Children's Health Ireland publishes summary of 2021 report, identifies 'bullying issues'
CHILDREN'S HEALTH IRELAND (CHI) has today published a summary of the 2021 report into the organisation's culture, the use of NTPF funded clinics, and the standard of care it offered to children.
CHI noted that the original review was meant to be private, confidential, and not for publication.
The Health Minister Jennifer Carroll MacNeill has repeatedly called for it to be published after large parts of it were leaked to the media and politicians.
CHI has been in charge of children's health services in Ireland since 2019.
It has been scandal hit over the last year, over the use of unauthorised implants in children's spinal surgeries, and unwarranted hip surgeries being carried out on children, which was initially reported by
The Ditch.
The Sunday Times also reported on unpublished findings that a consultant breached HSE guidelines by referring patients he was seeing in his public practice to weekend clinics that he was operating separately.
The consultant was paid €35,800 via the National Treatment Purchase Fund (NTPF), which aims to cut waiting times by paying private practices to treat patients on public waiting lists.
A summary of the 2021 report published today says that 'serious issues of concern' were identified within CHI, including 'bullying issues' and a poor working environment as a result. It further said HR processes ensued as a result of the initial report.
The summary states that there was a high level of dependence on one employee who managed the needs of a complex speciality, and that this was not in line with best practice.
It also says that the NTPF funded waiting list initiative did not follow guidelines on chronological scheduling, meaning patients who were on the waiting list the longest were not seen first.
CHI today said that no open disclosure to the families of children with undescended testes who faced a delay in their care, as there is 'no scientific evidence' that they were harmed as a result.
Advertisement
CHI said that patients seen in a weekend outpatient clinic, which was funded by the National Treatment Purchase Fund, were placed on an 'already long' inpatient waiting list 'without consideration of redistribution of patients to colleagues with a shorter waiting list'.
The 2021 internal review raised the possibility that this practice could have led to 'negative outcomes for patients'.
The 2021 report said that patients with undescended testes, who required orchidopexy surgery, were at that time waiting 'far in excess' of the recommended time frame for treatment, placing them at a 'real and known risk for fertility issues and or cancer later in life'.
It said that these patients were being placed on a long inpatient waiting list when there was an alternative cohort of experienced general surgery consultants who could have managed their care 'in a much shorter time frame', which would have mitigated or eliminated the risks.
'There are numerous studies and guidelines which outline that optimum timing for undertaking orchidopexy is between 6 months and 18 months of age,' the report said.
It further stated that at the time of the report, there were ten patients on a urology inpatient waiting list, referred through the NTPF clinics, who required the surgery.
'These children are beyond the threshold of 18 months as were referred for care and treatment in 2019,' it added.
The report noted that as of 7 October 2021, were an additional 20 patients referred with undescended testes.
The summary report published by CHI today said that a review of the relevant inpatient waiting list took place and patients were redistributed across the department to ensure 'equitable access to treatment'.
'This action was closed out in September 2022. Open disclosure was not carried out as there is no significant scientific evidence that delaying treatment will equate to patient harm in this patient cohort,' CHI said in its report today.
'CHI now has a robust process for NTPF funded waiting list initiatives which requires multiple internal stakeholder approvals both clinical and financial. CHI is regularly audited by the NTPF,' it added.
Senator Tom Clonan today said that he has become aware of 'dozens of disabled children becoming infertile due to a lack of routine surgical intervention'.
'This is de facto sterilisation in Ireland,' he said.
Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone...
A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article.
Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation.
Learn More
Support The Journal
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Extra.ie
9 hours ago
- Extra.ie
Urgent health warning to Irish holidaymakers this summer
The Health Service Executive (HSE) has issued a new travel health warning for Irish citizens planning trips abroad this summer. The advisory comes in response to a recent surge in reported cases of measles in several popular holiday destinations. These locations include a number of European cities as well as USA, Canada, Vietnam, Cambodia and the Philippines. The Health Service Executive (HSE) has issued a new travel health warning for Irish citizens planning trips abroad this summer. Pic: Getty Images The HSE is urging travellers to take extra precautions, including checking vaccination requirements and staying informed about local health risks before and during their travels. In a statement released this week, the Health Service wrote: 'The HSE is concerned that measles outbreaks may occur in Ireland this summer as families with unvaccinated children and adults travel to countries where measles cases have been reported. 'The best way to protect you and your family against measles is to ensure all family members are up to date with the recommended doses of MMR vaccine before travelling abroad.' The advisory comes in response to a recent surge in reported cases of measles in several popular holiday destinations. Pic: Shutterstock The MMR vaccine is available free of charge at your GP for individuals born on or after January 1st 1978 who are not 'age-appropriately vaccinated.' Also, infants aged 6 months to under 12 months are eligible to receive an MMR vaccine, free of charge with their GP, prior to travel abroad. It is recommended to receive the vaccine at least 14 days prior to travel. These locations include a number of European cities as well as USA, Canada, Vietnam, Cambodia and the Philippines. Pic: Shutterstock Sharing further concerns, they added: 'Measles is one of the most highly infectious diseases and spreads rapidly among individuals who are unvaccinated. Measles cases continue to be reported in most European countries, with large outbreaks reported in some countries in 2025. In the latest measles report from ECDC the highest number of cases were reported in: France Spain Romania Netherlands Belgium 'Large numbers of cases have also been reported in the USA, Canada and some countries in Asia – including Vietnam, Cambodia and the Philippines.' More information is available here.
