The Guardian view on Manchester United's stadium plans: put the fans first

Visitors to Salford's Lowry art gallery this summer will be able to enjoy a new take on one of the greatest paintings about sport. Depicting thousands of supporters bent purposefully towards a 1950s football stadium, LS Lowry's Going to the Match has become part of the iconography of the national game. As part of its silver jubilee celebrations, the gallery is staging an immersive experience of the painting, including a nostalgic soundtrack evoking the sounds of a lost world.
So much for the past. Barely a mile away from the Lowry, at Manchester United's Old Trafford base, it is the ghosts of football's future that are being summoned up. To great fanfare, this month the club unveiled computer-generated images of Lowryesque hordes approaching the new £2bn stadium it hopes to build by 2030.
Accommodating 100,000 fans, and topped by three spires that will allegedly be visible from Liverpool, 'New Trafford' is set to be the biggest and costliest football arena in Britain. Somewhat improbably, United's co-owner Sir Jim Ratcliffe has suggested that the stadium and its vast surrounding leisure campus could become a global draw on a par with the Eiffel Tower.
A project so gargantuan will undoubtedly be a catalyst for welcome economic growth in the wider Trafford area. The club is anticipating that substantial public funding can be unlocked to transform the stadium's post-industrial hinterland. Enthusiastic noises from the chancellor, Rachel Reeves, suggest that a substantial amount of cash may be forthcoming. But there is already criticism that the scheme could boost a billionaire tax exile's business at taxpayers' expense.
The 2012 London Olympics demonstrated what sporting-led regeneration projects can achieve. But Manchester United supporters' organisations, with good reason, are ambivalent about this brave new world. In the same week the initial stadium design was revealed, Sir Jim told interviewers that Britain's biggest football club had been at risk of going bust by Christmas. This was alarmist talk to justify deeply unpopular ticket price rises and internal cost-cutting. But the club owes more than £700m, largely thanks to the leveraged takeover by the US Glazer family 20 years ago, which piled a mountain of debt on to a previously debt-free institution.
Funding one of the most expensive stadiums in world sport will ratchet up the financial pressure still further, and investors will demand handsome returns. The grim likelihood is that, one way or another, ordinary supporters end up footing the bill. Well-versed in the monetising ways of modern football, an already disillusioned fanbase will treat the club's pledges of ticket affordability with understandable scepticism.
Ultimately, of course, the success of 'New Trafford' will depend on what happens on the field of play. In a caustic assessment of the plans, the Manchester MP Graham Stringer recalled a visit in the 1960s to Sheffield Wednesday's Hillsborough ground, which had been recently modernised. As the home team trailed, a disgruntled local commented acidly that he was 'still waiting for the bloody cantilever stand to score a goal'.
In an age when elite football regularly shows signs of losing touch with the soul of the game, that nugget of northern wisdom offers a salutary reminder of core sporting priorities. As they dream of a 'Wembley of the north', while the men's team continues to flounder on the pitch, the Glazers and Sir Jim should not lose sight of them.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Metro

an hour ago

• Metro

£50m star told to reject Chelsea transfer and join Man Utd

Dietmar Hamann has urged one of Enzo Maresca's top summer transfer targets to reject Chelsea in favour of a move to Manchester United. Chelsea made England U21 striker Liam Delap their first summer signing in a £30m deal from Ipswich Town. Maresca is keen to strengthen his squad in several other areas and has identified Borussia Dortmund winger Jamie Gittens as a top target. Gittens, 20, has a brief spell at Stamford Bridge as a youth player before being signed by Dortmund in 2020. The fellow England U21 star has since made over 100 appearances for Dortmund and was one of the most in-form players in the Bundesliga during the first-half of last season. Wake up to find news on your club in your inbox every morning with Metro's Football Newsletter. Sign up to our newsletter and then select your team in the link so we can send you football news tailored to you. Gittens' form tailed away in the second-half of the campaign but Chelsea are nevertheless determined to welcome him to Stamford Bridge this summer. Chelsea view Gittens as an ideal replacement for Jadon Sancho, who they sent back to Manchester United for a price of £5m after failing to agree terms over a permanent transfer. Borussia Dortmund have already rejected two bids from Chelsea and want a fee as close as possible to Gittens' £50.5m release clause. Ex-Germany midfielder Hamann expects Gittens to be on the move this summer but believes he should reject Chelsea in favour of a move to Manchester United. Like Maresca, Ruben Amorim is also keen to sign a new winger this summer as he prepares to offload Marcus Rashford, Sancho and Antony. Given the number of winger departures at Old Trafford, Hamann says Gittens could 'make a real difference' at Manchester United, who finished just 15th in the Premier League last season. 'Borussia Dortmund has been a great place for Jamie Gittens,' Hamann told InstantWithdrawalBettingSites. 'He played a huge role and scored goals and got assists but that stopped when [Dortmund manager] Niko Kovac came in. More Trending 'Chelsea will be fully aware of that, the player has made it clear he wants to leave but he is under contract. 'I would say that Dortmund are not in the strongest position because the manager wants hardworking players and Gittens isn't that type of player. 'I think he will leave Dortmund but they won't get the money they want. 'Chelsea have an abundance of players, but I think he could make a real difference at Manchester United. He is young but he has stood out and I think that might be the player for them to chase.' For more stories like this, check our sport page. Follow Metro Sport for the latest news on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram. MORE: Arsenal set asking price as Bayern Munich consider Gabriel Martinelli transfer MORE: Crystal Palace transfer odds: Eberechi Eze could leave for Tottenham but smart Eagles will want to keep Marc Guehi and Adam Wharton MORE: Kevin De Bruyne tells Antonio Conte to sign England star in blow to Manchester United

