across the country.
'Ireland is a small country. It's five and a half million people. We spend a very significant amount of our taxpayers money on health, quite appropriately, but we need to make sure that we're getting the best value for that.'
She said CHI was formed in an effort to create a single entity that would bring Temple Street and St James's hospitals together, adding that it has 'done that and has brought it to a certain point'.
'There's no question about that, but I do think that there's very much more work to be done to integrate a single pediatric system.'
National Children's Hospital
The Minister was also asked whether it was appropriate that CHI are permitted to run the new National Children's Hospital (NCH). The earliest date that the hospital will now be open to patients is June 2026.
'I think we'll be reflecting on that sort of policy structure over the next year,' she said, adding that her first concern is that the NCH is opened at the earliest possible date.
She said that there are 140 consultants within CHI, and that these issues have been created from 'a very small proportion'.
'I am a parent of a child in CHI, many, many others are and they know that it's a very good service. It's very, very functional. But that doesn't mean we don't need to get deep into these problem areas.'
Last month, Carroll MacNeill appointed two HSE board members to the board of CHI after three of its members resigned following the release of an
independent review into children's hip surgeries
at three CHI hospitals.
Related Reads
HSE to refer unpublished Children's Health Ireland report to gardaí and Medical Council
Health Minister calls for CHI report on consultant misuse of waiting list system to be published
Three members of Children's Health Ireland board resign after review into hip surgeries
'I do have another a number of vacancies which I think will need to be filled, and I think we will reflect on that in policy terms over the next number of months,' she said.
She said the Government would keep 'a steady focus' on the delivery of services, the implementation of reforms where they need to happen and planning for the NCH.
'But I am watching and managing this very carefully from a medium-term policy perspective,' she added.
National Treatment Purchase Fund
The matter of the National Treatment Purchase Fund (NTPF) was also raised. The NTPF provides funding for patients on waiting lists to get treatment in both public and private settings.
It pays for clinics to be set up in public hospitals outside of normal working hours, i.e on weekends, wherein staff already working at the hospital are paid additionally to carry out extra work. This is known as 'insourcing'.
The NTPF had suspended funding to CHI hospitals over concerns raised in an internal audit, related to an insourcing clinic at the hospital. On Wednesday, it
cut funding to another public hospital temporarily
after finding ' potential financial irregularities' in relation to NTPF-funded insourcing work.
Carroll MacNeill said that an audit of insourcing that she and HSE chief Bernard Gloster commissioned has been completed and that she expects to see the results 'possibly' in the next two to three weeks.
She said the matter needs 'very serious and careful analysis', as does the issue of insourcing more broadly 'because of how it intersects with getting the best productivity within the public system'.
'We cannot have a fully public system and also be creating these other incentives. We cannot cut off these other incentives overnight because of the impact on patient care, but by God, we're going to be weaning ourselves off them.'
Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone...
A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article.
Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation.
Learn More
Support The Journal
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
a day ago
- Irish Times
Could the Israel-Iran war completely destabilise the Middle East?
Sally Hayden and Harry McGee join Jack Horgan-Jones to look back on the week in politics: Sally Hayden joins the pod on the line from Beirut where missiles flying overhead have become a fact of daily life despite the ceasefire agreement Lebanon signed with Israel last November. With Israel's attention now firmly on Iran , the rising death toll and continuing aerial attacks from both sides show no signs of abating. And is the US on the verge of joining Israel's attack on Iran? What could that mean for stability in the Middle East? Children's Health Ireland appeared before the Oireachtas Health Committee this week with politicians eager to tear strips off the embattled group responsible for running children's hospital services in Dublin . After so many controversies since its inception in 2018, can CHI be trusted to run the new national children's hospital when it opens? And how will this all be handled by Minister for Health Jennifer Carroll-MacNeill given her short time as a first-time senior Minister? Plus, the panel picks their favourite Irish Times pieces of the week: How AIB came back from the brink after the crash, and a misguided viral appeal following the death of an Irish emigrant in London.
