Heydon defends DAFM's strategy for tackling TB
The Minister for Agriculture, Food and the Marine, Martin Heydon has outlined the reasons that his department captures badgers in areas where 'serious outbreaks of TB have been identified' and a veterinary inspector has found that badgers are 'the likely source on inspection'.
Minister Heydon was responding to a parliamentary question from People Before Profit-Solidarity TD, Paul Murphy this week (June 10).
Deputy Murphy asked the minister if he will bring an end to the culling of badgers by the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine (DAFM) 'in light of scientific evidence that it is ineffective in reducing TB levels in cattle'.
In response Minister Heydon said: 'Bovine tuberculosis is a challenging disease to control and eradicate due to several factors.
'Ireland's bovine TB eradication programme operates in line with best national and international scientific research and advice.
A large body of peer-reviewed research has been conducted into the spread of TB in Ireland and the risks underlying its transmission,' Minister Heydon added.
According to the minister, the research has found that the principal causes of TB introduction and spread include:
Movement of cattle with undetected infection.
Residual infection in cattle previously exposed to TB.
Spread across farm boundaries.
Indirect spread through other biosecurity breaches.
Spread from infected badgers to cattle.
TB
The minister believes that the relative contributions of each of these factors will vary from farm to farm.
Minister Heydon said: 'Ireland's current TB eradication programme necessarily incorporates a wildlife strategy which includes the removal of badgers from areas where there has been a TB outbreak.
'Such a requirement arises as tuberculosis is present both in cattle and in badgers and both species share the same environment, and the same strains of TB. The current policy was introduced in response to research conducted over many years by the department.
'Research carried out in Ireland demonstrates that TB levels in badgers are highest in areas where TB levels in cattle are highest and that the targeted removal of badgers in such areas contributes to a reduction in the incidence of TB,' Minister Heydon added.
The minister also highlighted that badgers are protected by national legislation, and are listed within the Berne convention.
This legislation outlines that local populations of badgers cannot be exterminated, and that badger habitats cannot be destroyed.
'Badgers are captured under license, issued by the National Parks and Wildlife Service of the Department of Housing Local Government and Heritage,' Minister Heydon said.
'My department's wildlife programme comprises a combination of vaccination and culling, depending on the circumstances,' he added.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Independent
9 hours ago
- Irish Independent
South Dublin council urged to stop use of controversial weedkiller glyphosate
A motion which seeks to ban the use of the controversial weedkiller by the council was passed yesterday at a special meeting of the authority. Glyphosate is used by the council and its contractors to control invasive plant species, along with weed control along footpaths and roads around the authority area. Introducing the motion, People Before Profit councillor Darragh Adelaide said: 'Over the last couple of years, there's been increasing evidence, study after study about the really detrimental effects on people's health of glyphosate. Not just related to cancer, but also neurotoxicity and damage to reproductive health.' "In testing actually done or funded by Uplift, every single person who they tested, all except one, had some concentration of glyphosate in their system,' he said. "Workers who are working full-time with glyphosate, they wear PPE, they have all sorts of protections, whereas regular people, we pick it up from food, we pick it up from being sprayed on the side of roads, and there's very little protection there.' Independent councillor Alan Edge said that it was 'quite clear' that glyphosate caused health issues. "What's clear as well is that glyphosate is being used by contractors who are doing verges along roadsides and footpaths. "One obvious fact is that you have gutters and gullies and they tell us that if you throw a cigarette butt or piece of chewing gum into one of those, you're effectively throwing it into the river or into the sea. 'We know that it has a negative impact on aquatic life, on amphibians, and when we are doing so much and leading as a local authority in terms of our biodiversity, I think we really do have to say that the time has come to put a stop to the use of glyphosate,' he said. Responding to the motion, SDCC senior engineer Leo Magee said that his understanding of glyphosate was that its human health impacts were 'not conclusive', but that the council was already reducing its usage. "Over the last three years we've achieved a 13pc reduction in the use of glyphosate,' he said. "What we're focusing on now, and it's set down in the road sweeping contract, is a condition within the terms of that contract that requires the service provider to achieve a 10pc reduction each year. "The road sweeping contract uses about 90pc of the use of glyphosate by the council and if we can reduce that by 50pc over the five years of the contract that will be a very substantial achievement'. Mr Magee said glyphosate was currently the only effective way of controlling Japanese knotweed, and that the council had trialled several other methods but those had been unsuccessful. SDCC elected members in 2017 passed a motion to ban the weedkiller within public parks, public gardens and public playgrounds.