Sunday World
9 hours ago
- Sunday World
Urgent warning to Irish holidaymakers about measles outbreaks in European countries
France, Spain, Romania and the Netherlands have all seen outbreaks as well the US, Canada, Vietnam, Cambodia and the Philippines. Irish families heading to European holiday destinations this summer have been warned of large measles outbreaks. France, Spain, Romania and the Netherlands have all seen outbreaks as well the US, Canada, Vietnam, Cambodia and the Philippines. The Health Protection Surveillance Centre (HSPC) said the HSE is concerned that measles outbreaks may occur in Ireland this summer as families with unvaccinated children and adults travel to countries where measles cases have been reported. Cases rose last year, with several outbreaks, and around 16 have been reported in the last 12 weeks. Last year, Europe had the highest level of measles in 25 years, with 127,000 cases reported, the most since 1997. The HSPC said the 'best way to protect you and your family against measles is to ensure all family members are up to date with the recommended doses of MMR vaccine before travelling abroad'. It is recommended that individuals receive MMR vaccine at least 14 days prior to travel 'MMR vaccine is available free of charge at your GP for individuals born on or after January 1, 1978 who are not age-appropriately vaccinated,' it said. 'In addition, infants aged six months to under 12 months are eligible to receive an MMR vaccine, free of charge at their GP, prior to travel abroad. 'It is recommended that individuals receive MMR vaccine at least 14 days prior to travel.' It pointed out that measles 'is one of the most highly infectious diseases and spreads rapidly among individuals who are unvaccinated'. 'Measles cases continue to be reported in most European countries, with large outbreaks reported in some countries in 2025,' it added. It advised that 'the best way to protect yourself and those around you against measles is to ensure you and your family members are age-appropriately vaccinated with MMR vaccine'. 'HSE recommends that all people who are eligible for MMR vaccination should be vaccinated, regardless of whether planning on travel abroad or not.' It said that children receive the MMR vaccine as part of their routine childhood vaccines at 12 months of age from their GP. Measles symptoms are typically fever, cough and a runny nose, with a rash that develops a few days later. It can lead to serious complications in some cases such as sepsis, pneumonia and swelling of the brain, which can cause long-term disability and even death. Two doses of MMR vaccine can lead to 99pc protection, but uptake is still too low in some areas.
Sunday World
9 hours ago
- Sunday World
Tanning salon hit with €2,600 fine for selling sun-bed session to 15-year-old girl
In the case before Ennis District Court, Judge Alec Gabbett imposed a fine of €1,000 and costs of €1,600 on Shannon based sun-bed business, Solcraft Ltd for selling a sun-bed session to a 15 year old girl at its sun-bed premises, Cosmopoli Tan in Shannon last November. Frequent sunbed use is known to increase skin cancer risk. Photo: Getty A judge, who has stated that it is a pity that there is not a ban on sun-bed operators facilitating sun-bed sessions for adults, has imposed a €2,600 penalty on a sun-bed business selling a sun-bed session to a minor. In the case before Ennis District Court, Judge Alec Gabbett imposed a fine of €1,000 and costs of €1,600 on Shannon based sun-bed business, Solcraft Ltd for selling a sun-bed session to a 15 year old girl at its sun-bed premises, Cosmopoli Tan in Shannon last November. The Health Service Executive (HSE) brought the rare prosecution under Section 4 of the Public Health (Sunbeds) Act 2014 after a 15 year old 'secret shopper' was deployed by the HSE to do a test purchase at Cosmopoli Tan at Unit 7, Block E, Bru Na Sionna, Shannon on November 26th 2024. Solicitor for the HSE, Barry Kelleher of of Comyn Kelleher Tobin solicitors told the court on Friday that on the date 'a 15 year old child attended at the salon and approached the counter and asked for use of sun-bed session' Mr Kelleher said that 'the child asked for three minutes of time and she was told that she could get four minutes for the price of three'. Mr Kelleher said that the child 'was never asked for her age or ID'. He said that the firm has no previous convictions. He said that the transaction took place and the child left the premises. Solicitor for the firm, John Casey said that the business has a number of notices placed across its premises saying 'No ID, no sunbed' and similar notices. Frequent sunbed use is known to increase skin cancer risk. Photo: Getty News in 90 Seconds - June 21st Mr Kelleher said that that there was a further inspection of the premises in April of this year as there was a report of underage sale continuing. Mr Casey said that on that date the company was found to be in compliance. Mr Kelleher said the test purchasers deployed by the HSE don't actually take the sun-bed sessions. Judge Gabbett said: 'You would need danger money to do that.' Mr Kelleher told the court that people aged under 35 who undergo sun-bed sessions increase their risk of contracting melanoma by 75pc. Judge Gabbett said that 'children should not in these premises - that is very straightforward' Judge Gabbett said that he was imposing the €1,000 fine as a deterrent to ensure compliance. When the case first came to court last month, Judge Gabbett remarked that it is a good thing that children are banned from having sun-bed sessions stating 'it is a pity that this doesn't apply to adults as well." Asked on the level of enforcement activity under the Public Health (Sunbeds) Act, a spokesman for the HSE said last month: 'In 2024, ten fixed payment notices were served and four prosecutions taken by the National Environmental Health Service under the Public Health (Sunbeds) Act 2014. He said: 'Two of the prosecutions were for sales to minors and both were upheld by the court.' He added: "In 2023, seventeen fixed payment notices were served, and four prosecutions taken by the National Environmental Health Service (NEHS) under the Public Health (Sunbeds) Act 2014. Two of the prosecutions were for sales to minors and one was upheld by the Court.