Irish Times
a day ago
- Irish Times
Minister in the spotlight as health controversies intensify
'It is frightening, what was happening at CHI', Sinn Féin health spokesman David Cullinane said as politician after politician at the Oireachtas health committee tore strips off the embattled group that runs children's hospital services in Dublin. The hospital group knew it would be facing a rough day given the litany of contentious issues facing it: the implantation of unauthorised springs , allegations surrounding unnecessary hip operations , controversy over lengthy waiting lists for spinal surgery, an internal report identifying dysfunctional behaviour and a toxic culture in parts of CHI as well as concerns over whether National Treatment Purchase Fund (NTPF) money earmarked for reducing hospital waiting lists had been misused. As CHI was heading to the bear pit that is the committee room on Thursday, Minister for Health Jennifer Carroll MacNeill was on her way to a European health council meeting in Luxembourg. But she and her officials were keeping a close eye on proceedings as the Oireachtas committee heard directly from those running CHI for the first time. 'There is absolutely zero confidence in the CHI board, zero confidence in the management,' said Fianna Fáil TD Martin Daly. READ MORE He later maintained he was reflecting the feelings of colleagues in the Oireachtas. On the ministerial corridors at Leinster House, senior figures may not be frightened by events at CHI. But there is no doubt there are strong concerns that after five years of relative quiet – accompanied by unprecedented levels of investment – health scandals are once again dominating the agenda. How all this is handled will be a big test for Carroll MacNeill in her first term as a senior Minister. Initially she was seen as one of the better performers in the Cabinet. But a number of figures in Government point out that in recent weeks things seem to be boiling over on a number of fronts. There is a clear sense within Government that the aggregate effect of the series of controversies represents an important moment and a shift in gears for Carroll MacNeill's ministerial career. 'It is a huge test for her, a huge challenge,' one source said, adding there were nascent concerns about keeping the centre of Government informed as the controversies develop. 'While she is the line minister, she is responsible, from a public perception point of view, the Government is responsible.' She must also master the inner workings and unpredictable dynamics of a health crisis – something that eventually falls to everyone in her position. This is particularly the case for one that is, in fact, composed of several overlapping sub-crises – a 'sprawling controversy with so many elements', as one source described it. She must keep track of timelines, keep the information flow running, keep across who knew what and when. For a first-time Cabinet minister, it is the ultimate acid test. Some of this may just be timing. The report by the health services watchdog, the Health Information and Quality Authority (Hiqa) on the unauthorised springs was always set for May and Government knew this would probably cause a storm that would be quickly followed by an equally damaging analysis into operations for children with developmental dysplasia of the hip. However, the stunning leak of an internal CHI report identifying potential patient safety risks, questionable use of NTPF-funded waiting list clinics and a toxic culture at one CHI hospital came out of left field. Ministers and health chiefs said they had been blindsided. The revelations also highlighted divisions between different parts of the health system and put the spotlight on flaws in the governance structures. Last week the NTPF confirmed it had suspended funding for waiting list initiatives at another centre, Beaumont Hospital in Dublin, on foot of potential financial irregularities. The Irish Times revealed this followed a letter sent to the chairwoman of Beaumont by consultants in which they maintained the hospital had billed the NTPF for about 1,400 patients treated in their regular public clinic. The Department of Health – and presumably the Minister – had been aware of this development since April. Carroll MacNeill had directed the HSE to send internal auditors into Beaumont . However, the public was not told until June 11th. Some highly placed sources maintain all this has led to concerns about the information flow around Government. One Minister told The Irish Times there had been discussions about what was coming out. 'As we hear things, things are being circulated,' they said. 'There is no concern about the political messaging, but there is huge concern about what we hear is going on – everything, from what you hear about [HSE chief] Bernard Gloster bringing in the gardaí to everything that is going on in terms of governance, the whole shooting match. But the primary concern is about the children.' Another Government figure said there is real concern that health may blow up (politically) in a way that it has not done in five years and that there may be too much of a hands-off approach by the Minister. The Government is only too aware there is more drama to come. CHI, the HSE and the NTPF will be before the Dáil Public Accounts Committee in early July. An external review into paediatric orthopaedic surgery being carried out for the HSE is also still awaited. A separate HSE report on 'insourcing', where some staff formed private companies to carry out additional work outside regular hours to tackle waiting lists, is also due, as are the findings of the internal auditors sent into Beaumont. Governments have spent more than €1.6 billion on waiting lists over recent years, using the NTPF, the HSE 'insourcing' and other arrangements. Any questionable findings will undoubtedly lead to more allegations about waste. Carroll MacNeill is facing a balancing act of trying to deal with serious issues in CHI at a time when the organisation should, ideally, be concentrating on moving the three existing paediatric centres in Dublin into the new €2.4 billion national children's hospital. TDs, like Daly, may have no confidence in CHI. But in the meantime services for children have to continue and workforce planning and other arrangements for the move have to be carried out in parallel. In late May the Minister told the Dáil: 'I am trying to look at this question in relation to the broader governance of CHI in a way that enables the functional continuity of CHI, both to respond to the various patient needs and ... the broader running of the paediatric system and to move us towards opening the new hospital. I want to ensure we see the appropriate governance structure in place to make sure that we have clinical leads who are managing each team.' However, within Government the ghost of the 2018 cervical check scandal casts a long shadow. This centred on retrospective audits of cervical cancer screenings that showed that 221 women's smear test readings missed