Agriland
13 hours ago
- Agriland
Animal health status a ‘clear driver' of sustainability levels
Taking a 'silo approach' to animal health misses out fundamentally on the impact this key principle of animal husbandry has across farming as a whole, according to veterinarian Dr. Sam Strain. This was the clear message the vet delivered to the recent Northern Ireland Institute of Agricultural Science (NIIAS) annual conference. He specifically referenced the link between animal health and the issues of production efficiency, carbon footprint, and medicine usage. Moreover, he said these are all matters that determine the overall sustainability of farming and food at the present time. Dr. Strain is the chief executive of Animal Health and Welfare Northern Ireland (AHWNI). In his presentation to the NIIAS conference, he confirmed that animal health status has an overarching impact on livestock performance. In other words, an animal's genetic potential will never be fully reached if its health status is compromised, irrespective of the nutritional regimes that are followed. Chatting at the NIIAS conference, Institute members (l-r) Sean McIntyre, Valerie Westfield, and Lowry Cunningham According to the vet, clear links have also been confirmed between animal health status, production output, and the associated impact on the environment. Dr. Strain explained: 'Between 2007 and 2017, milk output in the United States rose by 24.9%. 'However, greenhouse gas emission levels only increased by 1% during the same period. 'Analysis of these results has clearly shown that animal health status is a clear driver of whole herd efficiency and sustainability levels.' The AHWNI representative highlighted the need for calves to be tagged as early as possible. This is a key requirement, linked to the ongoing bovine viral diarrhoea (BVD) eradication programme in Northern Ireland. Dr. Strain also noted that further legislation will be required to allow for the full completion of the BVD measure. Animal health Animal health standards are directly linked to the usage of antibiotics within production agriculture. He also confirmed that a specific disease breakdown predisposes animals to other health-related issues, which in turn can lead to increased antimicrobial usage. He added: 'There is a tremendous level of interaction between diseases. For example, BVD predisposes animal to pneumonia. Infectious disease move within animals. 'But simple steps taken by farmers to tackle one specific issue can have repercussions across other aspects of animal health. 'For example, improving hygiene standards in calving areas to reduce the prevalence of Johne's disease will also act to reduce scour levels in newborn calves.' Dr Strain also spoke of how improving animal health can have benefits for efforts to reduce carbon emissions. 'There is also a clear line between improved livestock health standards and the carbon footprint generated by a livestock farming business,' the AHWNI representative said. 'For example, reducing lameness problems within dairy herds will significantly reduce greenhouse gas emission levels. 'And reducing parasite burdens, such as those created by fluke and worms, will also deliver overall reductions in carbon footprint values.'
Agriland
a day ago
- Agriland
DAERA: Bluetongue disease ‘will arrive at some stage'
Bluetongue disease will, inevitably, reach the island of Ireland. And this may well happen sooner rather than later. This is the strongly held view of Department of Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs (DAERA) deputy chief veterinary officer, Dr. David Kyle. He made the comments at the recent Northern Ireland Institute of Agricultural Science (NIIAS) annual conference. Dr. Kyle said: 'The disease carrying midges will arrive at some stage: we can't control the weather. 'DAERA is currently monitoring midge and virus populations, specifically in Irish Sea coastal areas.' The latest figures from Great Britain (GB) confirm the east/west march of the virus. However, to date, it has not reached those regions with high sheep populations. Once bluetongue reaches Irish shores, 20km radius incursion zones will be established in an attempt to get to grips with the disease, according to the DAERA deputy chief veterinary officer. Dr, Kyle referenced the future use of vaccines as a way farmers can get to grips with the problem within their own businesses. Chatting at the NIIAS conference, (l to r) Ian Stevenson, Dairy Council for Northern Ireland; and Dick Blakiston Houston, BlakistonHouston Estates According to the DAERA representative, a region's animal health status will have a direct bearing on its ability to export food products. In addition, disease has a direct bearing on animal performance and productivity. Illegal animal and food importations heighten the risk of new disease threats, and Dr. Kyle confirmed that DAERA has strengthened its presence at all of Northern Ireland's ports. He referred to the attempts that have been made by some people to smuggle live sheep into Northern Ireland as 'absolute folly'. The World Organisation for Animal Health lists 118 notifiable diseases. All of these are linked to international food trading conditions. Dr. Kyle said: 'Food exports are worth in excess of £6 billion to Northern Ireland's economy. So, protecting the future of our agri-food sectors is a key priority. 'And the same principle holds in the Republic of Ireland.' The DAERA representative referenced the triple threat of bluetongue, foot and mouth disease (FMD), and highly pathogenic avian influenza – or bird flu – as the key concerns for Ireland's agri-food sectors at the present time. While Dr. Kyle highlighted the tremendous efforts made by the poultry sector in keeping avian influenza at bay over recent times, he struck a cautionary note where FMD is concerned. This year has seen outbreaks of the disease confirmed in Germany, Hungary and Slovakia with two different lineages of the virus identified in these cases. However, when it comes to attributing the initial causes of the disease outbreaks, bio-terrorism has been one of the options followed up.