Daily Mirror

2 hours ago

• Daily Mirror

New Chelsea star details huge impact Man Utd boss Ruben Amorim had on his career

New Chelsea signing Dario Essugo has detailed the huge impact Manchester United boss Ruben Amorim had on his career during the pair's time together at Sporting Lisbon Chelsea midfielder Dario Essugo has revealed his huge debt of gratitude to Ruben Amorim. It was the Manchester United boss who gave Essugo's career lift-off when they were together at Sporting Lisbon and made him one of Europe's most sought after young players. Former Sporting boss Amorim gave Essugo his debut in the Champions League when he was just 16 years and 268 days, making him the Portuguese club's youngest debutant in the competition. ‌ Essugo, 20, joined Chelsea in the summer for £18.5m and will always be grateful for Amorim for putting him in the first team after just ONE training session. Portugal under-21 star Essugo said: 'He brought me to the first team so he helped me a lot, to understand the game, to reach the level I am here now. ‌ 'I am grateful. He is so demanding. He is a demanding person. He likes to win every time so he has helped me a lot. I made one training session with the first team and the coach Ruben Amorim likes what he saw and he called me to play. 'I didn't expect to play because at this time there was Covid and I wasn't playing anything because the Champions League had stopped. We had good players like Manuel Ugarte, João Palhinha and now Morten Hjulmand. 'They are three big players. I had the opportunity to learn with one of them and of course this for me was a big opportunity.' Essugo says he learned a lot from those players and Amorim but also wants to be his own man rather than be compared to players like Claude Makelele or Michael Essien and N'Golo Kante who have obvious similarities. He said: 'To be honest, I never saw Makelele on TV but the people told me a lot about Makelele and say I have some similar parts of his game. They are big players. I want to make my own way but also like to see Makelele, Essien and Kante, to follow their steps. 'I always play as a midfielder but also I am a defensive midfielder but I also like to go forward with the ball, box to box. Of course it is good when they compare you with a very big player but it is a mix of both because I want to try to have my way, to achieve the top.' ‌ And when Chelsea came calling this summer, there was never any doubt in Essugo's mind about where to go. His dad now manages his career after a career in construction while his mum works in a kitchen. Now Essugo wants to cook up something special at Stamford Bridge and says Enzo Maresca has also been hugely positive since he arrived. He added: 'Chelsea helped my parents so many times. I feel very good. When my father said Chelsea want me to come here, of course I can't say no. ‌ 'I am learning with the coach, the players, the midfielders here. Enzo has a different idea of football like all the managers. But I always to try catch what he wants. Romeo Lavia is so calm I learn so much from him. 'It is a different level. The players are amazing. Before, when I was at Las Palmas and Sporting, they had very big players but for me it is an amazing feeling to be here.'

Daily Mail​

3 hours ago

• Daily Mail​

Zlatan Ibrahimovic performs incredible stunt in swimming pool as former Man United and Barcelona star shows his ability is still intact

Former Manchester United star Zlatan Ibrahimovic has shown that his ability remains intact by performing a spectacular swimming pool stunt. The 43-year-old, who retired in 2023, had a penchant for scoring acrobatic goals during his career. Perhaps his most memorable strike came for Sweden against England in 2012 when Ibrahimovic scored an unbelievable overhead kick from 30 yards out. Ibrahimovic evoked memories of that goal by performing an overhead kick in a swimming pool in a post on social media. Since December 2023, Ibrahimovic has worked as a senior advisor at his former club AC Milan. He represented a host of high-profile clubs during a trophy-laden career. View this post on Instagram A post shared by Zlatan Ibrahimović (@iamzlatanibrahimovic) After starting out at Malmo, Ibrahimovic joined Ajax and later went on to play for Juventus, Inter Milan and Barcelona. In addition, he had two spells at AC Milan and also spent time at Paris Saint-Germain, Manchester United and LA Galaxy. Despite his stellar reputation during his playing days, Ibrahimovic hasn't escaped criticism from AC Milan's ultras since becoming an advisor. Milan endured a disappointing campaign as they ended up finishing in eighth place in Serie A. Ahead of the final game of the season against Monza last month Milan ultras were seen holding banners and hurling insults in protest against the club's hierarchy. A statement from the Milan ultras read: 'This is the best response we could give, because there is no curva, club, red, orange: there are only Milanisti and Milanismo. Things that those in that building have forgotten a long time ago. 'We are back in this square three years after celebrating the best Scudetto ever. After celebrating the return to the Champions League along with Paolo Maldini.' The ultras reserved specific criticism for Ibrahimovic, who they claimed was responsible for the 'disaster' which saw Milan's reserve team suffer relegation to Serie D in their first season in professional football. Ibrahimovic is now working as an advisor for AC Milan but has faced criticism from some fans