abnormalities, leading to the development of cervical cancer. The results were not disclosed to 162 women and a number subsequently died. [ Justine McCarthy: Ireland's grubby treatment of Covid-19 heroes will cause frontline workers to think twice next time Opens in new window ] The fallout caused a national outcry. Ministers, doctors and health administrators did not adequately argue their own case and in the face of relentless criticism, a narrative took root and proved difficult to eradicate. There are fears that further revelations at the Public Accounts Committee or in forthcoming reports could spark further controversy. A number of sources have voiced concerns that the health service and CHI could replicate the rolling controversy seen over the RTÉ payments scandal two summers ago. The gaps and governance flaws identified by the CHI controversy also leaves the Minister with a decision on whether further reforms are needed. Health economist at UCC Dr Brian Turner described the current system as a complex mix of public and private funding and delivery with a large degree of overlap. He said there were publicly-funded public hospitals (run by the HSE), publicly-funded voluntary hospitals (run by their own boards) and public patients in private facilities such as nursing homes. In addition, the NTPF buys treatment in both the public and private systems. On top of this HSE reforms introduced last year led to new regional chief executives appointed to oversee services in geographic areas that covered both public and voluntary hospitals. [ Flying to Spain for medical care: 'The Irish really appreciate the services; they are actually really easy patients' Opens in new window ] One obvious question from this is who does the chief executive in a voluntary hospital primarily report to? Is it to the hospital board or the HSE regional chief executive? Such questions are not purely academic. At the Oireachtas committee, it became clear CHI did not believe its internal report merited a referral to the Garda. The HSE, on the other hand, wanted gardaí involved. One experienced health service figure told The Irish Times the CHI issue was casting a spotlight on the key governance question: who is in charge of what in the health service? With some exceptions, most of the main academic teaching hospitals covering most of the main specialities are in the voluntary sector. The staff are considered to be public servants but the hospitals are run by their own boards. Voluntary hospitals tend to jealously guard their independence. One senior figure pointed to a row last year when former minister for health Stephen Donnelly wanted all hospitals to adopt a new system that would provide greater visibility over productivity. A number of voluntary hospitals objected until the minster threatened to withhold capital funding. CHI reported to the minister, not to the HSE. However, when Donnelly wanted a new chief executive appointed as the former chief executive Eilish Hardiman had served the maximum two terms under Government policy, the CHI board disagreed. Simon Harris , as minister for health in 2017 established a review of the role of voluntary organisations in the operation of the health sector. But many key structures remained in place. One senior health source said voluntary hospitals previously argued they provided a set level of services for the State under an agreement each year but were subsequently free to treat fee-paying patients and do other work. However, private practice in public hospitals is now to be eliminated over time under Sláintecare , the long-term plan to achieve universal, single-tier health and social care. One experienced health figure said it was widely known that the governance arrangements were flawed. However, he questioned whether the Government had the bandwidth or determination to deal with the aggravation that would flow from trying to change the current model of care – a process that could take several years, and possibly beyond the next general election.
RTÉ News
2 days ago
- RTÉ News
Spotlight on CHI far from over after tense committee hearing
Today's appearance by Children's Health Ireland before the Joint Oireachtas Committee on Health was a very tense and difficult affair. For the committee members, it left many questions unanswered, along with a sense of disbelief about the scale and gravity of events that have unfolded for children and parents. Committee chairperson Padraig Rice, of the Social Democrats, set the scene by saying he struggled to know where to start, noting that they could be there for days at the hearing. Some believed that all confidence in the CHI Board and management was now gone. There remain big questions about the ability of CHI to move to the new National Children's Hospital next year against this background. CHI has a lot of work to do to regain the trust of parents, the public and the political system, and it will likely be back before this committee soon for continuing scrutiny. Former CHI Chief Executive Eilish Hardiman expressed "heartfelt" sympathy for what actually happened. Committee members pointed out that the main events occurred on her watch. She is the Strategic Programme Director at CHI, and will have a key role in the move to the new hospital. The recently appointed Chief Executive Lucy Nugent apologised to families and promised to have CHI regain trust. Senator Tom Clonan said the events were a scandal of international dimensions, accusing CHI of running a three-ring circus and of having a toxic and broken culture with abhorrent work practices. Sinn Féin health spokesperson David Cullinane said that what was happening at CHI was frightening. There were questions about why some patients referenced in the unpublished internal review in a range of specialties, may have been affected by a lack of timely intervention, and why CHI has not been in contact with parents to notify them of this potential issue. Fine Gael TD Brian Brennan said it could all amount to one of the biggest medical malpractices in the history of the State. No one is quite sure how and when it will all end. Plus we learned of tension between the HSE and CHI, after claims that the HSE had been notified about the 2022 internal review report around that time. But the HSE told the committee the first its CEO Bernard Gloster and the HSE Regional Executive Officer learned about it was last month. CHI also took a different view to referring the report to An Garda Siochana, believing it did not meet the threshold for referral. The HSE decided to refer it recently. Another major report on spinal surgeries is due soon. And just 60 children out of 1,800 who had hip surgeries since 2010 have been reviewed to date under a lookback programme, which is expected to take six months to complete. There is a long and difficult road ahead for CHI, which has said there are no other live reports which are not in the public domain. The committee heard that a new CHI Director of Operations started on 9 June and the deputy CEO will start on 7 July.
